p.9 #1What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
John, how does the A7RII compare to your Nikon body with the Zeiss 135 and whichever Nikon body you use (or have used)?; as well as any other Zeiss lenses or other MF lenses you use. I'm on the fence so your assessment would be most helpful. Thank you.
p.9 #2What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
ariel777 wrote:
John, how does the A7RII compare to your Nikon body with the Zeiss 135 and whichever Nikon body you use (or have used)?; as well as any other Zeiss lenses or other MF lenses you use. I'm on the fence so your assessment would be most helpful. Thank you.
Ariel -
When I had my A7R the sharpness, sensor reflections, etc. were very similar, if not identical to my D800 with the same lenses. The only issue i had was that the noise was about 1 stop or so worse in typical situations. Not a big deal. What I didn't like about the A7R was the ergonomics and lack of IBIS to use with my MF Nikkors.
So far I've only used my 400/5.6 ED AI with the RII (now to be know affectionately as the "brick") and it looked great as expected. I did find that the IBIS is not as effective as I would like at this focal length when at full magnification trying to nail the focus - the images look good, but the EVF image is kind of jerky if you will (still much better than with IBIS off though). At shorter focal lengths it's excellent.
It reminds me of the IBIS of the EM1 - at shorter focal lengths IBIS is smooth in the EVF, but as you go longer in focal length it gets a bit jerky - I suspect because it reaches its limits regarding how much correction it can do small DOFs.
I'll report back with more Nikkor experience.
I should be using the 16/3.5, 105/2.5, 135/3.5, 300/4.5, and 400/5.6 a lot with the RII
p.9 #3What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
I think the fame and hype for Sony is soon coming to an end.
The reasons for people going to Sony mirrorless is because of it's FF high MP sensors with high DR and it small form factor.
At a time when Canon does not have a FF DSLR to match that, business was good because users buy them to mount their Canon lenses.
Not so much for Nikon because Nikon has similar sensors and better image processing firmwares. But some still do wants to try them out just to have a feel.
But, now Canon have what their users were asking for, there is little need to go for Sony, although DR can still do with some improvements.
As for size with long lenses is a non issue because using them is difficult for control and some FF DSLR are really not much bigger system wise. With little users buying Sony lenses other than the kit lens that comes with it, than what income can they generate?
The next thing is Sony's lens line up is a total joke, their rebranded Zeiss lenses are no match to the real things from Germany, and yet they cost more than an average Japanese lens that out performed them by light years.
Based on the above less people will be buying them because there will be less people willing to stand on two boats and beta testers are done with their beta testing.
Finally, they have been in the red for the past 6 years and only this year they were able to get back into the black by selling off assets. But how much assets can a company sells before they run out of assets to keep them in the black? Be reminded that the near term global economic forecast is not rosy.
All these are coming from a guy who has predicted that FF DSLR will drop to $1800-1500 when they were at $3000. More low cost lenses for users to cross over from DX to FX. Prices of long lenses coming down due to heated competitions.
So, far all the above have met their targets.
p.9 #4What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
hans98ko wrote:
The reasons for people going to Sony mirrorless is because of it's FF high MP sensors with high DR and it small form factor.
At a time when Canon does not have a FF DSLR to match that, business was good because users buy them to mount their Canon lenses.
Not so much for Nikon because Nikon has similar sensors and better image processing firmwares. But some still do wants to try them out just to have a feel.
But, now Canon have what their users were asking for, there is little need to go for Sony, although DR can still do with some improvements. ...Show more →
As a Canon user looking at both A7RII and Nikon for upgrading I mostly agree. Canon still lacks some things that both Sony and Nikon can offer at the moment and that may be important for those who are not all into action/sports/events (where Canon in general seems to have the edge).
The 5DS finally offers high resolution but how many users really need this? It also has slightly improved low ISO DR, but still about 2 stops behind Sony and Nikon which in practice can be a big difference. None of the Canon FF bodies offers a tilt screen and the only relatively light body is the 6D which is 'crippled' in several ways and still a lot bigger than a Sony A7 series camera.
The A7RII sounded nice because it suggested that you could use your Canon lenses with decent AF (no need to buy new lenses) and get all the features that Canon does not offer, plus some extras like great video, high framerates, IBIS for non-IS lenses etc. Unfortunately, the AF with Canon lenses seems to work well only with a small selection of recent and often expensive Canon lenses, and in decent to good lighting only. That means that for Canon users the A7RII is at best an expensive 'second' camera unless you only take pictures where AF isn't important anyway.
I'm waiting a bit more to see if the lens/adapter situation can be improved and if that doesn't look likely will buy a Nikon D750 with some lenses...
p.9 #5What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
I think Nikon will soon implement mirrorless technology in a full format camera. They have the capability, and I'm sure it would be a nice system. Maybe they need to get new native lenses for the system off the drawing board. Though Nikon has a broad product line there are several holes in it (from us FM'ers POV). One would be the Coolpix A with an EVF (and a 40mm lens version as well). Another would be a mirrorless product with several native lenses. Another would be that ever popular pro DX camera. It seems about time for Nikon's turn to introduce a new camera.
p.9 #6What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
Sony has the superior technical know-how in the area of sensors, IBIS, video, mass manufacturing, electronics manufacturing, and technology integration over Canon and Nikon. Based on my use of their cameras they don't necessarily have equal or superior ability in lens design, camera technology integration, camera ergonomics, image processing, and software design.
They do have some marginal lenses out there that I assume are due to cost and having to fill in the lens lineup ASAP. They also have some killer primes that can compete with CaNikon easily. Fortunately they can now effectively use A mount lenses with on sensor PDAF.
Sony has made up a lot of ground and needs to work on the lens lineup (major holes) and ergonomics/integration/software side of things before they can catch up to CaNikon. Don't think that Sony is going out of business any time soon . . . .
CaNikon will have to come out with a winning mirrorless solution right out of the gate in order to not lose any more customers to Sony. That means they need to solve the legacy lens issue, battery life, IBIS/OIS issues, shutter/EFCS etc. on the first model.
Whatever happens it will be interesting both to watch and to take advantage of the resulting camera bodies.
p.9 #7What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
I have the Nikon D810 and the new Sony A7rII. I feel the Nikon RAW file is probably better - but the Sony is a lot more fun to use, especially with third-party manual focus lenses - and also Nikon G lenses, using a metabones adapter. I love focus peaking and magnification with the beautiful EVF. I probably won't buy another Nikon camera, after having owned 10 different models or so.
Of course i'm just an amateur, and my photographic skills don't match my enthusiasm! If i was a pro, i'd pretty much always go with the D810 for a paid job. Perhaps the biggest threat to Nikon and Canon, is in the enthusiast amateur segment. I don't know how important this is.
p.9 #8What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
PeterGlaso wrote:
I have the Nikon D810 and the new Sony A7rII. I feel the Nikon RAW file is probably better - but the Sony is a lot more fun to use, especially with third-party manual focus lenses - and also Nikon G lenses, using a metabones adapter. I love focus peaking and magnification with the beautiful EVF. I probably won't buy another Nikon camera, after having owned 10 different models or so.
Just wondering: does MF with the Sony A7RII EVF work well with moving subjects? I'm guessing that despite the high quality EVF it is difficult to judge sharpness, compared to using the viewfinder image of a good DSLR. And although there are tools like peaking and magnify, my impression is that these are almost impossible to use when the subject is moving and you have to decide very quickly if the subject is in focus.
I'm sure the EVF is very nice (and in several ways better than a DSLR viewfinder) for stationary subjects like landscape but it seems to me in many situations you simply have to rely on the AF system (which can be a problem with adapted lenses).
p.9 #9What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
Using peaking, it is easier with the EVF than a DSLR. But never easy as such, to focus manually on a moving subject. With the D810 i find it difficult with stationary objects as well. Another huge advantage with the A7rII is the stabilized sensor, no matter which lens you use.
p.9 #10What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
For me, it's still easy to draw a line between my small Sony NEX-6 and what I might want to do with it and maybe a couple of smallish lenses at some point. On the other side of the line, I have my Nikon dslr and a couple of lenses. I don't doubt that kind of differentiation can't be made for many users even if going to full frame. Small/light or bigger, faster, bulkier dslr kit. that could be done with other small systems or dslr/dslt systems, too.
I think Canon is closer to being impacted because their lenses are closer to being adapted well to the mirrorless bodies than are Nikons.
p.9 #11What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
technic wrote: PeterGlaso wroteI have the Nikon D810 and the new Sony A7rII. I feel the Nikon RAW file is probably better - but the Sony is a lot more fun to use, especially with third-party manual focus lenses - and also Nikon G lenses, using a metabones adapter. I love focus peaking and magnification with the beautiful EVF. I probably won't buy another Nikon camera, after having owned 10 different models or so.Just wondering: does MF with the Sony A7RII EVF work well with moving subjects? I'm guessing that despite the high quality EVF it is difficult to judge sharpness, compared to using the viewfinder image of a good DSLR. And although there are tools like peaking and magnify, my impression is that these are almost impossible to use when the subject is moving and you have to decide very quickly if the subject is in focus.
I'm sure the EVF is very nice (and in several ways better than a DSLR viewfinder) for stationary subjects like landscape but it seems to me in many situations you simply have to rely on the AF system (which can be a problem with adapted lenses)....Show more →
I find it quite obvious with the A7RII EVF if something is not in focus, especially with fast glass because you are seeing what the sensor sees regarding DOF, whereas with a DSLR you are seeing at something like f/2.8 or f/4 version of the image, thus to me it's not nearly as obvious . . . An OVF is not always a perfect representation of the scene, especially with faster glass.
p.9 #12What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
Elijah wrote: slrl0ver wroteWould you use a 70-200 f/2.8 on such a body? Did you gain much weight or size reduction? Same with an f/1.4 autofocus lens -- they tend to be big, so a D6xx or D750 body seems like a good pairing.Spot on dude, spot on. I Bought a DF last year and it was an awkward body to use with my 70-200VRII. At first I didn't have an issue (I even remember saying it on here that I actually liked it) but then after 3 weddings I got so sick of it... My D3s handles that 70-200VTRII like a charm.
This is the best comment in the history of FM. Pros work long hours. The Nikon D bodies are big for a reason - they're comfortable to hold over long hours. Hobbyists look at the D4 and think it's obnoxious and silly. But after 10 hours of work they would realize how perfectly the D4 handles. YEARS of R&D went into Nikon ergonomics, Canon too, and the gear is huge so you can get the job done.
I wouldn't mind if Sony kicked Nikon's butt, and Nikon became a smaller company that specialized in over-priced pro gear. IMO, Canon is already too big and unfocused on the photographers who NEED their gear to pay the bills. To me, it feels like Nikon is already more focused on pros, but that's just my opinion.
p.9 #13What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
Part of me really wonder if Nikon needs to make a mirrorless camera to get most of the mirrorless advantages.
On sensor phase detection would help with LV AF and video AF. Maybe it's also possible to uses at part of the AF system during burst / continues shooting.
Maybe the view finder could be updated to show accurate DOF at larger apertures like f2.
Maybe the AF system can be improved for MF.
In camera stabilization can help in LV and maybe for regular shots to. Start stabilizing the sensor on 1/2 press of the shutter if needed.
Personally the A7rII seams to un polished for the 3,200 price tag. But Sony seams to be working very hard at pushing it's camera systems forwards, I am would not be surprised if the next generation will be very well rounded cameras.
p.9 #14What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
DWOfPaul wrote:
Part of me really wonder if Nikon needs to make a mirrorless camera to get most of the mirrorless advantages.
On sensor phase detection would help with LV AF and video AF. Maybe it's also possible to uses at part of the AF system during burst / continues shooting.
Maybe the view finder could be updated to show accurate DOF at larger apertures like f2.
Maybe the AF system can be improved for MF.
In camera stabilization can help in LV and maybe for regular shots to. Start stabilizing the sensor on 1/2 press of the shutter if needed.
I had high hopes for this camera, but alas it has not seen the light of day. I certainly hope that Nikon will indeed come out with such a thing.
Personally the A7rII seams to un polished for the 3,200 price tag. But Sony seams to be working very hard at pushing it's camera systems forwards, I am would not be surprised if the next generation will be very well rounded cameras.
Well, the A7RII is far less polished than a D8XX for sure, but is much much improved over the A7R. As for the $3200 price tag, that's for each person to decide - personally for me it was worth the price due to the IBIS, improved external ergonomics, improved weatherproofing, etc. It's a camera that can mount just about any legacy 135 format lens which opens up a whole new realm of photographic possibilities.
p.9 #15What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
jhinkey wrote:
Well, the A7RII is far less polished than a D8XX for sure
Which is exactly why I feel personally if I was going to spend 3k + on a camera I rather get a d810 that would make all my lenses better and not deal with quicks of compressed raw, long exposures, low light AF, and over heating with video. Granted if someones gets a working Nikon G to Sony E electric adapter the lens gap might shrink quite a bit especially for when fast AF is not a requirement.
jhinkey wrote:
personally for me it was worth the price due to the IBIS, improved external ergonomics, improved weatherproofing, etc. It's a camera that can mount just about any legacy 135 format lens which opens up a whole new realm of photographic possibilities.
The ideas of mounting a canon 17mm f4 TS on a Sony A7(something) always sounded like an awesome combination for landscape or architecture. If I was to throughout practicality for me, a A7rII + Canon 17mm f4 TS + 11-24 f4 would make an awesome combination for a lot of the work I enjoy doing, and would allow me to do things I just can't do in the Nikon camp.
Hummm wouldn't it have been so much nicer if camera manufactures all agreed on a mount so we could mix and match lenses and bodies.
p.9 #16What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
hans98ko wrote:
I think the fame and hype for Sony is soon coming to an end.
The reasons for people going to Sony mirrorless is because of it's FF high MP sensors with high DR and it small form factor.
At a time when Canon does not have a FF DSLR to match that, business was good because users buy them to mount their Canon lenses.
Not so much for Nikon because Nikon has similar sensors and better image processing firmwares. But some still do wants to try them out just to have a feel.
But, now Canon have what their users were asking for, there is little need to go for Sony, although DR can still do with some improvements.
As for size with long lenses is a non issue because using them is difficult for control and some FF DSLR are really not much bigger system wise. With little users buying Sony lenses other than the kit lens that comes with it, than what income can they generate?
The next thing is Sony's lens line up is a total joke, their rebranded Zeiss lenses are no match to the real things from Germany, and yet they cost more than an average Japanese lens that out performed them by light years.
Based on the above less people will be buying them because there will be less people willing to stand on two boats and beta testers are done with their beta testing.
Finally, they have been in the red for the past 6 years and only this year they were able to get back into the black by selling off assets. But how much assets can a company sells before they run out of assets to keep them in the black? Be reminded that the near term global economic forecast is not rosy.
All these are coming from a guy who has predicted that FF DSLR will drop to $1800-1500 when they were at $3000. More low cost lenses for users to cross over from DX to FX. Prices of long lenses coming down due to heated competitions.
So, far all the above have met their targets. ...Show more →
I would not be so sceptical about Sony at all. Sony currently makes the best sensors and very decent cameras( new A7rII is a step in right direction).
Re-branded ZEISS lenses might not be match to like you said real things from Germany but they are not bad either. I believe if Sony wants to have ZEISS sticker on its lenses it has to be approved by ZEISS first so...
Sony needs to make some decent but cheap lenses like Nikon/Canon has: 50/1.4-1.8,85/1.8,70-200/4 etc
and maybe some primes 300/400/500mm ect to attract more customers.
What i like about Sony is the fact that it is not afraid to bring something new and is innovative what could hardly be said about Nikon or Canon.
p.9 #17What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
Technology cooperation between apparent competitors has been known to occur so ... let's observe the likely outcomes IF this is the current case with SONY/NIKON.
I'd look for a new NIKON body ... say ... a lightweight, flipable screen D900 with the new SONY sensor in the not-so-distant future. In fact Rockwell hints at something yet this month: "Calm before the storm".
After all SONY is a chip company that seems to lag in the lens area (Perhaps by agreement) while NIKON/CANON maintain a large fraction of their product mix in lenses—especially the lucrative long focus lenses. Feeding the NIKON sensor channel is a logical marketing tactic.
p.9 #18What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
@milkod2001
It is not about sceptical of Sony but rather the understanding of the inside operation of these companies.
Recently, Sony has been loosing out on a number of industries they used to dominate. They are now left with movie entertainment, music and sensors (which they still dominates). But not so much on camera manufacturing.
For how long they would last is a question for their senior management.
One thing for sure that their sensors division will not last for long is because other manufacturers are hot on their heels. Companies like Canon and Samsung are closing in real fast. Yes, you hear me right Samsung. If you have been following what Samsung can do with their sensors on their phones and cameras, you will know that they meant business just like memory chips, phones and flat panels.
Than there is this failing partnership between Nikon and Sony, which will bring in new players because Nikon also holds some of the major patents that is used by Sony on their sensors. While they were partners both parties gained from cross licensing and information exchange, but once they break up the situation will be very different. The reason that this partnership cannot last for ever is because Nikon is too dependant on Sony for sensors and Sony is also into camera manufacturing which is a conflict of interest.
Than there is this very high possibility that both CaNikon will produce a FF mirrorless camera. One must remember that CaNikon produced mirrorless cameras long before Sony produced their first camera. Oh! By the way just in case is not obvious, they are called P&S. All they need to do is to put an interchangeable lens mount with a FF sensor and their well known user interface, that's all. Nothing difficult. It is just that if they think is profitable and there is a large enough market.
Even if both CaNikon came in late, they can built up a full pledge system in no time, even without a lens mount change. All they need to do is come up with a mirrorless camera with a converter for their EOS or F mount lenses and expand their mirrorless lenses as time goes.
As for Sony to come up with a full pledge system they will need to invest heavily at a time that they are short of disposable cash, as well as the need for users to buy into their system which I think is a lot more difficult after their A800, A99 and NEX transition.
p.9 #19What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
hans98ko wrote:
I think the fame and hype for Sony is soon coming to an end.
The reasons for people going to Sony mirrorless is because of it's FF high MP sensors with high DR and it small form factor.
At a time when Canon does not have a FF DSLR to match that, business was good because users buy them to mount their Canon lenses.
Not so much for Nikon because Nikon has similar sensors and better image processing firmwares. But some still do wants to try them out just to have a feel.
But, now Canon have what their users were asking for, there is little need to go for Sony, although DR can still do with some improvements.
As for size with long lenses is a non issue because using them is difficult for control and some FF DSLR are really not much bigger system wise. With little users buying Sony lenses other than the kit lens that comes with it, than what income can they generate?
The next thing is Sony's lens line up is a total joke, their rebranded Zeiss lenses are no match to the real things from Germany, and yet they cost more than an average Japanese lens that out performed them by light years.
Based on the above less people will be buying them because there will be less people willing to stand on two boats and beta testers are done with their beta testing.
Finally, they have been in the red for the past 6 years and only this year they were able to get back into the black by selling off assets. But how much assets can a company sells before they run out of assets to keep them in the black? Be reminded that the near term global economic forecast is not rosy.
All these are coming from a guy who has predicted that FF DSLR will drop to $1800-1500 when they were at $3000. More low cost lenses for users to cross over from DX to FX. Prices of long lenses coming down due to heated competitions.
So, far all the above have met their targets. ...Show more →
Sony was able to raise $4 Billion dollars to invest in their sensor business this year (link), so they are far from being in the position of not having access to capital. They currently have 40% of the total market share for image sensors (aggregate across all markets, from smartphones, auto, industrial, and cameras), and their continued innovation and investment means their market share will continue to grow. I foresee a point where Sony is in the same position as Intel - the only company with enough resources and accrued technical knowledge to make leading edge chips for their industry, becoming a natural monopoly.
That is for sensors. The question is whether competing companies like Canikon can continue to dominate their markets without access to leading-edge sensor technology, esp if Sony were to make a future leap in technology vs the iterative improvements so far, versus whether Sony can ever gain enough market share in the camera markets by sensor and camera innovation alone.
p.9 #20What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
hans98ko wrote:
One thing for sure that their sensors division will not last for long is because other manufacturers are hot on their heels. Companies like Canon and Samsung are closing in real fast.
Canon closing in on Sony with sensors, you are joking right? As a Canon user I have been waiting for years for a sensor that comes even close to those from Sony and there isn't even anything on the horizon to match them (except the 5Ds sensor, for those who only look at MP numbers). Some of the best (as in 'state-of-the-art') sensors that Canon is using they buy from Sony, and their DSLR sensors are years behind the competition in several ways.
hans98ko wrote:
Than there is this very high possibility that both CaNikon will produce a FF mirrorless camera. .
Right, that has been a 'very high possibility' for years. Sony has been delivering while Nikon and Canon have nothing similar, and Canon's EOS-M is a half-hearted attempt at mirrorless. Maybe they can but if they don't act ... and how likely is it that their first FF mirrorless is a roaring success right away? In the meantime, Sony is learning ...
hans98ko wrote:
Even if both CaNikon came in late, they can built up a full pledge system in no time, even without a lens mount change. All they need to do is come up with a mirrorless camera with a converter for their EOS or F mount lenses and expand their mirrorless lenses as time goes.
I think you really underestimate the importance of electronics (e.g. EVF technology) and software for mirrorless cameras; this is where Sony is a much bigger player than CaNikon. High quality video, similar story. Also, part of the problems that Sony has with adapting other lenses to their mirrorless cameras will exist just the same for CaNikon when adapting their own lenses for a mirrorless FF body. Until recently performance of most Canon EF lenses on the EOS-M was pathetic, probably only the latest lenses will work well on mirrorless.