fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2014 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2014Using Canon glass with Sony A7r

  
 
Scott Stoness
Offline
Details
p.2 #1Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
artd wrote:
The shutter vibration issue is really only an issue with telephoto lenses in the shutter speeds mentioned.

For portraits and sports, stick with the 1D series. For architecture and landscapes, go with the A7r.

Folks gripe about the battery issue. For a mirrorless camera, the A7r is actually quite respectable for battery life and outperforms many other mirrorless cameras (and, in fact, the Canon EOS m has much worse battery life!). No mirrorless camera will give the battery life of a DSLR, ever, because they are always in live view mode. However if I'm on an architecture shoot, an a7r
...Show more →

Not true according to reliable tester - Lloyd Chambers - "The shutter vibration issue is really only an issue with telephoto lenses in the shutter speeds mentioned." According to Lloyd (and me) the vibration issue exists even with the smaller lens. It just gets way way worse with long lens.

Not true according to me - "Folks gripe about the battery issue. For a mirrorless camera, the A7r is actually quite respectable for battery life and outperforms many other mirrorless cameras (and, in fact, the Canon EOS m has much worse battery life!). " The a7r really sucks in minus 20. Goes dead quickly. In normal tempertures the issue is not battery life but lousy implementation. The sony rarely times off automatically whereas the canon does. Thus if you want to hike for a week - which I do - expect to waste 2-3 batteries by forgetting to turn it off after shooting. Bring 20 to be reliable.

It is small - and can fit into my kit with my existing lens and canon - but its a pain in the butt. I usually carry 7d, 5diii (because A7r is useless at moving objects like bears, people) and then a7r hiking lens (35/2.8, 24-70, voigtlander 15 - ugh still not happy with) so I end up with a lot of stuff, adapters, and lens caps and stuff. Hardly a compact kit.

Contrary to other posts, I like the a7r but - would only recommend it for landscapes where you are plannig to print 25% bigger. Buy it but be aware of the clunkiness.



Edited on Aug 04, 2014 at 11:49 AM · View previous versions
Aug 04, 2014 at 11:47 AM
technic
Offline
Details
p.2 #2Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
retrofocus wrote:
This is a very good question - I tried something similar in the past with my 5D MkII and it was very difficult to catch the dragonfly sharp in flight. Many shots taken, but only a handful turned out well. I can't help you if this works on the A7 series somehow - because I don't have any Sony/Zeiss E-mount lens where the AF would work fast enough with the A7. Maybe somebody else can jump in to give advice.


Just to be sure: I accepted that AF is not going to work for this. The question is: can you do quick and accurate MF on an EVF like the one in A7/A7r? I'm assuming the focus aids will not be helpful because the subject is moving very fast, I have no time to switch to magnified view, and I think focus peaking will not work in such conditions. I will be using my Canon L-lenses that have direct MF control so there is no additional play/delay for the focusing action on the lens - any MF lens, or 'pro' AF lens used in MF mode, would probably behave similarly.

Of course my current MF procedure is far from full-proof, but the hit rate is much better than with AF (which would only work when the dragonfly is hovering or moving very slowly, usually the subject is out of the frame before the AF can get an initial lock).
Aug 04, 2014 at 11:48 AM
Scott Stoness
Offline
Details
p.2 #3Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
retrofocus wrote:
Welcome to the club, Jay - you are one of many doing this. I am doing the same and use successfully all my Canon glass on the A7R!

1) AF will work through the Metabones (MB) adapters, but it will be much slower than what you are used to with your EF lenses mounted directly onto a Canon DSLR. Depending how you mount your EF lens onto the MB adapter, you have two kind of AF similar systems but none of them matches the AF speed which you see from your DSLR. That's why others mentioned above the excellent capability to
...Show more →.

Re - "It is not true what somebody stated above that the DR of the A7R is the same as in a Canon camera with auto bracketing. The difference in dynamic range is huge between those sensors. You cannot achieve the same DR of the A7R with auto-bracketing in Canon's FF cameras. "

Retrofocus is wrong. The dynamic range of the a7r is only better from 100-400 iso. After that the canon comes close. Read dxomark. http://www.dxomark.com/Reviews/Nikon-D810-sensor-review-New-DxOMark-leader/Nikon-D810-versus-Sony-A7R-versus-Canon-EOS-5D-Mark-III-D810-has-slight-advantage-over-nearest-rival
But more importantly, if you shoot 3 stop above and 3 stop below you achieve 6 more stops (roughly). It requires blending or hdr. But the a7r at 100iso only gets 2 stops more dynamic range than the canon, So dynamic range is not an issue for auto-bracketers - and the a7r is still too low a dynamic range to avoid auto-bracketing.

So if you shoot low iso, no bracketing, the A7r is way better, but for me, this is not adequate dynamic range to change my shooting style.

Buy the camera - it has better focus peaking, mpx at high or low shutter speed, weight - but just don't expect it to solve all your problems and not cause others.
Aug 04, 2014 at 11:54 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.2 #4Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
Scott Stoness wrote:
retrofocus wroteWelcome to the club, Jay - you are one of many doing this. I am doing the same and use successfully all my Canon glass on the A7R!

1) AF will work through the Metabones (MB) adapters, but it will be much slower than what you are used to with your EF lenses mounted directly onto a Canon DSLR. Depending how you mount your EF lens onto the MB adapter, you have two kind of AF similar systems but none of them matches the AF speed which you see from your DSLR. That's why others mentioned above the excellent capability to focus the lenses with manual focus on the A7R. I am doing the same.

2) The focal length remains unchanged. 50 mm focal length remains 50 mm.

Shutter vibration supposedly can happen with the A7R with tele lenses, but I did not experience this yet with any of my lenses. And yes, correct what chez was saying, just take a spare battery with you just in case and you are all set. Since I am using the A7R, my regular 5D MkII is used only for flash photography when I need to rely on my Canon speedlites.
It is not true what somebody stated above that the DR of the A7R is the same as in a Canon camera with auto bracketing. The difference in dynamic range is huge between those sensors. You cannot achieve the same DR of the A7R with auto-bracketing in Canon's FF cameras.
.

Re - "It is not true what somebody stated above that the DR of the A7R is the same as in a Canon camera with auto bracketing. The difference in dynamic range is huge between those sensors. You cannot achieve the same DR of the A7R with auto-bracketing in Canon's FF cameras. "

Retrofocus is wrong. The dynamic range of the a7r is only better from 100-400 iso. After that the canon comes close. Read dxomark. http://www.dxomark.com/Reviews/Nikon-D810-sensor-review-New-DxOMark-leader/Nikon-D810-versus-Sony-A7R-versus-Canon-EOS-5D-Mark-III-D810-has-slight-advantage-over-nearest-rival
But more importantly, if you shoot 3 stop above and 3 stop below you achieve 6 more stops (roughly). It requires blending or
...Show more →

This only tells me that you never or only rarely have used the A7R, Scott. I was used to do a lot of bracketing with my 5D MkII, and now for sceneries taken with the A7R I don't need any HDR/bracketing at all. I can easily get details out of shadows if needed without creating artefacts and noise. Try this with your Canon camera! I sometimes shoot at about ISO 1600, and it is still the same thing (I rarely go above this ISO number). Even with bracketing, you cannot achieve the same excellent DR which the A7 series provides you with.
Aug 04, 2014 at 12:28 PM
Scott Stoness
Offline
Details
p.2 #5Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
Just so you have the complete pictue:

a7r better:
mpx except for 1/15 to 1/150 shutter
dyanmic range betweeen 100-400 iso
flip lcd screen
focuss peaking
lighter
ev finder allows focussing and zooming

5diii better:
moving subjects
battery life by an order of magnitude even with liveview at least 2x as good
dust conrol - a7r attacts the dust. 5diii sheds it.
no adapter needed. Adapters cause inconveniance and tolerance degradation
works at 30 below - a7r does not
dpp works - sony software fails most the time
uwa work without adapter - a7r requires juggling. There is no sony uwa and likely when it comes it will be big. You can adapt the large lens but then you carrying a big kit.
does not have the low dynamic range of a electronic viewfinder - you can't see much in bright light on a7r

All and all the a7r is a great camera but I would not recommend it without the qualifiers above.
Aug 04, 2014 at 12:30 PM
Jay Connor
Offline
Details
p.2 #6Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
Thanks Scott

I appreciate the pros and cons
Aug 04, 2014 at 12:33 PM
Jay Connor
Offline
Details
p.2 #7Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
Thanks Scott

I appreciate the pros and cons
Aug 04, 2014 at 12:33 PM
artd
Offline
Details
p.2 #8Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
Scott Stoness wrote:
Not true according to reliable tester - Lloyd Chambers - "The shutter vibration issue is really only an issue with telephoto lenses in the shutter speeds mentioned." According to Lloyd (and me) the vibration issue exists even with the smaller lens. It just gets way way worse with long lens.

I have tested an A7r at these shutter speeds with my Canon TS-Es in direct comparison to a 5DII. There is no discernable impact of shutter vibration. Certainly not to the point that it reduces the images to 22mp. My shots all showed noticeable improvement in resolution over the Canon sensor.


Not true according to me - "Folks gripe about the battery issue. For a mirrorless camera, the A7r is actually quite respectable for battery life and outperforms many other mirrorless cameras (and, in fact, the Canon EOS m has much worse battery life!). " The a7r really sucks in minus 20. Goes dead quickly. In normal tempertures the issue is not battery life but lousy implementation. The sony rarely times off automatically whereas the canon does. Thus if you want to hike for a week - which I do - expect to waste 2-3 batteries by forgetting to turn it off
...Show more →
I don't rely on auto off. I turn the camera off when I am done shooting (not just the Sony, but every camera I've ever used). It is really not that hard to flip a switch and turn a camera off when you are done with it. The fact is that compared the EOS m has one of the worst CIPA battery ratings out of any mirrorless camera at 230 shots (by comparison the A7r is 340). Neither will be better than a DSLR for cold weather work. But as a general hiking setup, you will get more shots per charge out of the Sony (provided you turn the camera off when not shooting, of course ).


It is small - and can fit into my kit with my existing lens and canon - but its a pain in the butt. I usually carry 7d, 5diii (because A7r is useless at moving objects like bears, people) and then a7r hiking lens (35/2.8, 24-70, voigtlander 15 - ugh still not happy with) so I end up with a lot of stuff, adapters, and lens caps and stuff. Hardly a compact kit.

If I'm carrying an A7r with my Canon kit, then I only carry one adapter, for Canon lenses. A single adapter is extremely compact. And lens caps...I mean, what kind of lens caps are you using that could possibly add such bulk to your kit


Aug 04, 2014 at 01:08 PM
Scott Stoness
Offline
Details
p.2 #9Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
artd wrote:
Scott Stoness wroteNot true according to reliable tester - Lloyd Chambers - "The shutter vibration issue is really only an issue with telephoto lenses in the shutter speeds mentioned." According to Lloyd (and me) the vibration issue exists even with the smaller lens. It just gets way way worse with long lens.
I have tested an A7r at these shutter speeds with my Canon TS-Es in direct comparison to a 5DII. There is no discernable impact of shutter vibration. Certainly not to the point that it reduces the images to 22mp. My shots all showed noticeable improvement in resolution over the Canon sensor.

Earlier quoteNot true according to me - "Folks gripe about the battery issue. For a mirrorless camera, the A7r is actually quite respectable for battery life and outperforms many other mirrorless cameras (and, in fact, the Canon EOS m has much worse battery life!). " The a7r really sucks in minus 20. Goes dead quickly. In normal tempertures the issue is not battery life but lousy implementation. The sony rarely times off automatically whereas the canon does. Thus if you want to hike for a week - which I do - expect to waste 2-3 batteries by forgetting to turn it off after shooting. Bring 20 to be reliable.
I don't rely on auto off. I turn the camera off when I am done shooting (not just the Sony, but every camera I've ever used). It is really not that hard to flip a switch and turn a camera off when you are done with it. The fact is
...Show more →
Earlier quoteIt is small - and can fit into my kit with my existing lens and canon - but its a pain in the butt. I usually carry 7d, 5diii (because A7r is useless at moving objects like bears, people) and then a7r hiking lens (35/2.8, 24-70, voigtlander 15 - ugh still not happy with) so I end up with a lot of stuff, adapters, and lens caps and stuff. Hardly a compact kit.


I have 2 adapters - one for handheld and one for tripod. You need to attach the metabones adapter to your tripod. So I carry two adapters - one with a L plate permanently affixed for the tripod and one for handheld (the only uwa that do not require adapter are samyang 14/2.8 and sony 12 touit apsc both of which have negatives).

I agree that if I just took my a7r and 35 and 24-70 it is a small kit. But that has no uwa.

But I like wildlife as well as landscape and really like uwa for hiking. So add 2 adapters, plate for adapter, two sets of power chargers, two sets of batteries, two sets of remote shutter release, 35 and 24-70 native, lots of caps because I lose them a lot. It adds up to a mess of extra small stuff.

I guess if I planned more and stuck to the plan, I could get by with a small kit. But I can't.

So it might work for you but having two systems is a pain for me.
Aug 04, 2014 at 01:49 PM
johnctharp
Offline
Details
p.2 #10Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
I feel similarly about carrying the EOS-M and 6D; lots of extra everything.
Aug 04, 2014 at 02:02 PM
Peter Le
Offline
Details
p.2 #11Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
You know it has really become very amusing checking in here lately just to see the crazy stuff the Canon Fanboys come up with to tare down the A7r.... I shot Canon for over 40 years.....they make great stuff......but they are way behind now in high resolution cameras..... It's that simple......will they catch up.....most likely someday.....but not now.
I choose a camera by what works for me now....just a tool....people just have to get over it and not take it so personal.
By the way I have been using the A7r for over seven months now so I'm not going by what someone else says but by what I see. I still have not seen a image blurred from shutter bounce at the speeds you say or any for that matter. I use the grip so have two batteries and a spare in my pocket let's me shoot all day and very rarely have to use the one in my pocket......maybe because I don't spray and pray. Also I have used it many times in - 25 degrees below zero with no problem at all. I think these things are just internet hyperbole for people that can't sleep knowing that Canon didn't make it. I move along now....but I'll be back to see the flames for a chuckle.
Aug 04, 2014 at 02:03 PM
Scott Stoness
Offline
Details
p.2 #12Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
Peter Le wrote:
You know it has really become very amusing checking in here lately just to see the crazy stuff the Canon Fanboys come up with to tare down the A7r.... I shot Canon for over 40 years.....they make great stuff......but they are way behind now in high resolution cameras..... It's that simple......will they catch up.....most likely someday.....but not now.
I choose a camera by what works for me now....just a tool....people just have to get over it and not take it so personal.
By the way I have been using the A7r for over
...Show more →

The difference between 36mpx and 22mpx is modest (22%). To get the 22% improvement you need to have good technique (remote shutter release, good tripod ball head, mirror lockup on canon...). If you shoot handheld you are wasting your time with 36mpx vs 22mpx. So, I am not surprised you have not seen the shutter noise trouble it takes demanding technique which most people don't do. But if you are buying a a7r for a 22% mpx improvement, its disappointing that sony screwed up the shutter. You can solve it by avoiding 1/15 to 1/150 but you should not have to.

Which fact are you challenging?

Aug 04, 2014 at 02:15 PM
johnctharp
Offline
Details
p.2 #13Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
Peter Le wrote:
You know it has really become very amusing checking in here lately just to see the crazy stuff the Canon Fanboys come up with to tare down the A7r....


We're not 'tare-ing' down anything; were calling it like it is. The A7R is an incredible imager, but it's far from 'perfect', and it's obvious that Sony didn't take the time to fully develop it or the lenses that they made available for the system. It's the odd man out; the A7 is the most balanced camera in the series, with usable AF, no issues with shutter shock, and more balanced with the lenses that Sony released.
Aug 04, 2014 at 02:33 PM
Jay Connor
Offline
Details
p.2 #14Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
Peter

Thanks for sharing your personal experience

I'm sure by using the camera for 7 months you know its strengths/weaknesses

I've been a Canon user for 10 years - bought every 1D body as they came out and I love the 1DX

But I have no hesitation to try something that might be better

I should be getting the A7r with the Metabones MIV adapter tomorrow

Best
Jay
Aug 04, 2014 at 02:39 PM
mttran
Offline
Details
p.2 #15Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
Jay Connor wrote:
Peter

Thanks for sharing your personal experience

I'm sure by using the camera for 7 months you know its strengths/weaknesses

I've been a Canon user for 10 years - bought every 1D body as they came out and I love the 1DX

But I have no hesitation to try something that might be better

I should be getting the A7r with the Metabones MIV adapter tomorrow

Best
Jay


+1, A7R is the 1DX best sister. You will enjoy it
Aug 04, 2014 at 03:10 PM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.2 #16Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
Peter Le wrote:
You know it has really become very amusing checking in here lately just to see the crazy stuff the Canon Fanboys come up with to tare down the A7r.... I shot Canon for over 40 years.....they make great stuff......but they are way behind now in high resolution cameras..... It's that simple......will they catch up.....most likely someday.....but not now.
I choose a camera by what works for me now....just a tool....people just have to get over it and not take it so personal.
By the way I have been using the A7r for over
...Show more →

Very well said, I couldn't agree more. If the Sony A7R would carry a Canon logo, those guys would be all saying the opposite and glorifying it.
Aug 04, 2014 at 03:44 PM
Peter Le
Offline
Details
p.2 #17Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
There is no perfect camera...and probably never will be. When and if Canon ever makes one it will demand flawless technique just like the Sony. Yes I am usually on a good tripod and ball head..... 36mp is high enough resolution that it places different demands on your setup and your technique then 20mp......that's simply a fact and it also shows 22% is more then you are portraying.......plus when printing large fine detail there is almost never enough resolution so every 20% helps....by now and have a good night.
Aug 04, 2014 at 04:22 PM
artd
Offline
Details
p.2 #18Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
Scott Stoness wrote:
I have 2 adapters - one for handheld and one for tripod. You need to attach the metabones adapter to your tripod. So I carry two adapters - one with a L plate permanently affixed for the tripod and one for handheld (the only uwa that do not require adapter are samyang 14/2.8 and sony 12 touit apsc both of which have negatives).


Hmm, well it is interestering how we all have different perspectives and methods of working. I have no trouble shooting handheld with my L-plate still attached to the Metabones, but for those situations where I do want to remove it I also carry a hex key....much more compact (and cheaper) than a second adapter

But to each their own
Aug 04, 2014 at 05:09 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.2 #19Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
Scott Stoness wrote:
Peter Le wroteYou know it has really become very amusing checking in here lately just to see the crazy stuff the Canon Fanboys come up with to tare down the A7r.... I shot Canon for over 40 years.....they make great stuff......but they are way behind now in high resolution cameras..... It's that simple......will they catch up.....most likely someday.....but not now.
I choose a camera by what works for me now....just a tool....people just have to get over it and not take it so personal.
By the way I have been using the A7r for over seven months now so I'm not going by what someone else says but by what I see. I still have not seen a image blurred from shutter bounce at the speeds you say or any for that matter. I use the grip so have two batteries and a spare in my pocket let's me shoot all day and very rarely have to use the one in my pocket......maybe because I don't spray and pray. Also I have used it many times in - 25 degrees below zero with no problem at all. I think these things are just internet hyperbole for people that can't sleep knowing that Canon didn't make it. I move along now....but I'll be back to see the flames for a chuckle.
The difference between 36mpx and 22mpx is modest (22%). To get the 22% improvement you need to have good technique (remote shutter release, good tripod ball head, mirror lockup on canon...). If you shoot handheld you are wasting your time with 36mpx vs 22mpx. So, I am not surprised you have not seen the shutter noise trouble it takes demanding technique which most people don't do. But if you are buying a a7r for a 22% mpx improvement, its disappointing that sony screwed up the shutter. You can solve it by avoiding 1/15 to 1/150 but you should not
...Show more →


Lots of talk...let's see some action. I've seen shots posted that were taken within your shutter ranges that were tack sharp at 100% viewing. Let's see you fuzzy images that you have taken using good techniques.

Also Scott, if you would take a look at Peter's website, I think you would agree that Peter knows how to take a good sharp image so I totally trust his opinions on such matters.
Aug 04, 2014 at 05:20 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.2 #20Using Canon glass with Sony A7r
johnctharp wrote:
Peter Le wroteYou know it has really become very amusing checking in here lately just to see the crazy stuff the Canon Fanboys come up with to tare down the A7r....
We're not 'tare-ing' down anything; were calling it like it is. The A7R is an incredible imager, but it's far from 'perfect', and it's obvious that Sony didn't take the time to fully develop it or the lenses that they made available for the system. It's the odd man out; the A7 is the most balanced camera in the series, with usable AF, no issues with shutter shock, and more balanced with the lenses that Sony released.


I guess the same can be said about the 5d3, being rushed out as it's ugly sister...much cheaper date too, the 6d beats the pants off the 5d3 with it's great sensor...right.
Aug 04, 2014 at 05:26 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister