Parariss wrote: ecarlino wroteParariss wroteecarlino wroteFred Miranda wroted Matt Grum wroteI think it's worth stating again that this forum is not a representative sample of potential customers - people here are exacting with very specific requirements, I'd probably buy the lens if it were a little be lighter or a little bit cheaper or a little bit faster, or if the timing was different, but as it is it falls just outside my very narrow criteria!It's also worth pointing out that FM members do not shy from expensive gear so price is not what's really driving these numbers. I believe the slower a aperture is a deal breaker for a lot of shooters.imagine if they had done a 2.4 like you had speculated a few weeks ago - but otherwise same specs (APO etc)
it might have as much as 10-15% more diameter
but i think psychologically it'd be less of a hump for people to get over.
it still wouldn't be the f/1.8 or f/2 that many want, but i think there is an excessive drop off in interest relative to the difference in light gathering between 2.4 and 2.8 - i think that my have been their Achilles heel with this.
f/2.4 and $1900 would have probably captured a lot of hearts and minds."...i think there is an excessive drop off in interest relative to the difference in light gathering between 2.4 and 2.8"
Excessive drop off? According to the (unscientific) poll herein, over 40% either have bought the lens, or are likely buying this lens assuming the reviews hold up as expected, or will buy the lens used when it's available. Sure, we're all a bunch of tweaker lens whores on this forum, but that seems like a pretty good number! you are either misinterpreting or misstating the polling data:
the 40% you refer to are not likely buyers at the $2000 price point.
only 4% are with an additional 12% waiting for reviews to make a decision.
the next 27% might be interested in a year if reviews are solid and the price drops at least 25%.
that is a big difference.Anyway, I'm sorry you didn't get the lens you wanted. Sony will get around to you at some point!
Between you and chez, I'm going to lose my mind.
What are you talking about?
I've been pretty clear that I'm more than a little interested in this lens and I'll likely buy it, if not day one, then soon thereafter.
ecarlino wrote: Parariss wroteecarlino wroteParariss wroteecarlino wroteFred Miranda wroted
It's also worth pointing out that FM members do not shy from expensive gear so price is not what's really driving these numbers. I believe the slower a aperture is a deal breaker for a lot of shooters.imagine if they had done a 2.4 like you had speculated a few weeks ago - but otherwise same specs (APO etc)
it might have as much as 10-15% more diameter
but i think psychologically it'd be less of a hump for people to get over.
it still wouldn't be the f/1.8 or f/2 that many want, but i think there is an excessive drop off in interest relative to the difference in light gathering between 2.4 and 2.8 - i think that my have been their Achilles heel with this.
f/2.4 and $1900 would have probably captured a lot of hearts and minds."...i think there is an excessive drop off in interest relative to the difference in light gathering between 2.4 and 2.8"
Excessive drop off? According to the (unscientific) poll herein, over 40% either have bought the lens, or are likely buying this lens assuming the reviews hold up as expected, or will buy the lens used when it's available. Sure, we're all a bunch of tweaker lens whores on this forum, but that seems like a pretty good number! you are either misinterpreting or misstating the polling data:
the 40% you refer to are not likely buyers at the $2000 price point.
only 4% are with an additional 12% waiting for reviews to make a decision.
the next 27% might be interested in a year if reviews are solid and the price drops at least 25%.
that is a big difference.Anyway, I'm sorry you didn't get the lens you wanted. Sony will get around to you at some point!Between you and chez, I'm going to lose my mind.
What are you talking about?
I've been pretty clear that I'm more than a little interested in this lens and I'll likely buy it, if not day one, then soon thereafter.
Ecarlino, glad you talked yourself into the lens. Hope it brings you joy. Didn't think I had such affect on your mind...hate to see you lose it.
ecarlino wrote: Parariss wroteecarlino wroteParariss wroteecarlino wroteFred Miranda wroted
It's also worth pointing out that FM members do not shy from expensive gear so price is not what's really driving these numbers. I believe the slower a aperture is a deal breaker for a lot of shooters.imagine if they had done a 2.4 like you had speculated a few weeks ago - but otherwise same specs (APO etc)
it might have as much as 10-15% more diameter
but i think psychologically it'd be less of a hump for people to get over.
it still wouldn't be the f/1.8 or f/2 that many want, but i think there is an excessive drop off in interest relative to the difference in light gathering between 2.4 and 2.8 - i think that my have been their Achilles heel with this.
f/2.4 and $1900 would have probably captured a lot of hearts and minds."...i think there is an excessive drop off in interest relative to the difference in light gathering between 2.4 and 2.8"
Excessive drop off? According to the (unscientific) poll herein, over 40% either have bought the lens, or are likely buying this lens assuming the reviews hold up as expected, or will buy the lens used when it's available. Sure, we're all a bunch of tweaker lens whores on this forum, but that seems like a pretty good number! you are either misinterpreting or misstating the polling data:
the 40% you refer to are not likely buyers at the $2000 price point.
only 4% are with an additional 12% waiting for reviews to make a decision.
the next 27% might be interested in a year if reviews are solid and the price drops at least 25%.
that is a big difference.Anyway, I'm sorry you didn't get the lens you wanted. Sony will get around to you at some point!Between you and chez, I'm going to lose my mind.
What are you talking about?
I've been pretty clear that I'm more than a little interested in this lens and I'll likely buy it, if not day one, then soon thereafter.
Ecarlino, I do think the Batis 135 will be excellent and really fill a niche for many. My issue is why they cannot make the physical dimensions smaller particularly for a f/2.8. The weight at 614gm is excellent, but length and diameter is longer and larger than the 135 Art? I have always preferred the shorter/squat lenses for portrait lenses.
Charles, you make a good point (what else is new?). My first observation is that recent Zeiss releases veer towards the large. If I had to find a reason for this, I'd say that, while Leica want a premium for small and light, Zeiss want large and heavy to justify the premium...:-). Then, I'd guess that this has something to do with a lens' ability to resolve sensors of no less than 80 Mp for full-frame (this is the number Zeiss are talking about, not any guess on my part of where Sony are going with A7RIII, which I expect to come out at 60Mp).
I find it interesting that Zeiss chose to make the lens APO (their only 4 APO lenses are top-notch) and slow-ish, an unusual combination for them. It rings a bell about the Milvus 50 f:1,4. It looks to be remarkably good, but with significant CA. Might what they have learned with this lens be moving Zeiss to say : CA, never again!?
I think the conversation goes like this. Not sure i want to give up my allotment of salt block for a lens this slow and brownie over there is certainly not going to give up feeding off this great grass we have here. Its just too much the black cow says with a sigh, they may just butcher my fat ass sooner than later better buy it now.
Yea i was on the prairie maybe one day too long. ROTFLMAO
charles.K wrote: ecarlino wroteParariss wroteecarlino wroteParariss wroteecarlino wroteimagine if they had done a 2.4 like you had speculated a few weeks ago - but otherwise same specs (APO etc)
it might have as much as 10-15% more diameter
but i think psychologically it'd be less of a hump for people to get over.
it still wouldn't be the f/1.8 or f/2 that many want, but i think there is an excessive drop off in interest relative to the difference in light gathering between 2.4 and 2.8 - i think that my have been their Achilles heel with this.
f/2.4 and $1900 would have probably captured a lot of hearts and minds."...i think there is an excessive drop off in interest relative to the difference in light gathering between 2.4 and 2.8"
Excessive drop off? According to the (unscientific) poll herein, over 40% either have bought the lens, or are likely buying this lens assuming the reviews hold up as expected, or will buy the lens used when it's available. Sure, we're all a bunch of tweaker lens whores on this forum, but that seems like a pretty good number! you are either misinterpreting or misstating the polling data:
the 40% you refer to are not likely buyers at the $2000 price point.
only 4% are with an additional 12% waiting for reviews to make a decision.
the next 27% might be interested in a year if reviews are solid and the price drops at least 25%.
that is a big difference.Anyway, I'm sorry you didn't get the lens you wanted. Sony will get around to you at some point!Between you and chez, I'm going to lose my mind.
What are you talking about?
I've been pretty clear that I'm more than a little interested in this lens and I'll likely buy it, if not day one, then soon thereafter.Ecarlino, I do think the Batis 135 will be excellent and really fill a niche for many. My issue is why they cannot make the physical dimensions smaller particularly for a f/2.8. The weight at 614gm is excellent, but length and diameter is longer and larger than the 135 Art? I have always preferred the shorter/squat lenses for portrait lenses.
I suppose length is down to the focal length minus whatever you choose to reduce it by through increasing the telephoto ratio, usually at some cost. But I doubt it's speed dependent. When you add that to the fact that at this fl mirrorless lenses have to be longer for same effective length to the sensor, the length is not surprising.
The filter size is smaller than the Art; surely the diameter isn't much greater is it?
DavidBM wrote: charles.K wroteecarlino wroteParariss wroteecarlino wroteParariss wrote"...i think there is an excessive drop off in interest relative to the difference in light gathering between 2.4 and 2.8"
Excessive drop off? According to the (unscientific) poll herein, over 40% either have bought the lens, or are likely buying this lens assuming the reviews hold up as expected, or will buy the lens used when it's available. Sure, we're all a bunch of tweaker lens whores on this forum, but that seems like a pretty good number! you are either misinterpreting or misstating the polling data:
the 40% you refer to are not likely buyers at the $2000 price point.
only 4% are with an additional 12% waiting for reviews to make a decision.
the next 27% might be interested in a year if reviews are solid and the price drops at least 25%.
that is a big difference.Anyway, I'm sorry you didn't get the lens you wanted. Sony will get around to you at some point!Between you and chez, I'm going to lose my mind.
What are you talking about?
I've been pretty clear that I'm more than a little interested in this lens and I'll likely buy it, if not day one, then soon thereafter.Ecarlino, I do think the Batis 135 will be excellent and really fill a niche for many. My issue is why they cannot make the physical dimensions smaller particularly for a f/2.8. The weight at 614gm is excellent, but length and diameter is longer and larger than the 135 Art? I have always preferred the shorter/squat lenses for portrait lenses.I suppose length is down to the focal length minus whatever you choose to reduce it by through increasing the telephoto ratio, usually at some cost. But I doubt it's speed dependent. When you add that to the fact that at this fl mirrorless lenses have to be longer for same effective length to the sensor, the length is not surprising.
The filter size is smaller than the Art; surely the diameter isn't much greater is it?
The Batis 135 filter size is 67 mm, diameter 98 mm versus 82 mm for the 135 Art, diameter 91 mm. Personally I now prefer polymer/carbon fiber materials that keep the weight down. Of course it is wonderful it is to pick beautifully crafted lenses like most of the Leica M series, but with FF anything that keeps the load of my lower back I appreciate
charles.K wrote: DavidBM wrotecharles.K wroteecarlino wroteParariss wroteecarlino wroteyou are either misinterpreting or misstating the polling data:
the 40% you refer to are not likely buyers at the $2000 price point.
only 4% are with an additional 12% waiting for reviews to make a decision.
the next 27% might be interested in a year if reviews are solid and the price drops at least 25%.
that is a big difference.Anyway, I'm sorry you didn't get the lens you wanted. Sony will get around to you at some point!Between you and chez, I'm going to lose my mind.
What are you talking about?
I've been pretty clear that I'm more than a little interested in this lens and I'll likely buy it, if not day one, then soon thereafter.Ecarlino, I do think the Batis 135 will be excellent and really fill a niche for many. My issue is why they cannot make the physical dimensions smaller particularly for a f/2.8. The weight at 614gm is excellent, but length and diameter is longer and larger than the 135 Art? I have always preferred the shorter/squat lenses for portrait lenses.I suppose length is down to the focal length minus whatever you choose to reduce it by through increasing the telephoto ratio, usually at some cost. But I doubt it's speed dependent. When you add that to the fact that at this fl mirrorless lenses have to be longer for same effective length to the sensor, the length is not surprising.
The filter size is smaller than the Art; surely the diameter isn't much greater is it?The Batis 135 filter size is 67 mm, diameter 98 mm versus 82 mm for the 135 Art, diameter 91 mm. Personally I now prefer polymer/carbon fiber materials that keep the weight down. Of course it is wonderful it is to pick beautifully crafted lenses like most of the Leica M series, but with FF anything that keeps the load of my lower back I appreciate
Yes there's a real tradeoff between Leica/ZM/Loxia gorgeousness which is such a pleasure, and weight and function. Canon have long made very sensible design choices with their premium lenses: L lenses are (IMHO) an ugly lot, but they are less likely to scratch than metal, lighter, and probably absorb impact better.
And Sony made a poor choice with their earlier lenses making the outer sheaths metal purely so that the reviewers would give marks for "build quality" while skimping on the anodising so that they scratch easily. (I have persuaded myself that by 1,8/55 has a street cred look)., GM lenses seem to be composite in the Canon way, or at least some of them.
But I think in the high end enthusiast market appealing to the jewellery loving side of our natures is probably a commercial necessity.
philber wrote:
Charles, you make a good point (what else is new?). My first observation is that recent Zeiss releases veer towards the large. If I had to find a reason for this, I'd say that, while Leica want a premium for small and light, Zeiss want large and heavy to justify the premium...:-). Then, I'd guess that this has something to do with a lens' ability to resolve sensors of no less than 80 Mp for full-frame (this is the number Zeiss are talking about, not any guess on my part of where Sony are going with A7RIII, which I expect to come out at 60Mp).
I find it interesting that Zeiss chose to make the lens APO (their only 4 APO lenses are top-notch) and slow-ish, an unusual combination for them. It rings a bell about the Milvus 50 f:1,4. It looks to be remarkably good, but with significant CA. Might what they have learned with this lens be moving Zeiss to say : CA, never again!?...Show more →
I love your comment Philippe about Leica's premium is for light/small and Zeiss' premium is large/heavy Truth is I still don't mind paying a premium for small/light systems but I am lot more reluctant now with so many options. The reality is we are offered so many wonderfully sharp lenses now that we can pixel peep at 200% and we then we don't like what we see. It is too clinical, harsh or the bokeh is too busy and we then seek the older style lenses that render more like paintings.
charles.K wrote: DavidBM wrotecharles.K wroteecarlino wroteParariss wroteecarlino wroteyou are either misinterpreting or misstating the polling data:
the 40% you refer to are not likely buyers at the $2000 price point.
only 4% are with an additional 12% waiting for reviews to make a decision.
the next 27% might be interested in a year if reviews are solid and the price drops at least 25%.
that is a big difference.Anyway, I'm sorry you didn't get the lens you wanted. Sony will get around to you at some point!Between you and chez, I'm going to lose my mind.
What are you talking about?
I've been pretty clear that I'm more than a little interested in this lens and I'll likely buy it, if not day one, then soon thereafter.Ecarlino, I do think the Batis 135 will be excellent and really fill a niche for many. My issue is why they cannot make the physical dimensions smaller particularly for a f/2.8. The weight at 614gm is excellent, but length and diameter is longer and larger than the 135 Art? I have always preferred the shorter/squat lenses for portrait lenses.I suppose length is down to the focal length minus whatever you choose to reduce it by through increasing the telephoto ratio, usually at some cost. But I doubt it's speed dependent. When you add that to the fact that at this fl mirrorless lenses have to be longer for same effective length to the sensor, the length is not surprising.
The filter size is smaller than the Art; surely the diameter isn't much greater is it?The Batis 135 filter size is 67 mm, diameter 98 mm versus 82 mm for the 135 Art, diameter 91 mm. Personally I now prefer polymer/carbon fiber materials that keep the weight down. Of course it is wonderful it is to pick beautifully crafted lenses like most of the Leica M series, but with FF anything that keeps the load of my lower back I appreciate
Charles that 98mm diameter is actually the diameter of the hood not the lens. The lens is 81mm (which is still quite fat) at all but the very end which flares out to match the hood. So, it is about the same diameter as the Sigma 135 Art. Also keep in mind that the Sigma Art will need the length of the MC-11 added. So, it is a bit smaller than the Art but not that much, but a noticeable amount lighter. So, the Sigma 135 Art is 91mm in diameter and 138mm long (with the MC-11) and the Batis is 81mm in diameter (except for the hood and where the body flares out to meet the hood) and 120mm in length. So, it isn't only in weight where the Sigma is larger it is also in bulk or volume. Still the bulk/volume of the Basis is not nearly as impressive as the weight.
I have been asking myself the question why I am more in the "maybe group". While I love the idea having a native 135mm lens, two main factors make me hesitate. Actually, there is a third one but let's start with the 2 simple reasons. They are namely 1) slowish aperture of f/2.8 and 2) a fairly steep price of the Batis. Neither one is a deal breaker to me but the combination of the two factors can easily get me there.
Then there is the third factor and that's the availability of others lenses that are very capable and every single one of them is less expensive than the Batis, at least on the onset. If we just limit ourselves to fairly modern and fast, having at least f/2.0 aperture, are the 2 AF lenses in the first group, the new Sigma f/1.8 Art, the Canon 135mm f/2L and the Sony 135mm f/1.8 ZA. Both requiring adapter to work but a non-issue to those that already have them. Then in the MF group there are two very capable contenders, the Samyang and the big brother Zeiss ZE/ZF 135mm APO.
The native AF system, OSS, promising IQ and a fairly small form factor and/or light-weoght speak greatly in favor the Batis but the combination of all 3 factors are a fairly big hurdle to overcome. Frankly, if it is coming to needing AF, very fast aperture for delicious bokeh and more reasonably priced, the new Sigma Art looks very appealing to me. It seems that it is more geared towards portrait photography however. The Samyang, on the other hand, seems to be a great contender for landscape. And, you can buy both for the price of the new Batis but you need to hire a sherpa for carrying both . Again, this is my opinion and I fully realize/understand that individual preferences vary widely among us.
I bought a Leica R mount 135mm lens and compared it to a rental copy of the 135/2 APO Zf.2 Zeiss lens and found I liked the color rendering of the Leica better. So, I saved a great deal of money at the time by sticking with the Leica ( never thought I would write that sentence ) as it was 400 dollars used. The only drawback was it was slightly slower. I haven't needed the extra stop, especially with IBIS on the A7Rii. So, the new Batis doesn't interest me right now. The advantage of AF doesn't make up for the cost for me.
Very good points indeed. If this was a 200mm discussion well I would have it in my hands already but at 135 it won't do runway for me because of my limited distance to stage. But a 135 is very handy for PR and events. Also the Rok last week on location shooting the wind turbines was used a lot. So I have all kinds of needs. In a way the Sigma makes more sense it's got the darn speed we all are after and it's less costly and even if it's a F2 lens IQ wise it equals this Batis, let's assume. The biggest drawback here is weight and size but if you think about it in reality your still going to be carrying a fairly large lens anyway since it's a 135. Quibbling over a few grams and inches is starting to seem silly. We have to carry it anyway. Just not going to get around it . Bottom line there is no Leica 135 3.4 small lens at 2.8,2 or 1.8. The secret here maybe a Leica 135 for the travel folks and the dang Sigma for speed freaks like me. I like this Batis it's just sitting smack in the middle of it all and it's not cheap either. I'm out testing this Sony 85 1.8 and looks to be killer at 600. Okay even if Sony gave us a 2.8 135 it might just be smaller and cheaper. I know this is a tough one for folks as we are all bouncing all around. It's really not so much the money but the function of it. Where the heck does it sit in this arena filled with some other good choices
AGeoJO wrote:
I have been asking myself the question why I am more in the "maybe group". While I love the idea having a native 135mm lens, two main factors make me hesitate. Actually, there is a third one but let's start with the 2 simple reasons. They are namely 1) slowish aperture of f/2.8 and 2) a fairly steep price of the Batis. Neither one is a deal breaker to me but the combination of the two factors can easily get me there.
Then there is the third factor and that's the availability of others lenses that are very capable and every single one of them is less expensive than the Batis, at least on the onset. If we just limit ourselves to fairly modern and fast, having at least f/2.0 aperture, are the 2 AF lenses in the first group, the new Sigma f/1.8 Art, the Canon 135mm f/2L and the Sony 135mm f/1.8 ZA. Both requiring adapter to work but a non-issue to those that already have them. Then in the MF group there are two very capable contenders, the Samyang and the big brother Zeiss ZE/ZF 135mm APO.
The native AF system, OSS, promising IQ and a fairly small form factor and/or light-weoght speak greatly in favor the Batis but the combination of all 3 factors are a fairly big hurdle to overcome. Frankly, if it is coming to needing AF, very fast aperture for delicious bokeh and more reasonably priced, the new Sigma Art looks very appealing to me. It seems that it is more geared towards portrait photography however. The Samyang, on the other hand, seems to be a great contender for landscape. And, you can buy both for the price of the new Batis but you need to hire a sherpa for carrying both . Again, this is my opinion and I fully realize/understand that individual preferences vary widely among us. ...Show more →
AGeoJO wrote:
I have been asking myself the question why I am more in the "maybe group". While I love the idea having a native 135mm lens, two main factors make me hesitate. Actually, there is a third one but let's start with the 2 simple reasons. They are namely 1) slowish aperture of f/2.8 and 2) a fairly steep price of the Batis. Neither one is a deal breaker to me but the combination of the two factors can easily get me there.
Then there is the third factor and that's the availability of others lenses that are very capable and every single one of them is less expensive than the Batis, at least on the onset. If we just limit ourselves to fairly modern and fast, having at least f/2.0 aperture, are the 2 AF lenses in the first group, the new Sigma f/1.8 Art, the Canon 135mm f/2L and the Sony 135mm f/1.8 ZA. Both requiring adapter to work but a non-issue to those that already have them. Then in the MF group there are two very capable contenders, the Samyang and the big brother Zeiss ZE/ZF 135mm APO.
The native AF system, OSS, promising IQ and a fairly small form factor and/or light-weoght speak greatly in favor the Batis but the combination of all 3 factors are a fairly big hurdle to overcome. Frankly, if it is coming to needing AF, very fast aperture for delicious bokeh and more reasonably priced, the new Sigma Art looks very appealing to me. It seems that it is more geared towards portrait photography however. The Samyang, on the other hand, seems to be a great contender for landscape. And, you can buy both for the price of the new Batis but you need to hire a sherpa for carrying both . Again, this is my opinion and I fully realize/understand that individual preferences vary widely among us. ...Show more →
You are making too much sense! That's a great analysis, however, I would only add that none of the above lenses can really compete with the new Batis regarding weight, native AF and OSS which are unique in this market of excellent 135mm lenses.
Fred Miranda wrote: AGeoJO wroteI have been asking myself the question why I am more in the "maybe group". While I love the idea having a native 135mm lens, two main factors make me hesitate. Actually, there is a third one but let's start with the 2 simple reasons. They are namely 1) slowish aperture of f/2.8 and 2) a fairly steep price of the Batis. Neither one is a deal breaker to me but the combination of the two factors can easily get me there.
Then there is the third factor and that's the availability of others lenses that are very capable and every single one of them is less expensive than the Batis, at least on the onset. If we just limit ourselves to fairly modern and fast, having at least f/2.0 aperture, are the 2 AF lenses in the first group, the new Sigma f/1.8 Art, the Canon 135mm f/2L and the Sony 135mm f/1.8 ZA. Both requiring adapter to work but a non-issue to those that already have them. Then in the MF group there are two very capable contenders, the Samyang and the big brother Zeiss ZE/ZF 135mm APO.
The native AF system, OSS, promising IQ and a fairly small form factor and/or light-weoght speak greatly in favor the Batis but the combination of all 3 factors are a fairly big hurdle to overcome. Frankly, if it is coming to needing AF, very fast aperture for delicious bokeh and more reasonably priced, the new Sigma Art looks very appealing to me. It seems that it is more geared towards portrait photography however. The Samyang, on the other hand, seems to be a great contender for landscape. And, you can buy both for the price of the new Batis but you need to hire a sherpa for carrying both . Again, this is my opinion and I fully realize/understand that individual preferences vary widely among us.You are making too much sense! That's a great analysis, however, I would only add that none of the above lenses can really compete with the new Batis regarding weight, native AF and OSS which are unique in this market of excellent 135mm lenses.
GMPhotography wrote:
Very good points indeed. If this was a 200mm discussion well I would have it in my hands already but at 135 it won't do runway for me because of my limited distance to stage. But a 135 is very handy for PR and events. Also the Rok last week on location shooting the wind turbines was used a lot. So I have all kinds of needs. In a way the Sigma makes more sense it's got the darn speed we all are after and it's less costly and even if it's a F2 lens IQ wise it equals this Batis, let's assume. The biggest drawback here is weight and size but if you think about it in reality your still going to be carrying a fairly large lens anyway since it's a 135. Quibbling over a few grams and inches is starting to seem silly. We have to carry it anyway. Just not going to get around it . Bottom line there is no Leica 135 3.4 small lens at 2.8,2 or 1.8. The secret here maybe a Leica 135 for the travel folks and the dang Sigma for speed freaks like me. I like this Batis it's just sitting smack in the middle of it all and it's not cheap either. I'm out testing this Sony 85 1.8 and looks to be killer at 600. Okay even if Sony gave us a 2.8 135 it might just be smaller and cheaper. I know this is a tough one for folks as we are all bouncing all around. It's really not so much the money but the function of it. Where the heck does it sit in this arena filled with some other good choices
...Show more →AGeoJO wroteI have been asking myself the question why I am more in the "maybe group". While I love the idea having a native 135mm lens, two main factors make me hesitate. Actually, there is a third one but let's start with the 2 simple reasons. They are namely 1) slowish aperture of f/2.8 and 2) a fairly steep price of the Batis. Neither one is a deal breaker to me but the combination of the two factors can easily get me there.
Then there is the third factor and that's the availability of others lenses that are very capable and every single one of them is less expensive than the Batis, at least on the onset. If we just limit ourselves to fairly modern and fast, having at least f/2.0 aperture, are the 2 AF lenses in the first group, the new Sigma f/1.8 Art, the Canon 135mm f/2L and the Sony 135mm f/1.8 ZA. Both requiring adapter to work but a non-issue to those that already have them. Then in the MF group there are two very capable contenders, the Samyang and the big brother Zeiss ZE/ZF 135mm APO.
The native AF system, OSS, promising IQ and a fairly small form factor and/or light-weoght speak greatly in favor the Batis but the combination of all 3 factors are a fairly big hurdle to overcome. Frankly, if it is coming to needing AF, very fast aperture for delicious bokeh and more reasonably priced, the new Sigma Art looks very appealing to me. It seems that it is more geared towards portrait photography however. The Samyang, on the other hand, seems to be a great contender for landscape. And, you can buy both for the price of the new Batis but you need to hire a sherpa for carrying both . Again, this is my opinion and I fully realize/understand that individual preferences vary widely among us.
The Leica-M 135mm f/3.5 Apo-Telyt with the Sigma 135mm f/1.8 Art would be an awesome combo. The first more for landscape/travel and the second for specialty portraits. The main drawback? The price, which will be quite a bit more expensive than the Batis 135mm APO.
Fred Miranda wrote: AGeoJO wroteI have been asking myself the question why I am more in the "maybe group". While I love the idea having a native 135mm lens, two main factors make me hesitate. Actually, there is a third one but let's start with the 2 simple reasons. They are namely 1) slowish aperture of f/2.8 and 2) a fairly steep price of the Batis. Neither one is a deal breaker to me but the combination of the two factors can easily get me there.
Then there is the third factor and that's the availability of others lenses that are very capable and every single one of them is less expensive than the Batis, at least on the onset. If we just limit ourselves to fairly modern and fast, having at least f/2.0 aperture, are the 2 AF lenses in the first group, the new Sigma f/1.8 Art, the Canon 135mm f/2L and the Sony 135mm f/1.8 ZA. Both requiring adapter to work but a non-issue to those that already have them. Then in the MF group there are two very capable contenders, the Samyang and the big brother Zeiss ZE/ZF 135mm APO.
The native AF system, OSS, promising IQ and a fairly small form factor and/or light-weoght speak greatly in favor the Batis but the combination of all 3 factors are a fairly big hurdle to overcome. Frankly, if it is coming to needing AF, very fast aperture for delicious bokeh and more reasonably priced, the new Sigma Art looks very appealing to me. It seems that it is more geared towards portrait photography however. The Samyang, on the other hand, seems to be a great contender for landscape. And, you can buy both for the price of the new Batis but you need to hire a sherpa for carrying both . Again, this is my opinion and I fully realize/understand that individual preferences vary widely among us.You are making too much sense! That's a great analysis, however, I would only add that none of the above lenses can really compete with the new Batis regarding weight, native AF and OSS which are unique in this market of excellent 135mm lenses.
Thanks, Fred! There is no denying that the native AF feature and to a lesser degree, the OSS, are the main plusses of the Batis. If you need or want that, then the choice is simple. The Sigma with MC-11 is close in terms of native AF but indeed, not quite there. The consolation here is that future firmwares may improve the AF performance of the combo. And Metabones V is coming, too....
GMPhotography wrote:
Geez you have to throw reality in here. Lol
Fred Miranda wroteAGeoJO wroteI have been asking myself the question why I am more in the "maybe group". While I love the idea having a native 135mm lens, two main factors make me hesitate. Actually, there is a third one but let's start with the 2 simple reasons. They are namely 1) slowish aperture of f/2.8 and 2) a fairly steep price of the Batis. Neither one is a deal breaker to me but the combination of the two factors can easily get me there.
Then there is the third factor and that's the availability of others lenses that are very capable and every single one of them is less expensive than the Batis, at least on the onset. If we just limit ourselves to fairly modern and fast, having at least f/2.0 aperture, are the 2 AF lenses in the first group, the new Sigma f/1.8 Art, the Canon 135mm f/2L and the Sony 135mm f/1.8 ZA. Both requiring adapter to work but a non-issue to those that already have them. Then in the MF group there are two very capable contenders, the Samyang and the big brother Zeiss ZE/ZF 135mm APO.
The native AF system, OSS, promising IQ and a fairly small form factor and/or light-weoght speak greatly in favor the Batis but the combination of all 3 factors are a fairly big hurdle to overcome. Frankly, if it is coming to needing AF, very fast aperture for delicious bokeh and more reasonably priced, the new Sigma Art looks very appealing to me. It seems that it is more geared towards portrait photography however. The Samyang, on the other hand, seems to be a great contender for landscape. And, you can buy both for the price of the new Batis but you need to hire a sherpa for carrying both . Again, this is my opinion and I fully realize/understand that individual preferences vary widely among us.You are making too much sense! That's a great analysis, however, I would only add that none of the above lenses can really compete with the new Batis regarding weight, native AF and OSS which are unique in this market of excellent 135mm lenses.
Well, there are a few typos in my post..... . Oh, well but I got the message across, I guess.
I think the OSS will be the big differentiator for this lens. As I understand IBIS it becomes less effective as the focal length increases as the sensor has move more to compensate whereas optical stabilization works well with telephotos. So the OSS should greatly increase the usability of this lens in low light environments even though it is one stop slower. Having a high quality APO telephoto prime with good AF and OSS could be great for wedding or other low light event shooting that are typically the domain of stabilized 70-200's. I know even at f/2 people really miss the OIS on the Fuji 90/2 and swap to OIS zoom in low light even though it's faster at f/2. I think this 135 will be able to perform well in different situations and lighting environments than other 135's and that will determine how successful a product it ends up being.
rbf_ wrote:
I think the OSS will be the big differentiator for this lens. As I understand IBIS it becomes less effective as the focal length increases as the sensor has move more to compensate whereas optical stabilization works well with telephotos. So the OSS should greatly increase the usability of this lens in low light environments even though it is one stop slower. Having a high quality APO telephoto prime with good AF and OSS could be great for wedding or other low light event shooting that are typically the domain of stabilized 70-200's. I know even at f/2 people really miss the OIS on the Fuji 90/2 and swap to OIS zoom in low light even though it's faster at f/2. I think this 135 will be able to perform well in different situations and lighting environments than other 135's and that will determine how successful a product it ends up being. ...Show more →
Do you know of any data or tests that show how much the IBIS is compromised at the 135mm focal length. I believe there was a previous post that claimed IBIS is not compromised until after 200mm.
I know the theory, but I'd be interested in actual test data.
chez wrote: rbf_ wroteI think the OSS will be the big differentiator for this lens. As I understand IBIS it becomes less effective as the focal length increases as the sensor has move more to compensate whereas optical stabilization works well with telephotos. So the OSS should greatly increase the usability of this lens in low light environments even though it is one stop slower. Having a high quality APO telephoto prime with good AF and OSS could be great for wedding or other low light event shooting that are typically the domain of stabilized 70-200's. I know even at f/2 people really miss the OIS on the Fuji 90/2 and swap to OIS zoom in low light even though it's faster at f/2. I think this 135 will be able to perform well in different situations and lighting environments than other 135's and that will determine how successful a product it ends up being.Do you know of any data or tests that show how much the IBIS is compromised at the 135mm focal length. I believe there was a previous post that claimed IBIS is not compromised until after 200mm.
I know the theory, but I'd be interested in actual test data.
No, only theory but as the theory goes it is a gradual degradation of effectiveness as the focal length increases and more shake needs to be compensated by sensor movement. I think the IBIS is still compensating at 135mm as they said the OSS would work with IBIS in this lens but I'm not sure how much. It would be interesting to see the performance of IBIS varies as focal range varies but I don't have Sony kit myself so can't test. However if they can get really good stabilized OSS + IBIS performance with that lens I think it will really expand the usability of that lens.