Jeff Fenske wrote:
You say: "they are well advised to do their own testing."
I strongly agree. To that I would add, beyond considering "perfect aperture," also consider the real world effect of departing from that aperture.
I understand quite well the idea of diffraction-limited aperture and how this plays out against different formats and different sensor resolutions. But I now am being to have enough photography under my belt with the 5Ds R to start to draw some conclusions based on what I see in photographs. To generalize a bit...
- if aperture choice is not significant for other reasons, to ahead and shoot at the so-called diffraction-limited aperture for your lens/camera, unless...
- the "personality" of the lens you are using (lets say it vignettes a bit more that some others at that aperture) may allow you improve things at a slightly different aperture with insignificant negative effect on resolution, unless...
- you need narrower depth of field, in which case you open up the aperture to create the visual effect you need, unless...
- you need larger depth of field, in which case you stop down to whatever aperture you need, understanding that trade-off you are making.
As to stopping down, I was very interested to see what photographs on the "R" would look like at apertures smaller than the so-called diffraction limited aperture. Using high quality L series lenses, a tripod, live view, remote release, and careful technique... f/8 looks excellent with all of my lenses. There is very little difference in resolution at f/11, especially after applying typical post-processing sharpening. At 100% magnification I can see some softening of finest detail at f/16, but I certainly can use this aperture effectively when I nee more depth of field. I generally steer clear of f/22 and smaller unless something other than resolution is much more important — and that can happen in some cases.
Dan