DavidBM wrote: GMPhotography wroteProbably so, they are very close. Here is when you look at size, weight money as your main buy factors. IQ wise it's close enough either way that small adjustments make up any difference.I think that's right. It's all back and forth in tiny hairsplitting ways that will not be visible even in very large prints (mostly if I had to pick I'd go zeiss), except for that corner where, if the image is representative, there's something wrong with that copy of the AA or else the Zeiss is much better. Counting an adapter (especially a helicoid one) the weight is very similar. Neither are super light, nor super heavy. And I don't think I care about the half stop.
I would go with the Loxia if money were not part of the decision, so even more so given its price.
David, for size I think they are close but the difference might be noticeable. The Zeiss is 7mm longer even including the adapter, but the Leica has a 1.5mm wider diameter. My Leica AA with the Hawk's helicoid no caps, but also the hood (as it is built-in) weighs 530g or very close to that. The Zeiss weighs 596 without caps, but if you include the hood probably weighs close to 90g more. Is that enough to matter? Does the half stop matter? Do the smaller size and faster aperture justify the price difference (about $600 comparing the Leica bought carefully used vs. the Zeiss new)? Reasonable people can easily disagree on all these issues and it makes the choice difficult, but it is a nice problem to have.
For those wanting one 85/90, the Leica might well win as the detail is excellent, there is no size penalty, it works with TAP for autifocus, and it is faster. Still, if one wants a more contrasty image out of the box with great sun stars, if you don't mind manual focus only the Loxia 85 is great. For a second lens at this focal length, it is a harder decision. For me, I own the Leica 75/2 apo which works well with TAP, and since I own the Loxia 21 and 50, the 85 shares a common look and filter size and this is weighing in my decision. For portrait, I too would prefer a 135. I need to try my Leica 135/3.4 for that more, but I often use my 180/2.8 for portrait duty. Ideally, a native 135/2 with eye autofocus would be about perfect, though an F2.8 might be good enough if the optics otherwise are great.
For those here in the U.S. waiting for the Loxia 85 to become available, I can almost guarantee it's availability any day now since I cancelled my preorder! I've decided to stick with my Contax G 90/2.8 (with Techart Contax G to Nex adapter) and Contax 100/3.5 (with Techart Pro adapter) since I just don't shoot at this FL often enough to justify the purchase.
Of course, if I'm right, you all owe it to me and I know I will regret my decision.
rji2goleez wrote:
For those here in the U.S. waiting for the Loxia 85 to become available, I can almost guarantee it's availability any day now since I cancelled my preorder! I've decided to stick with my Contax G 90/2.8 (with Techart Contax G to Nex adapter) and Contax 100/3.5 (with Techart Pro adapter) since I just don't shoot at this FL often enough to justify the purchase.
Of course, if I'm right, you all owe it to me and I know I will regret my decision.
Knowing which (good) lenses you don't need is a lesson not easily learned
I'm the worst , I have bought the same lens 3 or 4 times and that runs the whole gamut of focal lengths. Lol
BastianK wrote: rji2goleez wroteFor those here in the U.S. waiting for the Loxia 85 to become available, I can almost guarantee it's availability any day now since I cancelled my preorder! I've decided to stick with my Contax G 90/2.8 (with Techart Contax G to Nex adapter) and Contax 100/3.5 (with Techart Pro adapter) since I just don't shoot at this FL often enough to justify the purchase.
Of course, if I'm right, you all owe it to me and I know I will regret my decision. Knowing which (good) lenses you don't need is a lesson not easily learned
Steve my thoughts are if the Loxia is not earth shattering better than the ZM. I'll buy the ZM no question about it.
And your correct the costs are a little uncomfortable at 3200 for both the GM and Loxia. I can get the ZM for half the price as the Loxia. That's 700 towards my 18. I unfortunately have to look at the cost factor as a business. Why I always say I envy the hobbyist. Total freedom on purchases
Steve Spencer wrote: GMPhotography wroteEnd of day the investment in two 85s is very high. For me with GM and Loxia that's 3200 hundred dollars tied up in one focal length. That's a big investment for some of usFor you Guy, it seems pretty clear the GM plus ZM f/4 works well at 85. Why mess with that combo? The GM works as your people lens and the ZM is both small and excellent for landscapes. I like the Loxia 85 from what I have seen a lot, but in your case you get a lens double the size and double the price for a very very small gain and a stretch in the budget that doesn't seem comfortable.
I'm the worst , I have bought the same lens 3 or 4 times and that runs the whole gamut of focal lengths. Lol
BastianK wroterji2goleez wroteFor those here in the U.S. waiting for the Loxia 85 to become available, I can almost guarantee it's availability any day now since I cancelled my preorder! I've decided to stick with my Contax G 90/2.8 (with Techart Contax G to Nex adapter) and Contax 100/3.5 (with Techart Pro adapter) since I just don't shoot at this FL often enough to justify the purchase.
Of course, if I'm right, you all owe it to me and I know I will regret my decision. Knowing which (good) lenses you don't need is a lesson not easily learned
Same here! The problem with GAS is never being satisfied and jumping on the new lens bandwagon. Like I said, I'm sure I'll regret my decision or maybe I'll look for an 85ZM to use with TAP or . . .
GMPhotography wrote:
End of day the investment in two 85s is very high. For me with GM and Loxia that's 3200 hundred dollars tied up in one focal length. That's a big investment for some of us
---------------------------------------------
Steve Spencer wrote: GMPhotography wroteEnd of day the investment in two 85s is very high. For me with GM and Loxia that's 3200 hundred dollars tied up in one focal length. That's a big investment for some of usFor you Guy, it seems pretty clear the GM plus ZM f/4 works well at 85. Why mess with that combo? The GM works as your people lens and the ZM is both small and excellent for landscapes. I like the Loxia 85 from what I have seen a lot, but in your case you get a lens double the size and double the price for a very very small gain and a stretch in the budget that doesn't seem comfortable.
Some of us use the 80mm to 100mm focal length often, so I have quite a few lenses that I do not intend to part with and have no interest in the new Loxia 85mm lens. For work with my A7r and A7rM V3 cameras I have my Leica M 90mm f2.5 Summarit lens for my small and light lens and when infinity is not quite as important. When I need the highest resolution and performance, can deal with the weight and when I want to use the lens for macro work I have my Leica R 100mm f2.8 Apo-Macro-Elmarit lens.
When I want to use my A7r cameras with my Cambo Actus and want tilts, swings, rise/fall, shifts, stitching, etc. I have my Rodenstock 80mm f4 Apo Rodagon N and my SK 90mm f4.5 Apo Digitar in Copal 0 shutter. Additionally, I can also use my Leica R 100mm f2.8 Apo-Macro-Elmarit with the same movements and huge image circle as well as for close-up work on the Cambo Actus.
naturephoto1 wrote: GMPhotography wroteEnd of day the investment in two 85s is very high. For me with GM and Loxia that's 3200 hundred dollars tied up in one focal length. That's a big investment for some of us---------------------------------------------
Steve Spencer wroteGMPhotography wroteEnd of day the investment in two 85s is very high. For me with GM and Loxia that's 3200 hundred dollars tied up in one focal length. That's a big investment for some of usFor you Guy, it seems pretty clear the GM plus ZM f/4 works well at 85. Why mess with that combo? The GM works as your people lens and the ZM is both small and excellent for landscapes. I like the Loxia 85 from what I have seen a lot, but in your case you get a lens double the size and double the price for a very very small gain and a stretch in the budget that doesn't seem comfortable.Some of us use the 80mm to 100mm focal length often, so I have quite a few lenses that I do not intend to part with and have no interest in the new Loxia 85mm lens. For work with my A7r and A7rM V3 cameras I have my Leica M 90mm f2.4 Summarit lens for my small and light lens and when infinity is not quite as important. When I need the highest resolution and performance, can deal with the weight and when I want to use the lens for macro work I have my Leica R 100mm f2.8 Apo-Macro-Elmarit lens.
When I want to use my A7r cameras with my Cambo Actus and want tilts, swings, shifts, etc. I have my Rodenstock 80mm f4 Apo Rodagon N and my SK 90mm f4.5 Apo Digitar in Copal 0 shutter. Additionally, I can also use my Leica R 100mm f2.8 Apo-Macro-Elmarit with the same movements and huge image circle as well as for close-up work on the Cambo Actus.
Only four lenses in the 80-100mm range Rich? Surely there is room for another then! 😜
Seriously, I have long been tempted by the Leica R 100 macro. It is by reputation very close to as good as the 90 AA at infinity and is obviously way better at macro and I don't have a macro lens.... The problem with being a prime lens shooter is that if one wants to cover all the bases, then one must also hire a Sherpa to carry one's gear!
Luvwine wrote: naturephoto1 wroteGMPhotography wroteEnd of day the investment in two 85s is very high. For me with GM and Loxia that's 3200 hundred dollars tied up in one focal length. That's a big investment for some of us---------------------------------------------
Steve Spencer wroteGMPhotography wroteEnd of day the investment in two 85s is very high. For me with GM and Loxia that's 3200 hundred dollars tied up in one focal length. That's a big investment for some of usFor you Guy, it seems pretty clear the GM plus ZM f/4 works well at 85. Why mess with that combo? The GM works as your people lens and the ZM is both small and excellent for landscapes. I like the Loxia 85 from what I have seen a lot, but in your case you get a lens double the size and double the price for a very very small gain and a stretch in the budget that doesn't seem comfortable.Some of us use the 80mm to 100mm focal length often, so I have quite a few lenses that I do not intend to part with and have no interest in the new Loxia 85mm lens. For work with my A7r and A7rM V3 cameras I have my Leica M 90mm f2.4 Summarit lens for my small and light lens and when infinity is not quite as important. When I need the highest resolution and performance, can deal with the weight and when I want to use the lens for macro work I have my Leica R 100mm f2.8 Apo-Macro-Elmarit lens.
When I want to use my A7r cameras with my Cambo Actus and want tilts, swings, shifts, etc. I have my Rodenstock 80mm f4 Apo Rodagon N and my SK 90mm f4.5 Apo Digitar in Copal 0 shutter. Additionally, I can also use my Leica R 100mm f2.8 Apo-Macro-Elmarit with the same movements and huge image circle as well as for close-up work on the Cambo Actus.
RichOnly four lenses in the 80-100mm range Rich? Surely there is room for another then! 😜
Seriously, I have long been tempted by the Leica R 100 macro. It is by reputation very close to as good as the 90 AA at infinity and is obviously way better at macro and I don't have a macro lens.... The problem with being a prime lens shooter is that if one wants to cover all the bases, then one must also hire a Sherpa to carry one's gear!
Actually I have even more with my Leica R 100mm f4 Macro Bellows Elmar lens (requires bellows or my Cambo Actus) and my old Leica R 90mm f2 Summicron which has some issues and rather than have Leica USA perform a CLA that would not resolve all of the issues (lens has some pitting), applied the money toward my Leica M 90mm f2.5 Summarit.
To convince myself of my decision, I just went out and shot the Zeiss Contax 100/3.5. With the TAP, I can take advantage of closer than MFD focusing and narrow the DOF. I had crappy light but the details and the pop are there.
BastianK wrote: rji2goleez wroteFor those here in the U.S. waiting for the Loxia 85 to become available, I can almost guarantee it's availability any day now since I cancelled my preorder! I've decided to stick with my Contax G 90/2.8 (with Techart Contax G to Nex adapter) and Contax 100/3.5 (with Techart Pro adapter) since I just don't shoot at this FL often enough to justify the purchase.
Of course, if I'm right, you all owe it to me and I know I will regret my decision. Knowing which (good) lenses you don't need is a lesson not easily learned
BastianK wrote: GMPhotography wroteI agree the Batis and GM are not really for landscape but the person only wanting ONE 85 in their bag than they will have to decide which 85 fits them the best witn some compromises as well with sharpness, bokeh and look. For those of us that want TWO 85s than it's a easier choice. For me GM 85 for everything people and a 85 strictly for highest resolving power. So for us looking at that second lens we have Loxia, Zeiss and Leica but it's nice to know for the record and ONE lens folks how much they maybe giving up or making up with there choice.For me it is 85mm 2.4 Loxia for landscape / architecture / everyday shooting (city trip, hike, whatever)
and 135mm 2.0L for portrait or anything else where I want really shallow DoF.
As a "one lens" solution (which is something I am not looking for) I might go for 90AA or Batis.
if you want a short tele macro (STM), then a one lens solution is harder, because it would need to be the STM which won't be small, or fast, or ultra stellar at infinity (though likely good enough)
So I think it's three lens solutions: STM, portrait with AF, landscape solution.
Holding the STM fixed (I use the FE90, but there are plenty of good options) I think there are two pairings that make sense:
The lightweight solution: Batis for portraits, ZM for landscape
The slightly better but much heavier and more expensive solution: GM and Loxia.
I'm currently using the lightweight; I'm happy with it - I'd be happy with the weight of GM in the home studio or at events, but wouldn't take it traveling. And for hiking the ZM is usefully lighter than Loxia if you are out for more than a night. But GAS makes me think 4 lens solution! (actually that would be five, because I never sold my 3.5/100 that the ZM was meant to replace, because it wouldn't generate that much money and selling is a hassle...) But I hope I'll resist..
rji2goleez wrote]
Same here! The problem with GAS is never being satisfied and jumping on the new lens bandwagon. Like I said, I'm sure I'll regret my decision or maybe I'll look for an 85ZM to use with TAP or . . .
That's how I feel about my decision to sell my decent copy of the Sony 35 1.4. In retrospect, I should have just kept it.
The 24-70 is nice, but sometimes f2.8 is not fast enough, the rx series struggles with flare and sunstars. I hope the new to me 35 zm is the solution. It's a nice small package, but the battery drain of the TAP (I had removed and reinserted the battery, but still) sucks (had only one battery with me) and I'm still figuring out how to deal with the field curvature and learn what works and what does not as far as AF goes.
41 pages of Loxia 85, and I'm still not convinced. Not a good sign, and Bob's off-the-cuff S100 C/Y shots don't help. I agree that 135mm is an important FL for portrait, although f/8 is quite wide enough for headshots, while optics like the Rok 135/2 or Zony 135/1.8 A mount are gross overkill. I don't suppose we'll ever see a Loxia 135/4 in the tradition of the Tele-Elmar (portrait lens ideal).
rico wrote:
41 pages of Loxia 85, and I'm still not convinced. Not a good sign, and Bob's off-the-cuff S100 C/Y shots don't help. I agree that 135mm is an important FL for portrait, although f/8 is quite wide enough for headshots, while optics like the Rok 135/2 or Zony 135/1.8 A mount are gross overkill. I don't suppose we'll ever see a Loxia 135/4 in the tradition of the Tele-Elmar (portrait lens ideal).
I would LOVE a Lox 4/135 for landscape; stop me from getting an APO telyt m. I adore my APO Sonnar, but it never goes in a backpack...