fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2014 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2014Using Canon glass with Sony A7r

  
 
Jay Connor
Offline

p.1 #1Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
Hi Folks

I'm seriously considering getting the A7r for use with my Canon glass

As you all know its a FF sensor

My questions are:

1) Does the Metabones Canon EF Lens to Sony NEX Smart Adapter (Mark IV) allow Canon lenses to use the FF capability of the A7r ?

2) Does the focal length of the lens change or does a 50mm Canon lens with the Mark IV adapter remain a 50mm lens on the A7r?

I know the Metabones Speed Booster EF to Sony NEX adapter only uses the APS-C size of the Sony FF sensor
Quoted from Metabones
"Sony NEX Speed Booster® Adapters are NOT fully compatible with full-frame Sony A7 or A7R. When the Speed Booster® are used with Sony A7 or A7R, the camera is required to be used in the "APS-C Size Capture" mode."

I couldnt find answers from the Metabones website and I tried looking at the extensive pre-existing thread on the forum and couldnt find the answer

Thanks in advance
Jay
Aug 03, 2014 at 11:54 AM
Mescalamba
Offline
Details
p.1 #2Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
It has AF and you have FF. No change in focal length.

These are not Speedboosters, just adapters.

Dont expect that AF to be blazing fast tho.


Yea and very few Canon AF lens is worth 36 mpix.
Aug 03, 2014 at 11:58 AM
Dark Slider
Offline
Details
p.1 #3Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
There's a long thread here started by Fred Miranda detailing this very subject.
Aug 03, 2014 at 04:46 PM
Jay Connor
Offline
Details
p.1 #4Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
Thanks Mescalamba and Dark

Best
Jay
Aug 03, 2014 at 04:51 PM
Scott Stoness
Offline
Details
p.1 #5Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
Metabones iii or iv permits autofocusinng and all, but not as fast as on the canon.

It will permit ff and also gives you the option of using apsc lens too that canon does not do.

---------------------------------------

Are you considering a7r for 36mpx or dynamic range or light? And why?

The reason I ask is - that i) there could be a new canon announced in September, ii) in my view the clunkiness of the a7r is only worthwhile to landscape photographers - with adapter and adapted canon lens its not so small and:

1) The battery performance of the a7r is not great - this is the most frustrating feature. It lasts for maybe 200 pictures if you religiously turn it off after shooting because the auto off rarely works do to clunkiness

2) The shutter vibration cause it to lose the benefit of 36mpx because of vibration between 1/15 and 1/150 of second. It only achieves about 22mpx effective because of vibration in this range

3) After adapting canon lens its hardly small. The sony 24-70 and 35 are good lens but the 35 is the only small one. There is no small uwa available that works well except for the $6000 16-18-21. The samyang 14/2.8 works for example but it is huge on this camera so don't expect to hang it around your neck when walking. I have now bought about $5000 of lens to use with this camera so that it is light - so watch for mission creep anyway.

So buy it for landscape and expect frustrations (listed above) but don't bother otherwise. The canon eosm is a better choice, if you want a small hikable camera. I bought it for hiking and 36mpx (not dynamic range because I get this from canon with auto bracketing anyway). The hiking is frustrating because there is no small uwa. The camera works for mpx as long as I plan my exposures to avoid 1/15 to 1/150 and put up with adapters and lousy batteries.
Aug 03, 2014 at 05:08 PM
Jay Connor
Offline
Details
p.1 #6Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
Scott

Thanks for that valuable information

I shoot with the 1D series and they are very heavy and big so one reason was to get a lighter smaller body
I shoot a wide variety of stuff including landscapes, architecture, portraits, and sports
Am aware of slow autofocus - sports out of the question - but manual focus may be an improvement

I assume a 36 mpx sensor will allow me to make big prints and/or to be able to get good crops for smaller prints

Could you explain in more detail what you mean by the shutter vibration causing it to achieve about 22 mpx effective

Lastly I havent heard about a new higher res Canon body but assuming they have something coming in the 1D series those bodies usually start IIRC at $6K

Look forward to hearing from you

Best
Jay
Aug 03, 2014 at 05:30 PM
NCAndy
Offline
Details
p.1 #7Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
Aug 03, 2014 at 05:35 PM
artd
Offline
Details
p.1 #8Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
The shutter vibration issue is really only an issue with telephoto lenses in the shutter speeds mentioned.

For portraits and sports, stick with the 1D series. For architecture and landscapes, go with the A7r.

Folks gripe about the battery issue. For a mirrorless camera, the A7r is actually quite respectable for battery life and outperforms many other mirrorless cameras (and, in fact, the Canon EOS m has much worse battery life!). No mirrorless camera will give the battery life of a DSLR, ever, because they are always in live view mode. However if I'm on an architecture shoot, an a7r lasts me almost as long as a Canon DSLR battery, mostly because I am shooting with tilt-shift lenses and using live view for focusing with the Canon anyway.

For manual focus, there is no comparison, the A7r is way better. Being able to zoom in and focus through the LCD viewfinder is far less clunky than trying to manual focus on the back of an LCD screen as needed with the Canons.

A great thing about the A7r is the body is so small and light, I can slip it to my regular kit bag and still carry my Canon DSLR. Best of both worlds and I can always revert to the Canon if I need it for the situations where it's better than the Sony.
Aug 03, 2014 at 06:54 PM
Jay Connor
Offline
Details
p.1 #9Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
Artd

Thanks for the insights

Great point about just sticking it in your kit bag with your regular Canon Dlsr stuff

Best
Jay
Aug 03, 2014 at 07:52 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.1 #10Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
Scott Stoness wrote:
Metabones iii or iv permits autofocusinng and all, but not as fast as on the canon.

It will permit ff and also gives you the option of using apsc lens too that canon does not do.

---------------------------------------

Are you considering a7r for 36mpx or dynamic range or light? And why?

The reason I ask is - that i) there could be a new canon announced in September, ii) in my view the clunkiness of the a7r is only worthwhile to landscape photographers - with adapter and adapted canon lens its not so small and:

1) The battery performance of the a7r is not great
...Show more →

You can't put an extra battery into your pack so you have enough juice for the day? I find this such a pitiful excuse...if that is your biggest issue with the camera, there is a work around, carry a spare. In fact I never go out on a shoot with my 5d2 without a fully charged spare battery...so no difference.

The shutter vibration might exist with telephotos and slow shutters. I have not experienced this.

One big plus people don't mention is the ease of manual focus with the A7r. The focus peaking is miles ahead of using special screens with DSLR's. Coupled with a lens made for manual focus, I find street photography extremely enjoyable with the A7R. The feedom of not having to line up a little red rectangle with what you want to focus on is extremely liberating.

Just my 2 cents worth as I continually see the same slamming of the A7R without the benefits from it.
Aug 03, 2014 at 08:09 PM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.1 #11Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
Welcome to the club, Jay - you are one of many doing this. I am doing the same and use successfully all my Canon glass on the A7R!

1) AF will work through the Metabones (MB) adapters, but it will be much slower than what you are used to with your EF lenses mounted directly onto a Canon DSLR. Depending how you mount your EF lens onto the MB adapter, you have two kind of AF similar systems but none of them matches the AF speed which you see from your DSLR. That's why others mentioned above the excellent capability to focus the lenses with manual focus on the A7R. I am doing the same.

2) The focal length remains unchanged. 50 mm focal length remains 50 mm.

Shutter vibration supposedly can happen with the A7R with tele lenses, but I did not experience this yet with any of my lenses. And yes, correct what chez was saying, just take a spare battery with you just in case and you are all set. Since I am using the A7R, my regular 5D MkII is used only for flash photography when I need to rely on my Canon speedlites.
It is not true what somebody stated above that the DR of the A7R is the same as in a Canon camera with auto bracketing. The difference in dynamic range is huge between those sensors. You cannot achieve the same DR of the A7R with auto-bracketing in Canon's FF cameras.

Aug 04, 2014 at 05:33 AM
adrianb
Offline
Details
p.1 #12Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
chez wrote:
Scott Stoness wroteMetabones iii or iv permits autofocusinng and all, but not as fast as on the canon.

It will permit ff and also gives you the option of using apsc lens too that canon does not do.

---------------------------------------

Are you considering a7r for 36mpx or dynamic range or light? And why?

The reason I ask is - that i) there could be a new canon announced in September, ii) in my view the clunkiness of the a7r is only worthwhile to landscape photographers - with adapter and adapted canon lens its not so small and:

1) The battery performance of the a7r is not great - this is the most frustrating feature. It lasts for maybe 200 pictures if you religiously turn it off after shooting because the auto off rarely works do to clunkiness

2) The shutter vibration cause it to lose the benefit of 36mpx because of vibration between 1/15 and 1/150 of second. It only achieves about 22mpx effective because of vibration in this range

3) After adapting canon lens its hardly small. The sony 24-70 and 35 are good lens but the 35 is the only small one. There is no small uwa available that works well except for the $6000 16-18-21. The samyang 14/2.8 works for example but it is huge on this camera so don't expect to hang it around your neck when walking. I have now bought about $5000 of lens to use with this camera so that it is light - so watch for mission creep anyway.

So buy it for landscape and expect frustrations (listed above) but don't bother otherwise. The canon eosm is a better choice, if you want a small hikable camera. I bought it for hiking and 36mpx (not dynamic range because I get this from canon with auto bracketing anyway). The hiking is frustrating because there is no small uwa. The camera works for mpx as long as I plan my exposures to avoid 1/15 to 1/150 and put up with adapters and lousy batteries.
You can't put an extra battery into your pack so you have enough juice for the day? I find this such a pitiful excuse...if that is your biggest issue with the camera, there is a work around, carry a spare. In fact I never go out on a shoot with my 5d2 without a fully charged spare battery...so no difference.

The shutter vibration might exist with telephotos and slow shutters. I have not experienced this.

One big plus people don't mention is the ease of manual focus with the A7r. The focus peaking is miles ahead of using special screens with DSLR's.
...Show more →

I wouldn't consider his statement a pitiful excuse.. If a batter is rated for XXXX shots, that doesn't mean you'll necessarily get that number of shots. Constantly using the LCD or fiddling with the AF will also drain de battery (not to take weather/temperature into account).

A camera with a battery that can take 200/300 shots is very annoying,even if you have 2 more extra batteries with you.

Sure, it wouldn't be a deal breaker for me (for instance), but it can be more annoying that you might think...


Aug 04, 2014 at 05:40 AM
adrianb
Offline
Details
p.1 #13Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
Jay Connor wrote:
Hi Folks

I'm seriously considering getting the A7r for use with my Canon glass

As you all know its a FF sensor

My questions are:

1) Does the Metabones Canon EF Lens to Sony NEX Smart Adapter (Mark IV) allow Canon lenses to use the FF capability of the A7r ?

2) Does the focal length of the lens change or does a 50mm Canon lens with the Mark IV adapter remain a 50mm lens on the A7r?

I know the Metabones Speed Booster EF to Sony NEX adapter only uses the APS-C size of the Sony FF sensor
Quoted from Metabones
"Sony NEX Speed Booster® Adapters
...Show more →


It really depends on what you want to shoot with the A7r and what's driving you to buy it...

I'd go for a Fuji XT1 with 2 lenses, if I were you...

For anything else than landscape/ really still shots, the A7r pales in comparison with a proper dslr (5D3/etc ) in terms of usability
Aug 04, 2014 at 05:43 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.1 #14Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
adrianb wrote:
For anything else than landscape/ really still shots, the A7r pales in comparison with a proper dslr (5D3/etc ) in terms of usability


So - did you ever use yourself any of the A7 cameras? Doesn't sound like it....
Aug 04, 2014 at 06:03 AM
adrianb
Offline
Details
p.1 #15Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
retrofocus wrote:
adrianb wroteFor anything else than landscape/ really still shots, the A7r pales in comparison with a proper dslr (5D3/etc ) in terms of usability
So - did you ever use yourself any of the A7 cameras? Doesn't sound like it....


true, you got me, but I'd love to see you elaborating on how to shoot some flying birds with a A7R and a 400/500 AF Canon lens..
Aug 04, 2014 at 06:05 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.1 #16Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
adrianb wrote:
retrofocus wrote
adrianb wroteFor anything else than landscape/ really still shots, the A7r pales in comparison with a proper dslr (5D3/etc ) in terms of usability
So - did you ever use yourself any of the A7 cameras? Doesn't sound like it....
true, you got me, but I'd love to see you elaborating on how to shoot some flying birds with a A7R and a 400/500 AF Canon lens..


I am not a bird shooter, and I certainly would not recommend any of the A7 cameras for this kind of shooting. I also wouldn't recommend it for action/sports shooting either because especially the A7R is too slow in the fps rate which is needed for this kind of shooting. It is clear from the beginning when you look at the camera specs that this camera is not targeting this kind of photography. People interested in the A7 series are normally not into this kind of shooting or use a DSLR in parallel to manage this if needed.
Aug 04, 2014 at 06:09 AM
adrianb
Offline
Details
p.1 #17Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
retrofocus wrote:
adrianb wrote
retrofocus wrote
adrianb wroteFor anything else than landscape/ really still shots, the A7r pales in comparison with a proper dslr (5D3/etc ) in terms of usability
So - did you ever use yourself any of the A7 cameras? Doesn't sound like it....
true, you got me, but I'd love to see you elaborating on how to shoot some flying birds with a A7R and a 400/500 AF Canon lens..
I am not a bird shooter, and I certainly would not recommend any of the A7 cameras for this kind of shooting. I also wouldn't recommend it for action/sports shooting either because especially the A7R is too slow in the fps rate which is needed for this kind of shooting. It is clear from the beginning when you look at the camera specs that this camera is not targeting this kind of photography. People interested in the A7 series are normally not into this kind of shooting or use a DSLR in parallel to manage this if needed.


That's pretty much what I initially said...
Aug 04, 2014 at 06:14 AM
technic
Offline
Details
p.1 #18Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
retrofocus wrote:
adrianb wrotetrue, you got me, but I'd love to see you elaborating on how to shoot some flying birds with a A7R and a 400/500 AF Canon lens..
I am not a bird shooter, and I certainly would not recommend any of the A7 cameras for this kind of shooting. I also wouldn't recommend it for action/sports shooting either because especially the A7R is too slow in the fps rate which is needed for this kind of shooting.


In general probably good advice, however ... I'm looking at A7 for a similar subject, flying dragonflies. For this subject AF/tracking in general doesn't work because the subject is very small (difficult to lock on), it has very high angular velocity and moves erratically; plus the AF system doesn't know what to lock on (wings, legs sticking out everywhere). I'm now using a 450D with MF, either trying to keep focus on the dragonfly while it moves and hoping to nail focus, or using prefocus and firing the shutter when the dragonfly is at the right distance.

I want a compact, light camera with (much) better sensor, tilt screen and hopefully higher framerate than what I'm using now. 5D3 etc. is too heavy for me (when adding the required lenses) and I really need a tilt screen which Canon doesn't offer on FF cameras. If AF doesn't work well anyway, maybe I should look at MF performance. For my subject the A7 focus aids (magnify and focus peaking) are probably useless, so it depends on how good one can judge focus using the A7 EVF (or LCD) compared to a FF DSLR OVF. The OVF has more detail and better contrast, on the other side it isn't perfectly accurate for focusing especially the area outside the center.

Unfortunately I have no way to test out the A7 for this, but I'm wondering ... anyone here tried something similar?
Aug 04, 2014 at 11:05 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.1 #19Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
technic wrote:
retrofocus wrote
adrianb wrotetrue, you got me, but I'd love to see you elaborating on how to shoot some flying birds with a A7R and a 400/500 AF Canon lens..
I am not a bird shooter, and I certainly would not recommend any of the A7 cameras for this kind of shooting. I also wouldn't recommend it for action/sports shooting either because especially the A7R is too slow in the fps rate which is needed for this kind of shooting.
In general probably good advice, however ... I'm looking at A7 for a similar subject, flying dragonflies. For this subject AF/tracking in general doesn't work because the subject is very small (difficult to lock on), it has very high angular velocity and moves erratically; plus the AF system doesn't know what to lock on (wings, legs sticking out everywhere). I'm now using a 450D with MF, either trying to keep focus on the dragonfly while it moves and hoping to nail focus, or using prefocus and firing the shutter when the dragonfly is at the right distance.

I want a
...Show more →

This is a very good question - I tried something similar in the past with my 5D MkII and it was very difficult to catch the dragonfly sharp in flight. Many shots taken, but only a handful turned out well. I can't help you if this works on the A7 series somehow - because I don't have any Sony/Zeiss E-mount lens where the AF would work fast enough with the A7. Maybe somebody else can jump in to give advice.
Aug 04, 2014 at 11:22 AM
Scott Stoness
Offline
Details
p.1 #20Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
Jay Connor wrote:
Scott

Thanks for that valuable information

I shoot with the 1D series and they are very heavy and big so one reason was to get a lighter smaller body
I shoot a wide variety of stuff including landscapes, architecture, portraits, and sports
Am aware of slow autofocus - sports out of the question - but manual focus may be an improvement

I assume a 36 mpx sensor will allow me to make big prints and/or to be able to get good crops for smaller prints

Could you explain in more detail what you mean by the shutter vibration causing it to achieve about 22 mpx
...Show more →

36mpx does permit prints that are about 25% larger with same quality - not 36/22 because length x width which requires much bigger.

Llold Chambers (he sells his information but does a very good job) reports that if you use the a7r with any lens (not just long lens) and then downsize to the equivalent of about 22mpx it yields the same resolution as about 22mpx because the shutter vibration between 1/15 and 1/150 causes motion blur that negates the improvements related to 36mpx vs 22mpx


Aug 04, 2014 at 11:39 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister