p.4 #1Official Canon EOS R5 Mark II Images & Specifications
Scott Stoness wrote: arbitrage wroteScott Stoness wrotearbitrage wroteRickPJ wroteI am curious to know this:
Who out there is going to buy this because it does something that their current version, or other camera cannot do acceptably? And what is that need that you are filling?
Are these changes (and the competition between brands on relatively obscure features) a big deal or mostly bragging rights?
In what way does this camera change the game for a working professional or advanced amatur?If I was an R5 shooter, I would buy this day 1 for the following reasons:
1) Stacked sensor...game changer while actively firing on a BIF (I've enjoyed this with A1 and Z8/Z9)
2) RAW precapture...game changer for some really cool shots (I experienced this with A9III)
3) 30FPS over 20....more is always better. (A9III's 120FPS was starting to be a bit overkill but even 60FPS on A9III was great)I think I would would revise your statement to say:
If I was an R5 shooter focussed on BIF or video, I would buy this on day 1. The precapture is nice but not adjustable enough. The buffer is still not as good as it could be (about the same at 30fps as the R5 20fps which is good and bad). It's not yet clear to me if the fps is adjustable from 30fps in electronic. For BIF, the 30fsp and much lessened rolling shutter would be enough to switch but the precaptures already needs a hardware fix for more options on 0.5s.I said "If I"...
FPS can be 20, 15,10,5 (exact same as A1)
30FPS gets you the same 200 CRAW which means at 20FPS one should have a much deeper buffer than the R5. But less shooting time at 30FPS than you would have had at 20FPS (10s down to 6.7s)
Adjustable pre-capture will hopefully be added. At least for most things 0.5s is a happy medium...I used either 0.3 or 0.4s for birds on the A9III. I'd like to see some lower options but I can't see any use of longer ones for my type of photography.Noted about "I". I was not being critical just being helpful to other than "I" I am still looking for the reference to adjustable fps in electronic. Where have you seen this. That would be a big deal to me. It might make the difference to me in pre-ordering. Would cause higher buffer usability and less culling.
Adjustable FPS in ES: DPReview article (someone replied above with the exact quote), Jan's video, Gordon Lang's article (haven't watched his video yet).
Quote from Gordon's article:
"As for burst shooting, the mechanical shutter offers the same 12fps at up to 1/8000 as before, but the electronic shutter has accelerated to a top speed of 30fps at up to 1/32000. In a small but very useful upgrade, you can also select slower frame rates at more intervals including 20, 15, 12, 10, 7.5, 5, 3, 2 or 1fps."
Keeping in mind I am a still landscape and big animal (bear) photographer, with occasional 4k video of my grandson and bears.
$4300
Big Animal:
-30fps electronic - with no 12 bit drop - great on 14 bit but not clear if adjustable which is mostly a negative to me if it does not vs 20fps for capturing too many pictures
- pre burst is improved - not in container - but no ability to set pre burst time - fixed at 0.5s - good for me but will require more culling and bigger card to be useful
- precapture requires more power so older batteries (same form factor) will not be adequate requiring more new batteries - would cost me some money say 5x$100 and obsoletes a bunch of batteries. Newer batteries give higher output but not longer life
- 45mpx / bsi / stacked - delivers much improved rolling shutter but not perfect - good
- sd and cfexpress - type 4? - not - bit improved but not much
[Jan reports - Not much improved buffer based on video above (200craw vs 130 before and possibly stutter after. Was hoping for v4 of Cfexpress (not)] Petapixel says 93 raw on buffer which is perhaps 10% better than r5. Jury is out her for me, if R5ii can improve the 4s buffer clear with my fastest card it could be an improvement but not likely since not v4.
- eye focus where you look- meh so far to me - my eyes are not that good and I wear glasses
- better features - preprogramming people - for sticky - mostly meh for me because my grandson is 10 months and not into sports yet
- analog switch between video and still - good
- no blackout
Video:
- 8k raw 60/fps - meh to me - if I am slow mo'ing bears I want faster
- optional grips for video to manage heat - meh to me but useful to video centric people
- HDMI full - does not matter to me - meh to me but useful to video people
- Jordan - petal pixel says much improved rolling shutter
- more dynamic range re Clog2
- front light to indicate recording - good for video people but I will tape it over to not be noticeable for my bears
- dual shooting - stills while in video
- good on heating for 2 hours with fan grip
- don't see specifically a 30m + recording but canon propaganda above says 2hour video without overheating which implies >30min
Stills/Landscape:
- 45mpx is okay but not improved from r5 - meh to me
- IBIS 8.5 stops - meh to me, I am either action or tripod and my animals move
- Newer batteries give higher output but not longer life - would cost me 5x$100 negative
- have not seen any reports on better or same dynamic range - am looking
Other:
3 optional grips - just more battery, ethernet grip, or cooling grip - all in the range of $650 use - meh to me
My gut feel right now is:
- Preburst is improved to be useful (not container) but would require $500 in new batteries and a much bigger card and culling - okay you can just leave it on with culling penalty.
- 30 fps is better and worse - better in more options but worse in culling, and 14 bit, but its not clear if you can turn the speed down for culling - I would like 12fps electronic for no noise and culling.
- Negatives of $4300 and $500 for new batteries and would need bigger
- dynamic range - still reading reviews and not sure where this is at
- Rolling shutter is way improved, but this is not a big deal for me in video and stills
- Buffer not much improved as reported yet.
- Analog video vs stills is good
I am not preordering yet. Most of the features added are more for BIF and video. For mostly still photographers, the R5II is not much improved over the already excellent R5 (good news for buying R5).
For video centric shooters, the R5ii is a must have for clog2, heat management with fan grip, and poxy and other features.
For BIF centric shooter, lots of improvements (biggest is much improved rolling shutter, 14 bit electronic and preburst [with culling issues]), improved A/f, it feels like desirable but marginal. [14 bit does not matter much at high iso, pre burst will come with lots of work eg 30vs20fps and fixed 0.5s and lots of new batteries]. Most serious BIF people will be highly tempted but frustrated to be stuck in Canon system (batteries, culling) but get over it.
So I think in total, its not as good as the Nikon z8 but its great, and its not much of an improvement from R5ii for stills --- so if you have lots of Canon lens and are BIF and Video focussed, it will be good for you. For landscape, so far it appears that 5dsr (50mpx, no aa) and R5 (price) are more tempting.
As a Canon captive photographer (enough lens to stay and good enough), I would like Canon to remain #1 in market, so that ancillary are readily available. I think they have missed the boat on precapture, and buffer performance - and will cause switching to Nikon. Perhaps Canon can fix some issues (precapture, buffer, variable fps) in hardware updates, but why did they not get this right after several years. I think the video capability is going to be very appealing to video people. The R1 has too little mpx to be a serious choice for landscape or cropping.I think you might be wrong about a few of your assumptions here.
According to DPReview, the R5 Mark II frame rate is variable in electronic shutter mode:
Earlier quoteIf 30fps is too much for the shooting you do, the camera can be customized to shoot at 20, 15, 10 or 5fps instead...According to Petapixel, RAW buffer depth is effectively doubled if shooting C-RAW.
The camera is being reported now to be 14-bit in all capture modes.
Nobody has had a chance yet to evaluate the camera's eye control, or new "smart" features like blur detection for automatic culling in a burst, registered person recognition, or the new activity-aware autofocus algorithms. For certain photographers with certain workflows, these features could be game changers.
Other than having a slightly faster sensor readout speed, I'm not sure what you feel puts the Z8 ahead of this camera....Show more →
The Nikon does not pause for 4s after the buffer is filled - it just slows down. But if you are right about adjustable fps in electronic this solves the issue.
Keeping in mind I am a still landscape and big animal (bear) photographer, with occasional 4k video of my grandson and bears.
$4300
Big Animal:
-30fps electronic - with no 12 bit drop - great on 14 bit but not clear if adjustable which is mostly a negative to me if it does not vs 20fps for capturing too many pictures
- pre burst is improved - not in container - but no ability to set pre burst time - fixed at 0.5s - good for me but will require more culling and bigger card to be useful
- precapture requires more power so older batteries (same form factor) will not be adequate requiring more new batteries - would cost me some money say 5x$100 and obsoletes a bunch of batteries. Newer batteries give higher output but not longer life
- 45mpx / bsi / stacked - delivers much improved rolling shutter but not perfect - good
- sd and cfexpress - type 4? - not - bit improved but not much
[Jan reports - Not much improved buffer based on video above (200craw vs 130 before and possibly stutter after. Was hoping for v4 of Cfexpress (not)] Petapixel says 93 raw on buffer which is perhaps 10% better than r5. Jury is out her for me, if R5ii can improve the 4s buffer clear with my fastest card it could be an improvement but not likely since not v4.
- eye focus where you look- meh so far to me - my eyes are not that good and I wear glasses
- better features - preprogramming people - for sticky - mostly meh for me because my grandson is 10 months and not into sports yet
- analog switch between video and still - good
- no blackout
Video:
- 8k raw 60/fps - meh to me - if I am slow mo'ing bears I want faster
- optional grips for video to manage heat - meh to me but useful to video centric people
- HDMI full - does not matter to me - meh to me but useful to video people
- Jordan - petal pixel says much improved rolling shutter
- more dynamic range re Clog2
- front light to indicate recording - good for video people but I will tape it over to not be noticeable for my bears
- dual shooting - stills while in video
- good on heating for 2 hours with fan grip
- don't see specifically a 30m + recording but canon propaganda above says 2hour video without overheating which implies >30min
Stills/Landscape:
- 45mpx is okay but not improved from r5 - meh to me
- IBIS 8.5 stops - meh to me, I am either action or tripod and my animals move
- Newer batteries give higher output but not longer life - would cost me 5x$100 negative
- have not seen any reports on better or same dynamic range - am looking
Other:
3 optional grips - just more battery, ethernet grip, or cooling grip - all in the range of $650 use - meh to me
My gut feel right now is:
- Preburst is improved to be useful (not container) but would require $500 in new batteries and a much bigger card and culling - okay you can just leave it on with culling penalty.
- 30 fps is better and worse - better in more options but worse in culling, and 14 bit, but its not clear if you can turn the speed down for culling - I would like 12fps electronic for no noise and culling.
- Negatives of $4300 and $500 for new batteries and would need bigger
- dynamic range - still reading reviews and not sure where this is at
- Rolling shutter is way improved, but this is not a big deal for me in video and stills
- Buffer not much improved as reported yet.
- Analog video vs stills is good
I am not preordering yet. Most of the features added are more for BIF and video. For mostly still photographers, the R5II is not much improved over the already excellent R5 (good news for buying R5).
For video centric shooters, the R5ii is a must have for clog2, heat management with fan grip, and poxy and other features.
For BIF centric shooter, lots of improvements (biggest is much improved rolling shutter, 14 bit electronic and preburst [with culling issues]), improved A/f, it feels like desirable but marginal. [14 bit does not matter much at high iso, pre burst will come with lots of work eg 30vs20fps and fixed 0.5s and lots of new batteries]. Most serious BIF people will be highly tempted but frustrated to be stuck in Canon system (batteries, culling) but get over it.
So I think in total, its not as good as the Nikon z8 but its great, and its not much of an improvement from R5ii for stills --- so if you have lots of Canon lens and are BIF and Video focussed, it will be good for you. For landscape, so far it appears that 5dsr (50mpx, no aa) and R5 (price) are more tempting.
As a Canon captive photographer (enough lens to stay and good enough), I would like Canon to remain #1 in market, so that ancillary are readily available. I think they have missed the boat on precapture, and buffer performance - and will cause switching to Nikon. Perhaps Canon can fix some issues (precapture, buffer, variable fps) in hardware updates, but why did they not get this right after several years. I think the video capability is going to be very appealing to video people. The R1 has too little mpx to be a serious choice for landscape or cropping.I think you might be wrong about a few of your assumptions here.
According to DPReview, the R5 Mark II frame rate is variable in electronic shutter mode:
Earlier quoteIf 30fps is too much for the shooting you do, the camera can be customized to shoot at 20, 15, 10 or 5fps instead...According to Petapixel, RAW buffer depth is effectively doubled if shooting C-RAW.
The camera is being reported now to be 14-bit in all capture modes.
Nobody has had a chance yet to evaluate the camera's eye control, or new "smart" features like blur detection for automatic culling in a burst, registered person recognition, or the new activity-aware autofocus algorithms. For certain photographers with certain workflows, these features could be game changers.
Other than having a slightly faster sensor readout speed, I'm not sure what you feel puts the Z8 ahead of this camera....Show more →
It's not really slightly faster...it's fairly substantially faster readout (between 1/125 and 1/160s for the R5II, 1/270s for the Z8). However, overall, yes, they are fairly comparable bodies. It's worth noting that while the Z8's buffer is 'only' around 100 shots at 20fps in uncompressed RAW, Nikon's HE* format produces effectively identical image quality, and increases the buffer to 670 shots. The HE RAW format, which is just a touch lossier (and still generally imperceptable difference except in very specific low ISO scenarios with lots of shadows), it is effectively unlimited.
p.4 #8Official Canon EOS R5 Mark II Images & Specifications
Today is the last day for Rakuten 10% Cash Back at Canon Online for those with a Rakuten account. The cash back will apply to pre-orders paid for with a credit card.
p.4 #9Official Canon EOS R5 Mark II Images & Specifications
Wins:
- stacked sensor
- useable electronic shutter
- RAW pre-capture
- improved AF (to be confirmed?)
- on/off switch moved to right side of camera
- full-size HDMI port
Fails:
- no dual cards slots - still two mis-matched slots
- no tilting LCD - same old selfie screen
- requires new batteries
- no exposure zebras in stills mode (to be confirmed?)
p.4 #10Official Canon EOS R5 Mark II Images & Specifications
molson wrote:
Wins:
- stacked sensor
- useable electronic shutter
- RAW pre-capture
- improved AF (to be confirmed?)
- on/off switch moved to right side of camera
- full-size HDMI port
Fails:
- no dual cards slots - still two mis-matched slots
- no tilting LCD - same old selfie screen
- requires new batteries
- no exposure zebras in stills mode (to be confirmed?)
A small win for me is being able to shoot 1/32000th in ES mode. This helps when shooting f/1.2 in hot light and a few other scenarios
p.4 #13Official Canon EOS R5 Mark II Images & Specifications
Jeff wrote: artsupreme wroteSurprisingly it looks like the R5II is 68g lighter than the R5 with batteries and cards. A small win.Depends on what they removed to make that happen.
Dimensions are slightly different, but I thought for sure the R5Ii would be heavier
p.4 #14Official Canon EOS R5 Mark II Images & Specifications
I wish Canon had announced some mid-priced, high quality, lightweight, long telephotos to go along with this body. It might have been sufficient to make me want to return to the fold. Sadly, they did not though if by some miracle they do at least I have a couple of decent bodies to choose from.
p.4 #15Official Canon EOS R5 Mark II Images & Specifications
I would just like to say one thing:
My god are cameras today insanely good. We can argue small improvements here and there, of course, but when you look at what these bodies can do it's truly astounding. The image quality, autofocus, speed, in-body stabilization, buffer depth (especially), video, etc. It's all just light years beyond what was capable 10-15 years ago. Crazy times, to be honest.
p.4 #16Official Canon EOS R5 Mark II Images & Specifications
Jman13 wrote:
I would just like to say one thing:
My god are cameras today insanely good. We can argue small improvements here and there, of course, but when you look at what these bodies can do it's truly astounding. The image quality, autofocus, speed, in-body stabilization, buffer depth (especially), video, etc. It's all just light years beyond what was capable 10-15 years ago. Crazy times, to be honest.
That’s a really important and accurate perspective.
Virtually all of today’s cameras are very, very good. We can do things — often with great ease — that we wouldn’t have imaged just a couple of decades ago. The idea that we can produce really excellent 40’ x 60” prints from “35mm” systems would have been regarded as laughable in the late 1900s.
Yet here we are.
Even more impressive: If you account for inflation the costs of this gear have actually gone down over time.
p.4 #17Official Canon EOS R5 Mark II Images & Specifications
armd wrote:
I wish Canon had announced some mid-priced, high quality, lightweight, long telephotos to go along with this body. It might have been sufficient to make me want to return to the fold. Sadly, they did not though if by some miracle they do at least I have a couple of decent bodies to choose from.
I agree 100%
A couple of fast, wide primes would be nice, too - along the lines of the Sony 14mm f1.8 GM and 20mm f1.8G. Right now, Canon's widest L-series prime is the newly announced 35mm f1.4...
I had been hoping there might have been one or two new lenses announced along with the new cameras.
p.4 #18Official Canon EOS R5 Mark II Images & Specifications
molson wrote:
Wins:
- stacked sensor
- useable electronic shutter
- RAW pre-capture
- improved AF (to be confirmed?)
- on/off switch moved to right side of camera
- full-size HDMI port
Fails:
- no dual cards slots - still two mis-matched slots
- no tilting LCD - same old selfie screen
- requires new batteries
- no exposure zebras in stills mode (to be confirmed?)
Adding
Good:
- much lessened rolling shutter
- 30fps capable
- variable electronic fps speed in 14 bit
Bad:
- 45 mpx with AA instead of 85 without
- not new cfexpress v4 for faster buffer
p.4 #19Official Canon EOS R5 Mark II Images & Specifications
Since the Z8 is the R5II's closest competitor, one big win for the Canon is size and weight. I can carry two R5II's and an RF 35.14 for the same weight as just two Z8's without a lens. There's about a 1 pound difference between two R5II's and two Z8's. The R5II is also more compact for those who care.
Battery grip
Battery grip plus ethernet
Battery grip plus ethernet and cooling
Somehow the cooling version costs $150 less MSRP than the one without the cooling fan. As far as I can tell they offer the same functionality.
BHPhoto confirms this discrepancy, but the pricing is much less than the made up MSRP numbers.
BG = $349
BG + Eth = $499
BG + Eth + cooling = $399
And those prices also match the Canon USA store.
It seems like Canon is incentivizing you to take the one with the cooling fan.
I think you may want to double check this but it looks to me the last one has only Ethernet and cooling and no battery compartment. I believe B&H may have listed the spec incorrectly which is why it is cheaper.