fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Moire? 5Dsr.

  
 
rbf_
Offline
Details
p.5 #1Moire? 5Dsr.
By the way, that's another thing I've been wondering about the 5Ds R since it came out. Since it has deleted the AA filter can you shoot infrared photography with it?
Jul 18, 2015 at 02:48 PM
AJSJones
Offline
Details
p.5 #2Moire? 5Dsr.
rbf_ wrote:
By the way, that's another thing I've been wondering about the 5Ds R since it came out. Since it has deleted the AA filter can you shoot infrared photography with it?


The IR filter and the AA filter are different slices in the filter stack. Both have the IR filter...
Jul 18, 2015 at 03:02 PM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.5 #3Moire? 5Dsr.
rbf_ wrote:
By the way, that's another thing I've been wondering about the 5Ds R since it came out. Since it has deleted the AA filter can you shoot infrared photography with it?


They didn't exactly "delete" the filter. They reoriented its layers to cancel its effect.

Dan
Jul 18, 2015 at 03:06 PM
Sneakyracer
Offline
Details
p.5 #4Moire? 5Dsr.
From what I have seen the Nikon D810 has noticeably worse aliasing/moire than the 5DSR...and people have been using the D810 to make some amazing images for a while now. So I would not worry. Same goes with the 645Z.

I have a Phase IQ160 and have seen aliasing and moire, it doesnt show often at all, but even so it has been pretty easy to deal with and a non issue in prints.

The worst moire I have experienced was actually with the 5D3 when shooting a suit. It had just the perfect pattern I guess and the subject distance to produce the moire. Moved back a tad and it was gone. Like I mentioned before, the lightroom removal tool took care of it in the images that had moire.

Edited on Jul 18, 2015 at 07:37 PM · View previous versions
Jul 18, 2015 at 03:18 PM
rbf_
Offline
Details
p.5 #5Moire? 5Dsr.
AJSJones wrote:
rbf_ wroteBy the way, that's another thing I've been wondering about the 5Ds R since it came out. Since it has deleted the AA filter can you shoot infrared photography with it?
The IR filter and the AA filter are different slices in the filter stack. Both have the IR filter...


Oh yes, I may be confusing this a bit but I thought that the Fuji sensors were more sensitive to IR due to the removal of the AA/low-pass filtering. They still have some IR filtering going on in their filtering stack as you have to use fairly long exposures to get IR images without modification of the sensor. Some people have done IR filter modifications on their cameras to get more IR sensitivity. So I was wondering if the same held true for the 5Ds R, enough IR sensitivity to do some IR with reasonably 'short' long exposures. I recall getting decent IR images in under 10 secs during full daylight last time.
Jul 18, 2015 at 03:20 PM
rbf_
Offline
Details
p.5 #6Moire? 5Dsr.
gdanmitchell wrote:
rbf_ wroteBy the way, that's another thing I've been wondering about the 5Ds R since it came out. Since it has deleted the AA filter can you shoot infrared photography with it?
They didn't exactly "delete" the filter. They reoriented its layers to cancel its effect.

Dan


Sorry, as a software engineer sometimes I think in computer operations
Jul 18, 2015 at 03:21 PM
Monito
Offline
Details
p.5 #7Moire? 5Dsr.
rbf_ wrote:
By the way, that's another thing I've been wondering about the 5Ds R since it came out. Since it has deleted the AA filter can you shoot infrared photography with it?


I have a friend here who got two 5DsR and has sent one off to be converted to InfraRed.
Jul 18, 2015 at 03:35 PM
rbf_
Offline
Details
p.5 #8Moire? 5Dsr.
Monito wrote:
rbf_ wroteBy the way, that's another thing I've been wondering about the 5Ds R since it came out. Since it has deleted the AA filter can you shoot infrared photography with it?
I have a friend here who got two 5DsR and has sent one off to be converted to InfraRed.


That's one way to do it I might do the same with my X-E1 when I get a new body, I'm waiting for the next sensor update. It does pretty decently now though with a tripod and long exposures, but a full conversion would be much better.
Jul 18, 2015 at 03:46 PM
Jeff Fenske
Offline
Details
p.5 #9Moire? 5Dsr.
RustyBug wrote:
Jeff Fenske wroteIt does seem that compact cameras go into diffraction sooner, especially at the shortest focal lengths, but not as much when zoomed out.
This is because they have a smaller aperture for the light to pass through (not to be confused with f-stop). The smaller the hole, the more the diffraction being induced by the optical projection. The more we "squeeze" the photons through a tiny hole, the more they bounce off the edges of the hole and go scrambling about.

Kinda like dropping a pebble in a glass of water vs. a calm lake. The rippling effects of the smaller surface area are much more noticeable from the proximity of the wave amplitude interactions.

Diffraction is an optical projection issue ... not a capture
...Show more →

That's interesting!

So the hole (diaphram diameter) for f/8 in a compact camera is smaller than the hole for f/8 in a FF, for example? Why is that?

And does f/8 in a FF equal f/8 in a compact, as far as how much light is let in? I always thought it did.

The hole size of f/8 in a FF equals f/8 in a crop sensor, but it is smaller in M43, smaller still in a 1-inch sensor compact, and smaller still in a 1/1.7?

If so, do you know why?
Jul 19, 2015 at 07:38 AM
Monito
Offline
Details
p.5 #10Moire? 5Dsr.
Jeff Fenske wrote:
So the hole (diaphram diameter) for f/8 in a compact camera is smaller than the hole for f/8 in a FF, for example? Why is that? And does f/8 in a FF equal f/8 in a compact, as far as how much light is let in? I always thought it did. The hole size of f/8 in a FF equals f/8 in a crop sensor, but it is smaller in M43, smaller still in a 1-inch sensor compact, and smaller still in a 1/1.7? If so, do you know why?


Why? (disregarding the errors in the quoted post) ... Mathematics. Mathematics rules the universe.

If you wish to be reality-based it's worth knowing a little mathematics. In this case, division.

Look up the definition of f/stop. Wikipedia is a good place. It's a rather basic element of photography. It's a good thing to understand before chasing some more esoteric elements of photographic technology. There's a reason we always write 'f' with a slash.

Photographers prefer to use the term 'aperture' in preference to 'hole size'.

The aperture depends on focal length, not sensor size. Sensor size is just cropping. Cropping an image does not affect light or exposure.

f/8 makes the same exposure in a full-frame as it does in a compact.



Edited on Jul 19, 2015 at 09:06 AM · View previous versions
Jul 19, 2015 at 08:54 AM
Jeff Fenske
Offline
Details
p.5 #11Moire? 5Dsr.
Jeff Fenske wrote:
So the hole (diaphram diameter) for f/8 in a compact camera is smaller than the hole for f/8 in a FF, for example? Why is that? And does f/8 in a FF equal f/8 in a compact, as far as how much light is let in? I always thought it did. The hole size of f/8 in a FF equals f/8 in a crop sensor, but it is smaller in M43, smaller still in a 1-inch sensor compact, and smaller still in a 1/1.7? If so, do you know why?

Monito wrote:
Mathematics. Mathematics rules the universe.

If you wish to be reality-based it's worth knowing a little mathematics. In this case, division.

Look up the definition of f/stop. Wikipedia is a good place. It's a rather basic element of photography. It's a good thing to understand before chasing some more esoteric elements of photographic technology. There's a reason we always write 'f' with a slash.

Photographers prefer to use the term 'aperture' in preference to 'hole size'.

The aperture depends on focal length, not sensor size. Sensor size is just cropping. Cropping an image does not affect light or exposure.

f/8 makes the same exposure in
...Show more →

I used "hole size" and "diaphram diameter" for a reason, to indicate that it's a specific dimension.
Jul 19, 2015 at 09:06 AM
Monito
Offline
Details
p.5 #12Moire? 5Dsr.
Jeff Fenske wrote:
I used "hole size" and "diaphram diameter" for a reason, to indicate that it's a specific dimension.


Aperture diameter is the diameter of the "hole". The aperture is the opening. f/stop is the ratio.

The diaphragm diameter is the diameter of the aperture at the widest f/stop for the lens. As the "hole" size varies, the diaphragm does not change size, but it closes down and opens up.

You are thinking of the iris opening or the diaphragm opening or, more to the point, more succinctly, the aperture.

Look up the definition of aperture and you will see that it means the opening. The diaphragm is not the opening. The diaphragm has an opening.

One of the most important steps in thinking clearly and understanding a topic well is to understand the nomenclature very clearly. Then one is able to communicate clearly and precisely and accurately.
Jul 19, 2015 at 09:13 AM
Jeff Fenske
Offline
Details
p.5 #13Moire? 5Dsr.
Monito wrote:
Jeff Fenske wroteI used "hole size" and "diaphram diameter" for a reason, to indicate that it's a specific dimension.
Aperture diameter is the diameter of the "hole". The aperture is the opening. f/stop is the ratio.

The diaphragm diameter is the diameter of the aperture at the widest f/stop for the lens. As the "hole" size varies, the diaphragm does not change size, but it closes down and opens up.

You are thinking of the iris opening or the diaphragm opening or, more to the point, more succinctly, the aperture.

Look up the definition of aperture and you will see that it means the opening. The diaphragm is not the opening. The diaphragm has an opening.

One of the most important steps in
...Show more →

I prefer to use "hole size" and "diaphram diameter" to indicate that it's a specific dimension — to be as clear as possible.

My goal is to find out what is going on, not to have a challenge of the wits.
Jul 19, 2015 at 09:31 AM
Monito
Offline
Details
p.5 #14Moire? 5Dsr.
The diaphragm is not the "hole". The "hole" is where there is no diaphragm.

If you want to find out what is going on, then understanding the logic of things is fundamental.

Also, note how diaphragm is spelled. You want to be clear, so you need the 'g'.
Jul 19, 2015 at 09:38 AM
jcolwell
Online
Details
p.5 #15Moire? 5Dsr.
Jeff Fenske wrote:
I prefer to use "hole size" and "diaphram diameter" to indicate that it's a specific dimension — to be as clear as possible.


Monito wrote:
The diaphragm is not the "hole". The "hole" is where there is no diaphragm...


Monito's right. I'd just like to add that the "hole" is the "aperture".
Jul 19, 2015 at 10:16 AM
rbf_
Offline
Details
p.5 #16Moire? 5Dsr.
Jeff Fenske wrote:
RustyBug wrote
Jeff Fenske wroteIt does seem that compact cameras go into diffraction sooner, especially at the shortest focal lengths, but not as much when zoomed out.
This is because they have a smaller aperture for the light to pass through (not to be confused with f-stop). The smaller the hole, the more the diffraction being induced by the optical projection. The more we "squeeze" the photons through a tiny hole, the more they bounce off the edges of the hole and go scrambling about.

Kinda like dropping a pebble in a glass of water vs. a calm lake. The rippling effects of the smaller surface area are much more noticeable from the proximity of the wave amplitude interactions.

Diffraction is an optical projection issue ... not a capture issue. Just because you slice it into smaller pieces, sure you slice it small enough and your diffraction will "encompass" your tiny slice, while it may not encompass larger pieces. But, whether you put together a 100 piece jigsaw puzzle or a 10,000 jigsaw puzzle ... the overall picture remains a product of what was projected onto the entire puzzle, not how many slices it gets cut into.
That's interesting!

So the hole (diaphram diameter) for f/8 in a compact camera is smaller than the hole for f/8 in a FF, for example? Why is that?


The aperture diameter can be calculated using the f number. A 53mm f/8 lens will have a aperture diameter of 53/8 = 6.6 mm. But since the angle of view of a 53mm lens will change depending on the recording medium size a smaller camera with a smaller format sensor will use a different focal length lens to get the equivalent angle of view. So to get the same angle of view as a 53mm on 35mm(full frame) format sensor on an aps-c(1.5) sensor one would use a 35mm lens.

So for the same field of view as 53mm on 35mm ff on an aps-c format camera at f/8

35mm full frame format 53mm focal length - 53/8 = aperture diameter ~6.6m.
aps-c(1.5 crop) 35mm focal length - 35/8 = aperture diameter ~4.3mm.

Smaller cameras use smaller sensors and thus use smaller focal length lenses to get the same angle of view as larger cameras so they require smaller aperture diameters for the same angle of view/f-number.

Jeff Fenske wrote:
And does f/8 in a FF equal f/8 in a compact, as far as how much light is let in? I always thought it did.


f numbers are dimensionless numbers meant to represent the light transmission intensity that will be the same over various sized formats for purposes of calculating exposure. That's why the the f-number is often referred to as the speed of the lens, because it directly effects the diameter of the entrance given a fixed focal length and sensor size as you change it and thus the required shutter speed for a given exposure. So an f/x lens is always an f/x lens regardless of format size because it represents the light intensity(the speed) so one can calculate the exposure.

Jeff Fenske wrote:
The hole size of f/8 in a FF equals f/8 in a crop sensor, but it is smaller in M43, smaller still in a 1-inch sensor compact, and smaller still in a 1/1.7?


No, see above.




Edited on Jul 19, 2015 at 06:07 PM · View previous versions
Jul 19, 2015 at 11:35 AM
jcolwell
Online
Details
p.5 #17Moire? 5Dsr.
Jeff Fenske wrote:
...The hole size of f/8 in a FF ... is smaller in M43, smaller still in a 1-inch sensor compact, and smaller still in a 1/1.7?

If so, do you know why?


The f-stop is the ratio of lens focal length divided by the apparent diameter of the aperture, as seen through the front of the lens.

f-stop = f / Da, it's called a dimensionless quantity because it's (mm) / (mm) = no 'dimensions'

Consider that a "normal" lens on a FF DSLR has a 50mm focal length. Further, consider a 50/1.4 lens, which has a "fast" max. aperture of f-stop = 1.4. If you put that lens on an APC-C camera, like the 7DII, then it's still a 50mm f/1.4 lens, but since the sensor is smaller, the image that it caputres is equivalent to an 85mm lens on FF. This doesn't mean that it's an 85mm lens on the 7DII, it's still a 50/1.4 lens. The aperture, as defined by f-stop, is independent of the camera, it's defined by the lens itself, and only the lens.

One of the confusing things is that the lenses on many cameras with small sensors, like a Sony RX100 IV, are described in terms of "equivalent FF focal length". For example, the Sony RX100 IV lens is often described as being 24-70/1.8-2.8 (35mm equivalent). The actual focal length of this lens (as written on it) is 8.8-25.7mm. Its wide-open aperture is f/1.8 to f/2.8 for the 8.8mm to 25.7mm range of focal lengths, not for the 'equivalent' 24-70mm range. So, the small sensor camera has smaller aperture than a full frame (or larger sensor) camera at common f-stop values because it actually uses lenses with much shorter focal lengths.
Jul 19, 2015 at 12:05 PM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.5 #18Moire? 5Dsr.
To Monito's point @ mathematics ...

Note that the f-stop is written as f/8, where:

f = focal length
/ = divided by
8 = 8

e.g. 200mm focal length / 8 = 25mm aperture, or
200mm focal length / 25mm aperture = 8

The focal length is in units of mm, thus the resultant value will also be in mm. As photographer's we tend to drop the units and simply refer to it as a ratio (as indicated by the "/") Jim has likewise presented it from the opposite perspective @ how the "unitless" value is facilitated.

The diameter of the amount of light (entrance pupil) will yield an area via pi*r^2 (relative to the image circle size for a given format). The diameter of the aperture will also yield an area via pi*r^2. While the relationship of the amount of light (combined with a time function @ flow) passing through the aperture (i.e. orifice) of an f-stop of 1.0 would be the same amount of light as that entering the entrance pupil and subsequently transmitting to the capture media contained within the optical projection image circle.

Because, the function of r^2 is exponential, that is why our EV stops are predicated upon the square root of 2 @ 1.414 to properly balance the equation.

To Jim's point @ "equivalent" focal length ... the smaller format camera's are using smaller focal length lenses, and subsequently smaller apertures for a given f-stop ratio. Since diffraction is a function of the optical projection path, the physically smaller aperture is prone to effects of diffraction more. Conversely, MF and LF cameras are using longer focal lengths for a given format field of view, and thus are less prone to the effects of diffraction, even when stopped down significantly ... i.e. the f/64 club.

Exposure (f-stop) is based on the relative relationships ... diffraction is based on the physical dimensions of the aperture (orifice) being passed through. We don't often speak of the physical dimensions and the math of the aperture (orifice), but for diffraction, it does have its place.

HTH




Edited on Jul 19, 2015 at 07:34 PM · View previous versions
Jul 19, 2015 at 03:59 PM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.5 #19Moire? 5Dsr.
Monito wrote:
Mathematics rules the universe.


Hmmm. Mathematics does seem to describe much in the universe, I'll grant you that much. ;-)
Jul 19, 2015 at 04:00 PM
Monito
Offline
Details
p.5 #20Moire? 5Dsr.
r + 2 is additive

r x 2 is multiplicative

r ^ 2 is geometric (r-squared). 2^2 = 4. 3^2 = 9. 4^2 = 16. 5^2 = 25. 6^2 = 36

2 ^ r is exponential (2 raised to the power r). 2^2 = 4. 2^3 = 8. 2^4 = 16. 2^5 = 32. 2^6 = 64


Exponential series increase much faster than geometric. Getting geometric and exponential reversed is subtle and easy to do.

Common use of the term "exponential" to mean "big" or "at a big rate" is a little bit ignorant of high school mathematics since it is often applied to just a big addition or a big multiplication.

gdanmitchell wrote:
Hmmm. Mathematics does seem to describe much in the universe, I'll grant you that much. ;-)


Try to break it, then.

While 2 + 2 does not always equal 4 (in base three 2 + 2 = 11, in base four 2 + 2 = 10), ... two rocks plus two rocks always equals four rocks everywhere.


Edited on Jul 19, 2015 at 06:16 PM · View previous versions
Jul 19, 2015 at 05:56 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister