fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?

  
 
ariel777
Offline
Details
p.12 #1What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
To answer the OP's inquiry "as to me" it means a transition to Sony for all but my wildlife endeavors (mainly, birding); therefore, I plan on selling quite a few wide-angle and medium range lenses that are now no longer accommodative to that end. A principal reason is the opportunity to finally shoot with Zeiss AF lenses and also enjoy the superior MF capacities for those ZF.2 lenses I currently own; in the future any MF Zeiss lenses I purchase will be native to Sony. It will also be a pleasure not dealing with Nikon which repeatedly has stonewalled the acknowledgement of obvious defects in some new bodies, though ultimately capitulating. Not that Sony may be much better, but certainly can't be worse.
Aug 28, 2015 at 03:27 PM
sjms
Offline
Details
p.12 #2What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
if i were thinking in that scope personally i'd let this gestate another version or two. at this point it's not a rose without thorns.
Aug 28, 2015 at 03:54 PM
Mark_L
Offline
Details
p.12 #3What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
sjms wrote:
if i were thinking in that scope personally i'd let this gestate another version or two. at this point it's not a rose without thorns.


There are a few reports of lens quality issues on lloyd chambers' site
Aug 28, 2015 at 04:04 PM
jim allison
Offline
[X]
Details
p.12 #4What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
I wouldn't switch, but I could see adding a Sony body, so that I could use the Canon TSE
lenses.
Aug 28, 2015 at 04:37 PM
jancohen
Offline
Details
p.12 #5What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
jim allison wrote:
I wouldn't switch, but I could see adding a Sony body, so that I could use the Canon TSE
lenses.


+1
Aug 28, 2015 at 05:26 PM
DWOfPaul
Offline
Details
p.12 #6What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
jim allison wrote:
I wouldn't switch, but I could see adding a Sony body, so that I could use the Canon TSE
lenses.


I really want to do this too, but the 6k price tag for the A7rII, smart adapter, and TS 17 f4 has kept me away so far. I keep thinking about getting the PC 24mm for my d800. It's not a Canon TS, and it's not 17mm, but it's 4k cheaper, and a rather nice lens.
Aug 28, 2015 at 08:55 PM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.12 #7What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
You can save a few $$$ @ the A7R + TS-E instead of the A7R II.

I'm just not sure 6MP is worth $2K ... the diff @ A7R vs. A7R II.
Aug 28, 2015 at 09:25 PM
ariel777
Offline
Details
p.12 #8What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
RustyBug wrote:
You can save a few $$$ @ the A7R + TS-E instead of the A7R II.

I'm just not sure 6MP is worth $2K ... the diff @ A7R vs. A7R II.


The upgrades are considerably more extensive than the 6MP. Of course, whether they are worth it is unique to each individual.

Aug 28, 2015 at 09:38 PM
DWOfPaul
Offline
Details
p.12 #9What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
RustyBug wrote:
I'm just not sure 6MP is worth $2K ... the diff @ A7R vs. A7R II.


I feel like the MP bump is the least significant upgrade in the A7rII. 36mp is quite a nice number. If Nikon could get a 36mp sensor to have even better high ISO performance then the A7rII then I hope they stay at 36mp. 16mp cameras I can find a bit questionable if you want future proof images for digital display, now that displays are coming out, which have a higher resolution then a 16mp camera, such as 5k displays. 36mp should be good for quite a few more years. Look at how long it got us to get to the 4k - 5k range, I doubt we will be upping to 8k in the next few years, which is where you will need that 42mp sensor.
Aug 28, 2015 at 09:45 PM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.12 #10What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
+1 @ more to it than just the MP ... but for the 6MP, that's a chunk of change (300%) for what amounts to 16% more MP.
Aug 28, 2015 at 10:21 PM
oguruma
Offline
Details
p.12 #11What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
Are these megapixel wars ever going to end? I find these 36mp files to be enough of a pain the arse. I don't know that I would want any more resolution until better computer processors are available and affordable.
Aug 28, 2015 at 10:22 PM
jhinkey
Offline
Details
p.12 #12What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
oguruma wrote:
Are these megapixel wars ever going to end? I find these 36mp files to be enough of a pain the arse. I don't know that I would want any more resolution until better computer processors are available and affordable.


Oh come on, my 5 year old Intel Windows 7 machine copes with the 36MP from my D800 and now the 42.5MP of my A7RII just fine. ACR opens them up in about a second. Storage is more of a pain and if you are going to plunk down ~$3K on a 36MP+ camera a basic couple of TB RAID system is not that much to spring for.
Aug 29, 2015 at 01:07 AM
sjms
Offline
Details
p.12 #13What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
i was doing 40MP images out of a Hassy on my 2008 asus laptop in 2011 tethered via firewire.

Edited on Aug 29, 2015 at 04:28 AM · View previous versions
Aug 29, 2015 at 04:19 AM
Mark_L
Offline
Details
p.12 #14What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
jhinkey wrote:
oguruma wroteAre these megapixel wars ever going to end? I find these 36mp files to be enough of a pain the arse. I don't know that I would want any more resolution until better computer processors are available and affordable.
Oh come on, my 5 year old Intel Windows 7 machine copes with the 36MP from my D800 and now the 42.5MP of my A7RII just fine. ACR opens them up in about a second. Storage is more of a pain and if you are going to plunk down ~$3K on a 36MP+ camera a basic couple of TB RAID system is not that much to spring for.


Exactly. 20ishMP started becoming standard for Canon in 2008 (5DmkII). We now have 30% more pixels. Computers have got more than 30% faster in the intervening 7 years.
Aug 29, 2015 at 04:24 AM
Vcize
Offline
Details
p.12 #15What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?


jhinkey wrote:
oguruma wroteAre these megapixel wars ever going to end? I find these 36mp files to be enough of a pain the arse. I don't know that I would want any more resolution until better computer processors are available and affordable.
Oh come on, my 5 year old Intel Windows 7 machine copes with the 36MP from my D800 and now the 42.5MP of my A7RII just fine. ACR opens them up in about a second. Storage is more of a pain and if you are going to plunk down ~$3K on a 36MP+ camera a basic couple of TB RAID system is not that much to spring for.


Storage is even easier than raid now. You can pick up a 5tb external drive for a little over $100 now and back it up off-site via cloud storage for $10/mo.
Aug 29, 2015 at 09:36 AM
TMaG82
Offline
Details
p.12 #16What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
Of all the improvements from the a7r to the a7rII, the resolution jump is really low on my list of welcome improvements. Just a few of the ones that I personally put emphasis on.

- Better grip, better shutter placement
- 4k video in body (then again I don't shoot 20-25 minute clips, mostly 1-2 minutes or so, so I don't have issues with overheating
- IBIS. I like OIS, but I like IBIS that can be used in conjunction with it.
- Better dampening, elimination of shutter shock.
- Better sounding shutter,
- EFCS
- Silent shooting (under the right circumstances)

I shot with a D810, now I shoot with the a7rII. Both are great cameras, but for my needs, the a7rII is a better camera for me.

Even if Canon or Nikon were to come out with a new FF mirrorless line, they would either a) have to make a new line of glass b) have the body not that much smaller than the current DSLR body save for the room for a mirrorbox to make up for the flange distance or c) use adapters like the current ones to make up for the flange distance. And even then if they start using EVFs, the same argument that people have against the Sonys will still apply for the Canon/Nikon versions of battery life, ergonomics, and not comfortable to use long glass on, unless again they were to use a body size not that much smaller than the DSLR size.

Aug 29, 2015 at 11:30 AM
ariel777
Offline
Details
p.12 #17What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
When I received the A7Rii a few days ago my sense was that the size/weight differential was not that significant. However, upon delivery and mounting of the Sony 16-35/4 and then a hand in hand comparison with the 810 mounted with the Nikon 16-35/4, it was night and day. The Sony package was and felt considerably lighter, easier to handle and, generally speaking, much more facile to work with.
Aug 29, 2015 at 12:01 PM
jhinkey
Offline
Details
p.12 #18What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
TMaG82 wrote:
Of all the improvements from the a7r to the a7rII, the resolution jump is really low on my list of welcome improvements. Just a few of the ones that I personally put emphasis on.

- Better grip, better shutter placement
- 4k video in body (then again I don't shoot 20-25 minute clips, mostly 1-2 minutes or so, so I don't have issues with overheating
- IBIS. I like OIS, but I like IBIS that can be used in conjunction with it.
- Better dampening, elimination of shutter shock.
- Better sounding shutter,
- EFCS
- Silent shooting (under the right circumstances)

I shot with a D810, now
...Show more →

+1

I'd be happy if Nikon just made a DM810 - keep the body size, mount, etc. the same so that I could get many of the mirrorless advantages in the same size body and a much larger battery (though battery life would be greatly reduced). Obviously on sensor PDAF would have to work really really well with Nikon's current lenses to please many other users besides me.

I'd be even more happy if Nikon had a DM810 AND a A7R-II-like body for when size, weight, and adaptability to other lenses are important. As it is my D800 and A7R-II live happily side-by side for the most part, with the D800 being a much better tripod camera while the A7R-II is a much better on-the-go body that can use some excellent, compact, and light-weight legacy FX glass (in addition to my MF Nikkors).

I don't see an either-or scenario for Nikon - i.e., they don't have to abandon DSLR (at least not any time soon) to have a mirrorless FX camera. They need a mirrorless FX camera to keep the leakage of customers to Sony to a minimum.
Aug 29, 2015 at 12:26 PM
JimFox
Offline
Details
p.12 #19What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
oguruma wrote:
Are these megapixel wars ever going to end? I find these 36mp files to be enough of a pain the arse. I don't know that I would want any more resolution until better computer processors are available and affordable.


I am guessing you better go to Best Buy or Costco, etc. There are plenty of computers out that are fast enough and very inexpensive to handle the processing of these files. 36mp is great and no trouble at all.

Jim
Aug 29, 2015 at 01:21 PM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.12 #20What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
TMaG82 wrote:
And even then if they start using EVFs, the same argument that people have against the Sonys will still apply for the Canon/Nikon versions of battery life, ergonomics, and not comfortable to use long glass on, unless again they were to use a body size not that much smaller than the DSLR size.



+1 @ possible rinse & repeat.

I think they could pull it off in what we currently find as typical APS-C sized bodies ... but with a FF mirrorless sensor and an articulating display. Much maller than that, and yup, you're gonna run into a "rinse & repeat" just with a different name on it.

Will be curious to see if Sony responds by upsizing the mirrorless first, or CaNikon comes up with a FF mirrorless body for current glass. Also, curious to see what approach Pentax takes with their upcoming FF, and what Sony might do with the A99 II should it ever arrive.
Aug 29, 2015 at 03:34 PM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister