fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?

  
 
Alexluu627
Offline
Details
p.3 #1What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
Lol Lance!!

The new sony might not mean anything to you, but for us gear collectors and hobbyist it does lol! We want to try everything and test everything because its exciting.

about 80% of the people who switched from canon and nikon did it because of the weight and size of it. Which is a clear advantage if you like traveling and go on long hikes. Also the idea that you can use all your film lenses and have ibis and focus peaking is just a plus to many awesome things it brings. I don't see much disadvantages selling your dslr kit and moving to something smaller except for focusing which their working on. The quality of lenses coming out for the sony system is amazing.

IBIS, 4k video, Focus Peaking, EVF, Wifi, a 42mp sensor and 100k iso all in a small camera is a big deal for $3200. Thats why everyone is trying to figure out what nikon is gonna do. the specs alone already make the d810 $3200 dollar camera look outdated.

In a perfect world we wouldn't care about specs on a camera and just worry about capturing the moment. But if that was the case we wouldn't have awesome threads like this where we can truly be camera nerds and debate about stupid things that don't matter.
Jun 14, 2015 at 01:34 AM
Lance B
Offline
Details
p.3 #2What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
Like I said, miniscule perceived advantage. You "don't see much disadvantages selling your dslr kit and moving to something smaller except for focusing which their working on. The quality of lenses coming out for the sony system is amazing."

Except for the huge loss of money and ability, no not much loss at all. .

The specs do not make the D810 look outdated at all. There is nothing in the Sony that is an update to the D810 in any way shape or form.
Jun 14, 2015 at 07:05 AM
Lance B
Offline
Details
p.3 #3What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
trenchmonkey wrote:
^ Anyone who buys a new body...as an investment, is a moron.


Couldn't agree more, Will.

The DSLR body of today is like the film back in the days of film SLR's - a disposable commodity. If you add up the cost of the film you would have used over the life of your DSLR, the cost of the DSLR would pale into insignificance.
Jun 14, 2015 at 07:11 AM
sjms
Offline
Details
p.3 #4What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
Lance B wrote:
trenchmonkey wrote^ Anyone who buys a new body...as an investment, is a moron.
Couldn't agree more, Will.

The DSLR body of today is like the film back in the days of film SLR's - a disposable commodity. If you add up the cost of the film you would have used over the life of your DSLR, the cost of the DSLR would pale into insignificance.


+1
i've been saying that for a way long time to people.

and you know in the end all that technology and other crap the throw in many will still come out with the same results. And we all know what that potentially is.

for collectors its a bad option (this months cool is next months "i bought this why?" along with the price) as was said this are commoditized momentary toys. for so call "gear heads" it may be a feeding frenzy, but again short lived till "the next big thing".

Sony's product pricing general retires rapidly and fairly dramatically.
Jun 14, 2015 at 07:12 AM
jancohen
Offline
Details
p.3 #5What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
Lance B wrote:
trenchmonkey wrote^ Anyone who buys a new body...as an investment, is a moron.
Couldn't agree more, Will.

The DSLR body of today is like the film back in the days of film SLR's - a disposable commodity.


+1

A bit of philosophical meandering if you will. I hope it fits in here as it is about my reflections on the current discussion:

Call me a really, really old fogie, but there was a time when life seemed much simpler with respect to photography (and a heck of a lot of other things). In a way, I do somewhat miss the days of yore when taking nice (or great) photos was more about the journey.

It's not so much the incredible advances in technology that have occurred these past decades, mind you--technology always seemed to play some sort of role, whether with film camera or print easel in hand. It's just that producing those final, pleasing images always seemed to be the culmination of a process that could and often did lead to those enriching memories of a lifetime.

I say that because things just seem to happen so fast today; and the need for them to happen fast seems rather prevalent, rapidly advancing technology being a driving force. Others often seem caught up in megapixels and throughput, lens and sensor sharpness, having the next best thing, etc., and though I understand the role technological improvements play in today's world, I can't help but wonder how photographers like Adams, Capa, etc., would think about the current state of the art.

Afterthought edit: I imagine such photographers would probably simply shrug their shoulders, say it's not about the camera--which is merely the tool--but about the carving itself.

One does need sharp tools though, eh?

http://www.theshininglamp.com/gallery/colorbox2/content/lake.clear.area/lc4.jpg




Edited on Jun 14, 2015 at 10:20 AM · View previous versions
Jun 14, 2015 at 10:08 AM
Bernie
Offline
Details
p.3 #6What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
Lance B wrote:
Like I said, miniscule perceived advantage. You "don't see much disadvantages selling your dslr kit and moving to something smaller except for focusing which their working on. The quality of lenses coming out for the sony system is amazing."

Except for the huge loss of money and ability, no not much loss at all. .

The specs do not make the D810 look outdated at all. There is nothing in the Sony that is an update to the D810 in any way shape or form.


When you're looking at specs of a fraction of a stop improvement in DR, by the time you PP your images any advantage is gone. Because with those fractional improvements the quality of the final image is going to be determined by the skill of the person in performing the raw conversion (and the software) and then any other subsequent PP to the final image. The camera is virtually immaterial. When you move from one camera to another where you have multiple stops of difference, that is something else. I saw this moving from a D300 to the D750.

Aside from DR is how well the firmware in the camera itself processes the image. Just because the D750 has better edge detection and processing in camera, a DX mode shot from the D750 (10 mp) is at least as good as a 12 mp shot from the D300.
See

Similar logic can be used to compare with the Sony cameras. Specs are one thing, actual shooting and PP are another.
Jun 14, 2015 at 10:13 AM
Lauchlan Toal
Offline
Details
p.3 #7What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
Just a note on bodies - they're indeed an investment. However, they're an investment in yourself, like education. It's not about what you can resell it for, it's about what it lets you accomplish.

Just felt like chiming in.
Jun 14, 2015 at 10:51 AM
sjms
Offline
Details
p.3 #8What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
knowledge in the of a camera is the investment (which is elementally the same). the rest are just extras.
Jun 14, 2015 at 11:11 AM
EB-1
Offline
Details
p.3 #9What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
trenchmonkey wrote:
^ Anyone who buys a new body...as an investment, is a moron.


Yeah, cameras are expenses.

EBH
Jun 14, 2015 at 11:52 AM
EB-1
Offline
Details
p.3 #10What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
Can Nikon get that sensor and put it in a D900 for example?

EBH
Jun 14, 2015 at 11:59 AM
JimFox
Offline
Details
p.3 #11What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
Lance B wrote:
The new Sony means nothing to me and I guess most Nikon users, unless they think wasting money selling one system to get another for a miniscule PERCEIVED advantage in one area (probably none in actual fact) but lose out in a larger way in anther area of performance or features. I really don't get these people who switch back and forth at the drop of a hat just so they can claim some minor PERCEIVED advantage - if there actually is one which I doubt.

Sometimes I think it's more about, "hey, look at me I've got the
...Show more →

Hey Lance,

Myself I am not going to buy the Sony A7R II. I have no need for a mirrorless camera, I backpack just fine with my D8xx's, so less weight doesn't mean a thing to me. And actually the size would be horrible for me. I held the Sony A7R, it's way too small for my hands. And even though it's on the tripod when shooting mostly, I do hand hold sometimes, and the size of the Nikon D8xx is perfect for my hands.

But a lot of people do like the idea of smaller and lighter, so for them I am sure it gives hope that perhaps Nikon will make a FF Mirrorless camera sooner than later now. And they actually might do it sooner than Nikon will make a D400 which some people have been yearning for years for.

The thought for me though is with this twist on the sensor, can it really lead to better IQ and if it does will that lead to better IQ for us as Nikon Users? It also seems they have perhaps added a few tricks to making the AF better? Again will that trickle over to the Nikon camera's and help the AF for those people who like to shoot in Live View?

One thing their specs definitely reminded me of is how much I enjoy the battery life in the D8xx's. To be able to shoot almost 2000 images on one battery is something Sony users can only dream of. I think it said that battery life was projected to be only 285 images? On a backpacking trip the weight savings is probably very negligible by the time you add in carrying 6 or 8 spare batteries, or a solar charger and battery charger? Or I guess one would have to really refrain from shooting much. Myself at least even when I shot film, I always shot a lot of images, so that would really give me pause for thought on that aspect.

Jim
Jun 14, 2015 at 12:23 PM
JimFox
Offline
Details
p.3 #12What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
Lauchlan Toal wrote:
Just a note on bodies - they're indeed an investment. However, they're an investment in yourself, like education. It's not about what you can resell it for, it's about what it lets you accomplish.

Just felt like chiming in.


I am guessing from reading the comments here, we can all have our own personal take on whether a camera body is an investment or not. I don't view them as investments, and don't purchase them with that idea. For me, they are tools that I use until they are worn out (obsolete specs) and then I buy a new tool.

Now camera lenses? I believe very firmly that 95% of the people in this forum will say they are investments since they can easily have a life through many, many camera bodies.

Jim
Jun 14, 2015 at 12:26 PM
carlitos
Offline
Details
p.3 #13What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
jancohen wrote:
Lance B wrote
trenchmonkey wrote^ Anyone who buys a new body...as an investment, is a moron.
Couldn't agree more, Will.

The DSLR body of today is like the film back in the days of film SLR's - a disposable commodity.
+1

A bit of philosophical meandering if you will. I hope it fits in here as it is about my reflections on the current discussion:

Call me a really, really old fogie, but there was a time when life seemed much simpler with respect to photography (and a heck of a lot of other things). In a way, I do somewhat miss the days of yore when taking nice (or great) photos was more about the journey.

