Chris_88 wrote: Earlier quoterji2goleez wrote]
Same here! The problem with GAS is never being satisfied and jumping on the new lens bandwagon. Like I said, I'm sure I'll regret my decision or maybe I'll look for an 85ZM to use with TAP or . . . That's how I feel about my decision to sell my decent copy of the Sony 35 1.4. In retrospect, I should have just kept it.
The 24-70 is nice, but sometimes f2.8 is not fast enough, the rx series struggles with flare and sunstars. I hope the new to me 35 zm is the solution. It's a nice small package, but the battery drain of the TAP (I had removed and reinserted the battery, but still) sucks (had only one battery with me) and I'm still figuring out how to deal with the field curvature and learn what works and what does not as far as AF goes. ...Show more →
I would never give up my good copy of the 1.4/35FE. It's not quite as contrasty as the ZM, or perhaps as sharp centrally at wider apertures (though it's no slouch by any standards). But it does have the most staggeringly gorgeous bokeh; soft and alluring that makes it a sensational portrait lens - and the eyeAF is great there. Sure if there are specular highlights you might get a touch of onion ring, but if you really care about that in an exhibition picture, it can be worth it to edit. But I almost never mind, and I don't know anything else at this FL with such a lovely rendition OOF.
Of course, given the stories we hear, I don't know if I'd whole heartedly recommend anyone getting into the FE1.4/35 lottery unless they lived in the US and could deal with places that do easy returns...
DavidBM wrote:
I would never give up my good copy of the 1.4/35FE. It's not quite as contrasty as the ZM, or perhaps as sharp centrally at wider apertures (though it's no slouch by any standards). But it does have the most staggeringly gorgeous bokeh; soft and alluring that makes it a sensational portrait lens - and the eyeAF is great there. Sure if there are specular highlights you might get a touch of onion ring, but if you really care about that in an exhibition picture, it can be worth it to edit. But I almost never mind, and I don't know anything else at this FL with such a lovely rendition OOF.
Of course, given the stories we hear, I don't know if I'd whole heartedly recommend anyone getting into the FE1.4/35 lottery unless they lived in the US and could deal with places that do easy returns... ...Show more →
Mine had one weak corner, and I wanted my 35mm for both close up, bokeh-type shots and landscape shots. In retrospect, I should not have demanded perfection in this case. That is one curse of pixel peeping.
Chris_88 wrote: DavidBM wroteI would never give up my good copy of the 1.4/35FE. It's not quite as contrasty as the ZM, or perhaps as sharp centrally at wider apertures (though it's no slouch by any standards). But it does have the most staggeringly gorgeous bokeh; soft and alluring that makes it a sensational portrait lens - and the eyeAF is great there. Sure if there are specular highlights you might get a touch of onion ring, but if you really care about that in an exhibition picture, it can be worth it to edit. But I almost never mind, and I don't know anything else at this FL with such a lovely rendition OOF.
Of course, given the stories we hear, I don't know if I'd whole heartedly recommend anyone getting into the FE1.4/35 lottery unless they lived in the US and could deal with places that do easy returns...Mine had one weak corner, and I wanted my 35mm for both close up, bokeh-type shots and landscape shots. In retrospect, I should not have demanded perfection in this case. That is one curse of pixel peeping.
Oh well, what can you do? Mine has fine corners; stopped down there are better than my Lox 35. But I still prefer the overall contrast of the Loxia for landscape. Plus on the kind of adventures where I do landscape the FE would mean giving up another lens because of weight and size (I know folks have very different tolerances here.
I know it's a first world luxury, and even a luxury by first world standards, but if it can be managed it's great to have different lenses of the same FL that are just the right tool for different jobs. Of course in the case of 35 mm there's no real all purpose (around f2, maybe AF firvportraits not too big not too small) lens out there in FE mount yet..
DannyBurkPhoto wrote:
Looking forward to your photos!
I received another backorder notice from B&H today Luvwine, did you order from outside the US?
Yes. As I have previously said, I ordered from an authorized dealer in the UK from whom I have bought before--Robert White. Last I checked, they had three in stock and including customs duties, I still paid about $120 less than B&H's price.
My wife's nephew's girlfriend asked if I could take a pic for her to use on Linkedin. Since I had a new lens to play with, I was happy to comply. I am not one to do portraits commonly and she chose the shirt, but here were two of my shots. She chose neither of these for her portrait, but these are both at the same F 2.4, I think. Loxia 85 and Leica 90 AA. Sorry the background does not have a lot of point light sources, but it would not have served the mission.... These have just basic processing--color temp (daylight), autotone, standard sharpening, and medium contrast profile and nothing else, not even cropping. There is a chance that the Leica focus was off by a gnat's hair as the eye crop does not look quite as sharp as some others, but I include it with that caveat...I also took pics with the Leica M Apo 135/3.4, R apo 180/2.8 and R Apo 280/4. Kinda fun to see the different looks.
Well, very interesting. L85 has more image depth (as expected, also FL DOF difference) and more contrast (as expected). It used to be said that Leica lenses deliver painterly images whereas CZ lenses provide deeper, realistic imagery. Big difference here is perhaps also a brand trait - the 'haste to coloration'. L85 retains more realism, 90AA moves to yellow fast, seen in skin tones - L85 has a nice hint of rouging in cheeks. This can be important if you want more color in the image post WB tuning, you want skin color to 'stay within bounds'. Quite equal treatment of flaws, L85 does not present as too sharp (personal view obviously, I'm a fan of skin).
Visible also in hair: low contrast in Leica image has more of a surfer girl 'unwashed bleach' look to it, lacks sparkle, freshness, tone separation. Hair ends are less lively too - poorly defined curl crossovers, as are shirt folds. Some FL diffs too - nicer hair overlay on neck in L85. Crop is unfair, as 90AA is a little unsharp, but see how the high tone in the very luminous L85 crop retains tonal range representation with detail in high tones -> directly to better shaping. Clear brick mortar and nicer blue sky too, lol. thank you, again.
To my eye the two are very close again. The Zeiss has a little more macro contrast, but this means the highlights on the left side of the face have lost just the tiniest hint of detail, which was never there in the Leica. I like the highlights in the face better on the Leica, but this could be easily adjusted in post. The Zeiss is a little sharper here, but the Leica is probably slightly misfocussed. Both work exceptionally well. I see the brand traits of slightly more 3D in the Zeiss and slightly better control of highlights and shadows in the Leica. The differences are small though.
To my eyes, they look quite similar. However, the iris and moreso the eyelashes look sharper to me in the Loxia shot. This might be the result of DOF or focusing. At those distances and f stops, this can easily happen, I'd imagine (this is no criticsm, just an attempt explanation).
Then again, may be I'm just skeptical of the apparently widely held belief that a Zeiss always is or has to be superior.
GMPhotography wrote:
Frankly and I will be blunt. If it was me the Leica would be on the buy and sell board. Yellow does not cut it at all
I see what Guy sees. The Leica has a more yellow-ish tint than the Zeiss. This goes for the outdoor shot of the couple as as well. Thus, to me the Zeiss rendered the more pleasing and contrasty image.