alundeb wrote:
adrianb wrote
alundeb wrote
Yes, there will be a lot of debate. This modest increase in resolution indicates a separation between high resolution and low resolution bodies now. There will not be one camera that will excel at all parameters at the same time.
I wonder if this upgrade will be tempting for those who already have a 1DX. Increased resolution to about 28 MP seemed to be the single imrovement that was most asked for. Most users were satisfied with the AF performance and frame rate. Video aside, what is in it then? I have not shot the 1Dx but instead read a lot about it and with Nikon's D5 specs, to say that increased resolution to 28mp seemed to be the "single' improvement that was most asked for ...... I must ask myself what are people using their 1Dx ? as a social status statement? or to actually shoot stuff. Do they all print/ print large?
I'm not the most technical guy but since the 1D series have been keen on speed/accuracy, why put a large mp sensor in that body to cripple it? Since most of them will be used to shoot wildlife/sports, or anyways,stuff which requires supreme AF & etc.. The 1DX was supposed to merge the high resolution 1Ds line with the high speed 1D line. Because the 1D IV had higher pixel density, the 1DX was a downgrade from the 1D IV in terms of pixel density, and it was from the 1Ds III in terms of resolution. This strategy was controversial.
Pixel density and high resolution is not a negative thing itself, and the potential sacrifice in speed and high ISO read noise can be overcome and balanced with new developments.
The 1D IV had a resolution of 16 megapixels on an APS-H sensor. The 1D X had 18 megapixels on a full-frame sensor, which means larger pixels at a lower pixels/inch on the sensor - I presume that's what you mean by reduced pixel density. The advantages here were (slightly) increased resolution and improved high ISO from larger pixels.
The 1Ds III had a resolution of 21 megapixels on a full-frame sensor - the 1D X went backwards on that with no countervailing advantage.
I continue to maintain that the 1D X was never a replacement for the 1Ds III. Its frame rate makes it clear that it was only a replacement for the 1D IV.