fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2006 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2006'Unofficial' Photokina RUMOR Thread

  
 
timbop
Offline
Details
p.75 #1'Unofficial' Photokina RUMOR Thread
wjmeyer wrote:
danmitchell wrote"...My 350D creates images of the same quality that I would get on a 30D at a lower price, while providing the features I really need...
This is of course assuming you do not need high ISO I actually thought of buying a 400D as a backup until I saw it's limited ISO capabilities, no doubt implemented by Canon to set apart the 30D, etc.



uh-oh......
Sep 15, 2006 at 01:01 PM
Mark Shaxted
Offline
Details
p.75 #2'Unofficial' Photokina RUMOR Thread
erm... the 30D only actually has ISO 1600, just like the 400D.

I haven't seen any direct comparisons between these two cameras at any ISO, so I don't know how they actually compare. But if they compare well, you aren't actually loosing anything (ISO wise) by getting a 400D.
Sep 15, 2006 at 01:28 PM
Tentacle
Offline
Details
p.75 #3'Unofficial' Photokina RUMOR Thread
Mark Shaxted wrote:
erm... the 30D only actually has ISO 1600, just like the 400D.


The 10D, 20D and 30D can all be boosted to H, which is the equivalent of ISO 3200. And with Canon being modest, All ISO settings are (too) conservative by about a third of a stop, so ISO H (3200) setting actually has the sensitivity of ISO 4000.

With the 10D, the "H" stands for "noise Hell", but with the 30D it starts to become pretty decent. See http://www.dpreview.com/reviews/canoneos30d/page20.asp

You can't do ISO H with the 300D, 350D or 400D, unless you install a hacked firmware on the camera.


Edited by Tentacle on Sep 15, 2006 at 08:38 PM GMT
Sep 15, 2006 at 01:36 PM
DavidWEGS
Offline
[X]
Details
p.75 #4'Unofficial' Photokina RUMOR Thread
Mark Shaxted wrote:
erm... the 30D only actually has ISO 1600, just like the 400D.


Yeah?

Wow, I must have dreamed the 3200iso shots I've taken then.
Sep 15, 2006 at 01:38 PM
Mark Shaxted
Offline
Details
p.75 #5'Unofficial' Photokina RUMOR Thread
Unfortuantely it doesn't quite work like that.

ISO 3200 on a 20/30D is simply ISO1600 underexposed by 1 stop - then pushed back up a stop in software. It's not a real ISO, that's why it's hidden in the menu.

You can get exactly the same effect using a 350/400D. Just remember to underexpose (ISO 1600) by 1 stop, then push back up in DPP or whatever else you convert your raws with.
Sep 15, 2006 at 01:40 PM
Nowhere Man
Offline
Details
p.75 #6'Unofficial' Photokina RUMOR Thread
Mark Shaxted wrote:
Unfortuantely it doesn't quite work like that.

ISO 3200 on a 20/30D is simply ISO1600 underexposed by 1 stop - then pushed back up a stop in software. It's not a real ISO, that's why it's hidden in the menu.

You can get exactly the same effect using a 350/400D. Just remember to underexpose (ISO 1600) by 1 stop, then push back up in DPP or whatever else you convert your raws with.


DOH!
Sep 15, 2006 at 01:42 PM
Taff Reardon
Offline
Details
p.75 #7'Unofficial' Photokina RUMOR Thread
Well I for one cant wait. I bought my tickets to photokina today and am going on the 27th Sep

Just sold my 20D, 70-200 and some other stuff and now have £2000 burning a hole in my pocket waiting for any news on new bodies etc.

for once in my life i have the money ready and im only a few hours away from the biggest photographic show in europe.

Only trouble is, ill probably spend the money on beer and fags (cigarettes for the non brits!!) then hammer the credit card for a new body!!!!!!!!

One slight flaw is that i dont have a camera to take any pictures of the show!! Doh!!!
Sep 15, 2006 at 01:48 PM
Mark Shaxted
Offline
Details
p.75 #8'Unofficial' Photokina RUMOR Thread
Wonder if you'll get a chance to nick all the canon gear on dispay... hmmm
Sep 15, 2006 at 02:01 PM
danmitchell
Offline
Details
p.75 #9'Unofficial' Photokina RUMOR Thread
I wrote stuff about the 400D including the observations that it [would provide] "the features I really need..."

To which someone replied: "This is of course assuming you do not need high ISO I actually thought of buying a 400D as a backup until I saw it's limited ISO..."

Like I said... "while providing the features I really need..." 1600 ISO is high enough for me, and I can push in PS if I need to, not that I have so far - with my 350D. :-)

Take care,

Dan
Sep 15, 2006 at 02:22 PM
brunobarolo
Offline
Details
p.75 #10'Unofficial' Photokina RUMOR Thread

"Why do people buy a 400D? Most of them because of the low price, no doubt."

That is only half of the equation. Many people buy the 400D (and, like me, bought the 350D) because of the value it provides at the low price. My 350D creates images of the same quality that I would get on a 30D at a lower price, while providing the features I really need, and allowing me to use (four, including three L zooms) high quality Canon lenses. Not all 350D/400D users limit themselves to kit lenses.

What do you think, how many 400D buyers also buy 3 L zooms? My bet: less than 1%. More than 50% may buy the kit lens (and nothing else) because its "value" may look much better than the 17-55 with a more than 10 times higher price.

The costly EF-S lenses need a higher quality camera to match their level. I'm quite sure there will be 30D successors for the next 5 years at least.
Sep 15, 2006 at 02:39 PM
wjmeyer
Offline
Details
p.75 #11'Unofficial' Photokina RUMOR Thread
danmitchell wrote:
I wrote stuff about the 400D including the observations that it [would provide] "the features I really need..."

To which someone replied: "This is of course assuming you do not need high ISO I actually thought of buying a 400D as a backup until I saw it's limited ISO..."

Like I said... "while providing the features I really need..." 1600 ISO is high enough for me, and I can push in PS if I need to, not that I have so far - with my 350D. :-)

Take care,

Dan


Hi Dan, I merely meant my reply in jest realizing that you probably do not need 3200, most don't, but it comes in handy for me on many occasions.
Sep 15, 2006 at 03:49 PM
Philippe Arnez
Offline
Details
p.75 #12'Unofficial' Photokina RUMOR Thread
Taff Reardon wrote:
Well I for one cant wait. I bought my tickets to photokina today and am going on the 27th Sep

Just sold my 20D, 70-200 and some other stuff and now have £2000 burning a hole in my pocket waiting for any news on new bodies etc.

for once in my life i have the money ready and im only a few hours away from the biggest photographic show in europe.

Only trouble is, ill probably spend the money on beer and fags (cigarettes for the non brits!!) then hammer the credit
...Show more →

Ehm, I don't want to dissapoint you, but I don't think you can actually buy stuff at the photokina... If I got you right, that's your plan. But it's a tradeshow for the big guys of the business...
The companies don't sell any gear, it's just for show
Sep 15, 2006 at 05:06 PM
thw2
Offline
Details
p.75 #13'Unofficial' Photokina RUMOR Thread
RDKirk wrote:
The statement (not a direct quote, but a named attribution) appears here:
http://www.digit.no/wip4/detail.epl?id=59456


If I remember correctly, the Canon rep also said in the full interview that they will let the market/consumers dictate the ultimate direction they'll go. The same thing was said about in-camera stabilisation.
Sep 15, 2006 at 07:19 PM
RDKirk
Offline
Details
p.75 #14'Unofficial' Photokina RUMOR Thread
thw2 wrote:
RDKirk wroteThe statement (not a direct quote, but a named attribution) appears here:
http://www.digit.no/wip4/detail.epl?id=59456
If I remember correctly, the Canon rep also said in the full interview that they will let the market/consumers dictate the ultimate direction they'll go. The same thing was said about in-camera stabilisation.


Hence, the print button, right? The trick is to discover which consumers they're listening to, isn't it?
Sep 15, 2006 at 07:43 PM
Rusty1
Offline
Details
p.75 #15'Unofficial' Photokina RUMOR Thread
RDKirk wrote:
Hence, the print button, right? The trick is to discover which consumers they're listening to, isn't it?


Yes the print button and perhaps the "EOS Integrated Cleaning System". I'm not excited about having any new complexities put inbetween the lens and sensor or any unintended consequences this introduces.
Sep 15, 2006 at 08:36 PM
KIDERAL
Offline
Details
p.75 #16'Unofficial' Photokina RUMOR Thread
I just noticed the new Powershots..... a 10mp and a 7 mp IS.
I am debating which one to get... IS or no IS? 3x or 4x

But more importantly, it made me look at the sensor.
10mp CCD sensor which DPreview says is 7.18mm x 5.32mm.

if this is the case, then:

in a 5D or 1Ds format this is 225 mp.
in a 1D this is 142mp
in a 30d this is 88mp.


I think it is safe to say that canon has some spare pixel capacity in its quiver and is holding out on us...or as I have always thought the bottleneck is that they can't move the data fast enough...
Sep 15, 2006 at 09:04 PM
Graham Mitchell
Offline
Details
p.75 #17'Unofficial' Photokina RUMOR Thread
A well-connected little birdie just told me that Canon tried to bring out a 22MP body but they pulled the plug on it, for the time being at least.

We'll soon know for sure
Sep 15, 2006 at 09:24 PM
Davez0r
Offline
Details
p.75 #18'Unofficial' Photokina RUMOR Thread
KIDERAL wrote:
I just noticed the new Powershots..... a 10mp and a 7 mp IS.
I am debating which one to get... IS or no IS? 3x or 4x

But more importantly, it made me look at the sensor.
10mp CCD sensor which DPreview says is 7.18mm x 5.32mm.

if this is the case, then:

in a 5D or 1Ds format this is 225 mp.
in a 1D this is 142mp
in a 30d this is 88mp.

I think it is safe to say that canon has some spare pixel capacity in its quiver and is holding out on us...or as I have always thought the bottleneck is that they
...Show more →

I thought these ccd's would probably be sony sensors.

Dave
Sep 16, 2006 at 12:03 AM
DaveMart
Offline
Details
p.75 #19'Unofficial' Photokina RUMOR Thread
KIDERAL wrote:
I just noticed the new Powershots..... a 10mp and a 7 mp IS.
I am debating which one to get... IS or no IS? 3x or 4x

But more importantly, it made me look at the sensor.
10mp CCD sensor which DPreview says is 7.18mm x 5.32mm.

if this is the case, then:

in a 5D or 1Ds format this is 225 mp.
in a 1D this is 142mp
in a 30d this is 88mp.

I think it is safe to say that canon has some spare pixel capacity in its quiver and is holding out on us...or as I have always thought the bottleneck is that they
...Show more →
Enjoy the noise on those sensors!
Regards,
DaveMart
Sep 16, 2006 at 02:55 AM
Tentacle
Offline
Details
p.75 #20'Unofficial' Photokina RUMOR Thread
Rusty1 wrote:
Yes the print button and perhaps the "EOS Integrated Cleaning System". I'm not excited about having any new complexities put inbetween the lens and sensor or any unintended consequences this introduces.


As it stands now, I would not worry about the new ultrasonic vibrating thingy. The point is that the piezo electric cells make the existing AA filter shake, there is no additional sheet/layer between sensor and lens, compared to previous systems. If I understood that correctly that is.

Even if there was a new layer introduced, that does not have to affect the image quality per sé. The 2 to 3 mm thick high-pass filter doesn't seem to harm image quality either, does it? That's there to improve image quality by blocking IR wavelengths.
Sep 16, 2006 at 02:57 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister