fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2014 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2014Using Canon glass with Sony A7r

  
 
Scott Stoness
Offline
Details
p.4 #1Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
Matt Grum wrote:
Scott Stoness wroteThe difference between 36mpx and 22mpx is modest (22%). To get the 22% improvement you need to have good technique (remote shutter release, good tripod ball head, mirror lockup on canon...). If you shoot handheld you are wasting your time with 36mpx vs 22mpx
Can you explain how shooting handheld with a 35mm lens and 1/1000s shutter speed requires the use of a tripod in order to realize the 63% advantage* in pixels and lack of AA filter, and thus why shooting handheld is a waste of time in all scenarios?

There's plenty of things I don't like about the A7R, the lossy compression, no EFC option, native lens lineup but to say you can't benefit from the resolution shooting handheld or that you need 20 batteries is F.U.D. I haven't been shooting with it long enough to form a really concrete opinion on
...Show more →

Obviously shooting at 1/1000 is likely to take care of the vibration problem. However it will introduce focussing problems that are likely to be worse for moving subjects. If I am shooting handheld, I prefer that 5diii over the a7r.

Obviously not having a aa filter has a large gain on resolution with some moire risk.

The advantage is 22% when printed - that is the story.

I don't understand the passion in some a7r owners that will not let them acknowledge the issue. Its just a tool.
Aug 05, 2014 at 07:22 AM
Matt Grum
Offline
Details
p.4 #2Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
Scott Stoness wrote:
Any of these pictures could have been taken and likely would look better on the 5diii because it focuses better and faster.


Faster, certainly. Better? I don't think so (unless you're talking about tracking a moving object). In good conditions contrast detect and/or manual focus just nails it every time with every lens. Phase detection receives no feedback from the sensor and is prone to calibration faults and other weird problems (I recall one afternoon where my 5D mkIII and 135L decided to stop focusing accurately, good light, stationary subject with ample contrast but every image was unusably out of focus, can't say if it were camera or lens, but stuff like that doesn't seem to happen with contrast detect).

Scott Stoness wrote:
The reality is that the sony has a noisy (vibration prone) shutter. It causes degradation of the images in 1/15 to 1/150, regardless of the size of the lens ( although higher on longer and bigger) or the technique.


Does it? I certainly didn't notice it using the Canon 100L IS between 1/25 and 1/100s.

Regardless of the lens? People have reported problems with long lenses mounted on a tripod (so the camera can move about) only Lloyd Chambers seems to be able to invoke it with the FE 55mm, but you can't see the details of his report without paying him money (seems like a conflict of interest there).

I haven't seen evidence of shutter shock with wide angles, if you have please post it.

Scott Stoness wrote:
I don't understand the passion in some a7r owners that will not let them acknowledge the issue. Its just a tool.


Not being passionate, it just seems you are exaggerating the vibration issue, compared to my experience and others (who with the exception of Lloyd generally experience vibration with telephoto lenses).

Sony should address the issue in firmware if possible. But I didn't let it stop me buying the camera and I'm glad of that.



Aug 05, 2014 at 08:25 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.4 #3Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
Scott Stoness wrote:
The reality is that the sony has a noisy (vibration prone) shutter. It causes degradation of the images in 1/15 to 1/150, regardless of the size of the lens ( although higher on longer and bigger) or the technique. However, at worst it just degrades the image to about the resolution of the 5diii.


You repeatedly state this - and it is just wrong. No matter if I take photos on tripod or handheld with my A7R, and I often use exposure times between 1/60 -1/150 seconds, I see a better resolution in the photos compared to my 5D MkII. If you go longer than 1/30 seconds handheld of course, ANY camera will start to show blurriness due to you hand vibration - dude, it is user error!
Aug 05, 2014 at 08:27 AM
Matt Grum
Offline
Details
p.4 #4Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
Scott Stoness wrote:
The advantage is 22% when printed - that is the story.


I make it 28% linear advantage (image width of the A7R is 7360 pixels vs 5760 pixels for the 5DmkIII)

But images are 2 dimensional. If you can make out 28% more detail in the horizontal direction and 28% more detail in the vertical direction, then you can make out 64% more detail over the whole image!
Aug 05, 2014 at 08:29 AM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.4 #5Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
Matt Grum wrote:
But images are 2 dimensional. If you can make out 28% more detail in the horizontal direction and 28% more detail in the vertical direction, then you can make out 64% more detail over the whole image!


Perhaps, but Sony's 11-bit RAW files and lossy compression knock that advantage back down to about 28%
Aug 05, 2014 at 09:21 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.4 #6Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
molson wrote:
Matt Grum wroteBut images are 2 dimensional. If you can make out 28% more detail in the horizontal direction and 28% more detail in the vertical direction, then you can make out 64% more detail over the whole image!
Perhaps, but Sony's 11-bit RAW files and lossy compression knock that advantage back down to about 28%


?! Where do you actually see any loss of this compression? Total hyperbole.....
Aug 05, 2014 at 09:26 AM
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.4 #7Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
retrofocus wrote:
molson wrote
Matt Grum wroteBut images are 2 dimensional. If you can make out 28% more detail in the horizontal direction and 28% more detail in the vertical direction, then you can make out 64% more detail over the whole image!
Perhaps, but Sony's 11-bit RAW files and lossy compression knock that advantage back down to about 28%
?! Where do you actually see any loss of this compression? Total hyperbole.....


People are making legitimate statements based on their observations and use of the camera. It is perfectly reasonable to provide both positive and critical feedback on equipment, regardless of how much you find it helps YOUR images. Please stop trying to stifle others opinions with personal attacks.

Aug 05, 2014 at 09:42 AM
Scott Stoness
Offline
Details
p.4 #8Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
jctriguy wrote:
retrofocus wrote
molson wrote
Matt Grum wroteBut images are 2 dimensional. If you can make out 28% more detail in the horizontal direction and 28% more detail in the vertical direction, then you can make out 64% more detail over the whole image!
Perhaps, but Sony's 11-bit RAW files and lossy compression knock that advantage back down to about 28%
?! Where do you actually see any loss of this compression? Total hyperbole.....
People are making legitimate statements based on their observations and use of the camera. It is perfectly reasonable to provide both positive and critical feedback on equipment, regardless of how much you find it helps YOUR images. Please stop trying to stifle others opinions with personal attacks.



I agree - much of Retrofocus comments are generally unhelpful because he winds emotion into his response. The fact is in this example that Sony did a poor implementation of compression. Just waving your hands and saying - thats hyperbole is not constructive and misleading. Bring on the facts.

I am not sure that the effect of Sony compression is large and it would (did) not stop me from buying the camera, but it is an unecessary design flaw, that diminished performance. If you look at the performance of the d800e or d810 they outperform the a7r in Dxomark - this could be because of the compression. Eg. D800e achieved 33mpx effective vs A7r's 29 effective mpx with the same sensor and best available lens on both (Carl Zeiss Distagon T* Otus 1.4/55 ZF.2 on Nikon and Sony FE Carl Zeiss Sonnar T* 55mm F1.8 ZA on Sony). Still 20% better (again based on lxw than the 5diii) but it could have been better.

Again this is not likely to be an observable difference, however debating facts is better than debating hyperbole.



Aug 05, 2014 at 10:07 AM
artd
Offline
Details
p.4 #9Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
Scott Stoness wrote:
The fact is in this example that Sony did a poor implementation of compression. Just waving your hands and saying - thats hyperbole is not constructive and misleading. Bring on the facts.

I don't see either side presenting any facts on this point. Where is the evidence that the compression algorithims have "dimished performance"?

I am not saying it is not possible. But if it is, circumstances must be so exceedingly rare or the effect so tiny that I have not yet seen it after eight months of shooting and processing files with the camera.


I am not sure that the effect of Sony compression is large and it would (did) not stop me from buying the camera, but it is an unecessary design flaw, that diminished performance. If you look at the performance of the d800e or d810 they outperform the a7r in Dxomark - this could be because of the compression. Eg. D800e achieved 33mpx effective vs A7r's 29 effective mpx with the same sensor and best available lens on both (Carl Zeiss Distagon T* Otus 1.4/55 ZF.2 on Nikon and Sony FE Carl Zeiss Sonnar T* 55mm F1.8 ZA on Sony).

The more plausible explanation is that the Otus simply has more resolving power than Sony's FE lens.
Aug 05, 2014 at 10:22 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.4 #10Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
Scott Stoness wrote:
jctriguy wrote
retrofocus wrote
molson wrote
Matt Grum wroteBut images are 2 dimensional. If you can make out 28% more detail in the horizontal direction and 28% more detail in the vertical direction, then you can make out 64% more detail over the whole image!
Perhaps, but Sony's 11-bit RAW files and lossy compression knock that advantage back down to about 28%
?! Where do you actually see any loss of this compression? Total hyperbole.....
People are making legitimate statements based on their observations and use of the camera. It is perfectly reasonable to provide both positive and critical feedback on equipment, regardless of how much you find it helps YOUR images. Please stop trying to stifle others opinions with personal attacks.

I agree - much of Retrofocus comments are generally unhelpful because he winds emotion into his response. The fact is in this example that Sony did a poor implementation of compression. Just waving your hands and saying - thats hyperbole is not constructive and misleading. Bring on the facts.

I am not sure that the effect of Sony compression is large and it would (did) not stop me from buying the camera, but it is an unecessary design flaw, that diminished performance. If you look at the performance of the d800e or d810 they outperform the a7r in Dxomark -
...Show more →

So...let's look on your flow of argumentation in this thread. You started as always when it came down to talk about the A7 series complaining for example about battery life time, vibration issues. You were proven wrong here or shown that your points were totally exaggerated - hyperbole. Now you add simply the difference in the DxO Mark tests (which I don't doubt, I believe there is a small improvement in the D810 compared to the A7R) to draw the conclusion which you personally like that Canon is better than Sony - that's all what you are trying to do here, right? You are neither providing facts nor you provide personal images/results.

Aug 05, 2014 at 10:28 AM
mttran
Offline
Details
p.4 #11Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
I can count crazy number of canon fans in this thread but they can't tell lie on A7series images: https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1255248/0

Edited on Aug 05, 2014 at 10:42 AM · View previous versions
Aug 05, 2014 at 10:37 AM
chez
Offline
Details
p.4 #12Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
mttran wrote:
I can count crazy number of canon fans in this thread


Is that just your opinion or is that a fact?
Aug 05, 2014 at 10:42 AM
mttran
Offline
Details
p.4 #13Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
Peter Le wrote:
You know it has really become very amusing checking in here lately just to see the crazy stuff the Canon Fanboys come up with to tare down the A7r.... I shot Canon for over 40 years.....they make great stuff......but they are way behind now in high resolution cameras..... It's that simple......will they catch up.....most likely someday.....but not now.
I choose a camera by what works for me now....just a tool....people just have to get over it and not take it so personal.
By the way I have been using the A7r for over
...Show more →

I am a long time canon fans myself but canon IQ has sucked big time last half decade so I shoot with both A7r and canon lenses for now to wait for them to makeup in the mean time. Imo, A7 series IQ per Dollar is the best value factor to date
Aug 05, 2014 at 10:48 AM
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.4 #14Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
mttran wrote:
Peter Le wroteYou know it has really become very amusing checking in here lately just to see the crazy stuff the Canon Fanboys come up with to tare down the A7r.... I shot Canon for over 40 years.....they make great stuff......but they are way behind now in high resolution cameras..... It's that simple......will they catch up.....most likely someday.....but not now.
I choose a camera by what works for me now....just a tool....people just have to get over it and not take it so personal.
By the way I have been using the A7r for over seven months now so I'm not going by what someone else says but by what I see. I still have not seen a image blurred from shutter bounce at the speeds you say or any for that matter. I use the grip so have two batteries and a spare in my pocket let's me shoot all day and very rarely have to use the one in my pocket......maybe because I don't spray and pray. Also I have used it many times in - 25 degrees below zero with no problem at all. I think these things are just internet hyperbole for people that can't sleep knowing that Canon didn't make it. I move along now....but I'll be back to see the flames for a chuckle.
I am a long time canon fans myself but canon IQ has sucked big time last half decade so I shoot with both A7r and canon lenses for now to wait for them to makeup in the mean time. Imo, A7 series IQ per Dollar is the best value factor to date


Hyperbole?
Aug 05, 2014 at 11:34 AM
dhphoto
Offline
Details
p.4 #15Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
jctriguy wrote:
mttran wrote
Peter Le wroteYou know it has really become very amusing checking in here lately just to see the crazy stuff the Canon Fanboys come up with to tare down the A7r.... I shot Canon for over 40 years.....they make great stuff......but they are way behind now in high resolution cameras..... It's that simple......will they catch up.....most likely someday.....but not now.
I choose a camera by what works for me now....just a tool....people just have to get over it and not take it so personal.
By the way I have been using the A7r for over seven months now so I'm not going by what someone else says but by what I see. I still have not seen a image blurred from shutter bounce at the speeds you say or any for that matter. I use the grip so have two batteries and a spare in my pocket let's me shoot all day and very rarely have to use the one in my pocket......maybe because I don't spray and pray. Also I have used it many times in - 25 degrees below zero with no problem at all. I think these things are just internet hyperbole for people that can't sleep knowing that Canon didn't make it. I move along now....but I'll be back to see the flames for a chuckle.
I am a long time canon fans myself but canon IQ has sucked big time last half decade so I shoot with both A7r and canon lenses for now to wait for them to makeup in the mean time. Imo, A7 series IQ per Dollar is the best value factor to date
Hyperbole?


Indeed, but that's the internet for you.

It of course excludes the thousands of good quality photographers using Canon (and Nikon, Sony, Pentax etc) gear to make their living every day with no issues, they are always conveniently forgotten because they choose not to use forums to complain about percieved problems when the issues are generally their own fault anyway.
Aug 05, 2014 at 11:37 AM
mttran
Offline
Details
p.4 #16Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
jctriguy wrote:
mttran wrote
Peter Le wroteYou know it has really become very amusing checking in here lately just to see the crazy stuff the Canon Fanboys come up with to tare down the A7r.... I shot Canon for over 40 years.....they make great stuff......but they are way behind now in high resolution cameras..... It's that simple......will they catch up.....most likely someday.....but not now.
I choose a camera by what works for me now....just a tool....people just have to get over it and not take it so personal.
By the way I have been using the A7r for over seven months now so I'm not going by what someone else says but by what I see. I still have not seen a image blurred from shutter bounce at the speeds you say or any for that matter. I use the grip so have two batteries and a spare in my pocket let's me shoot all day and very rarely have to use the one in my pocket......maybe because I don't spray and pray. Also I have used it many times in - 25 degrees below zero with no problem at all. I think these things are just internet hyperbole for people that can't sleep knowing that Canon didn't make it. I move along now....but I'll be back to see the flames for a chuckle.
I am a long time canon fans myself but canon IQ has sucked big time last half decade so I shoot with both A7r and canon lenses for now to wait for them to makeup in the mean time. Imo, A7 series IQ per Dollar is the best value factor to date
Hyperbole?


Not at all, let your eyes do the walk for you, they don't tell lie: https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1255248/0
Aug 05, 2014 at 11:40 AM
ggreene
Offline
Details
p.4 #17Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
mttran wrote:
I am a long time canon fans myself but canon IQ has sucked big time last half decade so I shoot with both A7r and canon lenses for now to wait for them to makeup in the mean time. Imo, A7 series IQ per Dollar is the best value factor to date


And here I was thinking my 1DX was providing me pretty awesome high ISO images when in fact they suck big time. Media relations is not going to be happy that I have provided them with such lousy photos.
Aug 05, 2014 at 11:42 AM
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.4 #18Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
mttran wrote:
...but canon IQ has sucked big time last half decade...


This is the hyperbole that I was referring to. Lots of hypocrites on this thread...
Aug 05, 2014 at 11:53 AM
chez
Offline
Details
p.4 #19Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
dhphoto wrote:
jctriguy wrote
mttran wrote
Peter Le wroteYou know it has really become very amusing checking in here lately just to see the crazy stuff the Canon Fanboys come up with to tare down the A7r.... I shot Canon for over 40 years.....they make great stuff......but they are way behind now in high resolution cameras..... It's that simple......will they catch up.....most likely someday.....but not now.
I choose a camera by what works for me now....just a tool....people just have to get over it and not take it so personal.
By the way I have been using the A7r for over seven months now so I'm not going by what someone else says but by what I see. I still have not seen a image blurred from shutter bounce at the speeds you say or any for that matter. I use the grip so have two batteries and a spare in my pocket let's me shoot all day and very rarely have to use the one in my pocket......maybe because I don't spray and pray. Also I have used it many times in - 25 degrees below zero with no problem at all. I think these things are just internet hyperbole for people that can't sleep knowing that Canon didn't make it. I move along now....but I'll be back to see the flames for a chuckle.
I am a long time canon fans myself but canon IQ has sucked big time last half decade so I shoot with both A7r and canon lenses for now to wait for them to makeup in the mean time. Imo, A7 series IQ per Dollar is the best value factor to date
Hyperbole?
Indeed, but that's the internet for you.

It of course excludes the thousands of good quality photographers using Canon (and Nikon, Sony, Pentax etc) gear to make their living every day with no issues, they are always conveniently forgotten because they choose not to use forums to complain about percieved problems when the issues are generally their own fault anyway.


Obviously you are not one of the thousands as all you are doing is complaining about the complainers in a thread about a camera you have no interest. Something wrong here.
Aug 05, 2014 at 12:08 PM
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.4 #20Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
mttran wrote:
jctriguy wrote
mttran wrote
Peter Le wroteYou know it has really become very amusing checking in here lately just to see the crazy stuff the Canon Fanboys come up with to tare down the A7r.... I shot Canon for over 40 years.....they make great stuff......but they are way behind now in high resolution cameras..... It's that simple......will they catch up.....most likely someday.....but not now.
I choose a camera by what works for me now....just a tool....people just have to get over it and not take it so personal.
By the way I have been using the A7r for over seven months now so I'm not going by what someone else says but by what I see. I still have not seen a image blurred from shutter bounce at the speeds you say or any for that matter. I use the grip so have two batteries and a spare in my pocket let's me shoot all day and very rarely have to use the one in my pocket......maybe because I don't spray and pray. Also I have used it many times in - 25 degrees below zero with no problem at all. I think these things are just internet hyperbole for people that can't sleep knowing that Canon didn't make it. I move along now....but I'll be back to see the flames for a chuckle.
I am a long time canon fans myself but canon IQ has sucked big time last half decade so I shoot with both A7r and canon lenses for now to wait for them to makeup in the mean time. Imo, A7 series IQ per Dollar is the best value factor to date
Hyperbole?
Not at all, let your eyes do the walk for you, they don't tell lie: https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1255248/0


Eyes don't lie but they are interpreted by a brain that is different in each one of us. Countless people are happy with the output of numerous brands of cameras. I haven't seen anything that wow's me on the a7 image threads any more than all the other image threads in this forum or any other image sharing venue.

If I was to take the same claim as another poster on this thread, I would say that shadow banding and DR aren't issues with Canon since I've never seen them and it doesn't affect my images. Therefore anyone saying that banding/DR are issues is incorrect. I'm sure you can see the fault in that logic...
Aug 05, 2014 at 12:10 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister