fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2024 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2024Canon r1 official announcement.

  
 
artsupreme
Offline
Details
p.21 #1Canon r1 official announcement.
CelesteForza wrote:
My dream would be an R3 II with newest AF and R5 II sensor.


That should be the R1 at minimum, but we'll see next week.
Jul 12, 2024 at 01:05 PM
mbrown
Offline
Details
p.21 #2Canon r1 official announcement.
I will second the idea of putting the r5ii sensor in the r3ii body. That would be a camera I would gladly put down R1 money for.
Jul 13, 2024 at 10:21 AM
JaimitoFrog
Offline
Details
p.21 #3Canon r1 official announcement.
Flippy screen open

So far little changes from R3 exterior wise, but improved.

https://www.canonrumors.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/eosr1back-1.jpg


Jul 16, 2024 at 06:45 PM
ISO1600
Offline
Details
p.21 #4Canon r1 official announcement.
WHAT is that little camera/sensor on the bottom left corner? Is that just a light sensor for display dimming? Some kind of new remote control receiver? Or is it a tiny camera to get selfies of your face during the action?
Jul 16, 2024 at 11:39 PM
gkinard1952
Offline
Details
p.21 #5Canon r1 official announcement.
Sony and Nikon have to shaking in their boots... What a joke.
Jul 17, 2024 at 05:21 AM
bernardl
Offline
Details
p.21 #6Canon r1 official announcement.
gkinard1952 wrote:
Sony and Nikon have to shaking in their boots... What a joke.


I hear the Moet is running out of champaign due to the huge parties on-going in Shinagawa (Sony HQ) and Nishioi (Nikon HQ).

Well... cameras are just tools, it's all about photographer talent...

Cheers,
Bernard
Jul 17, 2024 at 06:14 AM
robert_in_ca
Offline
Details
p.21 #7Canon r1 official announcement.
What's your thoughts on R1 being only 24mp?

AmbientMike wrote:
arbitrage wrote
AmbientMike wrote
arbitrage wrote
rscheffler wroteWhat are pros looking for in a flagship body? All-in-one ruggedized body? Can the a1 actually be included because it uses a separate add-on vertical grip? Is the Z9 the only true option if you need/want a high MP 'pro' body? Perhaps this is an indicator of how truly niche the top-end pro market has become. (How many of the Z9 users could not instead use a Z8?)

Some of the R5's shortcomings - heat and battery life - are the reality of it being 4 years old; some of its components are likely even older. Those deficits will be addressed in the Mark II version and it will also be a lot faster. Just the two year gap between the R6 and R6II resulted in significant improvements in these metrics.

As a former life-long 1-series user (since the original EOS-1), at least as far as I'm concerned, I'm happy to have a 'pro' camera with an optional vertical grip. It gives me the choice of a smaller configuration when it's a priority, or add the grip when I need that convenience. I won't complain if Canon improves 5 series durability, weather sealing and improves the add-on grip's ergonomics.
Yeah, after knowing there were R1s at the Monaco GP, I kept a close eye on the photogs after the race during the ceremony etc. I saw a lot of them using flippy screens on non-gripped bodies. And these guys were getting jostled around like in a mosh pit trying to get shots of Leclerc's post race celebration.....these pros didn't have to have a rugged 100lb body to shoot professional sports. Some of them probably like the big tanks but a lot of them value other things.
Do you have a non rumor source saying 24mp? Is there anything besides CR? A lot of assumptions being made, I dont think anyone really knows

If you are going to gripe at Dave's positivity, you probably need to be griping at the negativity based on unknown specs
No. So far only CR has been saying it is 24MP.
I don't know who really knows. I try to read between the lines and the fact that just a few days earlier CR had their 30MP rumour out and then started talking about 24MP was odd but the guy seems really confident in the CR forum comments he makes.

I'm not griping at Dave's positivity, just wanting to know where he heard such praise for the AF. I'm fine with that being on a rumour site just like the 24MP spec is. If he is just making that up then I think that does a disservice to the Canon fans.

I'd say the R1's biggest competition in AF will be the A9III....I wouldn't be surprised that the R1 surpasses the A9III in many areas if not all areas. R1 could easily hold the AF title for a few months until the A1II comes out

If you go back and read some of my posts you will see I've actually defended Canon's choice of 24MPs. But I'd also see reason for it to be 45MP so we will wait and see. I'm confused where the R3 sits if it is 24MPs. Would make more sense looking at the entire Canon lineup that it is 45MP but we shall see.

Maybe you and Dave should make a dinner date for the R1 announcement....Dave knows some great restaurants that really know how to make a delicious plate of crow. Don't worry, I've got my preferred crow restaurant on speed dial just in case. It can go either way
Well, I'll probably just watch them fly around, if my 45+ mp guess is wrong, kind of like I usually do as opposed to eating them. Although I wouldn't discourage someone who is feeling down over their R1 predictions gone wrong from going out to nice restaurant Are you gonna get rid of that pokey old A1 if the 2 ms rumor pans out?

Pretty much verything I'm reading says high mp to me, although I can see that they'd be interested in keeping the sports shooters happy since they buy expensive cameras and lenses and being seen on
...Show more →

Jul 17, 2024 at 03:15 PM
AmbientMike
Offline
[X]
Details
p.21 #8Canon r1 official announcement.

robert_in_ca wrote:
What's your thoughts on R1 being only 24mp?

AmbientMike wrote
arbitrage wrote
AmbientMike wrote
arbitrage wrote
rscheffler wroteWhat are pros looking for in a flagship body? All-in-one ruggedized body? Can the a1 actually be included because it uses a separate add-on vertical grip? Is the Z9 the only true option if you need/want a high MP 'pro' body? Perhaps this is an indicator of how truly niche the top-end pro market has become. (How many of the Z9 users could not instead use a Z8?)

Some of the R5's shortcomings - heat and battery life - are the reality of it being 4 years old; some of its components are likely even older. Those deficits will be addressed in the Mark II version and it will also be a lot faster. Just the two year gap between the R6 and R6II resulted in significant improvements in these metrics.

As a former life-long 1-series user (since the original EOS-1), at least as far as I'm concerned, I'm happy to have a 'pro' camera with an optional vertical grip. It gives me the choice of a smaller configuration when it's a priority, or add the grip when I need that convenience. I won't complain if Canon improves 5 series durability, weather sealing and improves the add-on grip's ergonomics.
Yeah, after knowing there were R1s at the Monaco GP, I kept a close eye on the photogs after the race during the ceremony etc. I saw a lot of them using flippy screens on non-gripped bodies. And these guys were getting jostled around like in a mosh pit trying to get shots of Leclerc's post race celebration.....these pros didn't have to have a rugged 100lb body to shoot professional sports. Some of them probably like the big tanks but a lot of them value other things.
Do you have a non rumor source saying 24mp? Is there anything besides CR? A lot of assumptions being made, I dont think anyone really knows

If you are going to gripe at Dave's positivity, you probably need to be griping at the negativity based on unknown specs
No. So far only CR has been saying it is 24MP.
I don't know who really knows. I try to read between the lines and the fact that just a few days earlier CR had their 30MP rumour out and then started talking about 24MP was odd but the guy seems really confident in the CR forum comments he makes.

I'm not griping at Dave's positivity, just wanting to know where he heard such praise for the AF. I'm fine with that being on a rumour site just like the 24MP spec is. If he is just making that up then I think that does a disservice to the Canon fans.

I'd say the R1's biggest competition in AF will be the A9III....I wouldn't be surprised that the R1 surpasses the A9III in many areas if not all areas. R1 could easily hold the AF title for a few months until the A1II comes out

If you go back and read some of my posts you will see I've actually defended Canon's choice of 24MPs. But I'd also see reason for it to be 45MP so we will wait and see. I'm confused where the R3 sits if it is 24MPs. Would make more sense looking at the entire Canon lineup that it is 45MP but we shall see.

Maybe you and Dave should make a dinner date for the R1 announcement....Dave knows some great restaurants that really know how to make a delicious plate of crow. Don't worry, I've got my preferred crow restaurant on speed dial just in case. It can go either way
Well, I'll probably just watch them fly around, if my 45+ mp guess is wrong, kind of like I usually do as opposed to eating them. Although I wouldn't discourage someone who is feeling down over their R1 predictions gone wrong from going out to nice restaurant Are you gonna get rid of that pokey old A1 if the 2 ms rumor pans out?

