fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2017 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2017Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?

  
 
chez
Offline
Details
p.8 #1Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
Here is a thread right here on FM that talks about ibis. What is interesting is a couple of photographer that I respect actually claim the effectiveness of IBIS increases with focal length, resulting in 3 to 4 stops at 135mm.

One thing IBIS or OSS cannot fix is subject movement which is where a 1.8 lens really shines over a 2.8 lens allowing a faster shutter speed for the same ISO.

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1384518/0

Here is another test which shows the IBIS being very effective ( 4 stops ) at 200mm.

https://tysonrobichaudphotography.wordpress.com/2015/07/31/sony-5-axis-ibis-vs-ef-lens-based-is-vs-panasonic-2-axis-ibis-comparison/

Apr 09, 2017 at 10:28 AM
rbf_
Offline
Details
p.8 #2Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
chez wrote:
Here is a thread right here on FM that talks about ibis. What is interesting is a couple of photographer that I respect actually claim the effectiveness of IBIS increases with focal length, resulting in 3 to 4 stops at 135mm.

One thing IBIS or OSS cannot fix is subject movement which is where a 1.8 lens really shines over a 2.8 lens allowing a faster shutter speed for the same ISO.

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1384518/0

Here is another test which shows the IBIS being very effective ( 4 stops ) at 200mm.

https://tysonrobichaudphotography.wordpress.com/2015/07/31/sony-5-axis-ibis-vs-ef-lens-based-is-vs-panasonic-2-axis-ibis-comparison/



Perhaps Sony & Zeiss have made a huge mistake here and put OSS in this lens for no added benefit I tend to think that would be illogical however.

BTW - how one measures can be quite a tricky & subjective topic. Quickly looking I seem to see softening at least after two stops on some of those shots. I'd be more interested in the results of the 135:2.8 APO/OSS vs other 135's with just IBIS. That will flesh out the real tradeoffs.
Apr 09, 2017 at 10:56 AM
chez
Offline
Details
p.8 #3Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
rbf_ wrote:
chez wroteHere is a thread right here on FM that talks about ibis. What is interesting is a couple of photographer that I respect actually claim the effectiveness of IBIS increases with focal length, resulting in 3 to 4 stops at 135mm.

One thing IBIS or OSS cannot fix is subject movement which is where a 1.8 lens really shines over a 2.8 lens allowing a faster shutter speed for the same ISO.

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1384518/0

Here is another test which shows the IBIS being very effective ( 4 stops ) at 200mm.

https://tysonrobichaudphotography.wordpress.com/2015/07/31/sony-5-axis-ibis-vs-ef-lens-based-is-vs-panasonic-2-axis-ibis-comparison/
Perhaps Sony & Zeiss have made a huge mistake here and put OSS in this lens for no added benefit I tend to think that would be illogical however.

BTW - how one measures can be quite a tricky & subjective topic. Quickly looking I seem to see softening at least after two stops on some of those shots. I'd be more interested in the results of the 135:2.8 APO/OSS vs other 135's with just IBIS. That will flesh out the real tradeoffs.


The 2nd post compares the same lens with only IBIS using it on the A72 and just IS using it on the 5D3. I think the IBIS images compare quite well to the IS based images. And this is at 200mm.

I too question why the addition of OSS into the Batis 85 and 135. I like it in the 85 as I shoot an A7R right now so it really helps out...but going forward I would think all Sony cameras will have IBIS.
Apr 09, 2017 at 11:04 AM
AGeoJO
Offline
Details
p.8 #4Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
I had (and already sold) a Sony/Minolta 500mm f/8 mirror or reflex lens in A-mount that I used briefly with the LA-EA4 on both the Sony A7 II and A7r II. I was very impressed with the effectiveness of the IBIS in reducing movement. I didn't have the ability to measure that effect in terms of f-stops but I could see the effect of stabilization clearly on the viewfinder. My guess would be at least 2-stops. Plus, yes, a stabilized system is not a substitute of having a faster shutter speed in minimizing object/model movement albeit at the cost of shallower depth-of-field, which can be a double-edged sword.

With that said, I am sure that the OSS built into the Batis 135mm lens will be effective, more effective than the IBIS alone. And there are folks that use cameras without IBIS. So, the OSS is a very welcome feature for them. Keep also in mind that the new iteration of the Sony E mount camera may have an improved IBIS, as well.
Apr 09, 2017 at 11:09 AM
rbf_
Offline
Details
p.8 #5Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
chez wrote:
rbf_ wrote
chez wroteHere is a thread right here on FM that talks about ibis. What is interesting is a couple of photographer that I respect actually claim the effectiveness of IBIS increases with focal length, resulting in 3 to 4 stops at 135mm.

One thing IBIS or OSS cannot fix is subject movement which is where a 1.8 lens really shines over a 2.8 lens allowing a faster shutter speed for the same ISO.

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1384518/0

Here is another test which shows the IBIS being very effective ( 4 stops ) at 200mm.

https://tysonrobichaudphotography.wordpress.com/2015/07/31/sony-5-axis-ibis-vs-ef-lens-based-is-vs-panasonic-2-axis-ibis-comparison/
Perhaps Sony & Zeiss have made a huge mistake here and put OSS in this lens for no added benefit I tend to think that would be illogical however.

BTW - how one measures can be quite a tricky & subjective topic. Quickly looking I seem to see softening at least after two stops on some of those shots. I'd be more interested in the results of the 135:2.8 APO/OSS vs other 135's with just IBIS. That will flesh out the real tradeoffs.
The 2nd post compares the same lens with only IBIS using it on the A72 and just IS using it on the 5D3. I think the IBIS images compare quite well to the IS based images. And this is at 200mm.

I too question why the addition of OSS into the Batis 85 and 135. I like it in the 85 as I shoot an A7R right now so it really helps out...but going forward I would think all Sony cameras will have IBIS.


One thing I've noticed was that there's some variability in the performance of different optical stabilization implementations with the general trend of newer implementations getting better all the time and different lens models performing to different levels. I'd beware of making really general opinions about specific optical stabilization performance across brands and lenses because of this. Fuji for example issues firmware updates for each lens and some of them have improved their OIS performance across the lens range, which I have found to be really good even when released. Other manufacturers will make you buy a new lens to get their latest optical stabilization technology. Either way each of your lenses could/likely will have a different limit and the shooters handholding technique plays into it as well. One thing I would say is that the engineers at Sony/Zeiss probably have pretty good handle on the complex relationship between IBIS & OSS as focal range increases and it should be interesting to see the IQ this new lens can offer when you need the stabilization.
Apr 09, 2017 at 11:25 AM
chez
Offline
Details
p.8 #6Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
rbf_ wrote:
chez wrote
rbf_ wrote
chez wroteHere is a thread right here on FM that talks about ibis. What is interesting is a couple of photographer that I respect actually claim the effectiveness of IBIS increases with focal length, resulting in 3 to 4 stops at 135mm.

One thing IBIS or OSS cannot fix is subject movement which is where a 1.8 lens really shines over a 2.8 lens allowing a faster shutter speed for the same ISO.

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1384518/0

Here is another test which shows the IBIS being very effective ( 4 stops ) at 200mm.

https://tysonrobichaudphotography.wordpress.com/2015/07/31/sony-5-axis-ibis-vs-ef-lens-based-is-vs-panasonic-2-axis-ibis-comparison/
Perhaps Sony & Zeiss have made a huge mistake here and put OSS in this lens for no added benefit I tend to think that would be illogical however.

BTW - how one measures can be quite a tricky & subjective topic. Quickly looking I seem to see softening at least after two stops on some of those shots. I'd be more interested in the results of the 135:2.8 APO/OSS vs other 135's with just IBIS. That will flesh out the real tradeoffs.
The 2nd post compares the same lens with only IBIS using it on the A72 and just IS using it on the 5D3. I think the IBIS images compare quite well to the IS based images. And this is at 200mm.

I too question why the addition of OSS into the Batis 85 and 135. I like it in the 85 as I shoot an A7R right now so it really helps out...but going forward I would think all Sony cameras will have IBIS.
One thing I've noticed was that there's some variability in the performance of different optical stabilization implementations with the general trend of newer implementations getting better all the time and different lens models performing to different levels. I'd beware of making really general opinions about specific optical stabilization performance across brands and lenses because of this. Fuji for example issues firmware updates for each lens and some of them have improved their OIS performance across the lens range, which I have found to be really good even when released. Other manufacturers will make you buy a new lens to get
...Show more →

Same will be true with IBIS as the technology gets perfected with each new camera release.