It's not so much the incredible advances in technology that have occurred these past decades, mind you--technology always seemed to play some sort of role,
...Show more →

Today, I'm not sure Adams and Capa would even be recognized. They lived in a time when the way photography (or image capture and distribution) was practiced required money and organizations, like Life magazine. Today anyone can capture an image, and post it on the web. Facebook has and will replace most magazines and newspapers. I would say that today, movies are the only image capture technology that requires an organization and capital to create and distribute. And that may not even be the case in a few years.

Oh, and still about the journey, and what you bring to it. Don't expect crowds to understand, though.
Jun 14, 2015 at 01:07 PM
jhinkey
Offline
Details
p.3 #14What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
Lance B wrote:
Like I said, miniscule perceived advantage. You "don't see much disadvantages selling your dslr kit and moving to something smaller except for focusing which their working on. The quality of lenses coming out for the sony system is amazing."

Except for the huge loss of money and ability, no not much loss at all. .

The specs do not make the D810 look outdated at all. There is nothing in the Sony that is an update to the D810 in any way shape or form.


Do you really mean that there is no feature of the A7RII that is better than the D810?
Jun 14, 2015 at 01:18 PM
Lance B
Offline
Details
p.3 #15What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
jhinkey wrote:
Lance B wroteLike I said, miniscule perceived advantage. You "don't see much disadvantages selling your dslr kit and moving to something smaller except for focusing which their working on. The quality of lenses coming out for the sony system is amazing."

Except for the huge loss of money and ability, no not much loss at all. .

The specs do not make the D810 look outdated at all. There is nothing in the Sony that is an update to the D810 in any way shape or form.
Do you really mean that there is no feature of the A7RII that is better than the D810?


None worth swapping out systems for.
Jun 14, 2015 at 05:16 PM
Alexluu627
Offline
Details
p.3 #16What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
it should be up to you if you think it's worth it. I think mirroless is the future and will see in the next couple of years how it progresses. Sony seems to be the only innovative camera company left.
Jun 14, 2015 at 05:23 PM
Hardcore
Offline
Details
p.3 #17What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
I have tossed around sony mirrorless for some time. The problem with the Full frame mirrorless lenses is that you don't save any weight on glass. My lenses weigh 90% of my kit, maybe more, so going mirrorless on my body isn't going to make much of a difference.

That said, I did take the plunge and buy a E-M5 Mark II. It is an amazing little camera. Smaller body and smaller lenses so it makes sense for me. Coupled with the fact that I can shoot handheld @ 1 seconds is an amazing feat allowing me to shoot in low light and get very similar image quality to my D800 save for the shallow depth of field.
Jun 14, 2015 at 06:05 PM
EB-1
Offline
Details
p.3 #18What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
Alexluu627 wrote:
...about 80% of the people who switched from canon and nikon did it because of the weight and size of it. Which is a clear advantage if you like traveling and go on long hikes. Also the idea that you can use all your film lenses and have ibis and focus peaking is just a plus to many awesome things it brings. I don't see much disadvantages selling your dslr kit and moving to something smaller except for focusing which their working on. The quality of lenses coming out for the sony system is amazing.


I only see a total of 10 Sony FE mount lenses at the BH. That's paltry number compared to the available Nikkors. Where are the prime teles, like the 200/2, 300/2.8. 200-400/4, 400/2.8, 500/4, 600/4, 800/5.6? How is an A7 series body going to save me any meaningful weight with an 80-400 and 500/4 in the bag? I went through 3 batteries per day just sotoing landscapes, and can imagine that would be 5 batteries per day doing any length of waiting on wildlife.

EBH

Jun 14, 2015 at 06:26 PM
mshi
Offline
[X]
Details
p.3 #19What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
Marcus Aurelius, a Roman emperor, used to say something like the problem of Rome is that intelligent people are full of doubts, while the stupid ones are full of confidence. I guess his observation still rings true today.
Jun 14, 2015 at 07:18 PM
jhinkey
Offline
Details
p.3 #20What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
Lance B wrote:
jhinkey wrote
Lance B wroteLike I said, miniscule perceived advantage. You "don't see much disadvantages selling your dslr kit and moving to something smaller except for focusing which their working on. The quality of lenses coming out for the sony system is amazing."

Except for the huge loss of money and ability, no not much loss at all. .

The specs do not make the D810 look outdated at all. There is nothing in the Sony that is an update to the D810 in any way shape or form.
Do you really mean that there is no feature of the A7RII that is better than the D810?
None worth swapping out systems for.


Well, that's a completely different statement than what you initially said.
There clearly are features on the upcoming A7RII that are superior to the D810, but those alone are worth it to some and not to others.
Jun 14, 2015 at 07:59 PM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister