gdanmitchell wrote:
Monito wrote
gdanmitchell wrote
Hmmm. Mathematics does seem to describe much in the universe, I'll grant you that much. ;-) Try to break it, then.
While 2 + 2 does not always equal 4 (in base three 2 + 2 = 11, in base four 2 + 2 = 10), ... two rocks plus two rocks always equals four rocks everywhere. Describe Mozart's Requiem in mathematical terms, and then get back to me on how useful that is. ;-)
Dan
That depends on what you mean by useful. For just the enjoyment of the music, mathematics can be dispensed with entirely (to state the obvious). But mathematics is useful for several other aspects of music. India has a long tradition of weaving mathematical patterns in music. Here in the West, there have been outstanding studies of the aesthetics of music beginning with the pioneering contributions of the Harvard mathematician George Birkhoff and others. And in Germany we had Helmholz who found math useful in his investigations of musical tone. So whether it is the underlying patterns, the aesthetics, or purely the joy of intellectual sport, description of Mozart's Requiem in mathematical terms is conceivably useful to some.