adamx12m wrote:
drobertfranz wrote
garyvot wrote
drobertfranz wrote
It will be a great camera for the target market but far from a great at everything flagship camera we were all hoping for. Other than resolution, is there something else that makes this camera "far from great at everything"? As far as I can tell, it is incredibly capable at what it does, and breaks new ground in AF and in DR vs. the level of performance on offer.
I'm not even sure the 24Mp resolution is that limiting, given the already good (and improving) quality of AI upscaling--but that's a separate discussion.
Regardless, the R1 is not trying to be a "do everything" camera. It is a special-purpose dedicated sports/action camera intended to offer the highest level of speed and AF performance Canon can offer, like all 1-series models in the last 15-20 years.
"It's not innovative like the A9III".
No global shutter? Sure. But Canon has built a stacked BSI sensor having 2.7ms readout speed (faster even than the mechanical shutter in the 1DX Mark III) and with14-bits of resolution... This means the R1 will deliver excellent IQ and noise performance vs. the Sony, with an almost imperceptible level of rolling shutter. I know which compromise *I* would rather make in a 24Mp camera.
If a higher native resolution "do everything" model is needed, then the 5-series is there (as always) as the Canon alternative. As far as I can tell, the difference with the R5 Mark II vs.older 5-series models is that there is almost no performance compromise. While slower than the R1 or A9III, the R5 II easily performs at "flagship" level relative to the competition's "do everything" cameras. It just doesn't have an integrated grip (see, "Sony"), or a "1" in its name.
I think when the dust settles, and the anti-Canon brigade gets bored and moves on, there will be a more nuanced discussion of the benefits and tradeoffs of the R1. But just as with the 1DX models before it, there will likely not be much talk about it here on the FM Canon forum, because most of us do not fit the target audience for this camera. It's all about resolution for me. R1 will likely be best in class for it's target market. Looks like the LCD resolution also took a hit..
R1 - 3.0" 2.1m-Dot Vari-Angle Touchscreen LCD
R3 - 3.2" 4.2m-Dot Vari-Angle Touchscreen LCD
1DX3 - 3.2" 2.1m-Dot LCD
1DX2 - 3.2" 1.62m-Dot LCD
R5ii - 3.2" 2.1m-Dot Vari-Angle Touchscreen LCD
R5 - 3.2" 2.1m-Dot Vari-Angle Touchscreen LCD
R6ii - 3" 1.62m-Dot Vari-Angle Touchscreen LCD
Yes, which is admittedly a little weird.
On the other hand, the viewfinder is massively improved over the R3, having 9.44M dots at 0.9x magnification vs. 5.76M dots at 0.76x.
If I was forced to choose one of these over the other I would definitely go for the improved viewfinder.