p.4 #1New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
highdesertmesa wrote: bigtractor wroteI'm sure we'll know for sure within the next day, but I'm seeing some tweets from Japanese users at the setup day for CP+ stating that neither version of the 50mm 3.5 is collapsibleWho in their right mind would want to buy a lens that looks like a collapsable lens that was stuck in the extended position? That would be a major fail, IMO. If it's true it's not collapsable, I'll definitely be getting the normal-looking version then since it focuses closer anyway.
p.4 #2New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
The Anniversary f/2 Heliar is designed to look like a collapsible lens...but doesn't collapse (unlike it's M-Mount counterpart). So, there is precedent for this...
In the case of that lens, I prefer that they didn't try to make it collapse. The VM version barely shrinks down.
p.4 #3New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
Ideally we get a photo or demo of the lens collapsed down on a camera to see how small it can get. I would be shocked if the collapsible isn't actually collapsible, since Cosina has built them before.
Don't think I would go for collapsible lens ergonomics without the benefit of actually collapsing down the lens.
p.4 #4New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
Yeah, but you'd think if it was collapsible it would be clearly stated in the product announcement. If it doesn't I'll pretty much have lost interest, especially if the body of the other version rotates when focusing (including the aperture and filter threads). The 50/2.2 looks like the more practical one at this point.
p.4 #8New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
I’ll be curious to see the block diagram for the 50mm f/2.2. Will it be a derivative of the well-worn 6/7 Double Gauss as seen in nearly every high-speed design of 70-90’s? Will it more closely related to unique Double Gauss design of the 50/2.5 Color-Skopar (perhaps with a bit of anomalous partial dispersion glass or an aspheric element)? Or something altogether different? The rear element protrudes rather far for a Double Gauss 50. Might be something novel…
p.4 #10New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
RexGig0 wrote: Robin Smith wroteWhy? Is all I can ask. I guess VC believe they cannot have too many 50s. Baffling.There is plenty of love for the long-discontinued 50mm Color Skopar. They sell for premium prices, on the pre-owned market. I know, because I have been scanning about, for them. (I usually prefer lenses with some amount size and heft, to facilitate carrying in my left hand, but, now and then, it is nice to keep an M camera slung under a jacket, or inside a big pocket or small pouch, at which times a small lens is useful.)
..
I was about to offer up my OG 50 2.5, but then saw how gorgeous it looks on my M3..
I guess I would need to get the new black one for my M-A, M7 etc in addition to keeping the original. The brass construction feels very nice.
p.4 #11New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
At this point I'm fairly certain that I'll be buying the 50/2.2.... Should be a nice match to the Mr Ding 35/1.8 on my FP. Maybe one day I'll pick up an M body of some sort.
p.4 #12New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
hanay78 wrote:
I was not aware of this lens. Is it from the 50s?
Fred Miranda wroteI was told the new 50/3.5 is modeled after the LTM version of the Micro Nikkor:"Modern Photography reported Nikon describing the 5 element lens as an Apochromatic -- focusing all three primary colors to the same point. Resolving ability was reported to be extremely high, beyond the ability of most films at the time to record it."
So, it's definitely an inspiration for its design aesthetics, and there's also some resemblance since the CV 50/3.5 is also APO. (8 elements vs 5 though)
p.4 #13New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
The Nikkor lens is the precursor to the 55mm f/3.5 in F mount (with the latter's focal length being increased by 5mm to allow for it to clear the mirror). They are both 5/4 Xenotars.
I'm sure the new Voigt will be better than the old Micro-Nikkor...which is saying alot...the Micro-Nikkor has to be one of the best lenses ever made (especially when you factor in price).
p.4 #14New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
Both Leica AG and Cosina are wedded to short-throw focus which really renders the DOF scale useless by 50mm. Here's the Elmar classic for comparison—and it's a shorter throw than the period 'lux:
The C/V Heliar 50/3.5 "lens board" version has a serviceable DOF scale if you can work with single-helical focus, plus it collapses and is LTM. I guess this new APO-LANTHAR will perform even better optically (if that's even possible ).
p.4 #15New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
Product introduction video for 50/3.5. Type I doesn't seem to be collapsible based on the video. Type I lens doesn't rotate while focusing, the barrel just extends when focusing closer. Type II on the other hand rotates as one block, where aperture ring rotates together with the focus helicoid. Both versions are said to have a recognizable "click" on the focus ring when reaching 0.7m focus distance where rangefinder coupling disengages.
p.4 #17New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
Thank you for sharing these videos, Juha! They've answered most of our questions. From what I gathered from the auto-translation, Cosina decided to keep the 50/3.5 Type I extended because collapsing it wouldn't really add any extra functionality, except for making it more compact when not in use.
However, if they had made it collapsible, there would always be a risk of small vibrations and airflow, potentially allowing dust to get inside the lens. It seems like the decision was made to preserve the aesthetics of the past and avoid these potential issues. Personally, I prefer the slimmer Type II for the insane 0.35m MFD, even though it means the filters would rotate with focusing, like polarizers.
The CV 50/2.2 appears to be simple and elegant. According to the video, its compact screw-in hood doesn't interfere with the 50mm framelines, which is great for RF shooters.
It's great to hear that they're listening to feedback and adding a tactile feel when the focusing ring goes beyond 0.7m for the 50/3.5. However, it's puzzling why they haven't implemented this feature for the 50/2.2. I think it would be beneficial for them to incorporate this to all their future lenses.
p.4 #19New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
Fred Miranda wrote:
Thank you for sharing these videos, Juha! They've answered most of our questions. From what I gathered from the auto-translation, Cosina decided to keep the 50/3.5 Type I extended because collapsing it wouldn't really add any extra functionality, except for making it more compact when not in use.
However, if they had made it collapsible, there would always be a risk of small vibrations and airflow, potentially allowing dust to get inside the lens. It seems like the decision was made to preserve the aesthetics of the past and avoid these potential issues. Personally, I prefer the slimmer Type II for the insane 0.35m MFD, even though it means the filters would rotate with focusing, like polarizers....Show more →
I don't quite buy the apparent reasoning behind not making it collapsible. The whole point of a collapsible design, its sole functional reason, is to be more compact when not in use. And this slow 50/3.5 is quite long for a 50mm design, therefore it would really benefit from a collapsible design. Based on the design of the Leica 90/4 Macro, the whole optical assembly is inside the tube that collapses - there is no internal movement of elements to facilitate this capability, therefore there wouldn't be structural changes that would increase the opportunity for dust ingress.
Whatever the case, if I was to get this lens, my preference would be type 1 simply for the non-rotating aperture and filter rings and the raised red dot. I also think the design looks quite nice, particularly in panda, just that collapsibility would have made it that much more practical.
Looking forward to seeing how these new 50s stack up!
p.4 #20New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
rscheffler wrote: Fred Miranda wroteThank you for sharing these videos, Juha! They've answered most of our questions. From what I gathered from the auto-translation, Cosina decided to keep the 50/3.5 Type I extended because collapsing it wouldn't really add any extra functionality, except for making it more compact when not in use.
However, if they had made it collapsible, there would always be a risk of small vibrations and airflow, potentially allowing dust to get inside the lens. It seems like the decision was made to preserve the aesthetics of the past and avoid these potential issues. Personally, I prefer the slimmer Type II for the insane 0.35m MFD, even though it means the filters would rotate with focusing, like polarizers.I don't quite buy the apparent reasoning behind not making it collapsible. The whole point of a collapsible design, its sole functional reason, is to be more compact when not in use. And this slow 50/3.5 is quite long for a 50mm design, therefore it would really benefit from a collapsible design. Based on the design of the Leica 90/4 Macro, the whole optical assembly is inside the tube that collapses - there is no internal movement of elements to facilitate this capability, therefore there wouldn't be structural changes that would increase the opportunity for dust ingress.
Whatever the case, if I was to get this lens, my preference would be type 1 simply for the non-rotating aperture and filter rings and the raised red dot. I also think the design looks quite nice, particularly in panda, just that collapsibility would have made it that much more practical.
Looking forward to seeing how these new 50s stack up!...Show more →
Cosina likely anticipated that there would be questions about this and addressed it in the video. Personally, I would have preferred if the Type I featured collapsibility. I'm very curious about their performance and will be comparing them to the Voigtlander 50/2 APO-Lanthar.