chez wrote: johnctharp wrotePeter Le wroteYou know it has really become very amusing checking in here lately just to see the crazy stuff the Canon Fanboys come up with to tare down the A7r....We're not 'tare-ing' down anything; were calling it like it is. The A7R is an incredible imager, but it's far from 'perfect', and it's obvious that Sony didn't take the time to fully develop it or the lenses that they made available for the system. It's the odd man out; the A7 is the most balanced camera in the series, with usable AF, no issues with shutter shock, and more balanced with the lenses that Sony released.I guess the same can be said about the 5d3, being rushed out as it's ugly sister...much cheaper date too, the 6d beats the pants off the 5d3 with it's great sensor...right.
Peter Le wrote:
You know it has really become very amusing checking in here lately just to see the crazy stuff the Canon Fanboys come up with to tare down the A7r.... I shot Canon for over 40 years.....they make great stuff......but they are way behind now in high resolution cameras..... It's that simple......will they catch up.....most likely someday.....but not now.
I choose a camera by what works for me now....just a tool....people just have to get over it and not take it so personal.
By the way I have been using the A7r for over seven months now so I'm not going by what someone else says but by what I see. I still have not seen a image blurred from shutter bounce at the speeds you say or any for that matter. I use the grip so have two batteries and a spare in my pocket let's me shoot all day and very rarely have to use the one in my pocket......maybe because I don't spray and pray. Also I have used it many times in - 25 degrees below zero with no problem at all. I think these things are just internet hyperbole for people that can't sleep knowing that Canon didn't make it. I move along now....but I'll be back to see the flames for a chuckle. ...Show more →
johnctharp wrote: chez wrotejohnctharp wrotePeter Le wroteYou know it has really become very amusing checking in here lately just to see the crazy stuff the Canon Fanboys come up with to tare down the A7r....We're not 'tare-ing' down anything; were calling it like it is. The A7R is an incredible imager, but it's far from 'perfect', and it's obvious that Sony didn't take the time to fully develop it or the lenses that they made available for the system. It's the odd man out; the A7 is the most balanced camera in the series, with usable AF, no issues with shutter shock, and more balanced with the lenses that Sony released.I guess the same can be said about the 5d3, being rushed out as it's ugly sister...much cheaper date too, the 6d beats the pants off the 5d3 with it's great sensor...right. You lost me
Well you were claiming the A7R was rushed out because of some of it's short comings...I just pointed out the 5d3 has some short comings of it's own if you compare it to the 6d, namely the low iso dynamic range and the near dark focuing abilities which the 6d posseses. Every camera has it's weak points...you choose the right tools to get the job done. If the dynamic range and high mpix isn't something you need, then you'll probably pick and find short comings in the A7R...but if dynamic range and high mpix is top on your priority list, then you seem to work around any of these short comings...just like you need to work around short comings of any camera out there.
chez wrote:
Well you were claiming the A7R was rushed out because of some of it's short comings...I just pointed out the 5d3 has some short comings of it's own...
The 6D has newer technology, and is a newer camera; while I agree with what you're saying, the point I'm making is that many of the shortcomings in the A7R could have been avoided, and some were avoided in the A7. The shutter-shock issue is absolutely baffling, as is the choice to use lossy compression in their RAWs, for example.
johnctharp wrote: chez wroteWell you were claiming the A7R was rushed out because of some of it's short comings...I just pointed out the 5d3 has some short comings of it's own...The 6D has newer technology, and is a newer camera; while I agree with what you're saying, the point I'm making is that many of the shortcomings in the A7R could have been avoided, and some were avoided in the A7. The shutter-shock issue is absolutely baffling, as is the choice to use lossy compression in their RAWs, for example.
I hear a lot about this lossy compression issue, yet I have not seen a single example of it that would affect a large print. I feel the typical Internet hyperbole affect really takes over and makes huge mountains out of these issues. Sort of like the battery issue making it a no go for them...hugely overblown nitpicking.
chez wrote:
I hear a lot about this lossy compression issue, yet I have not seen a single example of it that would affect a large print. I feel the typical Internet hyperbole affect really takes over and makes huge mountains out of these issues. Sort of like the battery issue making it a no go for them...hugely overblown nitpicking.
I've seen the examples that show it, and while I agree that it's not going to make a huge difference, it's also quite silly that Sony chose in any way to compromise image quality on what was the premier 35mm imager upon release. And I mean, hell, the shutter shock issue caused problems that were seen by Photozone when they tested Sony's less than impressive 70-200/4 FE entry.
Peter Le wrote:
You know it has really become very amusing checking in here lately just to see the crazy stuff the Canon Fanboys come up with to tare down the A7r.... I shot Canon for over 40 years.....they make great stuff......but they are way behind now in high resolution cameras..... It's that simple......will they catch up.....most likely someday.....but not now.
I choose a camera by what works for me now....just a tool....people just have to get over it and not take it so personal.
By the way I have been using the A7r for over seven months now so I'm not going by what someone else says but by what I see. I still have not seen a image blurred from shutter bounce at the speeds you say or any for that matter. I use the grip so have two batteries and a spare in my pocket let's me shoot all day and very rarely have to use the one in my pocket......maybe because I don't spray and pray. Also I have used it many times in - 25 degrees below zero with no problem at all. I think these things are just internet hyperbole for people that can't sleep knowing that Canon didn't make it. I move along now....but I'll be back to see the flames for a chuckle. ...Show more →
Holy ellipsis! You realize that adding more dots does not add anything to your post and mostly exists to distract readers?
The A7 series has a number of critical and crucial flaws that make them a highly niche product that very much cannot compete with modern SLRs for a number of purposes. For instance, a 'long day' of shooting for me as an event photographer is 10-12 hours and somewhere between 1000-3000 photos. My 5D3 (if I don't use live view) and 1D3 can survive that on a single battery and are comfortable to hold due to their large ergonomic body designs. Further, having used an A7 at an event as a trial before returning it, I found that the shutter lag is heinously long compared to the even the slow-ish shutter on my 5D2 which caused me to miss some critical facial expressions in the photos I was taking. On top of all of that, the A7 series is pretty much incapable of continuous AF with a high shutter speed as those two things are mutually exclusive due to the mirrorless design, which makes them a huge PITA to use while tracking subjects and capturing photos during their motion. Finally, the button organization was piss poor for rapid use without having to adjust my hand during shooting - this is obviously subjective though.
I am not saying that the A7 series of cameras doesn't have a market somewhere. What I am saying is that there are more than a number of huge problems with the cameras that prevent them (like most Sony cameras) from having a mass market appeal that Canon, and less so Nikon, manage to achieve with their dSLRs. I think the IDEA behind the A7 is awesome, I just don't ever expect Sony to be able to execute it well and think that Nikon or Canon will do so long before Sony ever does. This seems to be reinforced by Sony's continuous struggle to maintain profitability in recent years in all aspects of their company.
chez wrote: Scott Stoness wrotePeter Le wroteYou know it has really become very amusing checking in here lately just to see the crazy stuff the Canon Fanboys come up with to tare down the A7r.... I shot Canon for over 40 years.....they make great stuff......but they are way behind now in high resolution cameras..... It's that simple......will they catch up.....most likely someday.....but not now.
I choose a camera by what works for me now....just a tool....people just have to get over it and not take it so personal.
By the way I have been using the A7r for over seven months now so I'm not going by what someone else says but by what I see. I still have not seen a image blurred from shutter bounce at the speeds you say or any for that matter. I use the grip so have two batteries and a spare in my pocket let's me shoot all day and very rarely have to use the one in my pocket......maybe because I don't spray and pray. Also I have used it many times in - 25 degrees below zero with no problem at all. I think these things are just internet hyperbole for people that can't sleep knowing that Canon didn't make it. I move along now....but I'll be back to see the flames for a chuckle. The difference between 36mpx and 22mpx is modest (22%). To get the 22% improvement you need to have good technique (remote shutter release, good tripod ball head, mirror lockup on canon...). If you shoot handheld you are wasting your time with 36mpx vs 22mpx. So, I am not surprised you have not seen the shutter noise trouble it takes demanding technique which most people don't do. But if you are buying a a7r for a 22% mpx improvement, its disappointing that sony screwed up the shutter. You can solve it by avoiding 1/15 to 1/150 but you should not have to.
Which fact are you challenging?Lots of talk...let's see some action. I've seen shots posted that were taken within your shutter ranges that were tack sharp at 100% viewing. Let's see you fuzzy images that you have taken using good techniques.
Also Scott, if you would take a look at Peter's website, I think you would agree that Peter knows how to take a good sharp image so I totally trust his opinions on such matters.
Chez - you take good pictures too but I don't trust biased anecdotal evidence which is what you and Peter are providing. In measured tests by Lloyd chambers, he has found that at about 1/100 shutter noise degrades the image substantially regardless of perfect setup to the extent that the 36mpx only achieves the equivalent of the 22mpx or so. The effect is different (less) in portrait mode. A 22mpx camera can make very sharp pictures too and that is what the a7r is delivering at 1/100 because of the shutter shock.
I don't need to do the tests because they are done already by Lloyd Chambers. You might say that in the real world this is not noticeable, but then you are saying don't bother with 36mpx because in the real world you won't notice the difference.
I am not saying the a7r is a dud, just that it has an issue from 1/15 to 1/150 that defeats the purpose of 36mpx.
what Canon lenses do you have? If you have one or two, I don't really see a point in getting an A7 over a Nikon body. Sure there are a few Canon lenses that are better than the nikon counter parts, but usually people get the Sony for the DR - and those people usually are landscape shooters. And if you are shooting landscapes, why not get a 14-24 - which you would be hard pressed to find a better landscape lens. You can adapt filters to it, if that tickles your fancy
Scott Stoness wrote:
I am not saying the a7r is a dud, just that it has an issue from 1/15 to 1/150 that defeats the purpose of 36mpx.
Let's start with the "worst case scenario": the shutter vibration is reported to be most noticeable at 1/100 of a second with a telephoto lens when the camera is mounted to a tripod. So let's go with the report that as a result of this worst case scenario effective resolution is reduced to 22mp.
1. In the worst case, the camera resolution is equivalent to 22mp. This means that in all other cases it will be better than 22mp.
2. The Sony sensor has other benefits over Canon sensors, namely dynamic range. So even in a worse case scenario where the Sony's effective resolution is reduced to the same resolution of a Canon sensor, it will still have better dynamic range.
3. Adding a battery grip to the camera will add mass and greatly mitigate the vibrations.
Sure, it would be nice if Sony would come up with a solution. But, to keep thing in perspective, the point of getting the camera is not "defeated" by the issue. In most circumstances the A7r will provide more resolution than a Canon body, in a narrow range of circumstances it will provide equivalent resolution, and in all circumstances it will provide more dynamic range.
Of course the Sony is not going to be the best choice for all shooting scenarios. And that's why I still own a Canon DSLR
Many of us would purchase an A7r if we thought it would serve our purpose & perform as one would wish it to. No matter what the best salesman in the world could say I would not buy one because of the many reported issues with the camera & the adapter. If I was told that if a fault was found I would receive a full refund & be able to keep the body I could be interested. My money, my choice, my loss.
I really don't know what people talking about. I have so many tack sharp A7R images with varieties of focal length (17-200mm) at the low speed (1/20-1/150) range and none of my lenses is OSS and I shoot handheld frequently. I am not a crazy one to dump some of my best canon ff dslr for the second A7R body if the issue was real. Imo, A7R is one of the best tools to get best IQ available to date
Tony B wrote:
Many of us would purchase an A7r if we thought it would serve our purpose & perform as one would wish it to. No matter what the best salesman in the world could say I would not buy one because of the many reported issues with the camera & the adapter. If I was told that if a fault was found I would receive a full refund & be able to keep the body I could be interested. My money, my choice, my loss.
I did just the opposite and bought the A7R and consider it the best digital camera I worked with so far (given that I am not a bird/event/sports/wedding shooter which I stated earlier). I am focusing on landscape, macro, fine art shooting, and in 99% of my photography I am fine or even better off with manual focus. That's why I use a bunch of MF lenses on the A7R - a huge advantage of the A7 series that you can adapt pretty much any lens on it (with a few exemptions in regard to rangefinder lenses). I am using currently five different adapters for Leica-M, Minolta MD, Canon FD, Canon EF, and M42 lenses and had zero(!) issues with any of my adapters. Reported issues with the camera - none. In my opinion all internet hyperbole (regarding vibration issues etc). Yes, it takes a bit longer to get accustomed to the menu functions, but after I had set up the camera in the way I preferred it, I got fully used to. I especially like that I can look through the EVF and can change all needed settings easily with my right hand without moving back and forward from wheel to button positions as on my 5D MkII. I used my A7R intensively for several months now, and it provided me with high resolution and DR photos which I couldn't have gotten with my 5D MkII - so simple is it.
mttran wrote:
I really don't know what people talking about. I have so many tack sharp A7R images with varieties of focal length (17-200mm) at the low speed (1/20-1/150) range and none of my lenses is OSS and I shoot handheld frequently. I am not a crazy one to dump some of my best canon ff dslr for the second A7R body if the issue was real. Imo, A7R is one of the best tools to get best IQ available to date
Your last pic is a poor image to gauge sharpness. Nothing looks 'tack sharp' to me and it would be hard to tell with the features in the scene even if displayed at 100%.
Why do people disagree so aggressively with legitimate reviewers who see the problem? What vested interest are people protecting....
jctriguy wrote: mttran wroteI really don't know what people talking about. I have so many tack sharp A7R images with varieties of focal length (17-200mm) at the low speed (1/20-1/150) range and none of my lenses is OSS and I shoot handheld frequently. I am not a crazy one to dump some of my best canon ff dslr for the second A7R body if the issue was real. Imo, A7R is one of the best tools to get best IQ available to date Your last pic is a poor image to gauge sharpness. Nothing looks 'tack sharp' to me and it would be hard to tell with the features in the scene even if displayed at 100%.
Why do people disagree so aggressively with legitimate reviewers who see the problem? What vested interest are people protecting....
I guess it's the same reason why so many people poopoo DXO results...many of the same people that accept other results as gospel. The only results I care about is the images I take with my gear.
Scott Stoness wrote:
The difference between 36mpx and 22mpx is modest (22%). To get the 22% improvement you need to have good technique (remote shutter release, good tripod ball head, mirror lockup on canon...). If you shoot handheld you are wasting your time with 36mpx vs 22mpx
Can you explain how shooting handheld with a 35mm lens and 1/1000s shutter speed requires the use of a tripod in order to realize the 63% advantage* in pixels and lack of AA filter, and thus why shooting handheld is a waste of time in all scenarios?
There's plenty of things I don't like about the A7R, the lossy compression, no EFC option, native lens lineup but to say you can't benefit from the resolution shooting handheld or that you need 20 batteries is F.U.D. I haven't been shooting with it long enough to form a really concrete opinion on these issues, but my guess is compression artifacts/camera shake are going to show up a lot less than shadow noise has in my 5D mkIII shots.
*Note that image "detail" is a 2D quantity, not a linear one, it's true the A7R has only 28% more pixels in each direction, but that is not telling the whole story.
chez wrote:
I guess it's the same reason why so many people poopoo DXO results...many of the same people that accept other results as gospel. The only results I care about is the images I take with my gear.
In the case of DXO I'd just like their overall scores to reflect the actual graphs underneath them. Especially for low light sports.
jctriguy wrote:
Why do people disagree so aggressively with legitimate reviewers who see the problem? What vested interest are people protecting....
Reviewers are trying to find issues, it's their job to cover all bases and create content for the review. What is very difficult for them to do however is gauge the relevance of these issues over time once one has become accustomed to shooting with a particular camera.
That's why opinions from people who have been using a camera for an extended period of time are valuable in addition to reading reviews.
Now in general I agree that people have a tendency to defend their chosen camera brand presumably because they don't want to admit to themselves or anyone else that their money could have been better spent elsewhere, and perhaps out of a general feeling of gratitude to the makers of a tool they enjoy using. Personally I don't care for brand loyalty whatsoever, I'm only interested in quality.
I really like the A7R and feel certain issues (batter life, shutter shock) are being overblown, but if Canon or anyone else make something that's better (for me) then off to eBay it will go.
ggreene wrote: chez wroteI guess it's the same reason why so many people poopoo DXO results...many of the same people that accept other results as gospel. The only results I care about is the images I take with my gear.In the case of DXO I'd just like their overall scores to reflect the actual graphs underneath them. Especially for low light sports.
Yes, that is the problem...but most people don't bother review the details and see for themselves. They just want a thumbs up or down. By and large, if you look at the details, they do mirror their ratings.
mttran wrote:
I really don't know what people talking about. I have so many tack sharp A7R images with varieties of focal length (17-200mm) at the low speed (1/20-1/150) range and none of my lenses is OSS and I shoot handheld frequently. I am not a crazy one to dump some of my best canon ff dslr for the second A7R body if the issue was real. Imo, A7R is one of the best tools to get best IQ available to date
I guess you prove my point with this shot and observations. If you are shooting handheld at 1/100, you are not achieving the benefit of 36mpx. Any of these pictures could have been taken and likely would look better on the 5diii because it focuses better and faster.
The reality is that the sony has a noisy (vibration prone) shutter. It causes degradation of the images in 1/15 to 1/150, regardless of the size of the lens ( although higher on longer and bigger) or the technique. However, at worst it just degrades the image to about the resolution of the 5diii. But if you were purely interested in the best sensor implementation you would buy the d810 that does not have this problem ( I would not because I prefer the ts17 and have too much money wrapped up in canon lens).
I have never said that that makes it a lousy camera. Its just a shame they screwed this up because 1/15 to 1/150 is a range that often gets used by landscape photographers. I will continue to use the a7r knowing its nuances.