fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2017 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2017Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?

  
 
chez
Offline
Details
p.3 #1Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
I still think the 55 1.8 is way overpriced as well.
Apr 06, 2017 at 10:53 AM
Steve Spencer
Online
Details
p.3 #2Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
chez wrote:
I still think the 55 1.8 is way overpriced as well.


And of course you are entitled to your view just as everyone else is, but it seems to me a lot of people are pretty happy with the 55 f/1.8 as a general purpose lens even at its price.
Apr 06, 2017 at 10:58 AM
artur5
Offline
Details
p.3 #3Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
Finally you gave yourself away. You work for Zeiss !
Now, seriously; even taking into account that 98mm. refer to the hood diameter, and the focusing ring is 81mm. it's definitively the hugest 135/2.8 ever made, only rivaled by the Contax 135/2.8, another fat product from Zeiss. Consider that the Canon EF 135/2. being a stop faster, has the same girth of this Batis..
Instead, at 614 gr isn't heavy at all. A lens of this size should weight twice; so we must assume that there's plenty of plastic and empty space inside.
I stand to my points. Too slow for portraits because there're several other excellent 135/2-1.8 out there, of the same size or smaller and much cheaper. Not a lens that I'd like to carry in a travel bag either, when every square inch of room is needed for fitting as much lenses/bodies as possible..
Apr 06, 2017 at 11:10 AM
CBokeh
Offline
Details
p.3 #4Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
There's no "I'll wait for the $1k Sony 135 with nearly the same performance and free extra button" option in the poll.
Apr 06, 2017 at 11:51 AM
Makten
Offline
Details
p.3 #5Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
I'm completely uninterested, only because of the focal length. I don't really see the use for a fixed lens, that long, unless it's cheap and small.

The longer the lens, the harder it gets to get a decent composition since you can't change the perspective by just taking a few steps to get a different photo. You have to move A LOT to get exactly what you want.
Hence I'd want a zoom for sort of everything longer than ~100 mm, while I like primes for shorter lenses.

The price might be high, but that's not the problem here.
Apr 06, 2017 at 12:33 PM
Steve Spencer
Online
Details
p.3 #6Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
artur5 wrote:
Finally you gave yourself away. You work for Zeiss !
Now, seriously; even taking into account that 98mm. refer to the hood diameter, and the focusing ring is 81mm. it's definitively the hugest 135/2.8 ever made, only rivaled by the Contax 135/2.8, another fat product from Zeiss. Consider that the Canon EF 135/2. being a stop faster, has the same girth of this Batis..
Instead, at 614 gr isn't heavy at all. A lens of this size should weight twice; so we must assume that there's plenty of plastic and empty space inside.
I stand to my points. Too slow for
...Show more →

No, I don't work for Zeiss, but I do have a lot of their lenses . Yes, it is the biggest 135 f/2.8 lens, but it is also by far the best corrected 135 f/2.8, so some bigger size is expected. And yes, Batis lenses have a lot of plastic which isn't my favorite aspect of them. I am sure Roger at the lens rentals blog will do a teardown at some point and we will see how much empty space is inside, but I don't expect all that much.

Now I would have no objection whatsoever if you said that you didn't want the lens because it is slower than some other 135mm lenses and you appreciate that speed. It is not as fast as you would like for portraits. That is a relative statement and as a preference is nothing I would ever quibble about. You said, however, that it was "too slow for portraits." In my view that is just not a very sensible argument. As I said at their respective minimum focus distance it has less depth of field than the Sony/Zeiss 50 f/1.4, so if it is depth of field that you are worried about and this lens has too little then all lenses wider than 50mm are too slow for portraits and at 50mm you need an f/1.2 aperture or wider aperture or your lens is too slow for portraits. That to me does not seem like a sensible argument, and if it is exposure you are worried about, then the high ISO capabilities of Sony cameras really should alleviate your worries. If this lens is too slow in terms of exposure on the A7r II or A7s for portraits, then 10 years ago literally all lenses were too slow for portraiture. Again not a very sensible argument. You made an absolute statement about its ability for portraits and the absolute statement (it is too slow for portraits) just doesn't hold up if you look at it closely. If you want to make it a relative statement (your view and what you would like), then by all means stick to it but one would hope that you could at least realize that the absolute statement you made is very much an overstatement.
Apr 06, 2017 at 04:52 PM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.3 #7Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
Jannik Peters wrote:
I have voted " I am not interested in that lens regardless of the price " although I miss the option "I would have been interested if it would have been half the price".

I honestly don't care if the lens has got 4 or 11 ED lenses - I can't really ask for more than the Rokinon 2/135's performance and I would have maybe paid double it's price for a 1 stop slower and almost equally heavy lens with AF and better build quality... But 4 times the price? Does this lens also cook coffee and make fire?

Sorry,
...Show more →

Fair enough. Jannik.
I agree that it's unlikely to be significantly higher in IQ than the Samyang (a good copy, and the good copy has to stay good unlike any of my Samyangs) or indeed the Sigma.

And I agree that it's a lot of money (though the way some people seem to think they know the fair price, or the right price for stuff without knowing the market size, expected sales, exact production costs, marketing costs etc is beyond me -- I know this doesn't apply to you though!)

So the question is: why am I prepared to pay 4x the Samyang for AF, better build, maybe higher contrast, and a weight reduction (maybe 200g if an adapted Samyang) that is not huge, but significant to me for travel?

Partly because this is exactly what I have been wanting for a long time. Someone else said that primes should be small and cheap or else super fast. Many people think that; I don't. In fact a slower prime that's super good (and that doesn't mean necessarily *better* that the premium fast ones, but at least as good, rather than less good like the small cheap ones) is what I want. Significantly smaller than the fast ones or a fast zoom, if not as small as one designed to trade off other qualities against size. All that with eye AF which for a 135 is a big win for my taste.

So I definitely want it.

But the price?

Well if I though that there would be a USD800 Sony version like the 85 out in a year I wouldn't buy it. On the assumption that that would be about as sharp, with slightly lesser colour correction and flare control (just projecting from the 85 situation - who knows if that would be correct) I wouldn't pay the extra 1200 (well if the Ca and flare were very different.....).

But I don't think there will be. Why? Because 2.8/135 lenses are *very* unpopular. There is no AF one current in anyone's line up. And no MF one either, come to think of it, unless the 3.4/135 APO Telyt counts. For all the reasons that many forumers have given people don't want them (overlaps with fast zoom, prefer primes only for super fast, prefer zooms for composition at a distance). 1.8/85 lenses, though, are reliable sellers in everyone's line. So it's these days a niche lens, that I doubt Sony will make in the foreseeable future (I'll bet we see a 2 or 1.8/135 GM though)

So if I want this lens I have been hoping for after all this time, I think this is likely the only option. And modulo some cats eyes, it looks like it's optically the sort of lens that you can't improve on visibly.

But of course I'm not saying that reasons people have given that they don't want a lens like this aren't valid; and of course how *much* you want it (together with available resources) determines whether you are prepared to pay the sticker price. For me, once I've sold the f2 APO sonnar, the upgrade (or is that downgrade?) price is, just, bearable, given that I do want it a lot...

Apr 06, 2017 at 05:47 PM
ecarlino
Offline
Details
p.3 #8Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
DavidBM wrote:
So the question is: why am I prepared to pay 4x the Samyang for AF, better build, maybe higher contrast, and a weight reduction (maybe 200g if an adapted Samyang) that is not huge, but significant to me for travel?


David, I've never handled a Samyang, but i think using their prices as a 'baseline' is somewhat of a stretch given the difference in construction and QC - i posted on the other thread while you were sleeping in Australia and I had nothing better to do today:

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1484189/5#13989794
Apr 06, 2017 at 06:10 PM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.3 #9Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
ecarlino wrote:
DavidBM wroteSo the question is: why am I prepared to pay 4x the Samyang for AF, better build, maybe higher contrast, and a weight reduction (maybe 200g if an adapted Samyang) that is not huge, but significant to me for travel?
David, I've never handled a Samyang, but i think using their prices as a 'baseline' is somewhat of a stretch given the difference in construction and QC - i posted on the other thread while you were sleeping in Australia and I had nothing better to do today:

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1484189/5#13989794


I don't disagree; the odds of getting a good one (though the 135 is a bit better in this regard than some, according to many) is not great, and the chance of it *staying* great doesn't seem that good either (I've had both troubles with Sammy stuff.

It's frustrating because some of their optical designs are terrific. If they made them a bit better...

I guess the problem is what a guy I met in Qingdao who was a manufacturer called the Chinese Manufacturer Problem, which may also apply to anyone without a great reputation for quality. Sure you could make the lens massively better for 10% more. So if you change 20% more to cover that, you are no longer cheap enough to trade on price. So your sales drop to half. So now you have to increase the price by 50% to get enough margin to cover design and fixed manufacturing costs. But now your sales drop, and before you know it your price is close to the premium brand, and no-one will will buy your product.

Sammy are trying to get out of this bind with their "premium" line still cheaper than the majors, but with the promise of better construction (and great optical design). Good luck to them! When some of these are made native for mirrorless I'll be there ... but their AF for Sony models seem to be competing on price still, and by all accounts are very variable (I had high hopes for the 14, but reports seem to be that it's as variable as the MF one)
Apr 06, 2017 at 06:38 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.3 #10Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
Folks not sure why everyone keeps referring to Samyang 135 . They do not have a native FE mount. There is the Rokinon 135 that does, NO adapter needed. Secondly it's getting a little old hearing about lens construction and Constryction issues. I have had three of these and it's built very well and all three copies I have had where as sharp as the next. Sure Samyang may have a bad name on somelenses but I have yet to see a issue with the 135. Not that I really care but there is a shit load of whining here about them . Not sure it's deserved with the Rokinon135. I see no CA issues but just really nice sharpness across the frame even at the wider apertures. I think it deserves a lot more credit it's been given. You know I'm pretty good at knowing lenses and I think this generalizing sometimes is not the best way to describe it. Just sayin. I'm still thinking about this Batis but what NO ONE has brought up in the 3 or 4 threads here and I'm actually shocked no one brought up how this manually focuses and most users are landscape shooters. That's the first question I ask when buying a AF lens and especially Batis since I find the manual focus sucks really bad as it has no feel whatsoever. Yes I'm old school used REAL manual lenses my whole career but if it does not have any feel I run away. I had both the 25 and 85 nice lenses but they have no feel. Why I sold them. Is this lens any different. Forget price forget everything if it don't feel good in your hands it's worthless. Again it's about performance.
Apr 06, 2017 at 06:50 PM
DannyBurkPhoto
Offline
Details
p.3 #11Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
Agreed very much, Guy, re: FWB. I'd never used it before and bought the S-Z 55/1.8 at the same time as the A7RII, just so I could try a native lens in addition to adapted Canon mount lenses. Shortly after, there was a $100 price reduction on the S-Z 16-35, so I bought that too.

I can't say enough times how much I hate FBW, as I discovered when trying to focus the 55. The zoom didn't seem as bad (have others here found that the 55/1.8 is particularly nasty in that regard??), but I ended up selling both. I'd probably have kept the zoom, but testing showed that my adapted Canon 16-35/4 was much better at the ends of the frame, even with the adapter.

I have one other AF lens, a Batis 25. Again, it doesn't seem quite as nasty to focus as the 55, and I've kept it just because it's otherwise very good. I never use it, though, and I keep thinking that I should probably sell it. Maybe replace it with a 25/2 ZE mount, although that's probably overkill since I already have a 28/2 ZE too.
Apr 06, 2017 at 07:10 PM
Faulta
Offline
Details
p.3 #12Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
Only quick opinion on samyang quality. In my experience, it varies from lens to lens. The 14mm, and 85mm, I would describe as very poor. My 14mm was literally falling apart in my hands.. really. My 85 had a lot of "leaks" I guess, I don't know what exactly happened but after half a year it was full of dust. Not only a little, I mean full of dust. The 35mm I used once, not mine, seemed to have a loose part in it, you could hear something when shaking the lens. Image quality was not as good as expected, really soft.
Those behaviors seems to be the case for most of their traditional DSLR lenses. You can read them all over the internet. And I'm definitely not a fan and won't be buying any of them anymore.

The mirrorless aps-c lineup however is somewhat different. There is definitely more metal in the construction and they feel good in the hand. But oh Lord can they be decentered. It's unbelievable what they sell. BUT, it's a step better than the DSLR lineup and optically they are really good (good amount of ca though), once you have a copy that is not decentered, I think it will last longer than any AF lens.

The 135, I would consider as their best lens even if it's a DSLR lens. I only bought one copy and kept it because it's almost perfect optically. It's sharp across the frame on F2, no decentering at all, good contrast, it's basically apo even if it's not written on the lens AND it's a heavy solid construction. I dropped it once, on the carpet but still from about two feet, and could not find any damage on the lens and no damage in optical quality. Also I never heard of serve decentering issues with this lens. The lens seems to vary from pretty good to pretty awesome.
But still it's nowhere near Zeiss build quality. So of course you cannot compare those lenses. Also it's very unlikely, that the quality control is better with the 135mm. It's more likely that they managed to get a relaxed optical design that is not much affected by misaligned lenses. For longer lenses that's the case anyways. And I'm pretty sure that there are bad 135mm samyang lenses out there.
And last point, the 135mm is the most expensive non premium line lens they offer. New on Amazon it's 650 Euros in Germany (it's sold as "walimex pro"), that's a lot for a samyang manual focus lens. Put on top of that 200 for quality control, 100 for IS, 200 for all metal design, 200 for AF, 100 for better coatings, 100 for even better optical design with more aspherical elements and you have a 1500€ lens. You would probably get something like the sigma art series.
There is always a reason that something costs less than something else. It all comes down to your personal needs and if you can life with the drawbacks.
Apr 06, 2017 at 07:25 PM
ecarlino
Offline
Details
p.3 #13Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
GMPhotography wrote:
Folks not sure why everyone keeps referring to Samyang 135 . They do not have a native FE mount. There is the Rokinon 135 that does, NO adapter needed.

Secondly it's getting a little old hearing about lens construction and Constryction issues.
Not that I really care but there is a shit load of whining here about them .


Guy,

Is there really a substantial difference in quality (or anything else?) between Samyang and Rokinon (other than the fact that @ 135, it's branded Rokinon for the native FE mount)? Aren't they all part of the same conglomerate?

I always thought (but had no reason to think this) that Rokinon was a touch higher in QC, but Roger said this of the Rokinon 14mm: "I will note, this is held together inside with plastic, glue, and small screws. You won’t be using it for years. But the price of a new one is less than the price of a repair on a Nikon 14-24 f/2.8." My impression of Roger is that he doesn't make stuff up nor exaggerate.

As far as "getting a little old" - there has not been a discussion for the past year that you haven't chimed in on the QC issues of the Zony FE 35/1.4 (which is fine) - but, the conversation about QC wrt to the 135mm has been going on for less than 24 hours. Why can't people point out that the Samyang/Rokinon lenses are built to a lower standard and that partially explains the price differential (which was the reason I brought it up in the first place), which is clearly an outlier (in a good way).

I hold you and your experience in the highest regards, but just because you have not had a bad experience with a particular lens does not prove anything. In fact, this is a case where proving the counterfactual from your experience is quite easy because there are a lot of reports from extremely qualified sources (e.g. Roger as mentioned above and others) as well as the peanut gallery on various forums that regularly report QC issues with a variety of Samyang/Rokinon lenses.

Not only do I think it's fairly obvious that they are designed and built to a lower standard - but I also don't think it's an issue (particularly wrt to pricing), because as several have said - you're not paying for a higher standard. But, people should understand the expected life differentials between various brands and/or product lines within brands.

