p.8 #2What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
jhinkey wrote:
Just last night I arrived at one of my locations 5 minutes late and just about missed what I wanted to shoot - I had to quickly throw the 400/5.6 ED AI onto the D800 and shoot hand-held at shutter speeds that were marginal w/o stabilization and using the not-always-trustworthy green dot for focus. A mirrorless D800 with IBIS would have been perfect for that situation - a situation I find myself in quite a bit for what I shoot (tripods not always workable and sometimes completely out of the question) in marginal light.
My point is that I hope things that Sony is now pushing in the A7rII end up appearing in a Nikon mirrorless FX format digital body....Show more →
Hey John,
Since when was the green dot not trustworthy?
What is it you would have used if you hadn't been 5 minutes late? A tripod can be extended and set up in less than 15 seconds. And if it's shooting through the Liveview instead of the viewfinder, then you really should trade the D800 in for a D810 so that you will have a Liveview that's useable. But I don't get your green dot not being trustworthy, because it's very trustworthy. I only use the green dot, and my photos are always in focus.
I wonder if you look back at what you write, you are clearly so unhappy with Nikon and the D800 I really wonder why you are purposely causing yourself to suffer by shooting with it. Why not just buy the new Sony A7R II, get the Nikon Lens adapter and you will have what you want.
Our photography should be fun and enjoyable, not full of sorrow and misgivings like you are making it out to be.
p.8 #3What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
alexluuphoto wrote:
I still find it funny that people think the Sony a7 series doesn't have enough glass. I mean are you guys smoking something? They have 10+ native glass, but they can adapt every lens from every manufacture. The advantage of this camera is the fact that you can use canon lenses and nikon lenses too. Now that its been confirmed and there is enough proof on the internet that the a7r ii can focus these lenses at a good speed. When you decide on a Canon or a Nikon you only get those lenses made by that company. With Sony you can get both sides and feel pretty good about it. Like you can have a Nikon 58mm 1.4 which Canon doesn't have and you can adapt a 85mm 1.2 which nikon doesn't have. Your not limited to anything anymore which is just a great idea. Its the ultimate middle man. Nikon has like 300 lenses, Sony has like 1000+ lenses lol.
And honestly who the hell has 300 nikon or canon lenses. When people shove that number out it includes all the crop lenses, kit lenses and crappy lenses you rarely use. Realistically each company has like 20-30 lenses that are actually practical. ...Show more →
Does Sony have a line of smallish f/2.8 primes? I think the answer there is no. Canon and Nikon do, and those f/2.8 primes are small, pocketable and pretty sharp. These lenses also very affordable since they've been made for decades -- Sony glass, while it might be "best in class" is crazy expensive. Also, Tamron, Sigma and Tokina all make interesting lenses for Canon and Nikon (and for other lens mounts as well) giving you lots of choice. Sigma even makes a line of f/2.8 primes for micro 4/3rds that's below the $300 mark for the lens, NEW.
Yes, you can adapt a Nikon or Canon or almost any other lens to a Sony body and for someone invested in another system it's not a bad choice, but unless you want a manual focus experience, Metabones and other adapters will still be clunky and add weight and complexity. If you owned a Nikon 58 f/1.4 and say a D600, why would you bother with an adapter+electronics+Sony body? Resolution? It certainly wouldn't be for size or weight reduction. All the new Nikon bodies are amazing at high ISO so IBIS is less of an issue.
I was an ardent enthusiast of the A7 series and I'm really happy to see Sony sticking with it. The new BSI-sensor, IBIS, and all the other improvements are amazing. They will have a positive impact on all camera companies pushing them to do even better, which helps all of us. But as a standalone product the A7 series seems niche until the lens size reduces to match the smaller body.
p.8 #4What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
slrl0ver wrote: alexluuphoto wroteI still find it funny that people think the Sony a7 series doesn't have enough glass. I mean are you guys smoking something? They have 10+ native glass, but they can adapt every lens from every manufacture. The advantage of this camera is the fact that you can use canon lenses and nikon lenses too. Now that its been confirmed and there is enough proof on the internet that the a7r ii can focus these lenses at a good speed. When you decide on a Canon or a Nikon you only get those lenses made by that company. With Sony you can get both sides and feel pretty good about it. Like you can have a Nikon 58mm 1.4 which Canon doesn't have and you can adapt a 85mm 1.2 which nikon doesn't have. Your not limited to anything anymore which is just a great idea. Its the ultimate middle man. Nikon has like 300 lenses, Sony has like 1000+ lenses lol.
And honestly who the hell has 300 nikon or canon lenses. When people shove that number out it includes all the crop lenses, kit lenses and crappy lenses you rarely use. Realistically each company has like 20-30 lenses that are actually practical.Does Sony have a line of smallish f/2.8 primes? I think the answer there is no. Canon and Nikon do, and those f/2.8 primes are small, pocketable and pretty sharp. These lenses also very affordable since they've been made for decades -- Sony glass, while it might be "best in class" is crazy expensive. Also, Tamron, Sigma and Tokina all make interesting lenses for Canon and Nikon (and for other lens mounts as well) giving you lots of choice. Sigma even makes a line of f/2.8 primes for micro 4/3rds that's below the $300 mark for the lens, NEW.
Yes, you can adapt a Nikon or Canon or almost any other lens to a Sony body and for someone invested in another system it's not a bad choice, but unless you want a manual focus experience, Metabones and other adapters will still be clunky and add weight and complexity. If you owned a Nikon 58 f/1.4 and say a D600, why would you bother with an adapter+electronics+Sony body? Resolution? It certainly wouldn't be for size or weight reduction. All the new Nikon bodies are amazing at high ISO so IBIS is less of an issue.
I was an ardent enthusiast of the A7 series and I'm really happy to see Sony sticking with it. The new BSI-sensor, IBIS, and all the other improvements are amazing. They will have a positive impact on all camera companies pushing them to do even better, which helps all of us. But as a standalone product the A7 series seems niche until the lens size reduces to match the smaller body....Show more →
The metabones doesn't add any bulk or clunkiness to the camera body, all it does is extend the lens out by an inch. You should maybe go play with one, because 100% of the time people who has never used one say it makes the camera heavier or it makes the camera bigger lol. No it makes the lens longer... Sony lenses aren't expensive at all for the quality they produce. If you want small cheap, but decent 2.8 lens primes then stick to nikon and canon, but i am happy with all the ziess lenses that sony has come out with. They all are small, have auto focus and produce extreme great quality images for a really cheap price. I prefer a camera line that isn't even 2 years out yet to be producing quality lenses over lenses that are marketed towards a price group.
p.8 #6What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
Nikonian scratches head after earnings call wondering what is happening. Nikon is bleeding right now. The question is how long can they continue to do so?
p.8 #7What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
It has probably already been said but Nikon needs to put some sales management focus on Canon's cash cow market which is big enterprise/corporate. That market drives a huge portion of their revenue allowing them to service the consumer market quite easily. And yes, I will buy a D820 with 42mp A7R II sensor yesterday
p.8 #8What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
slrl0ver wrote:
Does Sony have a line of smallish f/2.8 primes? I think the answer there is no. Canon and Nikon do, and those f/2.8 primes are small, pocketable and pretty sharp. These lenses also very affordable since they've been made for decades -- Sony glass, while it might be "best in class" is crazy expensive.
I'm not familiar with the compact Nikon WA primes, but the Canon ones (2.0/35IS, 2.8/28IS and 2.8/24IS) are good quality but not really cheap - when introduced a few years ago they were quite expensive, just like the better Sony lenses. I'm guessing that old, small, affordable WA lenses (from Nikon or others) are usually less than stellar in the corners.
Canon and Nikon have been narrowing the gap with mirrorless cameras by providing some new lenses for FF (like the Canon WA primes mentioned above, and the Nikon f/1.8 primes) and for APS-C that are relatively good, compact, bright enough (also thanks to IS) and affordable. Optically similar Sony lenses would at least need some extra tubing or collapsible design to compensate for the 2-3 cm shorter flange back on E-mount - a similar (retrofocus) design on Sony platform would almost by definition mean a longer, heavier lens.
A significantly lighter and more compact FF ILC camera with high quality optics will only be possible with new lens designs. The angle of incidence with such lenses and the presence of the shutter make things tough (just look at the optical design of cameras like Sony R1, RX1, RX10). Making such compact high quality lenses might be technically too difficult or financially not attractive enough because of the relatively small Sony A7 sales numbers; that situation might change in a few years.
I don't think A7 series is 'niche' just because of the lack of size/weight savings; it has several other advantages for some users compared to current FF DSLRs. And for many DSLR users size/weight doesn't seem a factor anyway (especially for those working with longer lenses who look primarily at right balance between body and lens).
p.8 #9What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
JimFox wrote: jhinkey wroteJust last night I arrived at one of my locations 5 minutes late and just about missed what I wanted to shoot - I had to quickly throw the 400/5.6 ED AI onto the D800 and shoot hand-held at shutter speeds that were marginal w/o stabilization and using the not-always-trustworthy green dot for focus. A mirrorless D800 with IBIS would have been perfect for that situation - a situation I find myself in quite a bit for what I shoot (tripods not always workable and sometimes completely out of the question) in marginal light.
My point is that I hope things that Sony is now pushing in the A7rII end up appearing in a Nikon mirrorless FX format digital body.Hey John,
Since when was the green dot not trustworthy?
What is it you would have used if you hadn't been 5 minutes late? A tripod can be extended and set up in less than 15 seconds. And if it's shooting through the Liveview instead of the viewfinder, then you really should trade the D800 in for a D810 so that you will have a Liveview that's useable. But I don't get your green dot not being trustworthy, because it's very trustworthy. I only use the green dot, and my photos are always in focus.
I wonder if you look back at what you write, you are clearly so unhappy with Nikon and the D800 I really wonder why you are purposely causing yourself to suffer by shooting with it. Why not just buy the new Sony A7R II, get the Nikon Lens adapter and you will have what you want.
Our photography should be fun and enjoyable, not full of sorrow and misgivings like you are making it out to be.
Jim - clearly I'm not not happy with my D800 - it just has some limitations that I'm not happy with, but for many of my photographic uses it's been a wonderful tool. Good grief talk about interpreting words to the extremes. When I have a static subject my big Manfrotto + 405 geared head + D800 tethered to tablet for live view is very hard to beat (well, the D810 would be better). But when that subject is moving (a tug boat in this case) either it's a gimbal setup or hand-held case situation. I challenge anyone to get a large tripod setup, camera and tele lens mounted in 15 seconds starting from being folded up and camera & lens in the backpack.
And regarding the green dot - no Nikon body I've every had (D300/D700/D800) has had the green dot reliable for critical focus, especially for sharp fast glass - and I'm not alone in that regard.
"Sorrow and misgivings"? that's a hyperbolic response to my clear statements about some features I wish the D800 had . . .
A7RII was ordered the day it was available. The A7RII is going to be my off-the-tripod camera (like I wanted the A7R to be) while I prefer the D800 (and a D810 sometime soon) for tripod work. Won't be buying any native Sony glass anytime soon - my F-mount glass is doing me just fine.
p.8 #10What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
Let's leave my previous post and associated discussion behind.
My fantasy is that Nikon makes their hybrid DSLR viewfinder patent a reality:
DSLR goodness with the mirror down, mirrorless goodness with the mirror up. Use it in either mode you wish. Maybe this type of thing is what Nikon is really working on so that their F-mount lenses don't necessarily need to be replaced (thought the E lenses are starting to roll out).
p.8 #11What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
Sony seems to be listening to its customers by giving us what we need. Within a year they have given us a camera with better auto focus, evf, battery life, vibration reduction, silent shutter, more resolution, better iso and better ergonomics. Thats within a year and to have new zeiss lenses coming out really quickly. I mean this should be what Sony means to Canon and Nikon thread.
I remember having the 5d mark ii and it took them 4 years to come out with the 5d mark iii and all it did was give the camera better af and iso. It didn't improve on dynamic range, the IQ was the same and 2 more fps. Took them that long for any improvements, and then the 5ds/r has lots of resolution, but is crippled by iso. Same dynamic range of the 2008 canon 5d mark ii.
Nikon released the d800/e which is a sony sensor in late 2012 and then in mid 2014 we got the d810. Better Auto focus which wasn't hard since the d800e had terrible autofocus system in the first place. Better iso and video performances. I mean it was a upgrade, but wasn't like oh my god i need to buy this camera over the d800.
My point is that each time nikon or canon releases a new model you kinda hesitate if you want it or if its a upgrade that was necessary. People who bought the sony a7 want the a7r ii.
Canon and Nikon need to make awesome updates that show that their improving, but i doubt it. They have such a huge market that they dont really need to.
p.8 #12What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
Having used the a7r for quite a while before selling it (in anticipation of the A7RII coming out around now) it's quite clear that Sony is committed to trying to make this work both via the technologies they've shoe-horned into a body (of any size) and the rapidity of body releases/iterations. It seems they are getting the innovative technology about stuffed full, hopefully they will now start to polish all the rough edges that they've created (I assume because they are iterating very fast) - like lossless RAW, less-than stellar external & menu ergonomics, EVF/LCD function, battery life, etc.
I wonder how their sensor relationship with Nikon is working these days . . .
p.8 #16What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
sjms wrote:
and 6-8 months from now they'll announce the A7RIII in the works.
Yes, they will, and they still need to. Though I'm impressed with the RII, it's no full D8XX replacement in many cases, but to me and for how I use it it's getting close.
It immediately felt far more usable than the A7R due to the better (though not quite D800-level) ergonomics, IBIS, electronic shutter (fully and EFCS) - I dare say my EM1 may be in danger of being sold to fund the RII and I'll struggle along with my GX7.
At this point I would put the Oly EM1 and Sony A7RII in kind of the same ergonomics/functionality category for how I use these cameras. I.e., I love the features but really struggle with the menu systems and button placements. My Pany GX7, though less technically capable, is a real pleasure to use simply because the button placement, display features and menus system just make sense for me right out of the box. I've had to customize the EM1 and A7RII settings extensively to make them workable for me.
Sony is getting close, very close to having a really killer system. As a long time Nikon shooter I think Nikon had better get their mirrorless FX system going before the R-III comes out and Sony gets more native E mount glass available. Sony just got my $3200 - Nikon did not.
p.8 #18What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
jhinkey wrote: jancohen wroteTime will tell. It always does
Yes, it does, doesn't it
I've never really been an early adopter of most new technology that comes along, for a variety of reasons. The most important reason though is that by far, I'd rather at least wait some minimal period of time (e.g., six months or more) to see how others feel in the long run about a product I might like. Doing so gives me a far better chance of not being unhappy with something purchased on impulse.
Who knows, maybe Nikon (or Canon, or Sony, Olympus, etc.) will make some kind of statement in the next six months about their next generation of cameras. Or maybe they won't, and the RII will have truly have proven itself to be a great product by those who have been using it for some period of time. The thing is, technology and its rate of change seem to have reached a point where today's latest and greatest quickly become tomorrow's closet stuffing (or tradeins). We experience that today especially with the smart phone markets and to a lesser degree perhaps, the camera market.
Of course, if something comes along that one absolutely feels will do a job of something that can't be done with an older version of it, purchasing it and actually being able to do that job with the new purchase would probably justify the rush for a replacement. I imagine such could be very true in the cases of the pro who earns their living with these tools, as well the very serious amateur who has a large amount of disposable income.
Me, I'm just an older guy, one who's been around a while now who, after a lifetime of ups and downs, has learned to accept the virtue that some would say can be found in patience...
p.8 #19What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
Most of the complaints I've been reading about regarding the A7II so far have been AF related. I believe the A7RII is sensitive to +0.5 EV rather than the -3.0EV like say, the D750. Overall, big improvement over the A7R though no doubt.
p.8 #20What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
CanadaMark wrote:
Most of the complaints I've been reading about regarding the A7II so far have been AF related. I believe the A7RII is sensitive to +0.5 EV rather than the -3.0EV like say, the D750. Overall, big improvement over the A7R though no doubt.
Yeah, I don't plan to use AF at all with this body, so that's definitely one area that I'm sure Sony still need improvement on. When I had my A7R I briefly rented the Sony 70-200/4 OIS and found it almost unusable due to OIS/shutter interactions thus that AF experiment ended early.