jctriguy wrote:
Eyes don't lie but they are interpreted by a brain that is different in each one of us. Countless people are happy with the output of numerous brands of cameras. I haven't seen anything that wow's me on the a7 image threads any more than all the other image threads in this forum or any other image sharing venue.
If I was to take the same claim as another poster on this thread, I would say that shadow banding and DR aren't issues with Canon since I've never seen them and it doesn't affect my images. Therefore anyone saying that banding/DR are issues is incorrect. I'm sure you can see the fault in that logic......Show more →
a) You don't have a FF digital camera to compare with
b) You never used an A7 series camera
c) You never posted any photo which you took either digital or film
So what are you doing here other than trying to disturb this thread?
retrofocus wrote: jctriguy wroteEyes don't lie but they are interpreted by a brain that is different in each one of us. Countless people are happy with the output of numerous brands of cameras. I haven't seen anything that wow's me on the a7 image threads any more than all the other image threads in this forum or any other image sharing venue.
If I was to take the same claim as another poster on this thread, I would say that shadow banding and DR aren't issues with Canon since I've never seen them and it doesn't affect my images. Therefore anyone saying that banding/DR are issues is incorrect. I'm sure you can see the fault in that logic...a) You don't have a FF digital camera to compare with
b) You never used an A7 series camera
c) You never posted any photo which you took either digital or film
So what are you doing here other than trying to disturb this thread?
I'm posting because you are a disruptive hypocrite...
And, that's not a personal attack but my personal opinion of your interactions on this forum.
jctriguy wrote: retrofocus wrotejctriguy wroteEyes don't lie but they are interpreted by a brain that is different in each one of us. Countless people are happy with the output of numerous brands of cameras. I haven't seen anything that wow's me on the a7 image threads any more than all the other image threads in this forum or any other image sharing venue.
If I was to take the same claim as another poster on this thread, I would say that shadow banding and DR aren't issues with Canon since I've never seen them and it doesn't affect my images. Therefore anyone saying that banding/DR are issues is incorrect. I'm sure you can see the fault in that logic...a) You don't have a FF digital camera to compare with
b) You never used an A7 series camera
c) You never posted any photo which you took either digital or film
So what are you doing here other than trying to disturb this thread?I'm posting because you are a disruptive hypocrite...
And, that's not a personal attack but my personal opinion of your interactions on this forum.
Still doesn't answer my question. Which value do you add here into this discussion other than insulting people? You don't do Canon any favor with your attitude.
jctriguy wrote: retrofocus wrotejctriguy wroteEyes don't lie but they are interpreted by a brain that is different in each one of us. Countless people are happy with the output of numerous brands of cameras. I haven't seen anything that wow's me on the a7 image threads any more than all the other image threads in this forum or any other image sharing venue.
If I was to take the same claim as another poster on this thread, I would say that shadow banding and DR aren't issues with Canon since I've never seen them and it doesn't affect my images. Therefore anyone saying that banding/DR are issues is incorrect. I'm sure you can see the fault in that logic...a) You don't have a FF digital camera to compare with
b) You never used an A7 series camera
c) You never posted any photo which you took either digital or film
So what are you doing here other than trying to disturb this thread?I'm posting because you are a disruptive hypocrite...
And, that's not a personal attack but my personal opinion of your interactions on this forum.
Totally uncalled for and is not putting this thread back on track.
retrofocus wrote: jctriguy wroteretrofocus wrotejctriguy wroteEyes don't lie but they are interpreted by a brain that is different in each one of us. Countless people are happy with the output of numerous brands of cameras. I haven't seen anything that wow's me on the a7 image threads any more than all the other image threads in this forum or any other image sharing venue.
If I was to take the same claim as another poster on this thread, I would say that shadow banding and DR aren't issues with Canon since I've never seen them and it doesn't affect my images. Therefore anyone saying that banding/DR are issues is incorrect. I'm sure you can see the fault in that logic...a) You don't have a FF digital camera to compare with
b) You never used an A7 series camera
c) You never posted any photo which you took either digital or film
So what are you doing here other than trying to disturb this thread?I'm posting because you are a disruptive hypocrite...
And, that's not a personal attack but my personal opinion of your interactions on this forum.Still doesn't answer my question. Which value do you add here into this discussion other than insulting people? You don't do Canon any favor with your attitude.
Your three points were totally irrelevant, so I ignored your question.
I hope you see the hypocrisy in your posting over the years. You are happy with the A7r, so any comments about it are hyperbole if you don't think they reflect well on the camera. You only see the positives and ignore the negatives. For years you've had an agenda against the canon sensors, anyone that was happy with canon was a fanboy. You are now the most aggressive advocate for the a7 series. You mostly just attack people without even reading their comments. You go after Scott with totally unfounded claims about him, even though he is a much more respected member of the community here. You also ignore the fact that he continues to shot with an a7r, but he can appreciate the good and bad of the camera.
jctriguy wrote:
Your three points were totally irrelevant, so I ignored your question.
I hope you see the hypocrisy in your posting over the years. You are happy with the A7r, so any comments about it are hyperbole if you don't think they reflect well on the camera. You only see the positives and ignore the negatives. For years you've had an agenda against the canon sensors, anyone that was happy with canon was a fanboy. You are now the most aggressive advocate for the a7 series. You mostly just attack people without even reading their comments. You go after Scott with totally unfounded claims about him, even though he is a much more respected member of the community here. You also ignore the fact that he continues to shot with an a7r, but he can appreciate the good and bad of the camera....Show more →
Very relevant points a) to c) which you continuously refuse to answer or acknowledge. But okay, to your points: I even wrote a review of the A7R here in the Canon forum describing my positive and negative findings at the time with the camera. I always said that this camera is not for everyone. What I am arguing against are some copied&pasted wrongly stated (including obvious user error) or highly exaggerated arguments posted by another person here who has his own agenda in this regard. Talk about yourself and not about others - because you have nothing to show so far, sorry.
mttran wrote:
I am a long time canon fans myself but canon IQ has sucked big time last half decade so I shoot with both A7r and canon lenses for now to wait for them to makeup in the mean time. Imo, A7 series IQ per Dollar is the best value factor to date
mttran, I love the IQ of the A7r as much as anyone, and I also agree that the IQ is unmatched for the price. But jctriguy is right, saying Canon IQ "has sucked big time" is as much of an exaggeration as any that has been leveled against the A7r.
There's nothing wrong with a good debate about the pros and cons of various cameras. It's good to cite the issues and limitations of each so that people are aware of them, and it's good for folks to chime in with their own views as to the extent of real world impacts of those issues. It's all about keeping things in perspective.
jctriguy wrote:
People are making legitimate statements based on their observations and use of the camera. It is perfectly reasonable to provide both positive and critical feedback on equipment, regardless of how much you find it helps YOUR images. Please stop trying to stifle others opinions with personal attacks.
Everyone is of course entitled to their opinion, but what Molson wrote is not a "legitimate statement":
molson wrote:
Perhaps, but Sony's 11-bit RAW files and lossy compression knock that advantage back down to about 28%
It doesn't make any sense (there is no spatial compression going on so how could it reduce detail by such a huge amount) and is not supported by any evidence, so I don't see any merit in it. Let's stick to the facts.
artd wrote: mttran wroteI am a long time canon fans myself but canon IQ has sucked big time last half decade so I shoot with both A7r and canon lenses for now to wait for them to makeup in the mean time. Imo, A7 series IQ per Dollar is the best value factor to date mttran, I love the IQ of the A7r as much as anyone, and I also agree that the IQ is unmatched for the price. But jctriguy is right, saying Canon IQ "has sucked big time" is as much of an exaggeration as any that has been leveled against the A7r.
There's nothing wrong with a good debate about the pros and cons of various cameras. It's good to cite the issues and limitations of each so that people are aware of them, and it's good for folks to chime in with their own views as to the extent of real world impacts of those issues. It's all about keeping things in perspective.
You are right, "has sucked big time" maybe not the right word...what do you call when newer version IQ is the same/lesser from the last of the last of the last. Beside the DR, color and shadows noise were my frustration waiting for a better one since 1Ds2/5D.
Scott Stoness wrote:
I agree - much of Retrofocus comments are generally unhelpful because he winds emotion into his response. The fact is in this example that Sony did a poor implementation of compression. Just waving your hands and saying - thats hyperbole is not constructive and misleading. Bring on the facts.
Ok, here are the facts. Nikon (and most others) use 14 bits to record where a pixel lies on the scale between complete darkness and overexposure. Sony use 7 bits to record where a pixel lies on the scale between the darkest pixel in the local 16 pixel neighborhood and the brightest pixel in the local 16 pixel neighborhood.
For areas where a high bit depth (lots of tones close together) is needed to prevent posterisation (banding) this works fine as the darkest and brightest values will be very close together and 7 bits (128 levels) is more than enough to store the in-between values, which wont vary much over 16 pixels.
For areas of high contrast, the levels will be coarser (spaced further apart), but your eyes wont be able to detect the posterisation due to the amount of contrast.
The only place this scheme falls down is where you have an area of fine shadow detail (low contrast) that happens to just clip a much brighter region. When this happens the brightest and darkest pixels will be far apart and 7 bits wont be enough to record the remaining pixels accurately.
This will only be noticeable if you do an extreme shadow lift, I'm not sure anyone would be able to tell the difference in a blind test with a "standard" image (when I have some time I'll do such a test, it would be easy to apply Sony's compression to a D800 image).
The fact that doing extreme shadow lists is one of the main reasons for buying the camera for Canon users makes the mandatory use of compression very disappointing, but to go as far as to suggest it is responsible for a lack of detail is plain wrong.
Scott Stoness wrote:
If you look at the performance of the d800e or d810 they outperform the a7r in Dxomark - this could be because of the compression. Eg. D800e achieved 33mpx effective vs A7r's 29 effective mpx with the same sensor and best available lens on both (Carl Zeiss Distagon T* Otus 1.4/55 ZF.2 on Nikon and Sony FE Carl Zeiss Sonnar T* 55mm F1.8 ZA on Sony)
Using what is essentially the same sensor, the D800e scores slightly higher in detail than the A7R but using different lenses. Don't you think it's possible, nay, probable that the $4000 Zeiss Otus 55mm, regarded as the finest lens normal ever produced for the 135 format could be slightly sharper than a lens a quarter of the price?
To suggest the difference is down how the cameras process data is, in my opinion, ignoring the facts!
Scott Stoness wrote: mttran wroteI really don't know what people talking about. I have so many tack sharp A7R images with varieties of focal length (17-200mm) at the low speed (1/20-1/150) range and none of my lenses is OSS and I shoot handheld frequently. I am not a crazy one to dump some of my best canon ff dslr for the second A7R body if the issue was real. Imo, A7R is one of the best tools to get best IQ available to date
The reality is that the sony has a noisy (vibration prone) shutter. It causes degradation of the images in 1/15 to 1/150, regardless of the size of the lens ( although higher on longer and bigger) or the technique. However, at worst it just degrades the image to about the resolution of the 5diii. But if you were purely interested in the best sensor implementation you would buy the d810 that does not have this problem ( I would not because I prefer the ts17 and have too much money wrapped up in canon lens).
I have never said that that makes it a lousy camera. Its just a shame they screwed this up because 1/15 to 1/150 is a range that often gets used by landscape photographers. I will continue to use the a7r knowing its nuances.
Scott, smallest 6mp jpg SOCC setting was previously used to quickly illustrate the handheld sharpness at lower speed range, hence the degradation in IQ when uploaded them to flickr. I did a full IQ comparison between my 1Ds2/5D2/A7R with all canon lenses before getting the second A7R. I don't experience any hand hold big loss from 36mp like the way you have mentioned. There is no reason to invest two A7R bodies if there was no improvement in IQ for my case. The canon to sony bodies transition is an eyes-wide-open experienced for me, it is better than great to retire both 1ds2 and 5d2 in couple weeks later. I am currently shooting one with canon lenses and other with FE lenses, and I am very happy with their ouputs.
jctriguy wrote: mttran wrotejctriguy wrotemttran wrotePeter Le wroteYou know it has really become very amusing checking in here lately just to see the crazy stuff the Canon Fanboys come up with to tare down the A7r.... I shot Canon for over 40 years.....they make great stuff......but they are way behind now in high resolution cameras..... It's that simple......will they catch up.....most likely someday.....but not now.
I choose a camera by what works for me now....just a tool....people just have to get over it and not take it so personal.
By the way I have been using the A7r for over seven months now so I'm not going by what someone else says but by what I see. I still have not seen a image blurred from shutter bounce at the speeds you say or any for that matter. I use the grip so have two batteries and a spare in my pocket let's me shoot all day and very rarely have to use the one in my pocket......maybe because I don't spray and pray. Also I have used it many times in - 25 degrees below zero with no problem at all. I think these things are just internet hyperbole for people that can't sleep knowing that Canon didn't make it. I move along now....but I'll be back to see the flames for a chuckle. I am a long time canon fans myself but canon IQ has sucked big time last half decade so I shoot with both A7r and canon lenses for now to wait for them to makeup in the mean time. Imo, A7 series IQ per Dollar is the best value factor to date Hyperbole?Not at all, let your eyes do the walk for you, they don't tell lie: https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1255248/0Eyes don't lie but they are interpreted by a brain that is different in each one of us. Countless people are happy with the output of numerous brands of cameras. I haven't seen anything that wow's me on the a7 image threads any more than all the other image threads in this forum or any other image sharing venue.
If I was to take the same claim as another poster on this thread, I would say that shadow banding and DR aren't issues with Canon since I've never seen them and it doesn't affect my images. Therefore anyone saying that banding/DR are issues is incorrect. I'm sure you can see the fault in that logic......Show more →
life is full of experiences, how do you know the differences if you don't try one
mttran wrote: jctriguy wrotemttran wrotejctriguy wrotemttran wrotePeter Le wroteYou know it has really become very amusing checking in here lately just to see the crazy stuff the Canon Fanboys come up with to tare down the A7r.... I shot Canon for over 40 years.....they make great stuff......but they are way behind now in high resolution cameras..... It's that simple......will they catch up.....most likely someday.....but not now.
I choose a camera by what works for me now....just a tool....people just have to get over it and not take it so personal.
By the way I have been using the A7r for over seven months now so I'm not going by what someone else says but by what I see. I still have not seen a image blurred from shutter bounce at the speeds you say or any for that matter. I use the grip so have two batteries and a spare in my pocket let's me shoot all day and very rarely have to use the one in my pocket......maybe because I don't spray and pray. Also I have used it many times in - 25 degrees below zero with no problem at all. I think these things are just internet hyperbole for people that can't sleep knowing that Canon didn't make it. I move along now....but I'll be back to see the flames for a chuckle. I am a long time canon fans myself but canon IQ has sucked big time last half decade so I shoot with both A7r and canon lenses for now to wait for them to makeup in the mean time. Imo, A7 series IQ per Dollar is the best value factor to date Hyperbole?Not at all, let your eyes do the walk for you, they don't tell lie: https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1255248/0Eyes don't lie but they are interpreted by a brain that is different in each one of us. Countless people are happy with the output of numerous brands of cameras. I haven't seen anything that wow's me on the a7 image threads any more than all the other image threads in this forum or any other image sharing venue.
If I was to take the same claim as another poster on this thread, I would say that shadow banding and DR aren't issues with Canon since I've never seen them and it doesn't affect my images. Therefore anyone saying that banding/DR are issues is incorrect. I'm sure you can see the fault in that logic...life is full of experiences, how do you know the differences if you don't try one
I thought people were letting this thread die...
Beauty of the modern world is that you don't need to try everything in order to form an opinion or make a decision. I'm quite happy with my ancient cropper and the occasional mamiya lens. I didn't find anything magical about the 5d when I used it and have no rush to get a FF body.
jctriguy wrote: mttran wrotejctriguy wrotemttran wrotejctriguy wrotemttran wroteI am a long time canon fans myself but canon IQ has sucked big time last half decade so I shoot with both A7r and canon lenses for now to wait for them to makeup in the mean time. Imo, A7 series IQ per Dollar is the best value factor to date Hyperbole?Not at all, let your eyes do the walk for you, they don't tell lie: https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1255248/0Eyes don't lie but they are interpreted by a brain that is different in each one of us. Countless people are happy with the output of numerous brands of cameras. I haven't seen anything that wow's me on the a7 image threads any more than all the other image threads in this forum or any other image sharing venue.
If I was to take the same claim as another poster on this thread, I would say that shadow banding and DR aren't issues with Canon since I've never seen them and it doesn't affect my images. Therefore anyone saying that banding/DR are issues is incorrect. I'm sure you can see the fault in that logic...life is full of experiences, how do you know the differences if you don't try one I thought people were letting this thread die...
Beauty of the modern world is that you don't need to try everything in order to form an opinion or make a decision. I'm quite happy with my ancient cropper and the occasional mamiya lens. I didn't find anything magical about the 5d when I used it and have no rush to get a FF body.
Maybe you have a special talent, my brain can't tell a darn thing if I don't have a base line to compare with. Maybe I am getting too old for this talent
mttran wrote: jctriguy wrotemttran wrotejctriguy wrotemttran wrotejctriguy wroteHyperbole?Not at all, let your eyes do the walk for you, they don't tell lie: https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1255248/0Eyes don't lie but they are interpreted by a brain that is different in each one of us. Countless people are happy with the output of numerous brands of cameras. I haven't seen anything that wow's me on the a7 image threads any more than all the other image threads in this forum or any other image sharing venue.
If I was to take the same claim as another poster on this thread, I would say that shadow banding and DR aren't issues with Canon since I've never seen them and it doesn't affect my images. Therefore anyone saying that banding/DR are issues is incorrect. I'm sure you can see the fault in that logic...life is full of experiences, how do you know the differences if you don't try one I thought people were letting this thread die...
Beauty of the modern world is that you don't need to try everything in order to form an opinion or make a decision. I'm quite happy with my ancient cropper and the occasional mamiya lens. I didn't find anything magical about the 5d when I used it and have no rush to get a FF body.Maybe you have a special talent, my brain can't tell a darn thing if I don't have a base line to compare with. Maybe I am getting too old for this talent
Exactly the reason why looking at a thread of random images from random people is mostly pointless. With no comparisons, that a7 thread could be relabelled as a canon or Nikon or Pentax thread and virtually no one could tell the difference. The quality of images is directly related to the people taking the images not the gear used.
retrofocus wrote: jctriguy wroteretrofocus wrotejctriguy wroteEyes don't lie but they are interpreted by a brain that is different in each one of us. Countless people are happy with the output of numerous brands of cameras. I haven't seen anything that wow's me on the a7 image threads any more than all the other image threads in this forum or any other image sharing venue.
If I was to take the same claim as another poster on this thread, I would say that shadow banding and DR aren't issues with Canon since I've never seen them and it doesn't affect my images. Therefore anyone saying that banding/DR are issues is incorrect. I'm sure you can see the fault in that logic...a) You don't have a FF digital camera to compare with
b) You never used an A7 series camera
c) You never posted any photo which you took either digital or film
So what are you doing here other than trying to disturb this thread?I'm posting because you are a disruptive hypocrite...
And, that's not a personal attack but my personal opinion of your interactions on this forum.You don't do Canon any favor with your attitude.
Who is trying to do canon any favours? Are you trying to do sony a favour?
jctriguy wrote: mttran wrotejctriguy wrotemttran wrotejctriguy wrotemttran wroteNot at all, let your eyes do the walk for you, they don't tell lie: https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1255248/0Eyes don't lie but they are interpreted by a brain that is different in each one of us. Countless people are happy with the output of numerous brands of cameras. I haven't seen anything that wow's me on the a7 image threads any more than all the other image threads in this forum or any other image sharing venue.
If I was to take the same claim as another poster on this thread, I would say that shadow banding and DR aren't issues with Canon since I've never seen them and it doesn't affect my images. Therefore anyone saying that banding/DR are issues is incorrect. I'm sure you can see the fault in that logic...life is full of experiences, how do you know the differences if you don't try one I thought people were letting this thread die...
Beauty of the modern world is that you don't need to try everything in order to form an opinion or make a decision. I'm quite happy with my ancient cropper and the occasional mamiya lens. I didn't find anything magical about the 5d when I used it and have no rush to get a FF body.Maybe you have a special talent, my brain can't tell a darn thing if I don't have a base line to compare with. Maybe I am getting too old for this talent Exactly the reason why looking at a thread of random images from random people is mostly pointless. With no comparisons, that a7 thread could be relabelled as a canon or Nikon or Pentax thread and virtually no one could tell the difference. The quality of images is directly related to the people taking the images not the gear used.
You mis-read my post. I don't trust my brain so I did compare everything before any of my justification.
jctriguy wrote:
The quality of images is directly related to the people taking the images not the gear used.
It is also directly related to the gear used, there's no escaping that.
For example, my favorite all time photo of mine is one I shot with an old film disc camera. I did my part as the photographer but the gear definitely added it's own flavoring in that the shape and size of the negative and the granularity of the film all contributed to how I viewed and composed the shot and the ultimate outcome.
mttran wrote: jctriguy wrotemttran wrotejctriguy wrotemttran wrotejctriguy wroteEyes don't lie but they are interpreted by a brain that is different in each one of us. Countless people are happy with the output of numerous brands of cameras. I haven't seen anything that wow's me on the a7 image threads any more than all the other image threads in this forum or any other image sharing venue.
If I was to take the same claim as another poster on this thread, I would say that shadow banding and DR aren't issues with Canon since I've never seen them and it doesn't affect my images. Therefore anyone saying that banding/DR are issues is incorrect. I'm sure you can see the fault in that logic...life is full of experiences, how do you know the differences if you don't try one I thought people were letting this thread die...
Beauty of the modern world is that you don't need to try everything in order to form an opinion or make a decision. I'm quite happy with my ancient cropper and the occasional mamiya lens. I didn't find anything magical about the 5d when I used it and have no rush to get a FF body.Maybe you have a special talent, my brain can't tell a darn thing if I don't have a base line to compare with. Maybe I am getting too old for this talent Exactly the reason why looking at a thread of random images from random people is mostly pointless. With no comparisons, that a7 thread could be relabelled as a canon or Nikon or Pentax thread and virtually no one could tell the difference. The quality of images is directly related to the people taking the images not the gear used.You mis-read my post. I don't trust my brain so I did compare everything before any of my justification.
So why post standalone images that you apparently take at 6mp (think that's what you stated above)?? Why constantly direct people to a thread with standalone images? Sure, they are nice images, but they don't really say anything about the camera unless you have a very specific type of scene you want to review.
Scott Stoness wrote: jctriguy wroteretrofocus wrotemolson wroteMatt Grum wroteBut images are 2 dimensional. If you can make out 28% more detail in the horizontal direction and 28% more detail in the vertical direction, then you can make out 64% more detail over the whole image!Perhaps, but Sony's 11-bit RAW files and lossy compression knock that advantage back down to about 28%?! Where do you actually see any loss of this compression? Total hyperbole.....People are making legitimate statements based on their observations and use of the camera. It is perfectly reasonable to provide both positive and critical feedback on equipment, regardless of how much you find it helps YOUR images. Please stop trying to stifle others opinions with personal attacks.
I agree - much of Retrofocus comments are generally unhelpful because he winds emotion into his response. The fact is in this example that Sony did a poor implementation of compression. Just waving your hands and saying - thats hyperbole is not constructive and misleading. Bring on the facts.
I am not sure that the effect of Sony compression is large and it would (did) not stop me from buying the camera, but it is an unecessary design flaw, that diminished performance. If you look at the performance of the d800e or d810 they outperform the a7r in Dxomark - this could be because of the compression. Eg. D800e achieved 33mpx effective vs A7r's 29 effective mpx with the same sensor and best available lens on both (Carl Zeiss Distagon T* Otus 1.4/55 ZF.2 on Nikon and Sony FE Carl Zeiss Sonnar T* 55mm F1.8 ZA on Sony). Still 20% better (again based on lxw than the 5diii) but it could have been better.
Again this is not likely to be an observable difference, however debating facts is better than debating hyperbole.
In my opinion Sony implemented a great compression algorithm. Since the A7R release, we have been trying to find noticeable flaws in the compressed raw files but in real world images, there is nothing to criticize. I was able to find some artifacts but it's very difficult to replicate these conditions as you need terrible lighting and push the shadows to unrealistic levels.
I would like to see more compression options in future models but to me, this is not an issue and I would be comfortable using the current compression when shooting landscape.
I'm very glad to have the A7R to use with my Canon lenses as I can see an improvement in my images, especially in post-processing.
Fred