Pretty much verything I'm reading says high mp to me, although I can see that they'd be interested in keeping the sports shooters happy since they buy expensive cameras and lenses and being seen on the sideline is good for sales, in general. 24mp really is enough for pretty much everything imo, yes I remember reading your post defending 24mp, something said about wanting more pixels as opposed to actual needs, though

They could crop highest quality 8k out of 39-40mp 3:2 sensor, 40mp being preferred by marketing. Taking a year delay to get the speeds higher sounds like higher mp to me, while CR sounds accurate, and I suppose 4k highest quality these days but in general highest quality video sounds more like 8k to me. The Canon batteries to date have been 2 or 3 li ion batteries, 15v might be 4 at nominal 3.7v, so might have improved performance if accurate


It's an A9 III competitor at about the same price. Not exactly the worst thing on the world.

The A9III is only 0.20 stops better DR on Bill Claff's site vs 5DsR, so I guess it's no good, if you are going to apply all the negativity DSLR'S got. R1 could be significantly better

After the C700 came out having 6k it's not too surprising the R1 doesn't. The guy really pushing me to buy into 24mp rumor started a thread a day or two ago complaining about some of the CR issues, part of the reason I didn't necessarily buy into every the CR guy said. He got the 24mp right this time though after all

Jul 17, 2024 at 04:14 PM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.21 #9Canon r1 official announcement.
AmbientMike wrote:
robert_in_ca wroteWhat's your thoughts on R1 being only 24mp?

AmbientMike wrote
arbitrage wrote
AmbientMike wrote
arbitrage wroteYeah, after knowing there were R1s at the Monaco GP, I kept a close eye on the photogs after the race during the ceremony etc. I saw a lot of them using flippy screens on non-gripped bodies. And these guys were getting jostled around like in a mosh pit trying to get shots of Leclerc's post race celebration.....these pros didn't have to have a rugged 100lb body to shoot professional sports. Some of them probably like the big tanks but a lot of them value other things.
Do you have a non rumor source saying 24mp? Is there anything besides CR? A lot of assumptions being made, I dont think anyone really knows

If you are going to gripe at Dave's positivity, you probably need to be griping at the negativity based on unknown specs
No. So far only CR has been saying it is 24MP.
I don't know who really knows. I try to read between the lines and the fact that just a few days earlier CR had their 30MP rumour out and then started talking about 24MP was odd but the guy seems really confident in the CR forum comments he makes.

I'm not griping at Dave's positivity, just wanting to know where he heard such praise for the AF. I'm fine with that being on a rumour site just like the 24MP spec is. If he is just making that up then I think that does a disservice to the Canon fans.

I'd say the R1's biggest competition in AF will be the A9III....I wouldn't be surprised that the R1 surpasses the A9III in many areas if not all areas. R1 could easily hold the AF title for a few months until the A1II comes out

If you go back and read some of my posts you will see I've actually defended Canon's choice of 24MPs. But I'd also see reason for it to be 45MP so we will wait and see. I'm confused where the R3 sits if it is 24MPs. Would make more sense looking at the entire Canon lineup that it is 45MP but we shall see.

Maybe you and Dave should make a dinner date for the R1 announcement....Dave knows some great restaurants that really know how to make a delicious plate of crow. Don't worry, I've got my preferred crow restaurant on speed dial just in case. It can go either way
Well, I'll probably just watch them fly around, if my 45+ mp guess is wrong, kind of like I usually do as opposed to eating them. Although I wouldn't discourage someone who is feeling down over their R1 predictions gone wrong from going out to nice restaurant Are you gonna get rid of that pokey old A1 if the 2 ms rumor pans out?

Pretty much verything I'm reading says high mp to me, although I can see that they'd be interested in keeping the sports shooters happy since they buy expensive cameras and lenses and being seen on the sideline is good for sales, in general. 24mp really is enough for pretty much everything imo, yes I remember reading your post defending 24mp, something said about wanting more pixels as opposed to actual needs, though

They could crop highest quality 8k out of 39-40mp 3:2 sensor, 40mp being preferred by marketing. Taking a year delay to get the speeds higher sounds like higher mp to me, while CR sounds accurate, and I suppose 4k highest quality these days but in general highest quality video sounds more like 8k to me. The Canon batteries to date have been 2 or 3 li ion batteries, 15v might be 4 at nominal 3.7v, so might have improved performance if accurate
It's an A9 III competitor at about the same price. Not exactly the worst thing on the world.

The A9III is only 0.20 stops better DR on Bill Claff's site vs 5DsR, so I guess it's no good, if you are going to apply all the negativity DSLR'S got. R1 could be significantly better

After the C700 came out having 6k it's not too surprising the R1 doesn't. The guy really pushing me to buy into 24mp rumor started a thread a day or two ago complaining about some of the CR issues, part of the reason I didn't necessarily buy into
...Show more →

I think you are reading the scale wrong...5DSR is 1/2 stop worse at the A9III's base ISO of 250 and 1/2 stop worse when the A9III goes through its' dual-gain step at ISO 800. At other ISO values it gets closer.
Jul 18, 2024 at 06:22 AM
AmbientMike
Offline
[X]
Details
p.21 #10Canon r1 official announcement.
arbitrage wrote:
AmbientMike wrote
robert_in_ca wroteWhat's your thoughts on R1 being only 24mp?

AmbientMike wrote
arbitrage wrote
AmbientMike wroteDo you have a non rumor source saying 24mp? Is there anything besides CR? A lot of assumptions being made, I dont think anyone really knows

If you are going to gripe at Dave's positivity, you probably need to be griping at the negativity based on unknown specs
No. So far only CR has been saying it is 24MP.
I don't know who really knows. I try to read between the lines and the fact that just a few days earlier CR had their 30MP rumour out and then started talking about 24MP was odd but the guy seems really confident in the CR forum comments he makes.

I'm not griping at Dave's positivity, just wanting to know where he heard such praise for the AF. I'm fine with that being on a rumour site just like the 24MP spec is. If he is just making that up then I think that does a disservice to the Canon fans.

I'd say the R1's biggest competition in AF will be the A9III....I wouldn't be surprised that the R1 surpasses the A9III in many areas if not all areas. R1 could easily hold the AF title for a few months until the A1II comes out

If you go back and read some of my posts you will see I've actually defended Canon's choice of 24MPs. But I'd also see reason for it to be 45MP so we will wait and see. I'm confused where the R3 sits if it is 24MPs. Would make more sense looking at the entire Canon lineup that it is 45MP but we shall see.

Maybe you and Dave should make a dinner date for the R1 announcement....Dave knows some great restaurants that really know how to make a delicious plate of crow. Don't worry, I've got my preferred crow restaurant on speed dial just in case. It can go either way
Well, I'll probably just watch them fly around, if my 45+ mp guess is wrong, kind of like I usually do as opposed to eating them. Although I wouldn't discourage someone who is feeling down over their R1 predictions gone wrong from going out to nice restaurant Are you gonna get rid of that pokey old A1 if the 2 ms rumor pans out?

Pretty much verything I'm reading says high mp to me, although I can see that they'd be interested in keeping the sports shooters happy since they buy expensive cameras and lenses and being seen on the sideline is good for sales, in general. 24mp really is enough for pretty much everything imo, yes I remember reading your post defending 24mp, something said about wanting more pixels as opposed to actual needs, though

They could crop highest quality 8k out of 39-40mp 3:2 sensor, 40mp being preferred by marketing. Taking a year delay to get the speeds higher sounds like higher mp to me, while CR sounds accurate, and I suppose 4k highest quality these days but in general highest quality video sounds more like 8k to me. The Canon batteries to date have been 2 or 3 li ion batteries, 15v might be 4 at nominal 3.7v, so might have improved performance if accurate
It's an A9 III competitor at about the same price. Not exactly the worst thing on the world.

The A9III is only 0.20 stops better DR on Bill Claff's site vs 5DsR, so I guess it's no good, if you are going to apply all the negativity DSLR'S got. R1 could be significantly better

After the C700 came out having 6k it's not too surprising the R1 doesn't. The guy really pushing me to buy into 24mp rumor started a thread a day or two ago complaining about some of the CR issues, part of the reason I didn't necessarily buy into every the CR guy said. He got the 24mp right this time though after all
I think you are reading the scale wrong...5DSR is 1/2 stop worse at the A9III's base ISO of 250 and 1/2 stop worse when the A9III goes through its' dual-gain step at ISO 800. At other ISO values it gets closer.



No, I'm looking at the maximum PDR numbers. 5DsR is 9.80 stops, A9 III is 10.00

I pulled up the graphs, mostly they are very similar. Even the couple little spots having a notch don't give much advantage
Jul 18, 2024 at 09:05 AM
plasticmoz
Offline
Details
p.21 #11Canon r1 official announcement.
Will be interesting to see how the price and aftermarket holds for this as sales get going end of year and early next.

Personally as someone who is shooting more sports the dedicated autofocus modes look great but completely happy with my R3 and should get me more mileage. Curious to see how popular the R1 actually ends up being as well as how motivated they will be to do updates and add SW features.
Jul 21, 2024 at 02:30 PM
drobertfranz
Offline
Details
p.21 #12Canon r1 official announcement.
R1 not getting much love.. Wonder why? It will be a great camera for the target market but far from a great at everything flagship camera we were all hoping for. The announcement did clear up a health issue, my GAS is gone! Worked better than beano!
Jul 22, 2024 at 08:13 AM
mawz
Offline
Details
p.21 #13Canon r1 official announcement.
drobertfranz wrote:
R1 not getting much love.. Wonder why? It will be a great camera for the target market but far from a great at everything flagship camera we were all hoping for. The announcement did clear up a health issue, my GAS is gone! Worked better than beano!


We're really not the target market for it. It's more focused on the needs of the 1D X III owner looking to upgrade (namely a LOT of working Pro's already in the space where robust connectivity, high performance AF and workflow speed beat pixels) than on the average user, unlike the Z9 or A1.
Jul 22, 2024 at 08:17 AM
garyvot
Offline
Details
p.21 #14Canon r1 official announcement.
drobertfranz wrote:
It will be a great camera for the target market but far from a great at everything flagship camera we were all hoping for.


Other than resolution, is there something else that makes this camera "far from great at everything"? As far as I can tell, it is incredibly capable at what it does, and breaks new ground in AF and in DR vs. the level of performance on offer.

I'm not even sure the 24Mp resolution is that limiting, given the already good (and improving) quality of AI upscaling--but that's a separate discussion.

Regardless, the R1 is not trying to be a "do everything" camera. It is a special-purpose dedicated sports/action camera intended to offer the highest level of speed and AF performance Canon can offer, like all 1-series models in the last 15-20 years.

"It's not innovative like the A9III".

No global shutter? Sure. But Canon has built a stacked BSI sensor having 2.7ms readout speed (faster even than the mechanical shutter in the 1DX Mark III) and with14-bits of resolution... This means the R1 will deliver excellent IQ and noise performance vs. the Sony, with an almost imperceptible level of rolling shutter. I know which compromise *I* would rather make in a 24Mp camera.

If a higher native resolution "do everything" model is needed, then the 5-series is there (as always) as the Canon alternative. As far as I can tell, the difference with the R5 Mark II vs.older 5-series models is that there is almost no performance compromise. While slower than the R1 or A9III, the R5 II easily performs at "flagship" level relative to the competition's "do everything" cameras. It just doesn't have an integrated grip (see, "Sony"), or a "1" in its name.

I think when the dust settles, and the anti-Canon brigade gets bored and moves on, there will be a more nuanced discussion of the benefits and tradeoffs of the R1. But just as with the 1DX models before it, there will likely not be much talk about it here on the FM Canon forum, because most of us do not fit the target audience for this camera.
Jul 22, 2024 at 09:40 AM
rscheffler
Offline
Details
p.21 #15Canon r1 official announcement.
I agree Gary. I also applaud Canon designing a solution to assist with culling the massive increase in images these types of cameras can generate from an average sports event. If I shoot the R6II at 40fps, I'm frequently in the 10,000 images range from a standard American football game, which indeed means more time sifting through images afterwards. While I find mirrorless is actually easier to cull, because most images are correctly focused (DSLR was more hit or miss, meaning more time spent confirming focus of individual images), I would still appreciate seeing a tag to confirm this while browsing thumbnails for images with peak subject content. I really hope this feature trickles down to at least the R6III.
Jul 22, 2024 at 10:16 AM
drobertfranz
Offline
Details
p.21 #16Canon r1 official announcement.
mawz wrote:
drobertfranz wroteR1 not getting much love.. Wonder why? It will be a great camera for the target market but far from a great at everything flagship camera we were all hoping for. The announcement did clear up a health issue, my GAS is gone! Worked better than beano!
We're really not the target market for it. It's more focused on the needs of the 1D X III owner looking to upgrade (namely a LOT of working Pro's already in the space where robust connectivity, high performance AF and workflow speed beat pixels) than on the average user, unlike the Z9 or A1.


I agree with that it but is still dissapointing. I've always used an Eos1 body since the original Eos1 film camera. Didn't get the 1dxmk3 nor will I get the R1. I do really miss having the 1 series. but I couldn't drop coin on a camera not ideal for my market. I will eventually pick up the R52 and it does fit my need in most ways.
Jul 22, 2024 at 11:32 AM
drobertfranz
Offline
Details
p.21 #17Canon r1 official announcement.
garyvot wrote:
drobertfranz wroteIt will be a great camera for the target market but far from a great at everything flagship camera we were all hoping for.
Other than resolution, is there something else that makes this camera "far from great at everything"? As far as I can tell, it is incredibly capable at what it does, and breaks new ground in AF and in DR vs. the level of performance on offer.

I'm not even sure the 24Mp resolution is that limiting, given the already good (and improving) quality of AI upscaling--but that's a separate discussion.

Regardless, the R1 is not trying to be a "do everything" camera. It is a special-purpose dedicated sports/action camera intended to offer the highest level of speed and AF performance Canon
...Show more →

It's all about resolution for me. R1 will likely be best in class for it's target market.
Jul 22, 2024 at 11:36 AM
adamx12m
Offline
Details
p.21 #18Canon r1 official announcement.
drobertfranz wrote:
garyvot wrote
drobertfranz wroteIt will be a great camera for the target market but far from a great at everything flagship camera we were all hoping for.
Other than resolution, is there something else that makes this camera "far from great at everything"? As far as I can tell, it is incredibly capable at what it does, and breaks new ground in AF and in DR vs. the level of performance on offer.

I'm not even sure the 24Mp resolution is that limiting, given the already good (and improving) quality of AI upscaling--but that's a separate discussion.

Regardless, the R1 is not trying to be a "do everything" camera. It is a special-purpose dedicated sports/action camera intended to offer the highest level of speed and AF performance Canon can offer, like all 1-series models in the last 15-20 years.

"It's not innovative like the A9III".

No global shutter? Sure. But Canon has built a stacked BSI sensor having 2.7ms readout speed (faster even than the mechanical shutter in the 1DX Mark III) and with14-bits of resolution... This means the R1 will deliver excellent IQ and noise performance vs. the Sony, with an almost imperceptible level of rolling shutter. I know which compromise *I* would rather make in a 24Mp camera.

If a higher native resolution "do everything" model is needed, then the 5-series is there (as always) as the Canon alternative. As far as I can tell, the difference with the R5 Mark II vs.older 5-series models is that there is almost no performance compromise. While slower than the R1 or A9III, the R5 II easily performs at "flagship" level relative to the competition's "do everything" cameras. It just doesn't have an integrated grip (see, "Sony"), or a "1" in its name.

I think when the dust settles, and the anti-Canon brigade gets bored and moves on, there will be a more nuanced discussion of the benefits and tradeoffs of the R1. But just as with the 1DX models before it, there will likely not be much talk about it here on the FM Canon forum, because most of us do not fit the target audience for this camera.
It's all about resolution for me. R1 will likely be best in class for it's target market.



Looks like the LCD resolution also took a hit..

R1 - 3.0" 2.1m-Dot Vari-Angle Touchscreen LCD
R3 - 3.2" 4.2m-Dot Vari-Angle Touchscreen LCD

1DX3 - 3.2" 2.1m-Dot LCD
1DX2 - 3.2" 1.62m-Dot LCD

R5ii - 3.2" 2.1m-Dot Vari-Angle Touchscreen LCD
R5 - 3.2" 2.1m-Dot Vari-Angle Touchscreen LCD

R6ii - 3" 1.62m-Dot Vari-Angle Touchscreen LCD

Jul 24, 2024 at 07:04 PM
garyvot
Offline
Details
p.21 #19Canon r1 official announcement.


adamx12m wrote:
drobertfranz wrote
garyvot wrote
drobertfranz wroteIt will be a great camera for the target market but far from a great at everything flagship camera we were all hoping for.
Other than resolution, is there something else that makes this camera "far from great at everything"? As far as I can tell, it is incredibly capable at what it does, and breaks new ground in AF and in DR vs. the level of performance on offer.

I'm not even sure the 24Mp resolution is that limiting, given the already good (and improving) quality of AI upscaling--but that's a separate discussion.

Regardless, the R1 is not trying to be a "do everything" camera. It is a special-purpose dedicated sports/action camera intended to offer the highest level of speed and AF performance Canon can offer, like all 1-series models in the last 15-20 years.

"It's not innovative like the A9III".

No global shutter? Sure. But Canon has built a stacked BSI sensor having 2.7ms readout speed (faster even than the mechanical shutter in the 1DX Mark III) and with14-bits of resolution... This means the R1 will deliver excellent IQ and noise performance vs. the Sony, with an almost imperceptible level of rolling shutter. I know which compromise *I* would rather make in a 24Mp camera.

If a higher native resolution "do everything" model is needed, then the 5-series is there (as always) as the Canon alternative. As far as I can tell, the difference with the R5 Mark II vs.older 5-series models is that there is almost no performance compromise. While slower than the R1 or A9III, the R5 II easily performs at "flagship" level relative to the competition's "do everything" cameras. It just doesn't have an integrated grip (see, "Sony"), or a "1" in its name.

I think when the dust settles, and the anti-Canon brigade gets bored and moves on, there will be a more nuanced discussion of the benefits and tradeoffs of the R1. But just as with the 1DX models before it, there will likely not be much talk about it here on the FM Canon forum, because most of us do not fit the target audience for this camera.
It's all about resolution for me. R1 will likely be best in class for it's target market.
Looks like the LCD resolution also took a hit..

R1 - 3.0" 2.1m-Dot Vari-Angle Touchscreen LCD
R3 - 3.2" 4.2m-Dot Vari-Angle Touchscreen LCD

1DX3 - 3.2" 2.1m-Dot LCD
1DX2 - 3.2" 1.62m-Dot LCD

R5ii - 3.2" 2.1m-Dot Vari-Angle Touchscreen LCD
R5 - 3.2" 2.1m-Dot Vari-Angle Touchscreen LCD

R6ii - 3" 1.62m-Dot Vari-Angle Touchscreen LCD



Yes, which is admittedly a little weird.

On the other hand, the viewfinder is massively improved over the R3, having 9.44M dots at 0.9x magnification vs. 5.76M dots at 0.76x.

If I was forced to choose one of these over the other I would definitely go for the improved viewfinder.
Jul 24, 2024 at 11:11 PM
Choderboy
Offline
Details
p.21 #20Canon r1 official announcement.
garyvot wrote:
Regardless, the R1 is not trying to be a "do everything" camera. It is a special-purpose dedicated sports/action camera intended to offer the highest level of speed and AF performance Canon can offer, like all 1-series models in the last 15-20 years.


Well, 15 years, not 20. 20 years ago there was a choice of 1D2 or 1DS2.
Even 1DX, in 2012, was only just behind the max available resolution. (18mp vs 20)
5DS/R in 2015 was the start of the dedicated sports/action body having significantly less than highest available resolution.

So it's a 9 year period the lower resolution sports/action camera has existed.
Jul 25, 2024 at 04:49 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister