I would be a little cautious about following that line of reasoning and reducing everything to 3D, the Zeiss look, or "Pop." These concepts have evolved over time and are still interpreted differently by different people. In many ways, they are simplifications of a much more complex visual experience.
For example, when discussing photographs made with telephoto lenses, it is often difficult to speak about the three-dimensional appearance of the subject itself, because perspective compression tends to flatten facial features and shapes. Yet images taken with telephoto lenses can still produce a strong sense of depth, separation, or what some people would describe as "Pop".
In fact, if we define "Pop" purely as 3D, many classic telephoto portraits would struggle to qualify, since the subjects often appear relatively flat due to compressed perspective. Nevertheless, those same images can still create a remarkable impression of depth and subject separation through tonal transitions, local contrast, rendering, and the overall visual impression.
That is one of the reasons why I think these concepts are broader than simply "3D" and why they continue to be interpreted in different ways.
I won't revisit whether someone sees it or does not see it, as that point has already been discussed many times. However, I would be cautious about positioning oneself as the final judge of what is and is not "pop." The topic has been debated for decades and remains open to interpretation. What one photographer attributes to perspective, another may associate with rendering, tonal transitions, micro-contrast, subject separation, or simply the overall visual impression.
For that reason, I believe the most productive approach is simply to present examples and allow people to draw their own conclusions rather than trying to establish a single definitive definition of what is and is not "3D Pop."
Just my personal opinion. 😊📷