fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Moire? 5Dsr.

  
 
J_ph
Offline
Details
p.2 #1Moire? 5Dsr.
>IMHO the difference would be very small if visible at all

All depends upon the audience and the application, I wouldn't discount that the R can outperform the S in some situations. And that is why there are 2 cameras for sale, there isn't a universal answer as to which is best.
Jun 24, 2015 at 12:31 PM
dhphoto
Offline
Details
p.2 #2Moire? 5Dsr.
J_ph wrote:
>IMHO the difference would be very small if visible at all

All depends upon the audience and the application, I wouldn't discount that the R can outperform the S in some situations. And that is why there are 2 cameras for sale, there isn't a universal answer as to which is best.


That's the point, what are the potential applications here?

Any printed application is going to lose any advantage the 5DSR has due to the printing process
Jun 24, 2015 at 12:40 PM
Eyvind Ness
Offline
Details
Jun 24, 2015 at 12:51 PM
Monito
Offline
Details
p.2 #4Moire? 5Dsr.
Eyvind Ness wrote:
http://briansmith.com/sony-a7r-removing-moire-lightroom/


Oh, that is child's play when it shows up in a gray shirt. Or black hair.
Jun 24, 2015 at 12:53 PM
dhphoto
Offline
Details
p.2 #5Moire? 5Dsr.
Eyvind Ness wrote:
http://briansmith.com/sony-a7r-removing-moire-lightroom/


It doesn't always work like that.
Jun 24, 2015 at 12:54 PM
J_ph
Offline
Details
p.2 #6Moire? 5Dsr.
>Any printed application is going to lose any advantage the 5DSR has due to the printing process

Not always, I've shot watches that have been printed at 10' and viewed at ground level so they don't have the advantage of being seen from a distance. And, I can say that every ounce of detail is needed. Can you get away with less... sure, but if you can do better, why not. The general audience wouldn't know the difference, but that's not why we care about things like MP and good lenses. So, most applications won't see the difference but some will. But even so, I chose the S version because of it's broad potential use.

You choose the tools based upon what you shoot and what you need.
Jun 24, 2015 at 12:55 PM
Eyvind Ness
Offline
Details
p.2 #7Moire? 5Dsr.
dhphoto wrote:
Eyvind Ness wrotehttp://briansmith.com/sony-a7r-removing-moire-lightroom/
It doesn't always work like that.


Not sure what you are getting at, but it worked very well on Paolos initial example, IMHO.
Jun 24, 2015 at 12:59 PM
dhphoto
Offline
Details
p.2 #8Moire? 5Dsr.
J_ph wrote:
>Any printed application is going to lose any advantage the 5DSR has due to the printing process

Not always, I've shot watches that have been printed at 10' and viewed at ground level so they don't have the advantage of being seen from a distance. And, I can say that every ounce of detail is needed. Can you get away with less... sure, but if you can do better, why not. The general audience wouldn't know the difference, but that's not why we care about things like MP and good lenses. So, most applications won't see the difference but some will.
...Show more →

I have huge posters made up all the time, generally from my 1Ds3 files and I maintain the litho process will destroy any advantage the 5DSR might have - the file's being screened to go on a four colour process machine, there's no way you would see the nuanced difference of a 5DSR file after that
Jun 24, 2015 at 01:01 PM
dhphoto
Offline
Details
p.2 #9Moire? 5Dsr.
Eyvind Ness wrote:
dhphoto wrote
Eyvind Ness wrotehttp://briansmith.com/sony-a7r-removing-moire-lightroom/
It doesn't always work like that.
Not sure what you are getting at, but it worked very well on Paolos initial example, IMHO.


Yes it did because that was a nice plain colour and the moire filter did it's job well, believe me it often doesn't.
Jun 24, 2015 at 01:02 PM
J_ph
Offline
Details
p.2 #10Moire? 5Dsr.
>there's no way you would see the nuanced difference of a 5DSR file after that

You will see it if you throw that data at a print size and a printer that can resolve more than you give it.

At the longest of dimensions the 5ds(r) is roughly 29in (8688px) @ 300 ppi. Now let's say you print using the device that can adequately resolve 300ppi, if you exceed that 29in dimension, imagine printing the same file at 90in, your file is now at 96ppi, it is at this point that a camera with more resolution will win. And yes you will see a difference. But throwing too much data at a printer that can't resolve that information will not show.
Jun 24, 2015 at 01:21 PM
dhphoto
Offline
Details
p.2 #11Moire? 5Dsr.
J_ph wrote:
>there's no way you would see the nuanced difference of a 5DSR file after that

You will see it if you throw that data at a print size and a printer that can resolve more than you give it.

At the longest of dimensions the 5ds(r) is roughly 29in (8688px) @ 300 ppi. Now let's say you print using the device that can adequately resolve 300ppi, if you exceed that 29in dimension, imagine printing the same file at 90in, your file is now at 96ppi, it is at this point that a camera with more resolution will win. And yes you will
...Show more →

Yes I know about the relative sizes of the images, the point is that the reproduction process itself is inherently lossy, it has to be, the finished jpeg or tiff file is at maximum quality and everything you do to that file will degrade the IQ to some extent if you try and mechanically reproduce it as a print or in a magazine or a billboard

You are stuck with the R.I.P. colour palette, shadow detail, contrast and background media of whatever it is you are printing. Any 5DSR over 5DS advantage will quickly be lost
Jun 24, 2015 at 01:27 PM
J_ph
Offline
Details
p.2 #12Moire? 5Dsr.
>the point is that the reproduction process itself is inherently lossy,

You are only looking at examples where the output is the restriction. As long as you are supplying enough data, the printer is the limitation. When the output is large enough the resolution of the original source is the limitation. So yes and magazine image that comes off a 5ds(r) is overkill.

If you go back to the example of the 10 ft poster, the file from a 5ds(r) would be a resolution of 72 ppi, and when printing this on any high-end printer, the file is the limitation not the printer.

We may need to agree to disagree.

regards,

Edited on Jun 26, 2015 at 05:09 AM · View previous versions
Jun 24, 2015 at 01:46 PM
dhphoto
Offline
Details
p.2 #13Moire? 5Dsr.
J_ph wrote:
You are only looking at examples were the output is the restriction.



Unless your final usage is looking at a file on a screen the output is ALWAYS the restriction. There isn't a reproduction method I know of that matches the digital file in every detail, there are always some changes in colour, contrast, shadow detail and sharpness.

Publishing/Printing a file is dependant on the Publishing/Printing tools being used and the tiny differences between the two cameras will be invisible after that is all I'm saying

I would love to see an example of where I'm wrong (but obviously on the web you can't really)
Jun 24, 2015 at 02:05 PM
J_ph
Offline
Details
p.2 #14Moire? 5Dsr.
this file is the DPreview image cropped to the scary lady in the etching and resized 400%. This would approximate what would occur if you printed the 5ds(r) at 12'. The crop is only 5.5" @300ppi, so you can download it and print this on a desktop inkjet. Is there a difference?

LINK
Jun 24, 2015 at 02:25 PM
Finman06
Offline
Details
p.2 #15Moire? 5Dsr.
gdanmitchell, Thanks for the info and your opinions on the matter of 5Ds vs 5Dsr and the moire issue. After reading and viewing everything that has ben brought up, I'm still on the fence! How does 50mb resolution print? ie, I wonder if after printing with the current epson and canon 13" wide printers if this amount of resolution can even been seen?? (new can of worms) That would make it all a moot point and the need for 50mb cameras questionable. Thanks again.
Jun 24, 2015 at 02:59 PM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.2 #16Moire? 5Dsr.
Finman06 wrote:
gdanmitchell, Thanks for the info and your opinions on the matter of 5Ds vs 5Dsr and the moire issue. After reading and viewing everything that has ben brought up, I'm still on the fence! How does 50mb resolution print? ie, I wonder if after printing with the current epson and canon 13" wide printers if this amount of resolution can even been seen?? (new can of worms) That would make it all a moot point and the need for 50mb cameras questionable. Thanks again.


It is entirely moot on a 13" carriage printer. At a side of close to 20" x 30" the 50MB files achieve native 300 ppi resolution. I'm positive that no one could tell the difference between sets of prints made from 5Ds and 5Ds R photographs at that size!

In other words, it is moot.

Dan
Jun 24, 2015 at 03:29 PM
Jeff Fenske
Offline
Details
p.2 #17Moire? 5Dsr.
Interesting that Sony didn't include an AA filter at all in the new a7R II, just like what Nikon did with the D810, while Canon did Nikon's D800E canceling method.

DPR writes this about their Studio Scene results:

http://www.dpreview.com/articles/7945517371/opinion-did-sony-just-do-the-impossible?

No AA filter

For one, there's no anti-aliasing filter at all, rather than the two birefringent filters in the 'anti-aliasing canceling' setup we saw in the D800E and, now, the 5DS R. Although the improvement may only be subtle, we saw slight improvements in micro-contrast when shooting our studio scene with a D810 vs. a D800E with the same exact lens (samples to be published shortly).
Jun 24, 2015 at 03:45 PM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.2 #18Moire? 5Dsr.
My take on this is that there is not yet universal agreement as to whether the advantages/disadvantages of AA filtering at high sensor resolution is, on balance, an improvement or not — given that there are both potential advantages and disadvantages, and that the impact of these pluses and minuses is at least partly affected by what you shoot.

Before a company makes a commitment to go one way (no AA filtering) or the other (AA filtering) consistently, the AA-filter-cancelation approach allows them to make the two versions with the greatest consistency among the design and manufacture of the two bodies.

It looks like Nikon must have decided that the non-AA version was mostly preferred and good enough to simply not need AA filtering. Sony must have come to the same conclusion a bit sooner. Canon seems to be on the fence, which isn't completely surprising as this is their first high-MP sensor camera that does away (virtually) with AA filtering.

I think that both the potential resolution advantages of eliminating AA filtering in high resolution sensors and the potential aliasing disadvantages will turn out to be much less than we might think. If so, at least with high MP cameras, I suspect that Canon will also eventually simply do away with the AA filter system entirely — just like Nikon did in the D810, which seems to be well-received from this perspective.

Dan

Jeff Fenske wrote:
Interesting that Sony didn't include an AA filter at all in the new a7R II, just like what Nikon did with the D810, while Canon did Nikon's D800E canceling method.

DPR writes this about their Studio Scene results:

http://www.dpreview.com/articles/7945517371/opinion-did-sony-just-do-the-impossible?

No AA filter

For one, there's no anti-aliasing filter at all, rather than the two birefringent filters in the 'anti-aliasing canceling' setup we saw in the D800E and, now, the 5DS R. Although the improvement may only be subtle, we saw slight improvements in micro-contrast when shooting our studio scene with a D810 vs. a D800E with the same exact lens (samples to be
...Show more →
Jun 24, 2015 at 05:30 PM
Sneakyracer
Offline
Details
p.2 #19Moire? 5Dsr.
gdanmitchell wrote:
My take on this is that there is not yet universal agreement as to whether the advantages/disadvantages of AA filtering at high sensor resolution is, on balance, an improvement or not — given that there are both potential advantages and disadvantages, and that the impact of these pluses and minuses is at least partly affected by what you shoot.

Before a company makes a commitment to go one way (no AA filtering) or the other (AA filtering) consistently, the AA-filter-cancelation approach allows them to make the two versions with the greatest consistency among the design and manufacture of the two bodies.
...Show more →
Jeff Fenske wroteInteresting that Sony didn't include an AA filter at all in the new a7R II, just like what Nikon did with the D810, while Canon did Nikon's D800E canceling method.

DPR writes this about their Studio Scene results:

http://www.dpreview.com/articles/7945517371/opinion-did-sony-just-do-the-impossible?

No AA filter

For one, there's no anti-aliasing filter at all, rather than the two birefringent filters in the 'anti-aliasing canceling' setup we saw in the D800E and, now, the 5DS R. Although the improvement may only be subtle, we saw slight improvements in micro-contrast when shooting our studio scene with a D810 vs. a D800E with the same exact lens (samples to be published shortly).


Glad Canon gives one the choice to do away with the AA filter right now. IMHO the New Canon has such a high pixel density (more than the Nikons and Sonys obviously) that an AA filter is not really needed. For Video it is good to have but for stills, no way IMHO.

Jun 24, 2015 at 07:55 PM
dhphoto
Offline
Details
p.2 #20Moire? 5Dsr.
Sneakyracer wrote:
gdanmitchell wroteMy take on this is that there is not yet universal agreement as to whether the advantages/disadvantages of AA filtering at high sensor resolution is, on balance, an improvement or not — given that there are both potential advantages and disadvantages, and that the impact of these pluses and minuses is at least partly affected by what you shoot.

Before a company makes a commitment to go one way (no AA filtering) or the other (AA filtering) consistently, the AA-filter-cancelation approach allows them to make the two versions with the greatest consistency among the design and manufacture of the two bodies.

It looks like Nikon must have decided that the non-AA version was mostly preferred and good enough to simply not need AA filtering. Sony must have come to the same conclusion a bit sooner. Canon seems to be on the fence, which isn't completely surprising as this is their first high-MP sensor camera that does away (virtually) with AA filtering.

I think that both the potential resolution advantages of eliminating AA filtering in high resolution sensors and the potential aliasing disadvantages will turn out to be much less than we might think. If so, at least with high MP cameras, I suspect that Canon will also eventually simply do away with the AA filter system entirely — just like Nikon did in the D810, which seems to be well-received from this perspective.

Dan

Jeff Fenske wroteInteresting that Sony didn't include an AA filter at all in the new a7R II, just like what Nikon did with the D810, while Canon did Nikon's D800E canceling method.

DPR writes this about their Studio Scene results:

http://www.dpreview.com/articles/7945517371/opinion-did-sony-just-do-the-impossible?

No AA filter

For one, there's no anti-aliasing filter at all, rather than the two birefringent filters in the 'anti-aliasing canceling' setup we saw in the D800E and, now, the 5DS R. Although the improvement may only be subtle, we saw slight improvements in micro-contrast when shooting our studio scene with a D810 vs. a D800E with the same exact lens (samples to be published shortly).
Glad Canon gives one the choice to do away with the AA filter right now. IMHO the New Canon has such a high pixel density (more than the Nikons and Sonys obviously) that an AA filter is not really needed. For Video it is good to have but for stills, no way IMHO.



Except that Canon haven't done away with the filter, they've added yet another one to the 5DSR to cancel the AA filter out
Jun 25, 2015 at 12:09 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister