Having the GM 85 1.4 and the ZM 85 F4 which is really small and maybe the best 85 I have seen. Mines a laser than I really have no interest. It does not replace either one on many levels and not fast enough to stand on its own. I'm out
My guess it's intended for video folks so for them it maybe a good choice. For still folks given some really nice AF lenses probably not. I think for a lot of folks it's a pass. But this also puts out a much needed 135, 100 macro out much further in the future.
DavidBM wrote:
Indeed; I guess I didn't mention the 90 macro because I think of it as, well, a macro (that's pretty much exclusively what I use it for) even though it's a very good general purpose 90 if a bit big if what you wanted was a general purpose short tele.
So it sort of seems it's trumped by the ZM 4/85 as a light landscape solution, it.s not a macro, trumped by the Batis as a generalist and by the GM as a portrait specialist .
It will have lovely sunstars though. And likely amazing performance against the light with its 7/7 construction. So maybe someone looking for those features but wanted more speed than the ZM might bite......Show more →
Agreed. I love the sunstars produced by those 10-blade aperture lenses as well as strong flare resistance as much as the next guy, but I wonder how many people are willing to shell out a significant amount of cash for those features. After all, sunstars are of concern for those of us using the lens stopped down shooting landscapes or cities at night: As you correctly pointed out, David, there is no need for 2.4 for that type of application. What is more, if you prefer a MF lens, used copies of the ZM 85 4, the Elmarit 90 2.8 and the Summarit 90 2.5 (if not the newer f2.4 version) will be much cheaper and optionally can be used with AF thanks to the TAP. The next Loxia *may be* better than those three, but by how much?
This it just a little tube of useless to me.. :\ I've got the Batis 85 and CY Sonnar 85 2.8. I just sold the FE 90 because I didn't need more in that general FL. A Batis 135 would've had me digging through pillow cushions for loose change, but this is a big ball of 'meh'.
Jannik Peters wrote:
I love my 200€ (ok, I was lucky) Sonnar 3.5/100 even more now... If I could just transplant that Loxia aperture into that lens
I was just thinking that the other day! There are lens technicians arounfpd that replace irises....I wonder if I *could* get ten straight blades installed into my c/y 100?
Fred Miranda wrote: DavidBM wroteCould be an image of an existing Lox....L21, say, so as not to give the game away.It does look very similar to the Loxia 21/2.8, but if the picture does not depict the lens itself, my guess the new Loxia will be a 85mm. (I was hoping for a 28mm)
I would say Fred must have had some inside knowledge
So 85mm it is. Keeps the same 52mm filter-good! Looks a tad bit longer than I would have thought. Hood looks very long.
While it looks like a great lens, I will keep using my adapted Nikon 100mm f2.8 E series lens. It looks smaller than this and also takes 52mm filters. It also provides better spacing for me since I bought a Sony 55mm.
Still look forward to see how well. This does when it gets in the market.
Chris_88 wrote: DavidBM wroteHmm. A lot of money. And it's too fast: it doesn't look like it's a significant size or weight benefit over the Batis 85. And really, even if it's sharper - would more sharpness than Batis be even visible? F 2.4 just seems the wrong speed to persuade anyone to have both this and another. You might want a Batis for travel and a GM for portraiture in the studio or location. Or you might want th Batis as a general solution and an f4 for hiking. So I don't see anyone wanting boththis and the Batis. And if forced to choose, the B has 2/3 of a stop, AF, OSS a no doesn't seem more cumbersome. I haven't seen th exact weight of th Lox yet. Anyone know?+1.
This lens is basically competing against lenses that are excellent in their own way. I'd add the 90 Macro to the GM and Batis. The Loxia won't have the close focus distance of the macro, it doesn't have the speed of the GM and the Batis, and doesn't seem to provide substantial savings in size/weight over the Batis. Are there that many people out there looking for somewhat old school MF operation in a moderately fast 85mm prime? I for my part definitely prefer the AF of the Batis with such longer FL's. With my Elmarit 90 2.8, focusing wide open works OK, but it's a challenge under time pressure....Show more →
I have no problems focusing an 80-100mm f/2.8, as long as the throw isn't so long that it slows me down. Easier then a slow wide. But I'm also not in the market for the Loxia - it's very hard to improve on the Contax G 90mm and C/Y 85mm, and both of those cost more than a grand less.
rji2goleez wrote:
It's quite a long lens compared to the rest of the Loxia line. As a Sonnar lens, how will this compare in rendering to the Batis 85/1.8? The positioning of this lens vs Batis and GM with such a high price point leaves me scratching my head a bit.
I think an f/2.4 is a good balance. I will be getting this. Yes, it is longer, but an 85mm pretty much has to be. I would have preferred a 28mm, but I am very happy with this.
I'll get one, too.
I have all the other 3 and have been holding back buying G or Batis to wait and see what would come as next Loxia. I had hoped for a 100/2.5 though, but I bet this one is sharp and contrasty to the edges wide open already, as it's a Sonnar design with less elements than Planar or Distagon. Which makes it lightweight also.
I already have a standing pre-order for a potential future Batis 135mm at the dealer I got my other three Batis lenses from.
Randolph K wrote:
So if Zeiss announces a 135mm Batis 1.8 or f2, would anyone here pre-order it? I've never pre-ordered anything camera related, but I think I would for a fast Batis 135.
I like that they made a moderate aperture telephoto...it's something missing from the system at the moment, and I'm sure it will be outstanding. However, the $1,500 price point is insane. When they already have the Batis 85/1.8, which is phenomenal, and has autofocus, AND costs $1,200, it's really hard to peddle a slower, manual focus lens (from the same manufacturer), for $300 more. I'm sure it's smaller than the Batis, but it's probably no lighter (the Batis is surprisingly light for its size). This lens should be priced at around $850-$900, and no more.
One of the best well kept secrets is this great priced lens.
The hood is kind of long for it. I just buy cheap metal hoods off eBay. For this you need a 43mm standard hood strohscw wrote:
Well, I just ordered a Zeiss 85 ZM and I am happy with it. It is smaller, costs less and with the TAP I also have Autofocus.
I've had the 85ZM for a while now and that lens continues to amaze me right from wide open being sharp across the frame on my A7RII. The ONLY issue I have with the TT85 is its flare resistance when pointed at the sun (and lack of CPU for EXIF).
What are the weight/size specs against the 85ZM? The links in this thread aren't working to get to the article on Optyczne . . .
The Leica Summarit 90/2.4 is 1950 EUR incl. VAT at Meister camera in Hamburg and 2195 USD at BHPhoto in New York. The google translated text from optyczne.pl indicates that the Loxia is a 7/7 elements/groups, wheras the Leica is a 5/4 elements/groups. This makes the price of 1400 EUR for the Zeiss Loxia 85/2.4 though expensive, still seem reasonable to me.