From Moonstruck, Cosmo Castorini:
"There are three kinds of pipe. There's what you have, which is garbage - and you can see where that's gotten you. There's bronze, which is pretty good, unless something goes wrong. And something always goes wrong. Then, there's copper, which is the only pipe I use. It costs money. It costs money because it saves money."
Apr 06, 2017 at 08:17 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.3 #14Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
I just not heard much about the IQ problems with the 135 . Others yes 14 and so on. But when I had my issues with the Sony 35 I did not take it out on the company as a whole. I only picked on that one lens. Here we are talking about a brand in total. Sure it's built below others standards and the price point surely says that. We all know you get what you pay for but that does not explain what many users here say about the 135. Over performer here. I just wanted to express more the separation from the general brand name. We are on the topic of the 135mm and we should keep it in that focal length about the differences between 135 brands that are available to us. Between these three threads it's all over the map. Just sayin. I'll let everyone weigh in on this lens. I said what I thought was important . This will take some thought for me. Seriously if this was a 200 2.8 there be no discussion for me I would be pushing all of you out of line to get it first.

I'm not fond of renting that 70-200 two or more times a year . Just rather own a 200 2.8 native lens. Wish they take the old Minolta 200 2.8 HS lens and use that but the chemicals used to make that glass are no longer legal to use from what I understand.

ecarlino wrote:
GMPhotography wroteFolks not sure why everyone keeps referring to Samyang 135 . They do not have a native FE mount. There is the Rokinon 135 that does, NO adapter needed.

Secondly it's getting a little old hearing about lens construction and Constryction issues.
Not that I really care but there is a shit load of whining here about them .
Guy,

Is there really a substantial difference in quality (or anything else?) between Samyang and Rokinon (other than the fact that @ 135, it's branded Rokinon for the native FE mount)? Aren't they all part of the same conglomerate?

I always thought (but had no reason to think this) that Rokinon was a touch higher in QC, but Roger said this of the Rokinon 14mm: "I will note, this is held together inside with plastic, glue, and small screws. You won’t be using it for years. But the price of a new one is less than the price of a repair
...Show more →
Apr 06, 2017 at 08:33 PM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.3 #15Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
GMPhotography wrote:
Folks not sure why everyone keeps referring to Samyang 135 . They do not have a native FE mount. There is the Rokinon 135 that does, NO adapter needed. Secondly it's getting a little old hearing about lens construction and Constryction issues. I have had three of these and it's built very well and all three copies I have had where as sharp as the next. Sure Samyang may have a bad name on somelenses but I have yet to see a issue with the 135. Not that I really care but there is a shit load of whining here
...Show more →

Hi Guy
Yes you can get the Samyang branded version of the f2 135 in native FE mount; I've used it!

They all come out of the same factory - the Samyang factory - but in the US are imported by a company that calls them Rokinon because that was a historic name they used for off brand stuff. In Europe the same thing is done by a different company that brands them Bower. There are a couple of other brand labels on these lenses.

Which one you should buy depends on who your local distributer is that will honour the warranty. In the US that's Rokinon. But here in Australia, for example, you must buy the Samyang labelled one if you want good warranty service or repair (and also in most of Asia including Korea where they are made)

As for the QC there's some evidence the QC is better on these 135 lenses than on their other ones; you for example, contribute to that - but that's a sample of a few.

So I hope that it has improved a lot. But I, and others I know, have been BADLY burned on the Rokinon/Samyang quality, not just in getting a good one (where it makes the worse Sonys look good) but also on it *staying* good.

You are right that's on other lenses. But I don't think people can be blamed for being a bit cautious who have had that experience until and unless there's much more evidence that things have improved. Especially if they live in countries where returning lenses is much less easy than in the US.

That's not to say it's not worth the money, or that the lottery is not worth playing. It's a smoking bargain and an optically great lens. But I can see how some wouldn't want to play.

