Jochenb wrote:
Before I'm going to try a third copy I think I will go for the 85/4 ZM instead (already have the adapter and a TAP). The rendering seems to be equally wonderful, in a smaller package. Maybe more luck with that one.
My first copy of the Loxia 85 was perfectly centered. I realized that I didn't like the Loxia haptics so I sold it to a forum member and bought a Classic ZE 85/1.4, which not only suits my shooting style a lot better but is a perfect complement to the 85/4 ZM I already had (the ZE being 1.5 stops faster and the ZM 1.5 stops slower than the L85). Bob's superb 85/4 ZM pictures on the previous page demonstrate what this tiny jewel can deliver.
genji wrote: Jochenb wroteBefore I'm going to try a third copy I think I will go for the 85/4 ZM instead (already have the adapter and a TAP). The rendering seems to be equally wonderful, in a smaller package. Maybe more luck with that one.My first copy of the Loxia 85 was perfectly centered. I realized that I didn't like the Loxia haptics so I sold it to a forum member and bought a Classic ZE 85/1.4, which not only suits my shooting style a lot better but is a perfect complement to the 85/4 ZM I already had (the ZE being 1.5 stops faster and the ZM 1.5 stops slower than the L85). Bob's superb 85/4 ZM pictures on the previous page demonstrate what this tiny jewel can deliver.
It's funny that you mention this Genji, because I had the same reasoning now.
I'm also still a user of the classic Zeiss 85/1.4 Planar (ZF.2 mount). I really like the lens for all shallow DOF stuff, but it lacks some sharpness on the edges/corners compared to the Loxia/ZM (or even the native Sony 85's).
The ZM might be a nice complement.
I got a perfect copy of the Loxia 85 right out of the gate. Really like this lens . My only issue with it it’s a little big for my PD sling bag and I thought about going back to the ZM but in all honesty I’m sick of buying and selling. It’s just a hassle and testing everything out but I’m really trying to get smaller why I sold my Laowa 15. Fred had a couple bad Loxia 85 I kept urging him to keep trying. The copy he has now is very good. So if you looking used grab his. But there are bad copies out there. Like the other thread here on the forum. I test every lens I buy because I’ve seen so much variance over the years I’m not going to keep a inferior lens . We pay a lot of money for this stuff and deserve good copies
genji wrote:
I realized that I didn't like the Loxia haptics...
Good to know that it's not just me. I much prefer the handling of my Voigtlanders. Everything from the placement of the aperture ring to the hood and end caps drive me nuts with the Loxias. At some FLs, however, the Loxias reign supreme (21, maybe 85 and 25?)
My bad luck is just unbelievable
Today I got a brand new 85/4 ZM and this one's decentered too.
Comparison of 2 corners @F4, again on "only" 24MP.
I really don't think I'm being too picky. Just look at how awful one corner looks (look at that grass on the left). It's not user error or a misaligned mount/sensor because I confirm this on both my cameras, with different tests.
It really starts to discourage me that I'm not able to get the 85mm that I want for an Iceland trip I have coming up very soon.
BTW, I quickly compared the ZM to the Loxia. This copy of the Loxia is superior to this copy of the ZM. The Loxia is just more detailed across the frame.
Here are a few examples for those interested. Nothing scientific, just to give a quick idea of their difference.
Both at F8, A7III.
GMPhotography wrote:
Anyone try the Voightlander 75mm 1.8. Could it be a landscape lens stopped down
Its an odd lens; basically a triplet design with each 'element' being a 2 element achromat.
So it looks and performs like a slightly upgraded 1930s portrait lens (a Cooke triplet or something like that)
MIght be fun, but no it won't be a landscape lens.
The little 2.5/75 on the other hand is superb stopped down. I used to have one until I replaced it with a Summitar 2.5/75. I think I regret that. The Summitar is better wide open and contraster, but it's bigger and is trumped by the Loxia at 85 and the CV at 65. I just haven't got around to selling it yet but I mean to. Whereas the superpower of the 2.5 is that it's tiny and light.
It appears there is some significant copy-to-copy variation in both the 85 Lox andf the 85/4ZM.
My 85 ZM is one stop behind the Lox (one copy that I tested) in sharpness across the image frame - i.e., The 85/4 wide open is close the Lox at f/2.4. The Lox at f/4 about as good as the 85/4 at f/5.6 and the Lox at f/5.6 is just stellar across the frame (f/8 on the ZM starts to have diffraction issues I think).
Still, my 85/4 ZM does excellently well even wide open unless you are going to pixel peep at 100%.
I've put off getting the Lox because I already have the ZM and 85/1.8 Sony (which is no slouch of a lens).
jhinkey wrote:
It appears there is some significant copy-to-copy variation in both the 85 Lox andf the 85/4ZM.
My 85 ZM is one stop behind the Lox (one copy that I tested) in sharpness across the image frame - i.e., The 85/4 wide open is close the Lox at f/2.4. The Lox at f/4 about as good as the 85/4 at f/5.6 and the Lox at f/5.6 is just stellar across the frame (f/8 on the ZM starts to have diffraction issues I think).
Still, my 85/4 ZM does excellently well even wide open unless you are going to pixel peep at 100%.
I've put off getting the Lox because I already have the ZM and 85/1.8 Sony (which is no slouch of a lens)....Show more →
That's about how my Lox and ZM compare. Lox a tiny bit better in backlight and a less CA.
I think though the pair you have makes perfect sense. It's possible to own far too many 85s.
These pairings make sense to me:
the size tolerant big budget pair:
85GM + Loxia. for portraits and other work
The keep it light pair:
Sony 85 (or Batis or a touch more contrast but a touch more size...) and ZM
My own setup makes less sense, but some: Loxia because I love it, ZM for hiking, and Batis for travel/potraits.
But if I was completely rational I probably would not have the Lox, as the noticeable but small improvement over the ZM is not obviously worth it given I won't take it hiking, and I won't give up ZM for that reason.
I have the Loxia for landscape and GM for portraits as I don’t mind the extra weight over the ZM and think that this pairing is the best. However, deciding between such excellent options is a very nice problem to have!
Got mine used a year or so ago. The Loxia lenses are great, the one flaw they had was that they were pricey. On the used market now, they are such great deal. I have the 25 and 85 and they are top notch modern but retain that Zeiss color and contrast.
MARKFER wrote:
Got mine used a year or so ago. The Loxia lenses are great, the one flaw they had was that they were pricey. On the used market now, they are such great deal. I have the 25 and 85 and they are top notch modern but retain that Zeiss color and contrast.
Yeah very pricey and now quite old , seams like most forgot about them. I still love them , have all but the 21mm, I should probably just bite the bullet and complete the set.