rico wrote: rbf_ wroteI'm interested to hear your results. I've always been intrigued by IBIS, it's a useful and cool technology even though it doesn't obsolete optical stabilization.Testing performed. I'm in agreement with @chez@ that 3-4 stops is achieved by A7ii IBIS at 135mm. Lens used was the Leitz Tele-Elmar 135/4. Specifically, 1/15s is drop-dead easy, while 1/8s is a 50% miss with best practices. I'm using pixel-peeping standards: a perfectly usable image at 4 stops slower than the 1/f Rule is captured every time if you are scaling down. These results are equivalent to my Nikkor 70-200/4 VR, so kudos to Sony.
You concur what other test and people are saying about the IBIS and focal lengths up to 200mm. Thanks for doing this test. Really got me interested in the Sigma 135 with an A7R2 camera for theatre / concert photography.
chez wrote: virtualrain wroteIt seems like Zeiss can expect to sell to about 10% of Sony enthusiasts. 4% will pre-order and another 7% after reviews confirm it's performance matches expectations. Over time another 10% may talk themselves and others into it. That would be the top 20% of Sony shooters and that's probably exactly where Zeiss wants to be. With the margins built into the price Zeiss will probably consider this a great success. This all seems to confirm Zeiss wants to position itself as an exclusive brand (no surprise there). My guess is that they felt their first two Batis products were also priced as exclusive high-end options but the overwhelming demand actually indicated they miss targeted the price point (on the low side). Rather than exclusive upmarket, the first two Batis lenses became mainstream options. After that Zeiss probably said "Note to self: price higher if you want to target the top 10-20% of buyers."
I think if Zeiss could do the first two Batis lens pricing over, they would be even higher.
The net is that I think this will be a success for Zeiss and the price is not ever likely to go down and future Batis products will likely be priced just as high.
I feel fortunate to have got my Batis 25 and 85 at what I feel are reasonable (but high) prices. They may be the last Batis products I own. It's a shame because their products are a good mix of performance and packaging for my needs. I just can't justify the current premium Zeiss is after here for a product that at f/2.8, doesn't offer me much utility or benefit vs cropping my 85. Hats off to the 10-20% of you that can justify this 135 f/2.8 at $2K and get enjoyment and utility from it.Given Sony's 85 and it's really aggressive pricing along with spectacular test results so far, I think Zeiss would be wise to see what Sony has up it's sleeves. Nothing like Sony coming out with a 135 2.8 that is lighter, much cheaper and just as good as the Batis to kill the little wind Zeiss has in the Batis 135.
I already have the Batis 85, bought it used for under $1,000. If Sony was out with their 85 when I was looking, the Batis would not even enter into the equation...the Sony 85 looks that good and at 1/2 the price of the Zeiss.
I can see the Zeiss Batis 85 demand drop drastically now that the Sony is released. If Sigma enters the native Sony mount competition, this will also weigh heavily on Zeiss boutique pricing. ...Show more →
I'm sure you're right about Batis 85 demand dropping. That probably happened to some extent when the GM 85 shipped and more so now. But you and many who would opt for the FE85 are very pragmatic. I'm sure there are enough buyers out there still who will pay a premium for the exclusivity, design and pride of owning a Zeiss to keep Zeiss happy. This is true of nearly any product segment where luxury and exclusivity can demand and get a premium even when the added utility is negligible.
I expect Sony to eventually offer a faster GM branded 135 but not a budget FE variant. And it might come a long ways down the road but who can say. The reason I say this is because the market for 135mm primes is relatively niche compared to other wider focal lengths and 135 is not a focal length that appeals to casual shooters. Even Canon only offers a single 135mm product that bears its higherend L-branding and it's clearly a low priority as it hasn't received an update since it was released 20 years ago.
Time will tell, but I wouldn't expect a Sony FE 135 for at least a year or probably two. Maybe even longer as there are probably more imoortant telephoto lenses to add to the line if they can improve telephoto focus performance.
chez wrote: robgo2 wroteAs of this moment, 71 of 173 respondents show some level of interest in the new Batis lens. That's 41%, which I consider to be fairly high, so Zeiss planners must have read their marketplace fairly well. Of course, FM readers are probably not representative of the broader A7x user base, and I suspect that interest in that group as a whole is somewhat lower.Funny how we see things differently here. What I see is out of your 41%, 30% do not like the features they get for the price Zeiss is asking. They basically said they will not buy at the current price level, so either they might pick one up used later on or Zeiss would have to drop the price on this lens.
It's like me voting for being interested in the GFX system...everything looks great except for the price. So even though I would love the GFX, I won't be buying it because of it's price...same logic.
But what that group are indicating is that they are indeed interested in the new Batis but will wait for a better price before considering a purchase.
robgo2 wrote: chez wroterobgo2 wroteAs of this moment, 71 of 173 respondents show some level of interest in the new Batis lens. That's 41%, which I consider to be fairly high, so Zeiss planners must have read their marketplace fairly well. Of course, FM readers are probably not representative of the broader A7x user base, and I suspect that interest in that group as a whole is somewhat lower.Funny how we see things differently here. What I see is out of your 41%, 30% do not like the features they get for the price Zeiss is asking. They basically said they will not buy at the current price level, so either they might pick one up used later on or Zeiss would have to drop the price on this lens.
It's like me voting for being interested in the GFX system...everything looks great except for the price. So even though I would love the GFX, I won't be buying it because of it's price...same logic.But what that group are indicating is that they are indeed interested in the new Batis but will wait for a better price before considering a purchase.
Rob
Right...price here is the key thing. Just like with the Sony 35 2.8 lens...it has nice specs and the price was right...so I purchased it. If the price was say $1500...no way would I even entertain it.
Price is a huge factor in many decisions when they are looking at alternative lens choices. In fact, price is a huge factor in just about any purchase whether it a house, car or a 135mm lens.
I'm sure many people would agree that the $5million home with ocean view meets their requirements if only the price was $250,000.
rico wrote: rbf_ wroteI'm interested to hear your results. I've always been intrigued by IBIS, it's a useful and cool technology even though it doesn't obsolete optical stabilization.Testing performed. I'm in agreement with @chez@ that 3-4 stops is achieved by A7ii IBIS at 135mm. Lens used was the Leitz Tele-Elmar 135/4. Specifically, 1/15s is drop-dead easy, while 1/8s is a 50% miss with best practices. I'm using pixel-peeping standards: a perfectly usable image at 4 stops slower than the 1/f Rule is captured every time if you are scaling down. These results are equivalent to my Nikkor 70-200/4 VR, so kudos to Sony.
Well I'm glad it's working well for you with a nice piece of glass like that Has anyone checked whether IBIS works as well on the 42MP A7rii bodies as it does on the 24MP A7ii bodies? I do hear really varying reports about it and haven't seen any definitive testing.
rbf_ wrote: rico wroterbf_ wroteI'm interested to hear your results. I've always been intrigued by IBIS, it's a useful and cool technology even though it doesn't obsolete optical stabilization.Testing performed. I'm in agreement with @chez@@ that 3-4 stops is achieved by A7ii IBIS at 135mm. Lens used was the Leitz Tele-Elmar 135/4. Specifically, 1/15s is drop-dead easy, while 1/8s is a 50% miss with best practices. I'm using pixel-peeping standards: a perfectly usable image at 4 stops slower than the 1/f Rule is captured every time if you are scaling down. These results are equivalent to my Nikkor 70-200/4 VR, so kudos to Sony. Well I'm glad it's working well for you with a nice piece of glass like that Has anyone checked whether IBIS works as well on the 42MP A7rii bodies as it does on the 24MP A7ii bodies? I do hear really varying reports about it and haven't seen any definitive testing.
Search for IBIS testing by Jim Kasson.
With high resolution sensors the old 1/FL for shutter speed is no longer appropriate. He's found, and I agree, that even with shutter = 2 or 3 x FL that IBIS is still helping. In fact, it's essential at 1/FL to get sharp shots on high res sensors. So it's no longer a question of how many stops below 1/FL you can achieve with stabilization but how sharp you can get photos at 1/FL or some multiple.
Of course it all depends on your tolerance for what is suitably sharp. I can get decently sharp photos with IBIS using my FE 55 at 1/15s but that requires sniper like discipline and technique (including breathing technique) and probably only one in three shots will pass muster. Run and gun street shooting requires 1/250 or 1/500 with my 85mm even with IBIS. In summary, I believe it's all shades of grey at high resolution. I don't think you can follow any particular rule of thumb anymore.
virtualrain wrote: rbf_ wroterico wroterbf_ wroteI'm interested to hear your results. I've always been intrigued by IBIS, it's a useful and cool technology even though it doesn't obsolete optical stabilization.Testing performed. I'm in agreement with @chez@@@ that 3-4 stops is achieved by A7ii IBIS at 135mm. Lens used was the Leitz Tele-Elmar 135/4. Specifically, 1/15s is drop-dead easy, while 1/8s is a 50% miss with best practices. I'm using pixel-peeping standards: a perfectly usable image at 4 stops slower than the 1/f Rule is captured every time if you are scaling down. These results are equivalent to my Nikkor 70-200/4 VR, so kudos to Sony. Well I'm glad it's working well for you with a nice piece of glass like that Has anyone checked whether IBIS works as well on the 42MP A7rii bodies as it does on the 24MP A7ii bodies? I do hear really varying reports about it and haven't seen any definitive testing.Search for IBIS testing by Jim Kasson.
With high resolution sensors the old 1/FL for shutter speed is no longer appropriate. He's found, and I agree, that even with shutter = 2 or 3 x FL that IBIS is still helping. In fact, it's essential at 1/FL to get sharp shots on high res sensors. So it's no longer a question of how many stops below 1/FL you can achieve with stabilization but how sharp you can get photos at 1/FL or some multiple.
Of course it all depends on your tolerance for what is suitably sharp. I can get decently sharp photos with IBIS using my FE 55 at 1/15s but that requires sniper like discipline and technique (including breathing technique) and probably only one in three shots will pass muster. Run and gun street shooting requires 1/250 or 1/500 with my 85mm even with IBIS. In summary, I believe it's all shades of grey at high resolution. I don't think you can follow any particular rule of thumb anymore. ...Show more →
Thanks for the pointer and info I will check that out.
AGeoJO wrote: robgo2 wroteAs of this moment, 71 of 173 respondents show some level of interest in the new Batis lens. That's 41%, which I consider to be fairly high, so Zeiss planners must have read their marketplace fairly well. Of course, FM readers are probably not representative of the broader A7x user base, and I suspect that interest in that group as a whole is somewhat lower.Yes, that's one way of looking at it but another way would be only 7 respondents out of 193 and that's a paltry 4% will commit or have committed to get this lens. No, actually it would be more than that, as explained below.
21 out of 173 actual respondents are either committed to getting or are seriously interested in the Batis 135. That, in itself, isn't too bad. Another 50 are interested at a lower price. To me, that shows that a sizable number of Sony shooters would like to use this lens. If Zeiss wants to sell more lenses, all they have to do is reduce the price. It's purely a business decision.
rbf_ wrote:
Well I'm glad it's working well for you with a nice piece of glass like that Has anyone checked whether IBIS works as well on the 42MP A7rii bodies as it does on the 24MP A7ii bodies? I do hear really varying reports about it and haven't seen any definitive testing.
I can't answer that question directly, as I haven't done this comparison,but I can testify to the A7RII stabilizer working very well indeed with both non-stabilized lenses (Zeiss Otus) and stabilized (85GM). Posting one picture wouldn't prove anything, because, if one tries often enough, getting one stable shot at insanely slow speed is possible. What I get is approximately 30% sharp shots at 1/3FL with the Otus, and 1/5FL with the Sony. I even got a sharp shot (though not absolutely the sharpest) at 1/14FL with the latter, and I don't have very stable hands. So I am not complaining, but my tripod is, because it sees so little action.
philber wrote: rbf_ wroteWell I'm glad it's working well for you with a nice piece of glass like that Has anyone checked whether IBIS works as well on the 42MP A7rii bodies as it does on the 24MP A7ii bodies? I do hear really varying reports about it and haven't seen any definitive testing.I can't answer that question directly, as I haven't done this comparison,but I can testify to the A7RII stabilizer working very well indeed with both non-stabilized lenses (Zeiss Otus) and stabilized (85GM). Posting one picture wouldn't prove anything, because, if one tries often enough, getting one stable shot at insanely slow speed is possible. What I get is approximately 30% sharp shots at 1/3FL with the Otus, and 1/5FL with the Sony. I even got a sharp shot (though not absolutely the sharpest) at 1/14FL with the latter, and I don't have very stable hands. So I am not complaining, but my tripod is, because it sees so little action.
rbf_ wrote:
However if they can get really good stabilized OSS + IBIS performance with that lens I think it will really expand the usability of that lens.
I can already get down to 1/15s at 135mm with IBIS alone, as that's already far too slow for anything that moves I'm not sure how much better I would really need it to be.
Matt Grum wrote: rbf_ wroteHowever if they can get really good stabilized OSS + IBIS performance with that lens I think it will really expand the usability of that lens.I can already get down to 1/15s at 135mm with IBIS alone, as that's already far too slow for anything that moves I'm not sure how much better I would really need it to be.
Wow! That is seriously impressive. I can't! Less coffee..
After shooting the new 85 1.8 I realized how much I like the AF/MF switch. I'm constantly going back and forth and this keeps it simple and also keeps me out of the menu or Fn. Also I never been thrilled with Batis manual focusing. So I'm out and wait for something else. I know it could be endless. I do reserve the right to change my mind as you can never trust a lens whore on these buy matters.
Option 4 was closest for me. I do like a nice 135/2.8, but it needs to be small and cheap. I feel like a "slow" 135 like this is a compromise lens, which needs those other two positive factors to be worth it for me.
robgo2 wrote: AGeoJO wroterobgo2 wroteAs of this moment, 71 of 173 respondents show some level of interest in the new Batis lens. That's 41%, which I consider to be fairly high, so Zeiss planners must have read their marketplace fairly well. Of course, FM readers are probably not representative of the broader A7x user base, and I suspect that interest in that group as a whole is somewhat lower.Yes, that's one way of looking at it but another way would be only 7 respondents out of 193 and that's a paltry 4% will commit or have committed to get this lens. No, actually it would be more than that, as explained below.21 out of 173 actual respondents are either committed to getting or are seriously interested in the Batis 135. That, in itself, isn't too bad. Another 50 are interested at a lower price. To me, that shows that a sizable number of Sony shooters would like to use this lens. If Zeiss wants to sell more lenses, all they have to do is reduce the price. It's purely a business decision.
Rob
Careful. What those figures actually show is something more like how there is interest among those shooters sufficiently active and enthusiastic as to be involved with gear forums at some level and additionally interested enough in the specific product to click on and participate in a forum discussion about it.
rbf_ wrote: rico wroterbf_ wroteI'm interested to hear your results. I've always been intrigued by IBIS, it's a useful and cool technology even though it doesn't obsolete optical stabilization.Testing performed. I'm in agreement with @chez@@ that 3-4 stops is achieved by A7ii IBIS at 135mm. Lens used was the Leitz Tele-Elmar 135/4. Specifically, 1/15s is drop-dead easy, while 1/8s is a 50% miss with best practices. I'm using pixel-peeping standards: a perfectly usable image at 4 stops slower than the 1/f Rule is captured every time if you are scaling down. These results are equivalent to my Nikkor 70-200/4 VR, so kudos to Sony. Well I'm glad it's working well for you with a nice piece of glass like that Has anyone checked whether IBIS works as well on the 42MP A7rii bodies as it does on the 24MP A7ii bodies? I do hear really varying reports about it and haven't seen any definitive testing.
Pardon the small departure: If I'm using back button focus, is IBIS/OSS engaged when I press either the back button *and/or* the shutter button (halfway), or is it activated by just one of those?
[I googled this, but the answers I found weren't sufficiently definitive/authoritative, thx.]
Parariss wrote: rbf_ wroterico wroterbf_ wroteI'm interested to hear your results. I've always been intrigued by IBIS, it's a useful and cool technology even though it doesn't obsolete optical stabilization.Testing performed. I'm in agreement with @chez@@@ that 3-4 stops is achieved by A7ii IBIS at 135mm. Lens used was the Leitz Tele-Elmar 135/4. Specifically, 1/15s is drop-dead easy, while 1/8s is a 50% miss with best practices. I'm using pixel-peeping standards: a perfectly usable image at 4 stops slower than the 1/f Rule is captured every time if you are scaling down. These results are equivalent to my Nikkor 70-200/4 VR, so kudos to Sony. Well I'm glad it's working well for you with a nice piece of glass like that Has anyone checked whether IBIS works as well on the 42MP A7rii bodies as it does on the 24MP A7ii bodies? I do hear really varying reports about it and haven't seen any definitive testing.Pardon the small departure: If I'm using back button focus, is IBIS/OSS engaged when I press either the back button *and/or* the shutter button (halfway), or is it activated by just one of those?
[I googled this, but the answers I found weren't sufficiently definitive/authoritative, thx.]
GMPhotography wrote:
After shooting the new 85 1.8 I realized how much I like the AF/MF switch. I'm constantly going back and forth and this keeps it simple and also keeps me out of the menu or Fn. Also I never been thrilled with Batis manual focusing. So I'm out and wait for something else. I know it could be endless. I do reserve the right to change my mind as you can never trust a lens whore on these buy matters.
As a shooter who still mainly shoots manual focus lenses, I concur about the AF/MF switch. One of the best features on the Sony FE 50/1.4 also. I don't like having to dig into a menu, or try to figure out what mode I'm in after I pick up the camera to shoot.
pdmphoto wrote: GMPhotography wroteAfter shooting the new 85 1.8 I realized how much I like the AF/MF switch. I'm constantly going back and forth and this keeps it simple and also keeps me out of the menu or Fn. Also I never been thrilled with Batis manual focusing. So I'm out and wait for something else. I know it could be endless. I do reserve the right to change my mind as you can never trust a lens whore on these buy matters. As a shooter who still mainly shoots manual focus lenses, I concur about the AF/MF switch. One of the best features on the Sony FE 50/1.4 also. I don't like having to dig into a menu, or try to figure out what mode I'm in after I pick up the camera to shoot.
I agree that the MF/AF lens button is very helpful. However, with lenses that do not offer this option, it's possible to assign MF/AF to a custom button making it just as easy to switch focus mode from the camera.