As for the manual focus experience, I know some people don't enjoy MF on the Batis series. I don't *enjoy* it either. It's not as fun as a well damped coupled helicoid. But in landscape situations I actually find the MF on Batis more accurate and quick than traditional MF. Once you get used to the variable speed you can get it roughly right really fast, and then can focus far more precisely as the effective travel increases for fine tuning. Now until your brain and fingers get used to variable speed focussing, it's a mess, and I can see some not wanting to mess up their finely tuned helicoid reflexes, but if you want to learn that kind of MF I think it's better. Practically better. I agree it's not as 'satisfying' somehow.
Apr 06, 2017 at 08:39 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.3 #16Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
Thanks David. Yes I know the names fall under the same company. I guess I never saw a Samyang listed here in the states as a FE mount. Maybe why I was wondering which one was being talked about. I had a Samyang 14 which looked like a fisheye with distortion. Was cheaply made but worse the focusing was really weird.
Apr 06, 2017 at 08:45 PM
ecarlino
Offline
Details
p.3 #17Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
GMPhotography wrote:
I just not heard much about the IQ problems with the 135 . Others yes 14 and so on. But when I had my issues with the Sony 35 I did not take it out on the company as a whole. I only picked on that one lens. Here we are talking about a brand in total. Sure it's built below others standards and the price point surely says that. We all know you get what you pay for but that does not explain what many users here say about the 135. Over performer here. I just wanted to express
...Show more →

It's also not just about 'reported problems' - my primary point was in the targeted level of design/construction - specifically Roger's point about the sort of construction that the company tends to use - which I was relating to price point. And that IS a company wide thing with them (that's sort of their brand, so it's fair to characterize them as such) - it's not as if their other lenses are falling apart and the 135 is priced similarly but going to somehow magically last forever

Whereas with Sony there seems to be a variance in how certain lenses are designed (Roger's also done a great job of showing us why certain designs lead to more common problems, eg the Zony 35/1.4 - in that case, it seemed like the optical engineers were almost reaching too far and striving for too tight of tolerances and the guys tasked with actually designing the housing etc were in a bad spot to start with - so that ends up being more lens by lens)

Again, I'm not saying what's good or bad, but rather just what is or isn't. In other areas of my life, i'm usually buying a Rokinon product (my family will tell you that i'm a pretty cheap bastard - but really my general philosophy is i buy the 80% solution that costs 20% the price) but I also am in the business of comparing assets of similar but not identical characteristics (that is what us bond arbitrage geeks do) and coming up with a fair way to evaluate their relative prices.

And I was simply pointing out to the chorus who wants to say that $2000 is empirically too much for a 135/2.8 lens because there exists a 135/2 lens for $400 that there are many factors that cause that differential - everyone was quick to point out that Zeiss was 'obviously' overpriced - but nobody wanted to discuss that while optically they were comparable (in fact the Rokinon could be considered better in some/all respects) that there definitely exists a huge difference in specification for the quality of construction and parts used - and that has to be noted to explain a good portion of the difference.

So, while I appreciate that you point out "we all know that you get what you pay for" - during the past 24hrs while everyone was bashing $2000 for the Zeiss and praising $400 for the Rokinon, nobody was acknowledging that according to some, you may end up having to purchase 2 or 4 of them during the same time that the Zeiss keeps on ticking.

Edited on Apr 06, 2017 at 09:37 PM · View previous versions
Apr 06, 2017 at 09:05 PM
ecarlino
Offline
Details
p.3 #18Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
DavidBM wrote:
It's frustrating because some of their optical designs are terrific. If they made them a bit better...

I guess the problem is what a guy I met in Qingdao who was a manufacturer called the Chinese Manufacturer Problem, which may also apply to anyone without a great reputation for quality. Sure you could make the lens massively better for 10% more. So if you change 20% more to cover that, you are no longer cheap enough to trade on price. So your sales drop to half. So now you have to increase the price by 50% to get enough margin to
...Show more →

David - that is a brilliant conversation you related - that should be used as a case study in grad school.
Apr 06, 2017 at 09:15 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.3 #19Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
Well even though I maybe praising the Rokinon, I still see the value of the Batis even at 2k. It hurts my wallet but I'm willing to pay the piper if it's what I'm after. Price is secondary to me even though important for me it's what I can do with it that counts more. Yea I may bitch about the price but I have spent far more on lenses that I don't want to even think about, actually I like to try and forget. Don't tell my wife but I have bought a few well over 8 grand each. Those days involved the best money can buy than you realize your really only buying a 10 percent gain in performance than reality comes to light about value.

But we are off topic. I do want to rent this from Roger before I commit to it. My thoughts are right now to look at the Sony 85 1.8 coming tomorrow and see what it can do. I really needed a 50mm on this job or I needed a tilt lens. So I'm bouncing this whole 50,85,135 around right now

ecarlino wrote:
GMPhotography wroteI just not heard much about the IQ problems with the 135 . Others yes 14 and so on. But when I had my issues with the Sony 35 I did not take it out on the company as a whole. I only picked on that one lens. Here we are talking about a brand in total. Sure it's built below others standards and the price point surely says that. We all know you get what you pay for but that does not explain what many users here say about the 135. Over performer here. I just wanted to express more the separation from the general brand name. We are on the topic of the 135mm and we should keep it in that focal length about the differences between 135 brands that are available to us. Between these three threads it's all over the map. Just sayin. I'll let everyone weigh in on this lens. I said what I thought was important . This will take some thought for me. Seriously if this was a 200 2.8 there be no discussion for me I would be pushing all of you out of line to get it first.

I'm not fond of renting that 70-200 two or more times a year . Just rather own a 200 2.8 native lens. Wish they take the old Minolta 200 2.8 HS lens and use that but the chemicals used to make that glass are no longer legal to use from what I understand.
It's also not just about 'reported problems' - my primary point was in the targeted level of design/construction - specifically Roger's point about the sort of construction that the company tends to use - which I was relating to price point. And that IS a company wide thing with them (that's sort of their brand, so it's fair to characterize them as such)

Whereas with Sony there seems to be a variance in how certain lenses are designed (Roger's also done a great job of showing us why certain designs lead to more common problems, eg the Zony 35/1.4 -
...Show more →
Apr 06, 2017 at 09:37 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.3 #20Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
DavidBM wrote:
GMPhotography wroteFolks not sure why everyone keeps referring to Samyang 135 . They do not have a native FE mount. There is the Rokinon 135 that does, NO adapter needed. Secondly it's getting a little old hearing about lens construction and Constryction issues. I have had three of these and it's built very well and all three copies I have had where as sharp as the next. Sure Samyang may have a bad name on somelenses but I have yet to see a issue with the 135. Not that I really care but there is a shit load of whining here about them . Not sure it's deserved with the Rokinon135. I see no CA issues but just really nice sharpness across the frame even at the wider apertures. I think it deserves a lot more credit it's been given. You know I'm pretty good at knowing lenses and I think this generalizing sometimes is not the best way to describe it. Just sayin. I'm still thinking about this Batis but what NO ONE has brought up in the 3 or 4 threads here and I'm actually shocked no one brought up how this manually focuses and most users are landscape shooters. That's the first question I ask when buying a AF lens and especially Batis since I find the manual focus sucks really bad as it has no feel whatsoever. Yes I'm old school used REAL manual lenses my whole career but if it does not have any feel I run away. I had both the 25 and 85 nice lenses but they have no feel. Why I sold them. Is this lens any different. Forget price forget everything if it don't feel good in your hands it's worthless. Again it's about performance.
Hi Guy
Yes you can get the Samyang branded version of the f2 135 in native FE mount; I've used it!

They all come out of the same factory - the Samyang factory - but in the US are imported by a company that calls them Rokinon because that was a historic name they used for off brand stuff. In Europe the same thing is done by a different company that brands them Bower. There are a couple of other brand labels on these lenses.

Which one you should buy depends on who your local distributer is that will honour the warranty. In
...Show more →

David,
In your experience using the Batis 'digital scale'...when you hit the infinity symbol, is it accurate?
Apr 06, 2017 at 09:43 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister