There's a running thread on the 28/1.4 and I was wondering whether it's "all that"? Noted Nikon guru, the unpleasant Bjørn Rørslett bucks the conventional wisdom and reports that the three samples he'd tested were not impressive wide open. While Ken Rockwell does his usual spiel about how wonderful it is ("greatest ever!") he does qualify it by adding that he may have had a particularly good sample.
There were photos on the 28 thread comparing it to the 24/1.4. The 28 might have been slightly better at pulling some detail out of the shadows. Maybe.
Anyone here had experience with both and can comment?
The primary image poster there, Greg, aka, "Nikkor AIS" has a real handle on that lens that impresses and his shots have a unique look about them but I'm uncertain if that's due to his style of shooting or attributable to the lens itself.