It wasn't too long ago here on FM there was a big discussion about IBIS and how it would be impossible for a full frame sensor as the mass to move around would be way too much. Technology has a way to figure things out.

Bottom line, with what I am seeing, it appears like IBIS is very effective at 135mm. That is one feature I'm looking at when upgrading to the A7R2 / A7R3.
Apr 09, 2017 at 11:27 AM
Parariss
Offline
Details
p.8 #7Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
At this focal length, having some sort of stabilization somewhere in the system is pretty important. A lot of the total e-mount body installed base which Zeiss might sell to doesn't have IBIS: first generation a7 series owners and the vast majority of those with APS-C cameras (whether as a primary or secondary body). [There's also no particular reason to believe that Sony won't continue to withhold IBIS from its entry level if not also its mid-market crop bodies to maintain product stratification -- Sony shipped the brand new a6300 knowing full well that the a6500 with IBIS would begin shipping less than a year later.] If Zeiss didn't include lens stabilization they would have been significantly limiting their number of prospective customers.

Moreover, even among owners of IBIS-enabled bodies, lens stabilization is a valuable product differentiator (which means it boosts both total sales quantity and earns higher unit gross margins). Even if IBIS+OSS were in truth no better than IBIS alone it wouldn't matter because that's not generally going to be the perception amongst buyers, and perception is reality.

OSS on board this 135 was a smart move, IMO, and I suspect we're going to continue to see OSS show up in longer focal lengths from both Zeiss and Sony, indefinitely.
Apr 09, 2017 at 01:37 PM
robgo2
Offline
Details
p.8 #8Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
As of this moment, 71 of 173 respondents show some level of interest in the new Batis lens. That's 41%, which I consider to be fairly high, so Zeiss planners must have read their marketplace fairly well. Of course, FM readers are probably not representative of the broader A7x user base, and I suspect that interest in that group as a whole is somewhat lower.
Apr 09, 2017 at 01:55 PM
AGeoJO
Offline
Details
p.8 #9Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
robgo2 wrote:
As of this moment, 71 of 173 respondents show some level of interest in the new Batis lens. That's 41%, which I consider to be fairly high, so Zeiss planners must have read their marketplace fairly well. Of course, FM readers are probably not representative of the broader A7x user base, and I suspect that interest in that group as a whole is somewhat lower.


Yes, that's one way of looking at it but another way would be only 7 respondents out of 193 and that's a paltry 4% will commit or have committed to get this lens. No, actually it would be more than that, as explained below.

I know you made a comment about the inclusion of the "Just view the result" group as skewing the result. The way I look at it, those are people that do not have or use a Sony system or visitors that roam to this Sony forum but they just want to see the result. That's the main reason for it being there. I would rather see them cast their vote in that round rather than randomly in any other groups that would skew the result without any backtracking. At least, we can backtrack this somewhat. So, yes, I agree with your notion and we can exclude those folks in that group. Yes, 41% is showing some level of interest but what percentage of that will end up buying the lens at the full retail price? Only time will tell....

I heard that notion of FMers not being representative thrown around more than just a few times. I am not saying that it is wrong or right but what are we basing that notion on? And who or which group is more representative then?
Apr 09, 2017 at 02:31 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.8 #10Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
robgo2 wrote:
As of this moment, 71 of 173 respondents show some level of interest in the new Batis lens. That's 41%, which I consider to be fairly high, so Zeiss planners must have read their marketplace fairly well. Of course, FM readers are probably not representative of the broader A7x user base, and I suspect that interest in that group as a whole is somewhat lower.


Funny how we see things differently here. What I see is out of your 41%, 30% do not like the features they get for the price Zeiss is asking. They basically said they will not buy at the current price level, so either they might pick one up used later on or Zeiss would have to drop the price on this lens.

It's like me voting for being interested in the GFX system...everything looks great except for the price. So even though I would love the GFX, I won't be buying it because of it's price...same logic.
Apr 09, 2017 at 02:59 PM
rico
Offline
Details
p.8 #11Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
I find A7ii IBIS to be ineffective at 300mm (alt prime), so in-lens IS has a role even for the latest Alpha 7 bodies. Am not sure if 135mm needs IS, but will test it today.
Apr 09, 2017 at 03:21 PM
virtualrain
Offline
Details
p.8 #12Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
It seems like Zeiss can expect to sell to about 10% of Sony enthusiasts. 4% will pre-order and another 7% after reviews confirm it's performance matches expectations. Over time another 10% may talk themselves and others into it. That would be the top 20% of Sony shooters and that's probably exactly where Zeiss wants to be. With the margins built into the price Zeiss will probably consider this a great success. This all seems to confirm Zeiss wants to position itself as an exclusive brand (no surprise there). My guess is that they felt their first two Batis products were also priced as exclusive high-end options but the overwhelming demand actually indicated they miss targeted the price point (on the low side). Rather than exclusive upmarket, the first two Batis lenses became mainstream options. After that Zeiss probably said "Note to self: price higher if you want to target the top 10-20% of buyers."

I think if Zeiss could do the first two Batis lens pricing over, they would be even higher.

The net is that I think this will be a success for Zeiss and the price is not ever likely to go down and future Batis products will likely be priced just as high.

I feel fortunate to have got my Batis 25 and 85 at what I feel are reasonable (but high) prices. They may be the last Batis products I own. It's a shame because their products are a good mix of performance and packaging for my needs. I just can't justify the current premium Zeiss is after here for a product that at f/2.8, doesn't offer me much utility or benefit vs cropping my 85. Hats off to the 10-20% of you that can justify this 135 f/2.8 at $2K and get enjoyment and utility from it.
Apr 09, 2017 at 03:48 PM
rbf_
Offline
Details
p.8 #13Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?


rico wrote:
I find A7ii IBIS to be ineffective at 300mm (alt prime), so in-lens IS has a role even for the latest Alpha 7 bodies. Am not sure if 135mm needs IS, but will test it today.


I'm interested to hear your results. I've always been intrigued by IBIS, it's a useful and cool technology even though it doesn't obsolete optical stabilization.
Apr 09, 2017 at 04:01 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.8 #14Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
virtualrain wrote:
It seems like Zeiss can expect to sell to about 10% of Sony enthusiasts. 4% will pre-order and another 7% after reviews confirm it's performance matches expectations. Over time another 10% may talk themselves and others into it. That would be the top 20% of Sony shooters and that's probably exactly where Zeiss wants to be. With the margins built into the price Zeiss will probably consider this a great success. This all seems to confirm Zeiss wants to position itself as an exclusive brand (no surprise there). My guess is that they felt their first two Batis products were
...Show more →

Given Sony's 85 and it's really aggressive pricing along with spectacular test results so far, I think Zeiss would be wise to see what Sony has up it's sleeves. Nothing like Sony coming out with a 135 2.8 that is lighter, much cheaper and just as good as the Batis to kill the little wind Zeiss has in the Batis 135.

I already have the Batis 85, bought it used for under $1,000. If Sony was out with their 85 when I was looking, the Batis would not even enter into the equation...the Sony 85 looks that good and at 1/2 the price of the Zeiss.

I can see the Zeiss Batis 85 demand drop drastically now that the Sony is released. If Sigma enters the native Sony mount competition, this will also weigh heavily on Zeiss boutique pricing.
Apr 09, 2017 at 04:15 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.8 #15Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
rico wrote:
I find A7ii IBIS to be ineffective at 300mm (alt prime), so in-lens IS has a role even for the latest Alpha 7 bodies. Am not sure if 135mm needs IS, but will test it today.


The test I posted a little while ago showed IBIS being very effective at the 135mm range...somewhere around 3 to 4 stops.
Apr 09, 2017 at 04:16 PM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.8 #16Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
chez wrote:
rico wroteI find A7ii IBIS to be ineffective at 300mm (alt prime), so in-lens IS has a role even for the latest Alpha 7 bodies. Am not sure if 135mm needs IS, but will test it today.
The test I posted a little while ago showed IBIS being very effective at the 135mm range...somewhere around 3 to 4 stops.


I've never seen a test of FF IBIS at *any* focal length that gives it 3-4 stops, even though Sony claim that. About two is usual. Exactly how effective it is depends a bit on details of the kind of vibration you have, how you hold the camera etc. so I suppose there could be some very usual interaction with your holding style. Of course exactly what "4 stops" means is also down to testing methodology. If you mean "doesn't look too bad sometimes 4 stops less than 1/FL" you will get one result, if you mean "indistinguishable from careful tripod mounting" you will get another.

At 135 in my tests (roughly my test is "usually likely to give me results I take to be critically sharp" at 135, on the APO Sonnar and my previous Canon, I get one stop at best. I do get a few of stops of visibly better viewfinder stability .- but that doesn't translate into critically sharp images. That one stop is pretty useful, nonetheless, but if OSS+IBIS gives us more (which it may not, I'm not sure it does on the Batis, though there's no way to test it directly) I'll be very grateful.
Apr 09, 2017 at 04:26 PM
Chris_88
Offline
Details
p.8 #17Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
AGeoJO wrote:
Yes, that's one way of looking at it but another way would be only 7 respondents out of 193 and that's a paltry 4% will commit or have committed to get this lens. No, actually it would be more than that, as explained below.

I know you made a comment about the inclusion of the "Just view the result" group as skewing the result. The way I look at it, those are people that do not have or use a Sony system or visitors that roam to this Sony forum but they just want to see the result. That's the main
...Show more →

Joshua, I think when people talk about us here not being representative, they talk about the larger DSLR and/or mirrorless market including soccer moms and what have you. I also think that we are not representative of that.

However, we are probably quite representative of the customer group that Zeiss, and depending on camera/lens, Sony too, are gunning for: Serious amateurs with affordable income and some pros. Folks like us who buy a larger number of more expensive (=higher margin?) lenses are probably more important to the companies' bottom line than somebody who buys an entry level DSLR bundled with one or two zooms at Walmart, even though there should still be far more people in the latter group, even in the age of smartphone cameras.
Apr 09, 2017 at 04:31 PM
charles.K
Offline
Details
p.8 #18Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
Another aspect is that the Zeiss Batis line have not opted for the fast lenses and left this for Sony, so f/2.8 is in line with the Batis philosophy. Market intelligence with the imminent release of the 135 Art may have further confirmed to Zeiss with the Batis 135 would need differentiate with a lighter lens. The market is decreasing so I am sure that Zeiss would be moving forward cautiously. The manufactured cost of a 135 f/2.8 lens is a lot cheaper than a f/1.8 and less risk overall for Zeiss. I am sure Sony will follow up with a GM 135
Apr 09, 2017 at 04:33 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.8 #19Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
charles.K wrote:
Another aspect is that the Zeiss Batis line have not opted for the fast lenses and left this for Sony, so f/2.8 is in line with the Batis philosophy. Market intelligence with the imminent release of the 135 Art may have further confirmed to Zeiss with the Batis 135 would need differentiate with a lighter lens. The market is decreasing so I am sure that Zeiss would be moving forward cautiously. The manufactured cost of a 135 f/2.8 lens is a lot cheaper than a f/1.8 and less risk overall for Zeiss. I am sure Sony will follow up with
...Show more →

I'd love to see Sony follow up with a 135 in the lines of their recently release 85 1.8.
Apr 09, 2017 at 04:39 PM
rico
Offline
Details
p.8 #20Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
rbf_ wrote:
I'm interested to hear your results. I've always been intrigued by IBIS, it's a useful and cool technology even though it doesn't obsolete optical stabilization.

Testing performed. I'm in agreement with @chez that 3-4 stops is achieved by A7ii IBIS at 135mm. Lens used was the Leitz Tele-Elmar 135/4. Specifically, 1/15s is drop-dead easy, while 1/8s is a 50% miss with best practices. I'm using pixel-peeping standards: a perfectly usable image at 4 stops slower than the 1/f Rule is captured every time if you are scaling down. These results are equivalent to my Nikkor 70-200/4 VR, so kudos to Sony.
Apr 09, 2017 at 05:33 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister