fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2025 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2025Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?

  
 
Toothwalker
Offline
Details
p.17 #1Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
bernardl wrote:
It is a very sweet lens indeed, no doubt. But I am getting very similar image quality with Nikon's 85mm f1.2 S and 135mm f1.8 S with fast AF and there was just too much overlap. For landscape the 105mm f2.8 S is better and offers macro capability. For people eye AF is just way easier to get tack sharp results wide open. The 100mm f1.4 is hard to focus optimally even on the Zf/Z6III that automatically jump to the eye for manual focus lenses.

So in the end there were no use cases where the Otus delivered better than other
...Show more →

In the SLR and DSLR era I only used manual focus, but autofocus convinced me when I migrated to mirrorless. Old habits can die, because I would not buy an Otus lens today for precisely the reasons you describe. That said, there are strong rumours that Zeiss will soon re-enter the photography business with a new line of lenses for mirrorless and I can't help but feel excited.

Feb 13, 2025 at 01:04 PM
Z250SA
Offline
Details
p.17 #2Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Not my R, but the RP (of all ancient-grade AFs...) with its focus stacking and then the R5 totally turned my attention away from MF despite the very nice focusing tools MIL provides. AF and zooms, yeah!!

But when I got the fast MMM4Pro with far better screen I have dived back in time to my MF years with Contax and ZE and, wow! There is something with the colours etc that my eyes just love to rest in and enjoy.

There is that point-and-shootiness of the fast AFs that makes me sloppy and lazy. The speed distracts from composition. There is no Zen in AF in the photography I do. Portrait is not my game at all. But when my daughter got her exam, I managed to get a one or two in perfect eye focus with my 5D4 and 50/2 Macro-Planar ZE. One or two of almost a hundred. Yes, there are scenarios were AF rules, as in BIF, DIF etc. But my WA work will return to Zeiss now. And I know exactly why!

Sounds great those rumors about a new line of lenses from Zeiss. I actually contacted Z about how I look(ed) at the future of MF Zeiss lenses. Yeah, nothing wrong in trying! I recommended small, light, sharp to the corners, best Zeiss colours, not necessarily fast at all. Contax Distagon 28/2.8 and Sonnar 85/2.8 as great examples. When I look around me on other photogs, few carry the big and heavy bodies. On FF I see many R8, sorry for speaking only Canon here on Nikon forum. Small and light but very capable. Surprisingly many of my old friends have gone to Olympus just for the size, especially from D850 of some reason. Wasn´t that one of the best Nikons, pehaps the best DSLR even, of that era?
Small and light lenses, flat field with sharpness to the edges and marvelous colour. I´ll be GASsing as ever before! Imagine, the Aquila line of Zeiss! Imagine! 
Feb 13, 2025 at 02:45 PM
bernardl
Offline
Details
p.17 #3Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
If the new Zeiss is MF then the space left above the voigtlander APO glass is IMHO very narrow, especially considering their incredible bulk to quality ratio and affordable price point, but it will be interesting to see what Zeiss comes up with.

I don’t rule out the possibility that these 5 years were about developing an AF system.

The possibility to license at least Sony and Nikon’s FF mounts opens new options for a company like Zeiss. And, although Sigma has become excellent, we have never had truly high end 3rd party AF lenses.

Cheers,
Bernard
Feb 13, 2025 at 05:26 PM
IlyaSnopchenko
Offline
Details
p.17 #4Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
I have felt for ages now that every manufacturer - yes, including Sigma, Tamron, and now Viltrox and the other Chinese manufacturers - has their own gems that I would have loved to be able to use all together on the same camera(s). Each manufacturer has some unique offerings, not really repeated by anyone else, too. So there is no unequivocal answer...

... However, these days I would, if asked persistently, give the edge to Nikon (Z mount)... If for no other reason than the ability of adapting just about anything to it if need be, including Sony E and Fuji X lenses, thus bringing the notion of universal system one step closer to existence. :-)

I'm not ready to proclaim Nikon the creator of best lenses though, because I'm only using two native Z mount lenses, one of which is a Laowa anyway. :-)

Edited on Mar 20, 2025 at 12:24 AM · View previous versions
Feb 23, 2025 at 02:37 AM
LostLensCap
Offline
Details
p.17 #5Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
I'm a Nikon shooter and will be as long as they are in business. I had a Sony A6000 for a few years but hated the ergonomics as well as the colors rendition. (jmho)
Feb 23, 2025 at 12:48 PM
skibum5
Offline
Details
p.17 #6Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
sungphoto wrote:
Tie between Canon and Nikon. I prefer Nikon ergonomics and control layout, which is why I consolidated to all Nikon and sold off all of my Canon kit a couple years ago. I was never totally happy with Sony glass and the resale value on them is horrible.


Hah I can't stand Nikon ergonomics, sooo bad (best implementation of Sony's top sensors though). Canon definitely has the best (even if their sensors have lagged for stretches, although they are about on par now finally again what with being improved and with other maker's recent sensors actually going backwards a bit in the chase for closer to global shutter).


Mar 20, 2025 at 12:14 AM
skibum5
Offline
Details
p.17 #7Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AlphaPhotography wrote:
It's purely for the sake of discussion and people's experiences across brands. Nothing to read too deeply into. It has been years since I shot Sony but I still love their lineup and compact bodies. I switched to Canon for specific lenses like the 28-70mm f2 which made all the difference in certain shoots over the years from corporate to architecture to events and has been an excellent walk around, albeit heavy. I'm only recently trying Nikon for the first time to see what all the recent hype is about, both with their bodies and lenses like the 135mm Plena,
...Show more →

Canon EF 300mm f/2.8L IS (plain or Mark II) is pretty fantastic.
Canon EF 100mm f/2.8L IS Macro is great.
Canon EF 70-300mm f/4-5.6L IS is a very nice long landscape walkaround lens.
Canon EF 65mm MP-E is pretty wild.
Canon EF 24-70mm f/2.8 Mark II is pretty decent (definitely seem quite some copy variation on it though)

although I see that many of these are also ones recently discontinued
Mar 20, 2025 at 12:21 AM
LostLensCap
Offline
Details
p.17 #8Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AlphaPhotography wrote:
This will obviously be subjective and very opinionated but for those who have shot or currently shoot multiple systems, what company do you feel makes the best lenses? Mainly in terms of IQ but also taking into account things like coatings, autofocus motors, etc. More specifically the mid and upper range lenses.

I previously shot Sony and LOVED many of their GM lenses including the still excellent 135mm f1.8 GM, Sony 24mm f1.4 GM, and Sony 200-600mm. Flare resistance and sharpness were exceptional. Autofocus was always fast and silent. The only issue I saw occasionally was LOCA depending on the lens
...Show more →
After reading all the different lenses and cameras you have owned and used, it is plain to me that you are far more qualified to answer this question than me or most any of us could be. I shoot Nikon and have owned some Sony. I've been able to get good results with either. There are many many satisfied Canon owners out there who swear by their cameras and lenses too. Trying to determine who makes the best anything is an endless rabbit hole these days. (jmho)

Mar 20, 2025 at 07:30 AM
sungphoto
Offline
Details
p.17 #9Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
skibum5 wrote:
sungphoto wroteTie between Canon and Nikon. I prefer Nikon ergonomics and control layout, which is why I consolidated to all Nikon and sold off all of my Canon kit a couple years ago. I was never totally happy with Sony glass and the resale value on them is horrible.
Hah I can't stand Nikon ergonomics, sooo bad (best implementation of Sony's top sensors though). Canon definitely has the best (even if their sensors have lagged for stretches, although they are about on par now finally again what with being improved and with other maker's recent sensors actually going backwards a bit in the chase for closer to global shutter).


Nikon and Canon are definitely the best in terms of ergos. I switched from Sony to Canon about a decade ago when I got tired of Sony reliability issues and providing middling upgrades that could have been accomplished with firmware updates rather than trying to sell a new body every year. I loved Canon colors, but found the RAWs to not be as flexible especially in the highlights for my workflow, whereas Nikon strikes that balance between color, RAW flexibility, ergos and rock solid reliability. The Z8 makes a great video and stills hybrid tool and I don't care who makes the sensors, Nikons just work better.
Mar 20, 2025 at 09:35 AM
JadedWriter
Offline
Details
p.17 #10Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Canon has had known dynamic range issues for years.
sungphoto wrote:
skibum5 wrote
sungphoto wroteTie between Canon and Nikon. I prefer Nikon ergonomics and control layout, which is why I consolidated to all Nikon and sold off all of my Canon kit a couple years ago. I was never totally happy with Sony glass and the resale value on them is horrible.
Hah I can't stand Nikon ergonomics, sooo bad (best implementation of Sony's top sensors though). Canon definitely has the best (even if their sensors have lagged for stretches, although they are about on par now finally again what with being improved and with other maker's recent sensors actually going backwards a bit in the chase for closer to global shutter).
Nikon and Canon are definitely the best in terms of ergos. I switched from Sony to Canon about a decade ago when I got tired of Sony reliability issues and providing middling upgrades that could have been accomplished with firmware updates rather than trying to sell a new body every year. I loved Canon colors, but found the RAWs to not be as flexible especially in the highlights for my workflow, whereas Nikon strikes that balance between color, RAW flexibility, ergos and rock solid reliability. The Z8 makes a great video and stills hybrid tool and I don't care who
...Show more →

Mar 20, 2025 at 10:13 AM
AmbientMike
Offline
[X]
Details
p.17 #11Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?


JadedWriter wrote:
Canon has had known dynamic range issues for years.
sungphoto wrote
skibum5 wrote
sungphoto wroteTie between Canon and Nikon. I prefer Nikon ergonomics and control layout, which is why I consolidated to all Nikon and sold off all of my Canon kit a couple years ago. I was never totally happy with Sony glass and the resale value on them is horrible.
Hah I can't stand Nikon ergonomics, sooo bad (best implementation of Sony's top sensors though). Canon definitely has the best (even if their sensors have lagged for stretches, although they are about on par now finally again what with being improved and with other maker's recent sensors actually going backwards a bit in the chase for closer to global shutter).
Nikon and Canon are definitely the best in terms of ergos. I switched from Sony to Canon about a decade ago when I got tired of Sony reliability issues and providing middling upgrades that could have been accomplished with firmware updates rather than trying to sell a new body every year. I loved Canon colors, but found the RAWs to not be as flexible especially in the highlights for my workflow, whereas Nikon strikes that balance between color, RAW flexibility, ergos and rock solid reliability. The Z8 makes a great video and stills hybrid tool and I don't care who makes the sensors, Nikons just work better.


A9III and to some degree the Z6III don't have it, either, according to one testing site.

Perhaps once DSLR'S basically vanquished, they got back more to reality in terms of DR, as opposed to the incessant, largely nonsense on the issue that seemed play a big part in mirrorless, especially Sony, taking over
Mar 20, 2025 at 10:49 AM
sungphoto
Offline
Details
p.17 #12Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
JadedWriter wrote:
Canon has had known dynamic range issues for years.
sungphoto wrote
skibum5 wrote
sungphoto wroteTie between Canon and Nikon. I prefer Nikon ergonomics and control layout, which is why I consolidated to all Nikon and sold off all of my Canon kit a couple years ago. I was never totally happy with Sony glass and the resale value on them is horrible.
Hah I can't stand Nikon ergonomics, sooo bad (best implementation of Sony's top sensors though). Canon definitely has the best (even if their sensors have lagged for stretches, although they are about on par now finally again what with being improved and with other maker's recent sensors actually going backwards a bit in the chase for closer to global shutter).
Nikon and Canon are definitely the best in terms of ergos. I switched from Sony to Canon about a decade ago when I got tired of Sony reliability issues and providing middling upgrades that could have been accomplished with firmware updates rather than trying to sell a new body every year. I loved Canon colors, but found the RAWs to not be as flexible especially in the highlights for my workflow, whereas Nikon strikes that balance between color, RAW flexibility, ergos and rock solid reliability. The Z8 makes a great video and stills hybrid tool and I don't care who makes the sensors, Nikons just work better.


I think one can mitigate it a bit by shooting a half or full stop under with high contrast scenes or pale subjects or when they're wearing white (a practice I still use with Nikon cameras). It's easier to denoise dark/shadow areas than to recover blown highlights. I can kind of see on the flipside why Canon would be conservative about changing their RAW characteristics if folks are used to a certain workflow. More than half of the pro shooters I know use Canon and their work is fantastic and it doesn't hold them back. I probably would have stuck with Canon if the R5 had come out sooner, but when I switched to Nikon the D850 was the best choice for autofocus (and the Mk2 Sony bodies were still behind in that regard).
Mar 20, 2025 at 01:10 PM
JadedWriter
Offline
Details
p.17 #13Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Yeah a good photographer can get good images out of anything. Vanessa Joy's work is great and she would probably melt if she held a Nikon camera.
sungphoto wrote:
JadedWriter wroteCanon has had known dynamic range issues for years.
sungphoto wrote
skibum5 wrote
sungphoto wroteTie between Canon and Nikon. I prefer Nikon ergonomics and control layout, which is why I consolidated to all Nikon and sold off all of my Canon kit a couple years ago. I was never totally happy with Sony glass and the resale value on them is horrible.
Hah I can't stand Nikon ergonomics, sooo bad (best implementation of Sony's top sensors though). Canon definitely has the best (even if their sensors have lagged for stretches, although they are about on par now finally again what with being improved and with other maker's recent sensors actually going backwards a bit in the chase for closer to global shutter).
Nikon and Canon are definitely the best in terms of ergos. I switched from Sony to Canon about a decade ago when I got tired of Sony reliability issues and providing middling upgrades that could have been accomplished with firmware updates rather than trying to sell a new body every year. I loved Canon colors, but found the RAWs to not be as flexible especially in the highlights for my workflow, whereas Nikon strikes that balance between color, RAW flexibility, ergos and rock solid reliability. The Z8 makes a great video and stills hybrid tool and I don't care who makes the sensors, Nikons just work better.
I think one can mitigate it a bit by shooting a half or full stop under with high contrast scenes or pale subjects or when they're wearing white (a practice I still use with Nikon cameras). It's easier to denoise dark/shadow areas than to recover blown highlights. I can kind of see on the flipside why Canon would be conservative about changing their RAW characteristics if folks are used to a certain workflow. More than half of the pro shooters I know use Canon and their work is fantastic and it doesn't hold them back. I probably would have stuck
...Show more →

AmbientMike wrote:
JadedWriter wroteCanon has had known dynamic range issues for years.
sungphoto wrote
skibum5 wrote
sungphoto wroteTie between Canon and Nikon. I prefer Nikon ergonomics and control layout, which is why I consolidated to all Nikon and sold off all of my Canon kit a couple years ago. I was never totally happy with Sony glass and the resale value on them is horrible.
Hah I can't stand Nikon ergonomics, sooo bad (best implementation of Sony's top sensors though). Canon definitely has the best (even if their sensors have lagged for stretches, although they are about on par now finally again what with being improved and with other maker's recent sensors actually going backwards a bit in the chase for closer to global shutter).
Nikon and Canon are definitely the best in terms of ergos. I switched from Sony to Canon about a decade ago when I got tired of Sony reliability issues and providing middling upgrades that could have been accomplished with firmware updates rather than trying to sell a new body every year. I loved Canon colors, but found the RAWs to not be as flexible especially in the highlights for my workflow, whereas Nikon strikes that balance between color, RAW flexibility, ergos and rock solid reliability. The Z8 makes a great video and stills hybrid tool and I don't care who makes the sensors, Nikons just work better.
A9III and to some degree the Z6III don't have it, either, according to one testing site.

Perhaps once DSLR'S basically vanquished, they got back more to reality in terms of DR, as opposed to the incessant, largely nonsense on the issue that seemed play a big part in mirrorless, especially Sony, taking over


I'm usually more of a real world shooter than I am a chart shooter. I have a Z6III and love it. I see the A9III as like an "additional" camera and not a camera I'd build a system around basically. Could I use one? Yes? Do I want one? Not really. It just doesn't do my bread and butter work well which usually boils down to ad work to the point where I'd need to supplement it with either an A1 or A7RV, which is why I'd take a Z9 over it.


Mar 20, 2025 at 02:26 PM
AmbientMike
Offline
[X]
Details
p.17 #14Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?

JadedWriter wrote:
Yeah a good photographer can get good images out of anything. Vanessa Joy's work is great and she would probably melt if she held a Nikon camera.
sungphoto wrote
JadedWriter wroteCanon has had known dynamic range issues for years.
sungphoto wrote
skibum5 wrote
sungphoto wroteTie between Canon and Nikon. I prefer Nikon ergonomics and control layout, which is why I consolidated to all Nikon and sold off all of my Canon kit a couple years ago. I was never totally happy with Sony glass and the resale value on them is horrible.
Hah I can't stand Nikon ergonomics, sooo bad (best implementation of Sony's top sensors though). Canon definitely has the best (even if their sensors have lagged for stretches, although they are about on par now finally again what with being improved and with other maker's recent sensors actually going backwards a bit in the chase for closer to global shutter).
Nikon and Canon are definitely the best in terms of ergos. I switched from Sony to Canon about a decade ago when I got tired of Sony reliability issues and providing middling upgrades that could have been accomplished with firmware updates rather than trying to sell a new body every year. I loved Canon colors, but found the RAWs to not be as flexible especially in the highlights for my workflow, whereas Nikon strikes that balance between color, RAW flexibility, ergos and rock solid reliability. The Z8 makes a great video and stills hybrid tool and I don't care who makes the sensors, Nikons just work better.
I think one can mitigate it a bit by shooting a half or full stop under with high contrast scenes or pale subjects or when they're wearing white (a practice I still use with Nikon cameras). It's easier to denoise dark/shadow areas than to recover blown highlights. I can kind of see on the flipside why Canon would be conservative about changing their RAW characteristics if folks are used to a certain workflow. More than half of the pro shooters I know use Canon and their work is fantastic and it doesn't hold them back. I probably would have stuck with Canon if the R5 had come out sooner, but when I switched to Nikon the D850 was the best choice for autofocus (and the Mk2 Sony bodies were still behind in that regard).
AmbientMike wrote
JadedWriter wroteCanon has had known dynamic range issues for years.
sungphoto wrote
skibum5 wrote
sungphoto wroteTie between Canon and Nikon. I prefer Nikon ergonomics and control layout, which is why I consolidated to all Nikon and sold off all of my Canon kit a couple years ago. I was never totally happy with Sony glass and the resale value on them is horrible.
Hah I can't stand Nikon ergonomics, sooo bad (best implementation of Sony's top sensors though). Canon definitely has the best (even if their sensors have lagged for stretches, although they are about on par now finally again what with being improved and with other maker's recent sensors actually going backwards a bit in the chase for closer to global shutter).
Nikon and Canon are definitely the best in terms of ergos. I switched from Sony to Canon about a decade ago when I got tired of Sony reliability issues and providing middling upgrades that could have been accomplished with firmware updates rather than trying to sell a new body every year. I loved Canon colors, but found the RAWs to not be as flexible especially in the highlights for my workflow, whereas Nikon strikes that balance between color, RAW flexibility, ergos and rock solid reliability. The Z8 makes a great video and stills hybrid tool and I don't care who makes the sensors, Nikons just work better.
A9III and to some degree the Z6III don't have it, either, according to one testing site.

Perhaps once DSLR'S basically vanquished, they got back more to reality in terms of DR, as opposed to the incessant, largely nonsense on the issue that seemed play a big part in mirrorless, especially Sony, taking over
I'm usually more of a real world shooter than I am a chart shooter. I have a Z6III and love it. I see the A9III as like an "additional" camera and not a camera I'd build a system around basically. Could I use one? Yes? Do I want one? Not really. It just doesn't do my bread and butter work well which usually boils down to ad work to the point where I'd need
...Show more →

You wonder how many people, what percentage, had real issues with DR on Canon cameras. That could have been solved, not too extreme, on the higher DR cameras

First you had to use 400 or less iso or thereabouts to get the high DR, is my understanding. I've managed to get iso lower but I was 800+ most of the time until recently. Z6III got about the same score as 1Dx2 I believe
Mar 20, 2025 at 06:19 PM
niteowl
Offline
Details
p.17 #15Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
I am a bit late to this thread but my answer to the original question Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony? is yes...
Mar 20, 2025 at 08:04 PM
Lee Saxon
Offline
Details
p.17 #16Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
jcolwell wrote:
Cosina.


This is the way. I'm working on having the entire SL collection in Nikon mount. Just added the 125, finally.
Mar 20, 2025 at 09:39 PM
dacha12
Offline
Details
p.17 #17Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
All lenses are so good these days.
Mar 21, 2025 at 08:40 AM
Surfnsun
Offline
Details
p.17 #18Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
One of the most important lessons I’ve learned in photography is to prioritize investing in high-quality glass over chasing the latest camera bodies. After experimenting with a wide range of lenses during my Nikon DSLR days—and trying out even more once I transitioned to Sony—I’ve come to deeply appreciate the lasting value of exceptional optics. I’ve now settled on a trio that I trust completely: the Sony 35mm f/1.4 GM, 50mm f/1.2 GM, and 70-200mm f/2.8 GM II. These lenses have not only elevated my work, but also taught me that while camera bodies will inevitably evolve, great lenses are the true long-term investment.
Mar 21, 2025 at 10:17 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.17 #19Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
One of the most important lessons I’ve learned in photography is to prioritize...

... make the primary focus on learning to see photographically. Using good senses and – especially — lenses that address my real-world functional needs has been important, but there are tons of fine lenses in the world. Chasing after "best lenses" is largely a waste of photographic time.
Mar 21, 2025 at 11:35 AM
tester_V
Offline
Details
p.17 #20Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Leika, from here all the waaaaay to hell....
Mar 26, 2025 at 01:15 AM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister