gdanmitchell wrote:
I’m going to try really hard to not allow myself to get sucked back into this, but…
I won't go down that rabbit hole either. People don't even see colors the same way, and the human brain is incredibly good at compensating for differences in vision. Given that, I'm not surprised that things like rendering, depth, or "pop" are perceived differently from person to person.
I also don't intend to get into arguments over terminology. The topic of this thread is clearly defined, and everyone is simply sharing what they consider their best examples and discussing them. If you have a different view, the best way to make your case is to post your own images and let them speak for themselves.
As for going through posts point by point, that may be useful if you're collecting experience on your way to becoming a moderator. 😉 I'd rather see more photographs and fewer scorecards.