fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2016 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 20161DX II- 22mp Just Posted

  
 
PetKal
Offline
Details
p.14 #11DX II- 22mp Just Posted
Stoffer wrote:
Some more impressions, this time from Canon Explorer Ángel Martínez:

EOS-1D X Mark II doing soccer

He compares it to the EOS-1D X.


Thank you Nils, that review I like better. It shows some intelligent comparo methodology, and the conclusions, while perhaps debateable, at least do not sound far fetched.
I guess his bottom line is that 1DXII has exceeded his expectations re metering, AF tracking and ISO noise. Fair enough.
Mar 02, 2016 at 10:31 AM
Lan11
Offline
[X]
Details
p.14 #21DX II- 22mp Just Posted
A wonderful demo-review.
But, I wonder what is faster? His mouth’s WPS (words per sec) or new Canon’s FPS?

In the nutshell:
http://web.ncf.ca/fm568/Demo.png
Mar 03, 2016 at 09:11 AM
PetKal
Offline
Details
p.14 #31DX II- 22mp Just Posted
Lan, that is very funny and cleverly done. I think Rouse might be getting a kick out of it too, if he sees it.

("Underware" = "Underwear" ?)
Mar 03, 2016 at 09:30 AM
ggreene
Offline
Details
p.14 #41DX II- 22mp Just Posted
Stoffer wrote:
Some more impressions, this time from Canon Explorer Ángel Martínez:

EOS-1D X Mark II doing soccer

He compares it to the EOS-1D X.


Good to see further confirmation that the gap "could be" larger then expected between the 1DX2/1DX especially with a test in a sports venue but I'm still reserving judgment until I read/watch something from an independent source.
Mar 03, 2016 at 10:03 AM
gordorad
Offline
Details
p.14 #51DX II- 22mp Just Posted
jcolwell wrote:
alundeb wrote...Because the 1D IV had higher pixel density, the 1DX was a downgrade from the 1D IV in terms of pixel density, and it was from the 1Ds III in terms of resolution.
Resolution is determined by pixel density. Both the 1DIV (175 ppmm) and 1DsIII (156 ppmm) have higher pixel density than the 1DX (144 ppmm).

I've used all three of these cameras extensively. I sold my 1DsIII to get the 1DX when the X first arrived, because I wanted a full frame, high-fps body to shoot alongside my 1DIV. Now, I use the 1DX more often than the 1DIV, because the 1DX is a better camera from almost every perspective. OTOH, I still use the 1DX and 1DIV together, whenever I'm shooting action or shooting in really bad weather, and the
...Show more →

The 1dx is better, but is it three times better? Personally, at today's prices, you can easily have two, realsitically three 1d mk IV's for the price of a single 1dx.

Mar 03, 2016 at 10:14 AM
jcolwell
Offline
Details
p.14 #61DX II- 22mp Just Posted
gordorad wrote:
The 1dx is better, but is it three times better? Personally, at today's prices, you can easily have two, realsitically three 1d mk IV's for the price of a single 1dx.


At high ISO, yes.

P.S. "today's prices" aren't particularly relevant to my decision making. I bought both the 1DX and 1DIV when they were new. Each one was well worth the price.

Mar 03, 2016 at 10:55 AM
adamx12m
Offline
Details
p.14 #71DX II- 22mp Just Posted
ggreene wrote:
Stoffer wroteSome more impressions, this time from Canon Explorer Ángel Martínez:

EOS-1D X Mark II doing soccer

He compares it to the EOS-1D X.
Good to see further confirmation that the gap "could be" larger then expected between the 1DX2/1DX especially with a test in a sports venue but I'm still reserving judgment until I read/watch something from an independent source.


At the end of the article, like he was going to say "There wasn't much difference between them". While the gap between the the two bodies should be noticeable, your wallet as usual is where it will be significant. His images at 1000 - 2000 iso @ 1/1600, that's no high-iso for sports. Something to be said for the metering if that's been significantly improved to deal with shadows.

If I recall the 1dx to shoot 12fps has to be at 1/1000 minimum, at 14fps I'd think it's up a bit which is maybe why all his shots were at 1/1600.
Mar 03, 2016 at 11:43 AM
ggreene
Offline
Details
p.14 #81DX II- 22mp Just Posted
Yeah, that's why I am waiting to see a 1DX2 vs. 1DX comparison in the 6400-12800 ISO range before I make any decision. That's where I shoot a lot of indoor sports. I don't know why but I just have a feeling I'm going to look at it and say, "meh".
Mar 03, 2016 at 12:29 PM
Lan11
Offline
[X]
Details
p.14 #91DX II- 22mp Just Posted
Petkal , “Lan, that is very funny and cleverly done”. ("Underware" = "Underwear" ?)

All complements are due to Andy & his intrepid camera crew.

• (wares) = articles offered for sale”.
Some of his garment pieces will be auctioned to collectors of memorabilia after this blood freezing adventure.
Mar 03, 2016 at 02:31 PM
JaimitoFrog
Offline
Details
p.14 #101DX II- 22mp Just Posted
here's some amateur shots of the viewfinder in action, looks like AI-Servo with center Large Zone on.

neat stand at Canon for people to try. summer Olympics coming up.

Mar 05, 2016 at 12:28 AM
rscheffler
Offline
Details
p.14 #111DX II- 22mp Just Posted
adamx12m wrote:
If I recall the 1dx to shoot 12fps has to be at 1/1000 minimum, at 14fps I'd think it's up a bit which is maybe why all his shots were at 1/1600.


My experience shooting sports has been that 1/1600 and higher is desirable to minimize subject motion blur. It becomes rather more noticeable at 1/1000 and of course when lower than that. This was first more evident with the 1DIV, which compared to the 1DIII was of course higher pixel density. With cameras like the 1DII my general rule was 1/800 and 1/640 was definitely preferable over 1/500, which was kind of the golden standard of the film era (trying to get to 1/500 @ f/2.8 shooting night sports back then was a challenge).

JaimitoFrog wrote:
here's some amateur shots of the viewfinder in action, looks like AI-Servo with center Large Zone on.

neat stand at Canon for people to try. summer Olympics coming up.


Sounds just as loud as the 1DX, unfortunately.



Stoffer wrote:
Some more impressions, this time from Canon Explorer Ángel Martínez:

EOS-1D X Mark II doing soccer

He compares it to the EOS-1D X.


A quote from that review:

"Regarding the new autofocus system, I had already seen the improvement in tracking and speed-servo AF in previous days, but this match also showed that performance in strong backlight situations is very good. It all related to the increase in frames-per-second which allowed me more images to choose from for decisive moments."

Interestingly, this is very similar to my feelings about the 1DX vs. the 1DIV back in 2012. I was skeptical about the on-paper differences but was pleasantly surprised with the more consistent AF that coupled with higher fps rate considerably increased my productivity at sports events.
Mar 05, 2016 at 12:43 AM
Stoffer
Offline
Details
p.14 #121DX II- 22mp Just Posted
On the note of high fps, here is another interesting improvement:

When doing 14 fps in live view on the original 1D X, you could only shoot in jpeg and the live view screen would go blank.

On the Mark II, you can now shoot 16 fps in raw, and the screen will no longer go blank while you rattle all those shots off. This means that you can now pan and follow your subject like a mirrorless pro.

AF and exposure is still locked of course, but if you can pre focus on where the action will happen, like an athlete jumping over a bar, those 16 fps might be a whole lot more useful than the 14 fps on the 1D X. Just something to think about.
Mar 05, 2016 at 03:46 AM
PetKal
Offline
Details
p.14 #131DX II- 22mp Just Posted
Stoffer wrote:
On the Mark II, you can now shoot 16 fps in raw, and the screen will no longer go blank while you rattle all those shots off. This means that you can now pan and follow your subject like a mirrorless pro.



I am sure our bird photography buddy known as "Machine gun" Joe (not his real name) will buy 1DXMkII if only for the ability to fire away at 14/16 FPS.

While many photographers love the sound of their dSLRs at a fast frame rate, "Machine gun" Joe shoots EVERYTHING at 12 FPS using his 1DX, be that a landscape, a portrait, a bird in flight, or a duck slowly drifting on water.
When we shoot the same thing together, he'd take home typically some 3000 shots while on my card I'd have about 300 frames.

At any point of time he has a backlog of tens of thousands of image files he has yet to review and sort out. Obviously most of those images are redundant repeats.

If you ask "Machine gun" Joe, he'd tell you he needs a very fast FPS in order to not miss any action. I do not think that is the real reason. I think he just likes to hear the prattle 12FPS makes because that makes him feel like a "pro". Moreover, the crackling of 1DX going at 12/14 FPS also intimidates other photographers whose "inferior" cameras are limited to "only" 10 or 8 FPS max frame rate.

In reality, when one stands next to "Machine gun" Joe in the field, the incessant fast prattle his camera makes is annoying.
Mar 05, 2016 at 05:50 AM
skid00skid00
Offline
Details
p.14 #141DX II- 22mp Just Posted
PetKal wrote:
Moreover, the crackling of 1DX going at 12/14 FPS also intimidates other photographers whose "inferior" cameras are limited to "only" 10 or 8 FPS max frame rate.
.


...Wait a second...

Aren't *you* the guy with the big whites..?!



Mar 05, 2016 at 06:53 AM
mptnest
Offline
Details
p.14 #151DX II- 22mp Just Posted
Doing a quick word search on this thread, one gets a repetitive return for the entry of 14/16, (which by the way is not a fraction)! I spend a lot of time in the forest — alone, so 'prattling' is an annoyance only for the four legged creatures. Unfortunately, for the 1Dx, single shot mode can be enough to send wildlife scurrying for whereabouts unknown. Thankfully, there is an alternative solution, the (little bit more) Silent Mode.

One nice attraction of the 1Dx II is the 4/5 silent mode burst, which btw is much faster than my trigger finger works on the current model.
Mar 05, 2016 at 07:23 AM
PetKal
Offline
Details
p.14 #161DX II- 22mp Just Posted
skid00skid00 wrote:
PetKal wroteMoreover, the crackling of 1DX going at 12/14 FPS also intimidates other photographers whose "inferior" cameras are limited to "only" 10 or 8 FPS max frame rate.
.
...Wait a second...

Aren't *you* the guy with the big whites..?!





Well, I often photograph pijuns using economy gears such as 135L, 200 f/2.8, 100L and 80-200L on 40D, T6s or 1DsMkII. Whenever I succeed in getting a nice picture or two with such gears, that gives me much satisfaction.
Mar 05, 2016 at 07:28 AM
Stoffer
Offline
Details
p.14 #171DX II- 22mp Just Posted
PetKal wrote:
"Machine gun" Joe shoots EVERYTHING at 12 FPS using his 1DX, be that a landscape, a portrait, a bird in flight, or a duck slowly drifting on water.
When we shoot the same thing together, he'd take home typically some 3000 shots while on my card I'd have about 300 frames.

At any point of time he has a backlog of tens of thousands of image files he has yet to review and sort out. Obviously most of those images are redundant repeats.



Peter, no question that your approach is the more smart one and 12 fps is far from needed for everything.

Live view 16 fps is obviously not aimed at BIF at all, since AF and exposure is locked at the first frame. It could be put to good use, however, if one has the imagination to exploit 16 fps and work around the limitations. Maybe one would like to capture the right pose during a golf swing. There is other sports where you will know more or less exactly where the action is going to be but the timing is critical. 16 fps will help you. Or you can shoot with a bit of wide angle to get enough DOF to get the shot even if the athlete is a bit off focus.

As I said, just something to get people's imagination flowing.
Mar 05, 2016 at 08:59 AM
PetKal
Offline
Details
p.14 #181DX II- 22mp Just Posted
Stoffer wrote:
Live view 16 fps is obviously not aimed at BIF at all, since AF and exposure is locked at the first frame. It could be put to good use, however, if one has the imagination to exploit 16 fps and work around the limitations. Maybe one would like to capture the right pose during a golf swing. There is other sports where you will know more or less exactly where the action is going to be but the timing is critical. 16 fps will help you. Or you can shoot with a bit of wide angle to get enough DOF
...Show more →

Nils, I agree with you, 14/16 FPS may come handy where the action evolution is so fast that one needs to have a commensurately quick stopping action.
I have shot a number of birds in flight where there is 2-3 seconds window of opportunity available, and the birds not only fly fast, they also flap their wings rapidly. I also wanted to get one particular wing attitude, all of which can be best captured by the fastest available frame rate.

However, like any other feature, a less than purposeful use of 12/14/16 FPS results in needless wear of the shutter/mirror mechanisms, it overloads us with redundant files, and it may diminish our mental focus on the target/scene we are photographing.
Mar 05, 2016 at 09:34 AM
skid00skid00
Offline
Details
p.14 #191DX II- 22mp Just Posted
PetKal wrote:
Well, I often photograph pijuns using economy gears such as 135L, 200 f/2.8, 100L and 80-200L on 40D, T6s or 1DsMkII. Whenever I succeed in getting a nice picture or two with such gears, that gives me much satisfaction.


Pinhole camera:


Nirvana!



Mar 05, 2016 at 12:10 PM
PetKal
Offline
Details
p.14 #201DX II- 22mp Just Posted
skid00skid00 wrote:
PetKal wroteWell, I often photograph pijuns using economy gears such as 135L, 200 f/2.8, 100L and 80-200L on 40D, T6s or 1DsMkII. Whenever I succeed in getting a nice picture or two with such gears, that gives me much satisfaction.
Pinhole camera:

Nirvana!





PH camera would be the close second. The true "nirvana" would be in being able to paint a nice picture or two using watercolours or oils.
Mar 05, 2016 at 02:08 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister