fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2016 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2016Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar

  
 
Luvwine
Offline
Details
p.40 #1Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Did some more shooting today. Let me know if you are getting tired of these. I am having a hard time deciding about the relative merits of the Leica 90 AA and the Zeiss Loxia 85. Both are very fine lenses. I guess I can resort to the "Spencer method" and just keep them both....

Anyway, first are some non scientific tests. Contrary to yesterday's, all of these shots are processed somewhat.

First a casual portrait while on a waterfall hike with the Loxia 85. Somehow this was at F 3.5 (don't have any idea how that happened):

http://m6.i.pbase.com/o9/91/505291/1/164757786.Fue9uLFp._DSC0059.jpg


Next, I got these two to allow me to take two pics--first with Loxia, second with Leica 90. I like their expressions for the Leica shot. Both are at F 2.8. Any preferences otherwise? Slight crop here cropping off the top of each image. Less than ideal background....

http://m6.i.pbase.com/o9/91/505291/1/164757796.eUnJfhgF._DSC0071.jpg


http://m7.i.pbase.com/o9/91/505291/1/164757797.IXc0CZ3g._DSC0072.jpg


Next I did two more scenes with a bit more "scientific" methodology. both are processed using autotone and auto color temp tho I lowered the exposure on each the same amount. I gave each a "medium contrast" curve in Lightroom and identical 46/.7/25 sharpening and both used camera standard color profles with no clarity, saturation or the like. All are at F5.6:

Test scene one (did a bad job as the focus was on infinity and the left side of the image is too close and is therefore blurry at F5.6 but hopefully this will still be useful):

http://m0.i.pbase.com/o9/91/505291/1/164758090.gyT5jzF4.testscene.jpg


Center crop Loxia:

http://m1.i.pbase.com/o9/91/505291/1/164758091.P2U1ZybO.centercrop.jpg


Center Crop Leica:

http://m2.i.pbase.com/o9/91/505291/1/164758092.rUF2iOVm.leicacentercrop.jpg


Left of center Loxia:

http://m3.i.pbase.com/o9/91/505291/1/164758093.OvCo5uO7.devilscthouse.jpg


Left of center Leica:

http://m4.i.pbase.com/o9/91/505291/1/164758094.2vrgIRtl.leicadevilscthouse.jpg


Mid lower right Loxia:

http://m5.i.pbase.com/o9/91/505291/1/164758095.4taoUf7T.midlowerright.jpg


Mid lower right Leica:

http://m7.i.pbase.com/o9/91/505291/1/164758097.2h9XzUwe.leicamidlowerright.jpg


Test scene two (another back yard test but with better light and a different direction):

http://m0.i.pbase.com/o9/91/505291/1/164758100.wum5Lj84.scene2.jpg


Center crop Loxia:

http://m1.i.pbase.com/o9/91/505291/1/164758101.1NpbQume.centercrop2.jpg


Center Crop Leica:

http://m2.i.pbase.com/o9/91/505291/1/164758102.cX87OFdh.Leicacentercrop2.jpg


Extreme right edge Loxia:

http://m3.i.pbase.com/o9/91/505291/1/164758103.c4Siy8O8.rightedge2.jpg


Extreme right Edge Leica:

http://m4.i.pbase.com/o9/91/505291/1/164758104.CGrWEYHY.Leicarightedge2.jpg


Lower Right corner Loxia:

http://m5.i.pbase.com/o9/91/505291/1/164758105.uGhhHER5.lowerrightcorner2.jpg


Lower Right Corner Leica:

http://m6.i.pbase.com/o9/91/505291/1/164758106.p9UgEjte.Leicalowerrightcorner2.jpg


Hope some of this is helpful. Both are excellent lenses. Any thoughts on a winner here?

Dec 28, 2016 at 08:17 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.40 #2Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Thanks again for the samples. I'm not tired of them, but then I have the same dilemma so I could easily see that others may feel differently. For the portraits, I really like both and I think these shots show the typical Zeiss/Leica difference. The Loxia has just a touch more 3D to my eye, but the bokeh has noticeably more contrast than the Leica and I prefer my bokeh with less contrast. I would pick the Leica here, but it is hard to not be impacted by the slightly nicer expression for the Leica shot as well. The longer shots I again see very similar results. I think I slight prefer the Leica for the mid zone shot as it seems to hold detail just a touch better, but that last pair of shots in the corner I definitely prefer the Zeiss. In sum, I think these lenses are a lot a like and both very very strong. I do think they show their brand, however. The Zeiss has a bit more contrast and the Leica has a nice reduction of contrast in the bokeh. In the end I think it may depend on how each lens fits with your existing set. For me I think the Leica will pair with my Leica M 50AA very well. In contrast, I think the Zeiss will fit well with my ZM 35 f/1.4, so depending on which set I want to take I will probably have a slight preference for one. Specifically, a four lens Leica WATE, 28 lux, 50 AA, and 90 AA set out to work extremely well together, as would a three lens Zeiss Loxia 21, ZM 35 f/1.4, Loxia 85 set. Perhaps more simple rationalization on my part, but I think I really do want both.
Dec 28, 2016 at 08:47 PM
Luvwine
Offline
Details
p.40 #3Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Steve Spencer wrote:
Thanks again for the samples. I'm not tired of them, but then I have the same dilemma so I could easily see that others may feel differently. For the portraits, I really like both and I think these shots show the typical Zeiss/Leica difference. The Loxia has just a touch more 3D to my eye, but the bokeh has noticeably more contrast than the Leica and I prefer my bokeh with less contrast. I would pick the Leica here, but it is hard to not be impacted by the slightly nicer expression for the Leica shot as well. The
...Show more →

Interesting way to look at it. I have been trying to build a set of lenses getting the lens at each focal length I like the best. I have ended up with a mix of Leica and Zeiss and one Voitlander....

Zeiss at 21, 35, 50, and 85.
Leica at 28, 75, 90, 135, 180, and 280 plus apo extenders.
CV at 12mm

I suspect your approach is more sensible...
Dec 28, 2016 at 09:04 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.40 #4Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Zeiss has a touch more 3D also has a touch more clarity to the look. Leica holds the highlights a touch better but it's a little flatter so makes sense. Hard to tell with skin tone since you did some adjustments but the Zeiss looks a little warmer toned.

Really could be a flip of the coin. As you can make it look more Zeiss or more Leica with minor adjustments. It's certainly not worlds away from each other here.
Dec 28, 2016 at 09:25 PM
DannyBurkPhoto
Offline
Details
p.40 #5Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Hard to go wrong with either one, although the corner certainly favors the Zeiss. I have a preference for Zeiss contrast in general, but both look really nice.
Dec 28, 2016 at 10:17 PM
Luvwine
Offline
Details
p.40 #6Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
I did shoot one more comparison when waiting for a sunset that never came due to clouds. The light was failing, but figure why not post it. The Leica shots were first and there was perhaps a minute or two later that I shot the Loxia so the Loxia did have a slight bit less light. This time there is NOTHING done other than color temp (auto) and Camera standard color profile. That is all. No tone, no sharpening, etc. Here is the scene:

http://m8.i.pbase.com/o9/91/505291/1/164758388.CfbyE0Nn.Scene3.jpg


Loxia center right crop:


http://m1.i.pbase.com/o9/91/505291/1/164758391.TNpm738W.loxiacenterright32.jpg


Leica center right crop:

http://m2.i.pbase.com/o9/91/505291/1/164758392.rkeIkttR.leicacenterright3.jpg


Loxia Lower left:

http://m0.i.pbase.com/o9/91/505291/1/164758390.etx5enfL.loxialowerleft32.jpg


Leica lower left:

http://m9.i.pbase.com/o9/91/505291/1/164758389.o4ATVz3k.leicalowerleft3.jpg


Loxia extreme right edge:

http://m4.i.pbase.com/o9/91/505291/1/164758394.6vhy6lnV.loxiaextremerightedge32.jpg


Leica extreme right edge:

http://m3.i.pbase.com/o9/91/505291/1/164758393.NoCRbWXN.leicarightedge3.jpg


Extreme lower right corner Loxia:

http://m6.i.pbase.com/o9/91/505291/1/164758396.lM1e7Dcs.loxiaextremelowerrightcorner3.jpg


Extreme lower right corner Leica:

http://m5.i.pbase.com/o9/91/505291/1/164758395.FG23dSRM.leicaextremelowerrightcorner32.jpg


That is all for today (a great sigh went out). I do want to try some more bokeh/portrait type tests but those are harder to do I think and we are entertaining a young couple so these tests were done rather quickly as time permitted...

Thanks to all for looking and commenting. I agree that these lenses are very close with different personalities. It is a first world problem to have the ability to choose!

Edited on Dec 29, 2016 at 06:03 AM · View previous versions
Dec 28, 2016 at 10:29 PM
Luvwine
Offline
Details
p.40 #7Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
DannyBurkPhoto wrote:
Hard to go wrong with either one, although the corner certainly favors the Zeiss. I have a preference for Zeiss contrast in general, but both look really nice.


I agree on this particular comparison, but testing lenses for me is a funny thing in that one picture may show a difference in a given area but the next does not so a number of different tests must be done. I really don't think that either lens has a big edge over the other anywhere on the frame that i can see. Agreed that the Loxia has more native contrast but sometimes I think this is at the cost of occasional slight (underline both occasional and slight) loss of detail that the Leica retains. However, these differences are really subtle and with processing they diminish still further.
Dec 28, 2016 at 10:38 PM
genji
Offline
Details
p.40 #8Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Although I'm waiting for the notification that my Loxia 85 is ready to be picked up, I have been following with interest the comparisons with the Leica 90 AA. What I do find surprising is that the shape of the 90 AA's aperture blades hasn't been discussed, given Phillip Reeve's strongly negative opinion in his review of the Summicron-M 90/2 Pre-ASPH, which has the same blades:

The general quality of the bokeh is very good, no onion rings, no outlining. But on stopping down the shape of highlights changes: at f2.0 they are perfectly round (except for the border regions, where mechanical vignetting occurs), between f2.8 and f8 they can best be described as “crown cork” shaped (take a look at the example below), at f11 they are edgy 11-sided-figures and at f16 perfectly round again. To be totally honest here: I don’t like these “crown cork” shaped highlights (as much as I don’t like the highlights produced by perfectly straight blades for portrait shots as well),...Show more →

and

What I don’t really like are the inwardly curved aperture blades (which are also still present in today’s APO-Summicron), to me this is the biggest slip up of the lens.

You can see the effect in the Bokeh section of Phillip's review and John Schwarz at PebblePlace includes a product shot showing the aperture blades in his review of the 90 AA.

I would have thought that this "feature" of the lens would have been of interest (or concern) to landscape shooters.
Dec 28, 2016 at 10:56 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.40 #9Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
I keep leaning in the Zeiss direction from the landscape scenes
Dec 28, 2016 at 11:11 PM
Luvwine
Offline
Details
p.40 #10Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
GMPhotography wrote:
I keep leaning in the Zeiss direction from the landscape scenes


Sometimes I agree, other times not. I see more detail in the last comparison on the Leica in the rock faces, for example. We are really splitting hairs here.
Dec 28, 2016 at 11:40 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.40 #11Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Probably so, they are very close. Here is when you look at size, weight money as your main buy factors. IQ wise it's close enough either way that small adjustments make up any difference.
Dec 28, 2016 at 11:46 PM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.40 #12Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
GMPhotography wrote:
Probably so, they are very close. Here is when you look at size, weight money as your main buy factors. IQ wise it's close enough either way that small adjustments make up any difference.


I think that's right. It's all back and forth in tiny hairsplitting ways that will not be visible even in very large prints (mostly if I had to pick I'd go zeiss), except for that corner where, if the image is representative, there's something wrong with that copy of the AA or else the Zeiss is much better. Counting an adapter (especially a helicoid one) the weight is very similar. Neither are super light, nor super heavy. And I don't think I care about the half stop.

I would go with the Loxia if money were not part of the decision, so even more so given its price.

Dec 29, 2016 at 01:36 AM
Luvwine
Offline
Details
p.40 #13Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
DavidBM wrote:
GMPhotography wroteProbably so, they are very close. Here is when you look at size, weight money as your main buy factors. IQ wise it's close enough either way that small adjustments make up any difference.
I think that's right. It's all back and forth in tiny hairsplitting ways that will not be visible even in very large prints (mostly if I had to pick I'd go zeiss), except for that corner where, if the image is representative, there's something wrong with that copy of the AA or else the Zeiss is much better. Counting an adapter (especially a helicoid one) the weight is very similar. Neither are super light, nor super heavy. And I don't think I care about the half stop.

I would go with the Loxia if money were not part of the decision,
...Show more →

Nothing wrong with this copy of the Leica. I purposefully included an extreme lower right corner crop in the last comparison. There is a focal length difference and this makes exact comparisons of the extreme corners a bit difficult as the subject matter is a bit different. That comparison was also processed so that might have affected that particular part of the image. Focus difference could also explain that particular difference as looking at the same image, the Leica is better in the upper left corner. One can cherry pick different parts of the image on a given comparison which is why for me I do a fair bit of testing and comparing multiple images with different lighting conditions and subjects to get an impression.

Here are the extreme lower right corner crops from one of the earlier comparisons, Loxia first:





Leica looks better to me here, but others may disagree.

Edited on Dec 29, 2016 at 06:25 AM · View previous versions
Dec 29, 2016 at 05:54 AM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.40 #14Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
So let's say all things being equal between the Loxia and Leica , I think the next lens that some if not more are looking at is the ZM 85. So have to see how that stacks up. I also think a good test for Batis 85 owners is what kind of difference there maybe. The GM 85 is awesome on center wide and very good in corners but ultimately the ZM was the better landscape lens in my tests.
Dec 29, 2016 at 06:09 AM
Luvwine
Offline
Details
p.40 #15Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
GMPhotography wrote:
So let's say all things being equal between the Loxia and Leica , I think the next lens that some if not more are looking at is the ZM 85. So have to see how that stacks up. I also think a good test for Batis 85 owners is what kind of difference there maybe. The GM 85 is awesome on center wide and very good in corners but ultimately the ZM was the better landscape lens in my tests.


From Fred's testing, the ZM 85 lost to the Leica 90/AA for landscape, so I would be surprised if it was any better than the Loxia, but given the vagaries of copy variation, one never knows for sure. I would also be surprised if the Batis or GM 85 were better for landscape, but I have never shot with either so this is rank speculation based upon the notion that at least the GM seems more optimized for portrait and bokeh rather than corner to corner sharpness at infinity.
Dec 29, 2016 at 06:14 AM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.40 #16Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
I agree the Batis and GM are not really for landscape but the person only wanting ONE 85 in their bag than they will have to decide which 85 fits them the best witn some compromises as well with sharpness, bokeh and look. For those of us that want TWO 85s than it's a easier choice. For me GM 85 for everything people and a 85 strictly for highest resolving power. So for us looking at that second lens we have Loxia, Zeiss and Leica but it's nice to know for the record and ONE lens folks how much they maybe giving up or making up with there choice.

This is a very crowded focal length with some real winnng lenses. So deciding is tougher to do.

I also agree wholeheartedly unfortunately in copy variations. This part sucks as many of us has run into this problem

Edited on Dec 29, 2016 at 06:37 AM · View previous versions
Dec 29, 2016 at 06:34 AM
BastianK
Offline
Details
p.40 #17Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
GMPhotography wrote:
I agree the Batis and GM are not really for landscape but the person only wanting ONE 85 in their bag than they will have to decide which 85 fits them the best witn some compromises as well with sharpness, bokeh and look. For those of us that want TWO 85s than it's a easier choice. For me GM 85 for everything people and a 85 strictly for highest resolving power. So for us looking at that second lens we have Loxia, Zeiss and Leica but it's nice to know for the record and ONE lens folks how much they
...Show more →
For me it is 85mm 2.4 Loxia for landscape / architecture / everyday shooting (city trip, hike, whatever)
and 135mm 2.0L for portrait or anything else where I want really shallow DoF.

As a "one lens" solution (which is something I am not looking for) I might go for 90AA or Batis.
Dec 29, 2016 at 06:36 AM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.40 #18Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
See I'm with you. If there was a native 135 E mount than it would be even easier choice as I would drop my GM 85 pick the best landscape lens here and use the 135 for people. No question about it.

The 135 is a very important people lens that has been ignored in E mount. It really is my biggest bitch about our lens choices. Like to see a native 200 2.8 as well

Right now we have to play 85 to cover too much types of shooting which leads to two 85s and that's the issue we are facing today.

Great discussion
Dec 29, 2016 at 06:41 AM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.40 #19Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
End of day the investment in two 85s is very high. For me with GM and Loxia that's 3200 hundred dollars tied up in one focal length. That's a big investment for some of us
Dec 29, 2016 at 06:45 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.40 #20Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
GMPhotography wrote:
End of day the investment in two 85s is very high. For me with GM and Loxia that's 3200 hundred dollars tied up in one focal length. That's a big investment for some of us


For you Guy, it seems pretty clear the GM plus ZM f/4 works well at 85. Why mess with that combo? The GM works as your people lens and the ZM is both small and excellent for landscapes. I like the Loxia 85 from what I have seen a lot, but in your case you get a lens double the size and double the price for a very very small gain and a stretch in the budget that doesn't seem comfortable.
Dec 29, 2016 at 07:35 AM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister