Fred Miranda wrote: pdmphoto wroteGMPhotography wroteAfter shooting the new 85 1.8 I realized how much I like the AF/MF switch. I'm constantly going back and forth and this keeps it simple and also keeps me out of the menu or Fn. Also I never been thrilled with Batis manual focusing. So I'm out and wait for something else. I know it could be endless. I do reserve the right to change my mind as you can never trust a lens whore on these buy matters. As a shooter who still mainly shoots manual focus lenses, I concur about the AF/MF switch. One of the best features on the Sony FE 50/1.4 also. I don't like having to dig into a menu, or try to figure out what mode I'm in after I pick up the camera to shoot.I agree that the MF/AF lens button is very helpful. However, with lenses that do not offer this option, it's possible to assign MF/AF to a custom button making it just as easy to switch focus mode from the camera.
My biggest gripe with both the MF/AF buttons and the focus hold buttons is that if you need to use these (I use MF/AF all the time, not focus hold, though I do use eyeAF) you need to assign them to a camera button anyway. Having done that, the lens buttons just make for inconsistency in the interface when you switch lenses. So in fact I usually don't use the lens buttons. A pity; if all AF lenses had them I would.
I can see how some would like to be able to look at the lens switch to see if MF is engaged. But for me there is a downside. Mostly I like 'sticky' settings. But sometimes, if I use the switch, it's still engaged after a few weeks and I put it on a camera and I'm expecting AF, but no. So I actually like a 'default' that reverts after a long period of time (with lenses I much prefer if the focus stays put when you turn the camera on and off. But I like it to default to infinity after removal from the lens)
By using the camera buttons for AF/MF you avoid this excess stickiness.
Parariss wrote: robgo2 wroteAGeoJO wroterobgo2 wroteAs of this moment, 71 of 173 respondents show some level of interest in the new Batis lens. That's 41%, which I consider to be fairly high, so Zeiss planners must have read their marketplace fairly well. Of course, FM readers are probably not representative of the broader A7x user base, and I suspect that interest in that group as a whole is somewhat lower.Yes, that's one way of looking at it but another way would be only 7 respondents out of 193 and that's a paltry 4% will commit or have committed to get this lens. No, actually it would be more than that, as explained below.21 out of 173 actual respondents are either committed to getting or are seriously interested in the Batis 135. That, in itself, isn't too bad. Another 50 are interested at a lower price. To me, that shows that a sizable number of Sony shooters would like to use this lens. If Zeiss wants to sell more lenses, all they have to do is reduce the price. It's purely a business decision.
RobCareful. What those figures actually show is something more like how there is interest among those shooters sufficiently active and enthusiastic as to be involved with gear forums at some level and additionally interested enough in the specific product to click on and participate in a forum discussion about it.
Of course, and I alluded to that fact in one of my earlier posts. Nevertheless, I don't think that the Batis line is aimed at the average Sony shooter.
DavidBM wrote: Fred Miranda wrotepdmphoto wroteGMPhotography wroteAfter shooting the new 85 1.8 I realized how much I like the AF/MF switch. I'm constantly going back and forth and this keeps it simple and also keeps me out of the menu or Fn. Also I never been thrilled with Batis manual focusing. So I'm out and wait for something else. I know it could be endless. I do reserve the right to change my mind as you can never trust a lens whore on these buy matters. As a shooter who still mainly shoots manual focus lenses, I concur about the AF/MF switch. One of the best features on the Sony FE 50/1.4 also. I don't like having to dig into a menu, or try to figure out what mode I'm in after I pick up the camera to shoot.I agree that the MF/AF lens button is very helpful. However, with lenses that do not offer this option, it's possible to assign MF/AF to a custom button making it just as easy to switch focus mode from the camera.My biggest gripe with both the MF/AF buttons and the focus hold buttons is that if you need to use these (I use MF/AF all the time, not focus hold, though I do use eyeAF) you need to assign them to a camera button anyway. Having done that, the lens buttons just make for inconsistency in the interface when you switch lenses. So in fact I usually don't use the lens buttons. A pity; if all AF lenses had them I would.
I can see how some would like to be able to look at the lens switch to see if MF is engaged. But for me there is a downside. Mostly I like 'sticky' settings. But sometimes, if I use the switch, it's still engaged after a few weeks and I put it on a camera and I'm expecting AF, but no. So I actually like a 'default' that reverts after a long period of time (with lenses I much prefer if the focus stays put when you turn the camera on and off. But I like it to default to infinity after removal from the lens)
By using the camera buttons for AF/MF you avoid this excess stickiness....Show more →
I really like the solution Fuji came up for this option by putting a dedicated selector switch for AF-S/AF-C/AF-M on all their bodies (usually in the same place). It's such a universally important setting it seems to make sense. I hadn't realized the manual interface on Sony lenses varied so much. They also let you AF in AF-S mode and then fine tune with MF without changing any setting, it's pretty cool.
rbf_ wrote: DavidBM wroteFred Miranda wrotepdmphoto wroteGMPhotography wroteAfter shooting the new 85 1.8 I realized how much I like the AF/MF switch. I'm constantly going back and forth and this keeps it simple and also keeps me out of the menu or Fn. Also I never been thrilled with Batis manual focusing. So I'm out and wait for something else. I know it could be endless. I do reserve the right to change my mind as you can never trust a lens whore on these buy matters. As a shooter who still mainly shoots manual focus lenses, I concur about the AF/MF switch. One of the best features on the Sony FE 50/1.4 also. I don't like having to dig into a menu, or try to figure out what mode I'm in after I pick up the camera to shoot.I agree that the MF/AF lens button is very helpful. However, with lenses that do not offer this option, it's possible to assign MF/AF to a custom button making it just as easy to switch focus mode from the camera.My biggest gripe with both the MF/AF buttons and the focus hold buttons is that if you need to use these (I use MF/AF all the time, not focus hold, though I do use eyeAF) you need to assign them to a camera button anyway. Having done that, the lens buttons just make for inconsistency in the interface when you switch lenses. So in fact I usually don't use the lens buttons. A pity; if all AF lenses had them I would.
I can see how some would like to be able to look at the lens switch to see if MF is engaged. But for me there is a downside. Mostly I like 'sticky' settings. But sometimes, if I use the switch, it's still engaged after a few weeks and I put it on a camera and I'm expecting AF, but no. So I actually like a 'default' that reverts after a long period of time (with lenses I much prefer if the focus stays put when you turn the camera on and off. But I like it to default to infinity after removal from the lens)
By using the camera buttons for AF/MF you avoid this excess stickiness.I really like the solution Fuji came up for this option by putting a dedicated selector switch for AF-S/AF-C/AF-M on all their bodies (usually in the same place). It's such a universally important setting it seems to make sense. I hadn't realized the manual interface on Sony lenses varied so much. They also let you AF in AF-S mode and then fine tune with MF without changing any setting, it's pretty cool.
Agreed that a selector switch on the body is good, but in effect there is one on Sony since you can program one of the buttons. Of course, more programmable switches and buttons would be welcome. There are more things I'd like direct access to. But I don't think dedicated buttons or switches are the go: they are useless to people who don't care about those particular settings. (Maybe Fuji is programmable? I don't know)
Sony also allows you to do the AF with fine tuning without changing a setting (it's called DMF). But you don't *have* to make it work that way - it's your choice whether to enable it or not. (but once enabled that's how it works)
DavidBM wrote: rbf_ wroteDavidBM wroteFred Miranda wrotepdmphoto wroteGMPhotography wroteAfter shooting the new 85 1.8 I realized how much I like the AF/MF switch. I'm constantly going back and forth and this keeps it simple and also keeps me out of the menu or Fn. Also I never been thrilled with Batis manual focusing. So I'm out and wait for something else. I know it could be endless. I do reserve the right to change my mind as you can never trust a lens whore on these buy matters. As a shooter who still mainly shoots manual focus lenses, I concur about the AF/MF switch. One of the best features on the Sony FE 50/1.4 also. I don't like having to dig into a menu, or try to figure out what mode I'm in after I pick up the camera to shoot.I agree that the MF/AF lens button is very helpful. However, with lenses that do not offer this option, it's possible to assign MF/AF to a custom button making it just as easy to switch focus mode from the camera.My biggest gripe with both the MF/AF buttons and the focus hold buttons is that if you need to use these (I use MF/AF all the time, not focus hold, though I do use eyeAF) you need to assign them to a camera button anyway. Having done that, the lens buttons just make for inconsistency in the interface when you switch lenses. So in fact I usually don't use the lens buttons. A pity; if all AF lenses had them I would.
I can see how some would like to be able to look at the lens switch to see if MF is engaged. But for me there is a downside. Mostly I like 'sticky' settings. But sometimes, if I use the switch, it's still engaged after a few weeks and I put it on a camera and I'm expecting AF, but no. So I actually like a 'default' that reverts after a long period of time (with lenses I much prefer if the focus stays put when you turn the camera on and off. But I like it to default to infinity after removal from the lens)
By using the camera buttons for AF/MF you avoid this excess stickiness.I really like the solution Fuji came up for this option by putting a dedicated selector switch for AF-S/AF-C/AF-M on all their bodies (usually in the same place). It's such a universally important setting it seems to make sense. I hadn't realized the manual interface on Sony lenses varied so much. They also let you AF in AF-S mode and then fine tune with MF without changing any setting, it's pretty cool.Agreed that a selector switch on the body is good, but in effect there is one on Sony since you can program one of the buttons. Of course, more programmable switches and buttons would be welcome. There are more things I'd like direct access to. But I don't think dedicated buttons or switches are the go: they are useless to people who don't care about those particular settings. (Maybe Fuji is programmable? I don't know)
Sony also allows you to do the AF with fine tuning without changing a setting (it's called DMF). But you don't *have* to make it work that way - it's your choice whether to enable it or not. (but once enabled that's how it works)...Show more →
I think a prudent mix of dedicated controls and programmable controls is the right way to go(I think AF modes should be dedicated). Of course you can argue forever about exactly what the exactly right mix is but in the end it is a good discussion to have It seems that a good mix of consistency with flexibility is the ultimate goal.