fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?

  
 
JimFox
Offline

p.1 #1What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
So the Sony forum is blowing up with the announcement of the new A7R II by Sony. Outside of a whole new set of trolls that I never knew existed before, there is some interesting information in there on some of the design choices.

One of the most interesting I thought was the "back-illuminated sensor". It sounds like a step forward, but is it really? And I wonder if Nikon will be looking at something along this line in the future? More light getting to the sensor should be a good thing right?

Jim
Jun 11, 2015 at 07:19 PM
jbonzo1
Offline
Details
p.1 #2What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
Looks like Nikon gets the 54mp sensor first!
A friend shoots with the A7R and A99 and has several Zeiss lenses and loves them. I don't care for the EVF...
Jun 11, 2015 at 07:33 PM
LMT1972
Offline
Details
p.1 #3What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
Thom Hogan has a recent article looking at this Jim.

http://www.dslrbodies.com/newsviews/re-bsi-and-stacked-sensors.html

Seems as though BSI is more of an advantage on smaller sensors, but time will tell I suppose.

Cheers
Leigh
Jun 11, 2015 at 07:34 PM
JimFox
Offline
Details
p.1 #4What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
jbonzo1 wrote:
Looks like Nikon gets the 54mp sensor first!
A friend shoots with the A7R and A99 and has several Zeiss lenses and loves them. I don't care for the EVF...



Ha ha... maybe so!

Yeah, I am not a big EVF person either, I don't really care for them.

A Mirrorless camera doesn't interest me in the slightest personally, I am totally fine with good old DSLR design. But if Sony took a step forward in the sensor design, that hopefully that part will trickle over to us in future bodies?

Jim
Jun 11, 2015 at 07:43 PM
sjms
Offline
Details
p.1 #5What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
as with pretty much every Sony product the bluster blows over pretty quick.
Jun 12, 2015 at 11:00 AM
Craig Gillette
Offline
Details
p.1 #6What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
I think there is a natural and non-brand definitive point where small cameras go Sony (and some others) and big/fast can go any mount. Nikon can co-exist with Sony. The fun is with Canon that there is maybe not just an ability to use Canon lenses well on Sony bodies (away goes some of the "limited lenses" discussion) but now, hmmh, unlike Nikon which has Sony (etc.) sensor goodness perhaps one can say that Canon lens users now have access to Sony sensor tech...
Jun 12, 2015 at 11:15 AM
jhinkey
Offline
Details
p.1 #7What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
JimFox wrote:
So the Sony forum is blowing up with the announcement of the new A7R II by Sony. Outside of a whole new set of trolls that I never knew existed before, there is some interesting information in there on some of the design choices.

One of the most interesting I thought was the "back-illuminated sensor". It sounds like a step forward, but is it really? And I wonder if Nikon will be looking at something along this line in the future? More light getting to the sensor should be a good thing right?

Jim


There is far more to this sensor than just BSI (back side illuminated) design. Yes, it will give a slight bump in DR, but it also appears that the micro-lenses may be able to accept a wider ray of light because the electrodes are not as far away/deep as with front side illuminated designs.
Also, the ability to have a truly electronic shutter is, to me, a huge thing as well since there is absolutely no shutter-induced vibrations.

As I found with my now-sold A7R, how Sony implements these features can sometimes be irritating.

What this tells me is that Nikon potentially, hopefully, probably will have access to this kind of sensor sometime soon and I really look forward to seeing this in Nikon's first mirrorless FX system. It might not have IBIS, but electronic shutter, better ray acceptance, slightly better DR, etc., etc. - all good things when coupled with Nikon's ICs to get it into a 14bit NEF file.

I will find a way to order the A7rII and will keep my D800 until Nikon comes out with a mirrorless FX body at 36MP.
Jun 12, 2015 at 11:32 AM
curious80
Offline
Details
p.1 #8What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
JimFox wrote:
So the Sony forum is blowing up with the announcement of the new A7R II by Sony. Outside of a whole new set of trolls that I never knew existed before, there is some interesting information in there on some of the design choices.

One of the most interesting I thought was the "back-illuminated sensor". It sounds like a step forward, but is it really? And I wonder if Nikon will be looking at something along this line in the future? More light getting to the sensor should be a good thing right?

Jim


There are at least three potential benefits of BSI sensors:

1. Possible improvement in light gathering though it has to be seen if it would help in a sensor this big. When Sony announced the 1" BSI sensor in RX100 series, it was thought that 1" was too big to get any benefit from BSI but Sony was able to get about 30% increase in light gathering. Samsung also claimed to get improved light gathering form use of BSI in its APS-C NX1 sensor but we don't know how much. And FF is even bigger.

2. Increased readout speed - should help with faster FPS, better video etc.

3. Reduces the issues faced by digital sensors on sensor edges where light rays from the lens hit at an angle. This is of lower concern to DSLRs where the increased distance between sensor and lens means that the rays are not likely to hit at very extreme angles. But it could still help a bit in say reducing vignetting etc.
Jun 12, 2015 at 11:39 AM
Next39
Offline
Details
p.1 #9What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
I'm definitely interested in it for video production. Will be following user reviews very closely.

I have no interest in it for stills.

Jun 12, 2015 at 11:40 AM
trenchmonkey
Offline
Details
p.1 #10What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
Nikonions?? I'd rather be called a scallion...just sayin'

Jun 12, 2015 at 11:43 AM
snapsy
Online
Details
p.1 #11What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
I think it means bad news for Nikon. Starting with the D800 Nikon distinguished itself vs Canon by having the highest IQ camera system available. Even after the A7r was released the D800 was still the better system due to the large selection of native AF lenses. The game changer with the the A7rii is its ability to PDAF with Canon lenses at speeds nearly equal with those same lenses on native Canon bodies. This means Sony now has the best FF sensor available in combination with the best lenses available. I suspect Sony will keep the sensor exclusive to itself for a year or two but even after that it'll still give pause to any existing Canon user who would've otherwise switched over to Nikon for IQ reasons, esp after the relative disappointment of the 5DS/R sensor improvements. I think Canon body sales might be hurt due to the A7rii but at least their lens sales should remain strong.

In summary I think Nikon is the odd man out here.
Jun 12, 2015 at 11:47 AM
CanadaMark
Offline
Details
p.1 #12What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
I'm more interested in Sony's 1" Stacked sensor, which should be noticeably improved across the board including video (and hopefully make it into the Nikon 1 V4, but they seem to like Aptina sensors for that).

The advantages of BSI start to fall off pretty sharply beyond the really small sensors (1/2.3", cell phones, etc.). They did however also change the microlens array and allow for full electronic shutter, which will help no doubt. I wouldn't expect an enormous jump in IQ from that 42MP sensor on top of the D810, but probably noticeable increases across the board (noise, DR) while having the extra 6MP. Video should be improved as well.

The Sony A7 bodies have never interested me much personally, if I overlook the minimal size advantage once you start using most full frame lenses, EVF's and system depth (sans adapters) are deal breakers for me (YMMV). I would be all over the RX 100 IV for a backup/underwater camera if it weren't $1000 and if they would just put the on-sensor PDAF tech they use in so many of their other bodies in it.

I actually think the A7R II is most exciting for Canon users (or other brands), who still have no option for a modern, well-rounded high MP sensor or high DR landscape camera if they want to use their own lenses. It can now take full advantage of it's new AF system with adapters, and has a better dampened shutter along with EFC. I think the A7R2 would make an awesome landscape/hiking camera as well.
Jun 12, 2015 at 11:50 AM
Mark_L
Offline
Details
p.1 #13What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
Probably not much given nikon’s attitude towards mirrorless and video. I’d be surprised if this sensor made it into a Nikon body given Canon’s 50MP. It is a large nail in the slr coffin though and possibly the tipping point where Sony’s mirrorless cameras lead slrs in terms of feature set.
Jun 12, 2015 at 11:53 AM
aut0maticdan
Offline
Details
p.1 #14What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
snapsy - I'm very skeptical about the AF speed on this thing. The reports are hyperbolic as they always are. I'm going to wait and see. I believe that Steve Huff said it was on par with the a7S for native lenses which is ok, but not amazing. He's not one to downplay anything Sony does. If that's the case, there is little chance that its as fast as a Canon body with a Canon lens. If it truly is, that's mind blowing.

I don't think this means much for Nikonians other than us having another alternative system for primary or secondary shooting. I don't expect Nikon to come out with anything like this, maybe ever. Its one hell of a specs sheet and I want one but Sony still has quite a bit to learn about making cameras (I'm a part time a7S shooter). Nikon is philosophically different in their approach. Parallels could be drawn to iPhone/Android. Android often kills it on specs while iPhone goes for a particular aesthetic and experience. Everyone has their preferences. That being said, Nikon would be wise to steal some new sensor here, 4K there, etc much like Apple went bigger and stole key features from Android. Sony is definitely going to take a great deal of marketshare in the near term and it is quite likely they will debut the hot new sensors in the alpha line rather than letting Nikon steal the show going forward. Can't wait to see what the next low MP sensor is all about.

I'm really curious to see how the 8 new lenses by 2016 shake out. I can see making a switch to them for my primary if they can give me the one or two killer lenses I'll want to shoot all the time. What I've seen from the 50/1.8 and 35/1.4 isn't promising for my tastes. I feel like they are kind of in the same camp as ART lenses. Definitely killer lenses, super sharp everywhere at every setting and test really well but make me long for the character of the Nikon 1.4 primes and old AIS lenses. Speaking of old AIS lenses, the a7S is stellar for shooting them if you can live without EXIF info... 50 1.2 AIS all day.
Jun 12, 2015 at 12:08 PM
aut0maticdan
Offline
Details
p.1 #15What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
I think the use of BSI is less about sensitivity and a lot more about sensor read-out time as well as potentially addressing an issue with wide angle lenses on a short flange.
Jun 12, 2015 at 12:13 PM
snapsy
Online
Details
p.1 #16What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
aut0maticdan wrote:
snapsy - I'm very skeptical about the AF speed on this thing. The reports are hyperbolic as they always are. I'm going to wait and see. I believe that Steve Huff said it was on par with the a7S for native lenses which is ok, but not amazing. He's not one to downplay anything Sony does. If that's the case, there is little chance that its as fast as a Canon body with a Canon lens. If it truly is, that's mind blowing.

I'm skeptical too. However dpreview's lead editor saw a demonstration first-hand and said to worked very well (link).
Jun 12, 2015 at 12:18 PM
kaplah
Offline
Details
p.1 #17What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
jhinkey wrote:
[...] the ability to have a truly electronic shutter is, to me, a huge thing as well since there is absolutely no shutter-induced vibrations.

And a theoretically infinite x-sync, harking back to the D70. Possibly negating the need for ND filters with flash in most situations outdoors.
Jun 12, 2015 at 12:35 PM
jbonzo1
Offline
Details
p.1 #18What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
trenchmonkey wrote:
Nikonions?? I'd rather be called a scallion...just sayin'

http://i244.photobucket.com/albums/gg31/rvrsbnd/810_4975_zpspjgp31nn.jpg



How about Nikkoneers?
Jun 12, 2015 at 01:08 PM
philber
Offline
Details
p.1 #19What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
My guess is that Sony had/has a deal with Nikon along the lines of "you get the best sensor tech, but only for DSLRs, while I get it for mirrorless". That went well, and both Sony and Nikon ate Canon's breakfast for landscape shooters, previously enslaved by Canon's superior offerings.
Now, either Nikon is late to the game with a D820, or their deal is over. At any rate, looking at it from the outside, Nikon has, with a few short weeks, fallen from "most attractive for landscape photographers" to "least attractive in terms of resolution". And Sony have progressed from "the best mirrorless out there" (the A7 range) to "we want to show that he best out there is mirrorless" with the A7R II.
While I don't think it will really damage Nikon, it can't help them gain market share at this time. But who knows what tomorrow holds?
Jun 12, 2015 at 01:31 PM
Two23
Offline
Details
p.1 #20What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
jhinkey wrote:
Also, the ability to have a truly electronic shutter is, to me, a huge thing as well since there is absolutely no shutter-induced vibrations.



For me, the potential of an electronic shutter to offer sync speeds far above 1/250s is truly exciting. As is, I need massive amounts of light to give me fill flash on a large area.

Kent in SD

Jun 12, 2015 at 01:35 PM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister