Fred Miranda wrote: RustyBug wroteToday is my third day using the APO 28, and I'm still amazed at what a great lens it is. My first impressions are very positive. But now comes the hardest part: deciding whether to keep the new APO 28 as a great addition to my existing APO 50, or to keep my current Nokton 28/1.5. Has anyone else faced a similar dilemma? How did you decide?Great post. I agree that having more choices often leads to more confusion and indecision about what to carry or own. Detailed reviews with real results, samples, and tests can be more helpful than videos that focus mostly on personal opinions.
Earlier quoteMe, I'm right there with ya ... tough call with so many options. Personally, I think the decision between the VM APO and the Nokton comes down to size / blockage. The rendering of each is close enough in aesthetic that the bokeh quality is still very nice for the APO, and the fringing of the Nokton isn't so terrible that I'd hate owning it. (Fringing from Voigt has been a pain point for me). That said ... if you're needing the corners, I think the APO tips the scales.I'd have to respectfully disagree here...the rendering difference between the 28/1.5 Nokton and the 28/2 APO is more than subtle. They're easy to distinguish even in casual sample comparisons. The 28 APO delivers a far more corrected and refined look: CA correction is in a completely different league (virtually absent on the APO), and bokeh transitions are smoother, cleaner, and more neutral. The Nokton leans into a more classic and structured rendering (which I love), with stronger outlining and some visible fringing wide open. Now, if you had said the APO is close to the Ultron, I would completely agree. Those differences are much smaller.
As for viewfinder blockage, they're about the same without hoods. But from a rendering standpoint, they only begin to look somewhat similar when stopped down...and even then, the APO maintains its edge in overall precision and refinement. The Nokton gives you that unique f/1.5 blur, yes, but it comes with its own trade-offs.
As capable as the Q2's 28mm f/1.7 lens is, with the mandatory software distortion correction, it's not on the same level optically as the CV 28/2 APO. Yes, both have a modern signature, but there are clear differences beyond distortion. Edge-to-edge sharpness, microcontrast, CA handling, and overall technical rendering (setting aside subjective preferences) all favor the APO. That said, I get your point that in real world images, both have a modern look and produce beautiful results. My point is that although modern lenses can look similar, there are still noticeable differences for those of us who care about these details....Show more →Earlier quote5) Mix / match with a near focal length (i.e. 28 Nokton + 35 APO vs. 28 APO + 35 Cron). In my case, I've got the 35 Cron ASPH and the 28 APO would be the complement replacement to my Q2 (superb lens rendering, but I'dl prefer less distortion) and the 50 VM Nok, so that three different renderings (technical, middle, aesthetic) are spread across three diff focal lengths.
And yup, you've nailed what I didn't say very well regarding my perspective of the Q2 Lux. The one thing the Q2 Lux has is that macro mode that is pretty unique to have also. That'll be the thing that I'm "giving up" the most. But, I figure the MFD of the APO is close enough that a bit of cropping isn't a massive difference. Particularly, when you realize that the Lux is simply being pulled farther from the film plane to enlarge the projection. Basically, an optical version of cropping-ish, anyway, that takes a corresponding IQ / contrast diff. Six of one, 1/2 dozen the other kind of thing. And, yes, the uncorrected APO will be significantly diff in terms of distortion vs. the Lux.
That said ... as I currently have the M 24/2.8 APSH and the 35/2 ASPH ... I'll likely pick up the 28 APO (not the Nokton) in due time. I've also got the 50/1.5 Nok and the 40 Cron-C for when I want those diff rendering. Imo, my WA stuff is generally more technical, than aesthetic rendering oriented. Of course, that's a personal decision and everyone's YMMV applies. But, even though the APO is more technical oriented ... it's falloff doesn't seem to suffer from nervous bokeh, etc. Still very pleasing, even if there are others that are "more pleasing". "Max" bokeh isn't my agenda for my WA's ... but, pleasant enough is fine for my needs ... in understanding the quid pro quo of things.
Fred Miranda wrote:
Is https://cosina.co.jp/ down? I can't seem to connect since yesterday.
I use https://www.cosina.co.jp/ and it's been working for me without interruptions.
However, if I try your link without the www part, it doesn't load for me.
Juha Kannisto wrote: Fred Miranda wroteIs https://cosina.co.jp/ down? I can't seem to connect since yesterday.I use https://www.cosina.co.jp/ and it's been working for me without interruptions.
However, if I try your link without the www part, it doesn't load for me.
Looks like something changed on their end. Maybe they removed a redirect since I used to access the site without the "www" in the URL. That's how I had it bookmarked. Anyway, glad it's working now.
Comparison with Lux 28 (3 sets of images, f/1.4-f/5.6) in this thread.
Other random 'day 1' impressions:
The APO Lanthar 28mm without lens hood is the same size as the Leica APO Summicron 50mm.
Wearing glasses, the viewfinder blockage is at the limits of my field of view (= irrelevant); 28mm is a focal length where I depend on the EVF or contact lenses for framing.
The shape of the included Voigtlander lens hood is unusual.
Nice samples. The CV 28/2 APO never gives distracting rendering. It's similar to the CV 50/2 APO but with less optical vignetting and more rounded bokeh balls. In a way, it has a rendering style like the RX1's Sonnar 35/2 but without any color fringing or onion ring bokeh artifacts. Now we just need a CV 35/2 APO-Lanthar II with the same signature and compact size.
For me: I prefer the look of the 28mm Apo over the 50mm Apo Lanthar. The 50 was always to perfect and clinical without a look or a charme. It’s just perfect and boring. Again: For me.
Now I have to find out if I can live with these 28mm focal length…
The Voigtländer 28mm f/2 APO-Lanthar Aspherical (AL28) does everything it promises, and does it exceptionally well. To put it simply: if I could only have one 28mm M-mount lens, regardless of price, this would be it.
As an f/2 lens, it’s a natural competitor to the beloved Leica 28mm Summicron-M. I suspect for many, the AL28 will become what Benj Haisch called the Summicron in his Long Term Review on YouTube: a true modern workhorse, capable of handling any task with excellence.
But its true significance is being the first APO 28mm for the M-mount. It finally offers photographers who love the M-system's size and discretion a level of optical correction previously reserved for massive lenses like the SL-Summicrons or the Zeiss Otus. While it may not reach the absolute peak performance of those larger lenses (due in part to system constraints), it sets a new 28mm benchmark for edge-to-edge acuity on the M-mount without the usual trade-offs.
That Voigtländer delivers this innovation at a fraction of Leica's APO prices—while Leica itself has yet to release a 28mm APO for the M-system—is a remarkable achievement.
For me, this is the lens of the year. It's a wonderful tool that brings pure joy to the process of photography. I don't have the time to write a full-blown review right now, and frankly, one isn't needed since Fred has already done a marvelous job. Instead, I'll just share a few snapshots from today (full size on flickr):
The Voigtländer 28mm f/2 APO-Lanthar Aspherical (AL28) does everything it promises, and does it exceptionally well. To put it simply: if I could only have one 28mm M-mount lens, regardless of price, this would be it.
As an f/2 lens, it’s a natural competitor to the beloved Leica 28mm Summicron-M. I suspect for many, the AL28 will become what Benj Haisch called the Summicron in his Long Term Review on YouTube: a true modern workhorse, capable of handling any task with excellence.
But its true significance is being the first APO 28mm for the M-mount. It finally offers photographers who love the M-system's size and discretion a level of optical correction previously reserved for massive lenses like the SL-Summicrons or the Zeiss Otus. While it may not reach the absolute peak performance of those larger lenses (due in part to system constraints), it sets a new 28mm benchmark for edge-to-edge acuity on the M-mount without the usual trade-offs.
That Voigtländer delivers this innovation at a fraction of Leica's APO prices—while Leica itself has yet to release a 28mm APO for the M-system—is a remarkable achievement.
For me, this is the lens of the year. It's a wonderful tool that brings pure joy to the process of photography. I don't have the time to write a full-blown review right now, and frankly, one isn't needed since Fred has already done a marvelous job. Instead, I'll just share a few snapshots from today (full size on flickr):
I've always maintained that "glass rules" ... and in the paradigm of M-sized glass vs. SL sized glass ... there will be a difference in what can be achieved. There is no such thing as a free lunch and you can only do so much with whichever hand you're dealing in.
To that point, the "larger" VM sits in what looks to be an excellent "sweet spot" on the size / performance paradigm. Imo, if Leica were to bring an APO 28mm to the table, they might make it about 10% smaller than the VM. And / or, it might be a smidge thinner / shorter for a slightly better viewfinder blockage, yet still being very well corrected to APO levels, etc. Price point would likely be 4X, in doing so, though.
The prospect of this being a "workhorse" lens ... yeah, it'll find its way on plenty of bodies for a while to come. Even from the early, first view, trade show pics, you could tell this one was gonna be one to watch. Does it have the same draw as a Simera, or the same size as an Elmarit or Skopar, no. But, as a "Goldilocks" that is well positioned among a lot of factors, particularly for those looking for technical optical performance (vs. character rendering or diminutive haptic). The reference to a Cron is reasonable ... albeit a bit larger than the Cron. Oddly enough, the Cron still calls to me a bit. But, then again ... glass rules.
gammarART wrote: RustyBug wrotethe "larger" VM sits in what looks to be an excellent "sweet spot" on the size / performance paradigm.28 Apo Lanthar → 55,6 x 50 mm, 265g
28 Summicron (current) → 58 x 55 mm, 275g
The 28 Summicron (v1), however, is 53 X 40.8 mm, 270g, so very similar in weight to the VM 28 APO Lanthar, but blocks the viewfinder quite a bit less. That is unless you use the hood on that lens which is pretty huge and you block the viewfinder massively (you can probably tell I wasn't a fan of that hood).
Okay, I compared it with the current Summicron model.
And never used the original hood from the 28 Apo. Works well without it. Maybe, when the Apo will stay, I go for a hood from Tahusa like with my Nokton.
Steve Spencer wrote: gammarART wroteRustyBug wrotethe "larger" VM sits in what looks to be an excellent "sweet spot" on the size / performance paradigm.28 Apo Lanthar → 55,6 x 50 mm, 265g
28 Summicron (current) → 58 x 55 mm, 275gThe 28 Summicron (v1), however, is 53 X 40.8 mm, 270g, so very similar in weight to the VM 28 APO Lanthar, but blocks the viewfinder quite a bit less. That is unless you use the hood on that lens which is pretty huge and you block the viewfinder massively (you can probably tell I wasn't a fan of that hood).
Which begs the point ... if Leica bumped the size of the current (I wasn't thinking current) Cron vs. v.1, did an optical performance bump come along for the ride to induce the larger size. And, is it better corrected, but not labeled as an APO, in the realm of near-APO.
I"m remiss to recall the differences of the newer version, as I wasn't in the market for that $$$ point for the most recent version.