Regarding the poll itself, it is misleading to include the "just view the poll result" group in the tabulations. That group should be considered non-responders, and including them with the responders skews the percentage numbers. It's not a big deal, but I think it's worth pointing out.
Fred Miranda wrote: Matt Grum wroteFred Miranda wroteThe results from this poll do not look good for the new Batis 135/2.8. I think it's worth stating again that this forum is not a representative sample of potential customers - people here are exacting with very specific requirements, I'd probably buy the lens if it were a little be lighter or a little bit cheaper or a little bit faster, or if the timing was different, but as it is it falls just outside my very narrow criteria!It's also worth pointing out that FM members do not shy from expensive gear so price is not what's really driving these numbers. I believe the slower a aperture is a deal breaker for a lot of shooters.
I don't think it's the slow aperture by itself....it's the slower aperture combined with the insane price. It's one thing to pay $2K for an exceptional AF lightweight 135mm f/2. It's another to pay that for an f/2.8. I still wouldn't be in the market at that price if it was f/2, but I'd at least understand it.
It's the same to me as if they offered a 24-70mm f/4 and priced it at $3500. People would lose their minds, since top end f/2.8 models are in the $1500 to $2500 range.
Right now, there are only 2 135mm lenses available for sale that are more expensive than this Batis. One is the Leica 135/3.4 M mount, (which is also insane, but all of Leica's prices are insane). The other is the 135/2 Milvus, which is only $200 more and a full stop faster.
The other AF 135mm lenses are all far cheaper than the Batis, and most are faster than the Batis as well. And considering how insanely good Sigma's latest primes have been, having the Sigma 135/1.8 sitting at 1-1/3 stops faster an $600 cheaper (or $350 cheaper if you get the MC-11 with it), makes it a hard sell. The Batis may be better, but it's that combination of modest speed with very high price that is the real issue to my eye.
Fred Miranda wrote: Matt Grum wroteFred Miranda wroteThe results from this poll do not look good for the new Batis 135/2.8. I think it's worth stating again that this forum is not a representative sample of potential customers - people here are exacting with very specific requirements, I'd probably buy the lens if it were a little be lighter or a little bit cheaper or a little bit faster, or if the timing was different, but as it is it falls just outside my very narrow criteria!It's also worth pointing out that FM members do not shy from expensive gear so price is not what's really driving these numbers. I believe the slower a aperture is a deal breaker for a lot of shooters.
imagine if they had done a 2.4 like you had speculated a few weeks ago - but otherwise same specs (APO etc)
it might have as much as 10-15% more diameter
but i think psychologically it'd be less of a hump for people to get over.
it still wouldn't be the f/1.8 or f/2 that many want, but i think there is an excessive drop off in interest relative to the difference in light gathering between 2.4 and 2.8 - i think that my have been their Achilles heel with this.
f/2.4 and $1900 would have probably captured a lot of hearts and minds.
chez wrote:
F2 and $1500 would have captured a lot more
that would be a totally different lens and i know that's the only lens anybody wants apparently.
what i'm saying is that with a very minimal change in spec, there would have been a huge increase in interest.
to go all the way to f/2 and still include the IQ and features that they did in this lens - it would weigh 2x and forget about sub $2000.
ecarlino wrote: Fred Miranda wroteMatt Grum wroteFred Miranda wroteThe results from this poll do not look good for the new Batis 135/2.8. I think it's worth stating again that this forum is not a representative sample of potential customers - people here are exacting with very specific requirements, I'd probably buy the lens if it were a little be lighter or a little bit cheaper or a little bit faster, or if the timing was different, but as it is it falls just outside my very narrow criteria!It's also worth pointing out that FM members do not shy from expensive gear so price is not what's really driving these numbers. I believe the slower a aperture is a deal breaker for a lot of shooters.imagine if they had done a 2.4 like you had speculated a few weeks ago - but otherwise same specs (APO etc)
it might have as much as 10-15% more diameter
but i think psychologically it'd be less of a hump for people to get over.
it still wouldn't be the f/1.8 or f/2 that many want, but i think there is an excessive drop off in interest relative to the difference in light gathering between 2.4 and 2.8 - i think that my have been their Achilles heel with this.
f/2.4 and $1900 would have probably captured a lot of hearts and minds.
I thought they had a 135/2.4 instead. Size and weight would be a bit more but they could've removed the OSS elements to even things out. Marketing-wise, f/2.8 just does not sound that exciting for a prime and it directly competes with their zoom. I was also hoping specular highlights looked better towards the edges. No doubt it's a high performance lens though.
ecarlino wrote: chez wroteF2 and $1500 would have captured a lot morethat would be a totally different lens and i know that's the only lens anybody wants apparently.
what i'm saying is that with a very minimal change in spec, there would have been a huge increase in interest.
to go all the way to f/2 and still include the IQ and features that they did in this lens - it would weigh 2x and forget about sub $2000.
I guess the question is do we need corner to corner sharpness in what is likely a portrait lens?
Personally I'd rather have a fast ( f2 or f1.8 ) lens at $1500 that might not be that sharp in extreme corners than f2.8 at $2,000 and having very sharp corners.
chez wrote:
I don't need sharp corners for this focal length.
it's not about what you or I want, there's a huge range of wants/needs in the marketplace.
in direct response to Fred's comment "the slower aperture is a deal breaker for a lot of shooters"
which was in response to my comment "imagine if they had done a 2.4 @ $1900 "
i am trying to evaluate the elasticity of the demand curve with respect to aperture.
and what i am postulating is that with only a minor adjustment to the aperture spec, they would likely have seen an disproportionate increase in demand relative to their costs and other factors (e.g. size/weight, etc).
I'm not talking about them having developed the product that you want - which is a COMPLETELY different product, but rather a slightly different product from what they delivered. this is an interesting business case where a small change in spec probably cost them a huge amount of sales and I wonder what they saw in their numbers (either demand or costs) that encouraged them to make this decision.
It would really be a lot of fun to have access to the data that these manufacturers have and to be a fly on the wall when they're making these decisions b/c as much as we like to think they are, they're not idiots. and there must have been a few good reasons that they did what they did.
I hope it didn't have anything to do with non-economic, non-technical reasons, such as competitive agreements with Sony to not get 'too close' to what Sony plans to deliver.
Who knows, maybe they did lay an egg; maybe they end up a year from now cutting prices or offering big rebates. however, premium brands are reluctant to do that and would rather just cut production runs for an item that isn't selling because cutting prices on any item affects the overall pricing power of their brand.
ecarlino wrote: Fred Miranda wroteMatt Grum wroteFred Miranda wroteThe results from this poll do not look good for the new Batis 135/2.8. I think it's worth stating again that this forum is not a representative sample of potential customers - people here are exacting with very specific requirements, I'd probably buy the lens if it were a little be lighter or a little bit cheaper or a little bit faster, or if the timing was different, but as it is it falls just outside my very narrow criteria!It's also worth pointing out that FM members do not shy from expensive gear so price is not what's really driving these numbers. I believe the slower a aperture is a deal breaker for a lot of shooters.imagine if they had done a 2.4 like you had speculated a few weeks ago - but otherwise same specs (APO etc)
it might have as much as 10-15% more diameter
but i think psychologically it'd be less of a hump for people to get over.
it still wouldn't be the f/1.8 or f/2 that many want, but i think there is an excessive drop off in interest relative to the difference in light gathering between 2.4 and 2.8 - i think that my have been their Achilles heel with this.
f/2.4 and $1900 would have probably captured a lot of hearts and minds.
"...i think there is an excessive drop off in interest relative to the difference in light gathering between 2.4 and 2.8"
Excessive drop off? According to the (unscientific) poll herein, over 40% either have bought the lens, or are likely buying this lens assuming the reviews hold up as expected, or will buy the lens used when it's available. Sure, we're all a bunch of tweaker lens whores on this forum, but that seems like a pretty good number!
chez wrote: ecarlino wrotechez wroteF2 and $1500 would have captured a lot morethat would be a totally different lens and i know that's the only lens anybody wants apparently.
what i'm saying is that with a very minimal change in spec, there would have been a huge increase in interest.
to go all the way to f/2 and still include the IQ and features that they did in this lens - it would weigh 2x and forget about sub $2000.I guess the question is do we need corner to corner sharpness in what is likely a portrait lens?
It's preferable unless you want to place your subject in the center of the frame and later on fix (crop) your composition in post.
If a lens is mostly sharp in the center with noticeably fall-off towards the mid/corners, it loses flexibility when composing our images and aiming for high IQ.
Parariss wrote: ecarlino wroteFred Miranda wroteMatt Grum wroteFred Miranda wroteThe results from this poll do not look good for the new Batis 135/2.8. I think it's worth stating again that this forum is not a representative sample of potential customers - people here are exacting with very specific requirements, I'd probably buy the lens if it were a little be lighter or a little bit cheaper or a little bit faster, or if the timing was different, but as it is it falls just outside my very narrow criteria!It's also worth pointing out that FM members do not shy from expensive gear so price is not what's really driving these numbers. I believe the slower a aperture is a deal breaker for a lot of shooters.imagine if they had done a 2.4 like you had speculated a few weeks ago - but otherwise same specs (APO etc)
it might have as much as 10-15% more diameter
but i think psychologically it'd be less of a hump for people to get over.
it still wouldn't be the f/1.8 or f/2 that many want, but i think there is an excessive drop off in interest relative to the difference in light gathering between 2.4 and 2.8 - i think that my have been their Achilles heel with this.
f/2.4 and $1900 would have probably captured a lot of hearts and minds."...i think there is an excessive drop off in interest relative to the difference in light gathering between 2.4 and 2.8"
Excessive drop off? According to the (unscientific) poll herein, over 40% either have bought the lens, or are likely buying this lens assuming the reviews hold up as expected, or will buy the lens used when it's available. Sure, we're all a bunch of tweaker lens whores on this forum, but that seems like a pretty good number!
you are either misinterpreting or misstating the polling data:
the 40% you refer to are not likely buyers at the $2000 price point.
only 4% are with an additional 12% waiting for reviews to make a decision.
the next 27% might be interested in a year if reviews are solid and the price drops at least 25%.
that is a big difference.
ecarlino wrote: Parariss wroteecarlino wroteFred Miranda wroteMatt Grum wroteFred Miranda wroteThe results from this poll do not look good for the new Batis 135/2.8. I think it's worth stating again that this forum is not a representative sample of potential customers - people here are exacting with very specific requirements, I'd probably buy the lens if it were a little be lighter or a little bit cheaper or a little bit faster, or if the timing was different, but as it is it falls just outside my very narrow criteria!It's also worth pointing out that FM members do not shy from expensive gear so price is not what's really driving these numbers. I believe the slower a aperture is a deal breaker for a lot of shooters.imagine if they had done a 2.4 like you had speculated a few weeks ago - but otherwise same specs (APO etc)
it might have as much as 10-15% more diameter
but i think psychologically it'd be less of a hump for people to get over.
it still wouldn't be the f/1.8 or f/2 that many want, but i think there is an excessive drop off in interest relative to the difference in light gathering between 2.4 and 2.8 - i think that my have been their Achilles heel with this.
f/2.4 and $1900 would have probably captured a lot of hearts and minds."...i think there is an excessive drop off in interest relative to the difference in light gathering between 2.4 and 2.8"
Excessive drop off? According to the (unscientific) poll herein, over 40% either have bought the lens, or are likely buying this lens assuming the reviews hold up as expected, or will buy the lens used when it's available. Sure, we're all a bunch of tweaker lens whores on this forum, but that seems like a pretty good number! you are either misinterpreting or misstating the polling data:
the 40% you refer to are not likely buyers at the $2000 price point.
only 4% are with an additional 12% waiting for reviews to make a decision.
the next 27% might be interested in a year if reviews are solid and the price drops at least 25%.
that is a big difference.
Pictures here at FM will assist in making a decision too. I'm sorry that I'm not going to be the guinea pig in this case.
I voted for "seriously considering it". I am, for now, sticking with a 3-lens kit. 28mm Otus, 55mm Otus and one more that needs to be both longer, and AF. Today, it is a Sony 85 GM, and I wish I had a longer lens, like my erstwhile Zeiss 135 APO-Sonnar. So trading my 85GM for a Batis 135 could be a good trade if the Batis offers at least as good IQ. Sure I would lose some speed, but gain some length. I need to see some pics from known photographers, or ask Zeiss to let me try one out.
chez wrote:
I guess the question is do we need corner to corner sharpness in what is likely a portrait lens?
Fred Miranda wrote:
Yes we do unless you want to place your subject in the center of the frame and later on fix (crop) your composition in post.
If a lens is mostly sharp in the center with noticeably fall-off towards the mid/corners, it loses flexibility when composing our images and aiming for high IQ.
Fred, i think that is one of the things that interests me a lot in this lens: as good as it is on its finer points, it also manages to be a bit of a jack of all trades, or as you stated better, b/c of its finer qualities it has a lot of flexibility and that incremental increase in flexibility comes with a big price usually.
i know f/2.8 is too slow for portraits and unnecessarily fast for landscapes but the demand may surprise for a mixed use besides or between those two purposes.
i know it gets compared to f/2.8 zooms (because of aperture, but really, what else do they have in common?) - there may be a lot of people who are unwilling to walk around w/ a 2.8 zoom on the a7 series body and i'm going to guess the IQ @ 2.8 on the Batis will exceed that of any zoom @ 2.8 (any focal length).
philber wrote:
I voted for "seriously considering it". I am, for now, sticking with a 3-lens kit. 28mm Otus, 55mm Otus and one more that needs to be both longer, and AF. Today, it is a Sony 85 GM, and I wish I had a longer lens, like my erstwhile Zeiss 135 APO-Sonnar. So trading my 85GM for a Batis 135 could be a good trade if the Batis offers at least as good IQ. Sure I would lose some speed, but gain some length. I need to see some pics from known photographers, or ask Zeiss to let me try one out....Show more →
They have to know that letting you share some pics with the Batis 135 is their best chance of boosting sales!
btw - i know you guys like to nickname your lenses, looking at your line-up, do you refer to your 135 APO as "TINY TIM"?
Fred Miranda wrote: chez wroteecarlino wrotechez wroteF2 and $1500 would have captured a lot morethat would be a totally different lens and i know that's the only lens anybody wants apparently.
what i'm saying is that with a very minimal change in spec, there would have been a huge increase in interest.
to go all the way to f/2 and still include the IQ and features that they did in this lens - it would weigh 2x and forget about sub $2000.I guess the question is do we need corner to corner sharpness in what is likely a portrait lens?It's preferable unless you want to place your subject in the center of the frame and later on fix (crop) your composition in post.
If a lens is mostly sharp in the center with noticeably fall-off towards the mid/corners, it loses flexibility when composing our images and aiming for high IQ.
But when we say corners, it usually ends up in pretty extreme corners where I highly doubt very many portraits are taken. Looking at the samples that are posted, seems to me the subject is much closer to the center than the edges.
I know when I compose a portrait, I don't put the subject onto the edge of the frame.
I would think bokeh quality would be much more important in this type of lens compared to far corner sharpness.
ecarlino wrote: chez wroteI don't need sharp corners for this focal length.it's not about what you or I want, there's a huge range of wants/needs in the marketplace.
in direct response to Fred's comment "the slower aperture is a deal breaker for a lot of shooters"
which was in response to my comment "imagine if they had done a 2.4 @ $1900 "
i am trying to evaluate the elasticity of the demand curve with respect to aperture.
and what i am postulating is that with only a minor adjustment to the aperture spec, they would likely have seen an disproportionate increase in demand relative to their costs and other factors (e.g. size/weight, etc).
I'm not talking about them having developed the product that you want - which is a COMPLETELY different product, but rather a slightly different product from what they delivered. this is an interesting business case where a small change in spec probably cost them a huge amount of sales and I wonder what they saw in their numbers (either demand or costs) that encouraged them to make this decision.
It would really be a lot of fun to have access to the data that these manufacturers have and to be a fly on the wall when they're making these decisions b/c as much as we like to think they are, they're not idiots. and there must have been a few good reasons that they did what they did.
I hope it didn't have anything to do with non-economic, non-technical reasons, such as competitive agreements with Sony to not get 'too close' to what Sony plans to deliver.
Who knows, maybe they did lay an egg; maybe they end up a year from now cutting prices or offering big rebates. however, premium brands are reluctant to do that and would rather just cut production runs for an item that isn't selling because cutting prices on any item affects the overall pricing power of their brand....Show more →
Just saying people that are complaining about the speed are saying geez if it were only f2.4, I'd snap it up in a heartbeat. The bar has been set by the competition at f2 or even f1.8...anything less would not make a difference IMHO.
chez wrote:
But when we say corners, it usually ends up in pretty extreme corners where I highly doubt very many portraits are taken. Looking at the samples that are posted, seems to me the subject is much closer to the center than the edges.
I know when I compose a portrait, I don't put the subject onto the edge of the frame.
I would think bokeh quality would be much more important in this type of lens compared to far corner sharpness.
Maybe this thing will be SO sharp, that people will jump just because they can't help themselves.
Also consider that Sony is probably going to announce some new FE products this month. If nothing is announced that has people ready to put down a pre-order, maybe some will say "eh, this is probably about it for me for awhile based on new releases, so I'll take the plunge". Or- something will get announced and folks won't want $4-$5k worth of preorders out there.