p.17 #3New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
I'm still looking forward to finding out more about the 50/3.5 APO. It may not last long in production in the non-collapsible 150g variant I want, due to the release of several other CV lenses in the same time frame, and the general response to the unusual form factor.
Still, four variants is curious and appears to demonstrate a level of commitment unexpected of an f3.5 lens in this day and age. Why not an f2.8, closer to the longer APOs at 90mm and 110mm, and much more acceptable in general? The company has long been enamored of the 50/3.5 Heliar, however, a (still available) 2016 release.
And they do not take the APO-Lanthar designation lightly, it has only been bestowed on four lenses in their modern period. 51.3 mm actual focal length at infinity, and eight elements (8/6) inside what will be the slowest APO-Lanthar by far in recent times. So plenty of design freedom exists there. The obvious comparison is the well-received 50/2 APO-Lanthar, a very different design with a much broader (and conventional) target group.
Sales will diminish if the new lens does not at least match the 50/2 APO for middle aperture work, and that alone is a tough order to fill. It's hard to see it not having one, possibly two double-sided asph elements, with generally good response to the OOF of the 35/50 pair which share this layout.
I commend them for their courage here, and hope we see more landscape-oriented slow lenses at both wider and longer focal lengths, as they have a charm all their own, with terrific colour. At such a slow max aperture, 50mm should also present little drama on mirrorless platforms. Time will tell.
p.17 #4New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
If Cosina has planned 50/3.5 for August release I think they will make official announcement tomorrow 7/12 or next Tuesday 7/16 since the usual new release announcement date (15th) happens to be a national holiday in Japan this time. I'll update here as soon as the announcement comes.
On the other hand, there's also a chance that they might skip releasing anything new in August (apart from the limited Map Camera 30th anniversary collaboration release Fuji X 23/1.2 SC on 8/13) and then there would be no new announcement in mid-July.
p.17 #6New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
philip_pj wrote:
And they do not take the APO-Lanthar designation lightly, it has only been bestowed on four lenses in their modern period. 51.3 mm actual focal length at infinity, and eight elements (8/6) inside what will be the slowest APO-Lanthar by far in recent times. So plenty of design freedom exists there. The obvious comparison is the well-received 50/2 APO-Lanthar, a very different design with a much broader (and conventional) target group.
Where did you see the 51.3mm focal length spec? That would be great if it's on the longer end like many Leica lenses.
p.17 #7New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
On page one here:
'APO-LANTHAR 50mm F3.5 VM:
6 groups 8 elements
Angle of view: 45.7°'
I wonder also about close focusing lenses' levels of focus breathing. (I imagine you cannot detect breathing with a Leica RF.)
As an example, the E 50/2 APO has a true focal length of 50.4mm, but Gordon Laing reports a 14% magnification increase at a focal distance of 0.62m (MFD is 0.45m). Breathing tends to be rather linear with ring rotation too.
Ideally, the actual taking focal length would be reported whenever focus distance is captured. It must have an impact on DOF and rendering if you focus at say, 3m. I can't help my curiosity and dislike 'trade secrets'.
Even the beloved CV 35/2 APO breathes noticeably, narrowing your AOV and probably costing you a half stop at near distance to obtain a given DOF. Which builds the case for an APO-Lanthar at 28/2, doesn't it?
They are a bit more expensive than I was expecting.
The spec change since CP+ seems to be that the Black Type II is now made of aluminium or something like that and it's lighter at 175g whereas Silver Type II is 250g.
The 2 black lenses seem to be all black on the bottom as well and it will apparently impact 6-bit code reading attempts (I think 40/2.8 black VM version has same situation) so it may be necessary to turn off the lens recognition on Leica M cameras.
There was also a warning on the product introduction video stating that even though the lenses can be adapted on mirrorless, the same high performance will not be achieved as with M-mount Leica cameras.
They are a bit more expensive than I was expecting.
MTF suggest they’re not quite as good as the 50mm f2, but the weight to performance ratio is impressive. Only 175g for the black type II.
Ergonomically both versions seem strange at best though.. with type II the front element rotates so using a polarizer would be annoying and the whole focus ring moves out when you focus closer 😵💫
p.17 #12New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
In the video, we see the design lacks asph elements entirely, as with the 50/2.2. The lens block resembles a large Planar base, with four APD elements spread quite evenly across its eight elements. Not surprisingly, it falls short of the 50/2 APO-Lanthar in raw MTF. Its character will of course be interesting to observe. Best aperture is shown as f5.6, Resolution decline is very steady, and these are still very impressive data for such a small lens. And the impressively neutral colour of the 50/2.2 samples will likely be shared in this one.
In the video: better images at 2:00; Hoods at 2:07; lens block design 2:16; close ups: 4:14.
Below see the design block and the MTF (note the second line pair represents 30lpmm not the usual 20lpmm used by Zeiss, Leica etc.).
p.17 #13New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
I would personally be tempted to buy the Type I two-tone version but I was guessing that it would be priced at around 85K whereas it's ~98K at Map Camera, so it's a bit more than I was thinking. Also, I've already pre-ordered CV 75/1.5 in E-mount for next week and CV X-mount 23/1.2 SC special Map Camera annversary edition for August so my lens budget is getting tight for the next months. And the warning about performance when adapted to mirrorless is additionally making me cautious. I may want to wait for some reviews showing how it performs on Sony before making any decisions.
p.17 #14New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
I'm very interested in the Type 1 black. Only 150g. I already have the 50 f/2 Apo Lanthar but it is larger and heavier. This could be better suited for daytime all-day carry. Still a shame about the design, I would have preferred either true collapsing or a more conventional design with a focus tab - this is kind of worst of both worlds. Filter size is also annoying, who sells a 34mm -> 39mm step up?
My favorite addition: Focusing click of the rangefinder coupling range
A mechanism is provided to recognize the junction point of the rangefinder-linked range by a clicking sensation during focusing operation
p.17 #15New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
philip_pj wrote:
On page one here:
'APO-LANTHAR 50mm F3.5 VM:
6 groups 8 elements
Angle of view: 45.7°'
I wonder also about close focusing lenses' levels of focus breathing. (I imagine you cannot detect breathing with a Leica RF.)
As an example, the E 50/2 APO has a true focal length of 50.4mm, but Gordon Laing reports a 14% magnification increase at a focal distance of 0.62m (MFD is 0.45m). Breathing tends to be rather linear with ring rotation too.
Ideally, the actual taking focal length would be reported whenever focus distance is captured. It must have an impact on DOF and rendering if you focus at say, 3m. I can't help my curiosity and dislike 'trade secrets'.
Even the beloved CV 35/2 APO breathes noticeably, narrowing your AOV and probably costing you a half stop at near distance to obtain a given DOF. Which builds the case for an APO-Lanthar at 28/2, doesn't it? ...Show more →
Thanks. I hope the quoted FOV angles are accurate.
p.17 #16New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
Juha Kannisto wrote:
I would personally be tempted to buy the Type I two-tone version but I was guessing that it would be priced at around 85K whereas it's ~98K at Map Camera, so it's a bit more than I was thinking. Also, I've already pre-ordered CV 75/1.5 in E-mount for next week and CV X-mount 23/1.2 SC special Map Camera annversary edition for August so my lens budget is getting tight for the next months. And the warning about performance when adapted to mirrorless is additionally making me cautious. I may want to wait for some reviews showing how it performs on Sony before making any decisions....Show more →
I also like the look of the duo-tone (panda) Type I the most, but it is almost twice as heavy as the matte black! That's something I need to consider. My other preference is the Type II black paint since I will be using it on a black paint M. It looks stunning, although the drawback is that the aperture and focusing rings rotate together. It's not a deal breaker but not ideal either.
p.17 #17New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
philip_pj wrote:
In the video, we see the design lacks asph elements entirely, as with the 50/2.2. The lens block resembles a large Planar base, with four APD elements spread quite evenly across its eight elements. Not surprisingly, it falls short of the 50/2 APO-Lanthar in raw MTF. Its character will of course be interesting to observe. Best aperture is shown as f5.6, Resolution decline is very steady, and these are still very impressive data for such a small lens. And the impressively neutral colour of the 50/2.2 samples will likely be shared in this one.
In the video: better images at 2:00; Hoods at 2:07; lens block design 2:16; close ups: 4:14.
Below see the design block and the MTF (note the second line pair represents 30lpmm not the usual 20lpmm used by Zeiss, Leica etc.). ...Show more →
I agree with your assessment. The optical design is based on a symmetric planar with some deviations. Similar to their super compact 50/2.2, Cosina favors more APD elements and no aspherical elements. I expect this lens to have more character in its rendering compared to the CV 50/2 APO-Lanthar. Based on the MTF charts, it's clear it won't match the latter in resolution and contrast, but the new APO is still a high-performing lens.
p.17 #18New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
oscartb wrote:
I'm very interested in the Type 1 black. Only 150g. I already have the 50 f/2 Apo Lanthar but it is larger and heavier. This could be better suited for daytime all-day carry. Still a shame about the design, I would have preferred either true collapsing or a more conventional design with a focus tab - this is kind of worst of both worlds. Filter size is also annoying, who sells a 34mm -> 39mm step up?
Heliopan does have one and it's high quality. Many already use it with the Voigtlander 28/2.8 and 40/2.8 lenses.
p.17 #19New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
Fred Miranda wrote:
I expect this lens to have more character in its rendering compared to the CV 50/2 APO-Lanthar. Based on the MTF charts, it's clear it won't match the latter in resolution and contrast, but the new APO is still a high-performing lens.
I'd be interested in seeing a comparison of this new 50mm with reportedly excellent the little Heliar 50/3.5, if anyone still has one.
p.17 #20New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
zugzwang2 wrote: Fred Miranda wroteI expect this lens to have more character in its rendering compared to the CV 50/2 APO-Lanthar. Based on the MTF charts, it's clear it won't match the latter in resolution and contrast, but the new APO is still a high-performing lens.I'd be interested in seeing a comparison of this new 50mm with reportedly excellent the little Heliar 50/3.5, if anyone still has one.
The current CV 50/3.5 Heliar is indeed excellent but there is noticeable field curvature when I tested it at infinity distance.