fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2023 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2023Anybody switched from Sony to Nikon?

  
 
3catsinky
Offline
Details
p.13 #1Anybody switched from Sony to Nikon?
FWIW, I have been shooting the Z8 with Megadap, and nearly all of my Sony and Sigma ART lenses Since May, and it has been nearly flawless. A few times it froze up on my 70-200, but a quick remount of the lens reset it, and all was good. I've shot portraits, sports and video with it, and it can indeed save you from buying native mount Z glass.
Nov 22, 2023 at 01:06 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.13 #2Anybody switched from Sony to Nikon?
Please stop posting on topic thoughts immediately. This thread is for yelling at ghosts.

3catsinky wrote:
FWIW, I have been shooting the Z8 with Megadap, and nearly all of my Sony and Sigma ART lenses Since May, and it has been nearly flawless. A few times it froze up on my 70-200, but a quick remount of the lens reset it, and all was good. I've shot portraits, sports and video with it, and it can indeed save you from buying native mount Z glass.

Nov 22, 2023 at 01:35 PM
ajamils
Offline
Details
p.13 #3Anybody switched from Sony to Nikon?
3catsinky wrote:
FWIW, I have been shooting the Z8 with Megadap, and nearly all of my Sony and Sigma ART lenses Since May, and it has been nearly flawless. A few times it froze up on my 70-200, but a quick remount of the lens reset it, and all was good. I've shot portraits, sports and video with it, and it can indeed save you from buying native mount Z glass.


That's great to know. My Megadap Pro adapter finally showed up so have the Z8 battery charging now. Will be testing it with the following lenses.
- Sigma 105/1.4
- Sony 20-270 F4
- Samyang 50/1.4 II
- Tamron 150-500
Nov 22, 2023 at 02:28 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.13 #4Anybody switched from Sony to Nikon?
ajamils wrote:
3catsinky wroteFWIW, I have been shooting the Z8 with Megadap, and nearly all of my Sony and Sigma ART lenses Since May, and it has been nearly flawless. A few times it froze up on my 70-200, but a quick remount of the lens reset it, and all was good. I've shot portraits, sports and video with it, and it can indeed save you from buying native mount Z glass.
That's great to know. My Megadap Pro adapter finally showed up so have the Z8 battery charging now. Will be testing it with the following lenses.
- Sigma 105/1.4
- Sony 20-270 F4
- Samyang 50/1.4 II
- Tamron 150-500


Definitely interested in hearing your thoughts. There are a few FE lenses I wouldn't mind adapting if the performance is right.
Nov 22, 2023 at 02:40 PM
phinix
Offline
Details
p.13 #5Anybody switched from Sony to Nikon?
I'm switching from Sony.
Just an enthusiast amateur, have a7c and few lens, selling all and getting Zf.
I don't know much about Nikon system, but decided to switch based on Zf look and features, especially towards MF lens.
Nov 23, 2023 at 04:42 AM
lukeiam
Offline
Details
p.13 #6Anybody switched from Sony to Nikon?
3catsinky wrote:
FWIW, I have been shooting the Z8 with Megadap, and nearly all of my Sony and Sigma ART lenses Since May, and it has been nearly flawless. A few times it froze up on my 70-200, but a quick remount of the lens reset it, and all was good. I've shot portraits, sports and video with it, and it can indeed save you from buying native mount Z glass.


I’m someone who loves his Z but occasionally misses some of my Sony primes like the ART DG DN line. Keep hearing hit or miss stuff on the megadap so it’s kept me from this path, but maybe worth a shot.

Is there any indication of anyone else entering this market like Sigma (the adapter market). Thx
Nov 23, 2023 at 10:49 AM
aboutthelight
Offline
Details
p.13 #7Anybody switched from Sony to Nikon?
This doesn't exactly address the question but I was photographing birds this weekend with 2 Sony shooters who were former Nikon shooters. Both said that if they were buying new gear today that they would buy Nikon because of the built in tc's on the 400 and 600 and because of the fantastic PF lenses.
Nov 23, 2023 at 05:52 PM
C_n_red_again
Offline
Details
p.13 #8Anybody switched from Sony to Nikon?
Full disclosure. I am a Sony shooter but have no brand loyalty. Currently own both the a7rv and the a1. Rented the z8 in the hopes that I would like it so I could take advantage of some of Nikons long primes. Found af with birds wasn’t on par with either the a1 or rv. Tbh. It wasn’t even close. Raptors in particular like eagles and ospreys the hit ratio was a distant third. Also disliked the size of the z8. Guess I’ve grown a custom to the nimbleness of the sonys. If and when the af system improves maybe I’ll give Nikon another look.
Nov 23, 2023 at 06:53 PM
ajamils
Offline
Details
p.13 #9Anybody switched from Sony to Nikon?
I expected A1 to be better but I'm surprised about A7rV. I've owned A7rV for many months and even though the AF has been amazing (specially eye-AF) I didn't had much luck with bird photography with it. So far I haven't tried anything challenging with Z8, but in my limited at home testing, AF seems to be just as quick and accurate as my A7RV and this is with Megadap Pro adapter.

Z8 size is definitely a drawback that I'm still concerned about as it will definitely come into play when I'm trying to decide on the kit to keep for my upcoming international trips.

C_n_red_again wrote:
Full disclosure. I am a Sony shooter but have no brand loyalty. Currently own both the a7rv and the a1. Rented the z8 in the hopes that I would like it so I could take advantage of some of Nikons long primes. Found af with birds wasn’t on par with either the a1 or rv. Tbh. It wasn’t even close. Raptors in particular like eagles and ospreys the hit ratio was a distant third. Also disliked the size of the z8. Guess I’ve grown a custom to the nimbleness of the sonys. If and when the af system improves maybe
...Show more →
Nov 24, 2023 at 01:33 AM
saaketham
Offline
Details
p.13 #10Anybody switched from Sony to Nikon?
C_n_red_again wrote:
Full disclosure. I am a Sony shooter but have no brand loyalty. Currently own both the a7rv and the a1. Rented the z8 in the hopes that I would like it so I could take advantage of some of Nikons long primes. Found af with birds wasn’t on par with either the a1 or rv. Tbh. It wasn’t even close. Raptors in particular like eagles and ospreys the hit ratio was a distant third. Also disliked the size of the z8. Guess I’ve grown a custom to the nimbleness of the sonys. If and when the af system improves maybe
...Show more →

Same here. I shoot with a1 and a7Rv and z6ii.
For any fast action and tracking, the a1 rocks.
For not so fast action but excellent subject recognition and eye AF, the a7Rv is as good as and sometimes better than a1.
I traded my z8 for an a7Rv, although I loved the looks and ergonomics of the z8. The weight I didn't like as much.


Thank you for at least trying the gear before posting your opinion. That makes your opinion much more valuable than armchair experts who've never seen or touched a z body or lens, but post 1000s of useless messages about it each week.
Nov 24, 2023 at 05:54 AM
3catsinky
Offline
Details
p.13 #11Anybody switched from Sony to Nikon?
While the Z8 is definitely bigger than the sony bodies, i don't find it that much of a pain to travel with. But then again, I swore off taking gear with me anymore. It's all phone from now on.
Nov 24, 2023 at 06:14 AM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.13 #12Anybody switched from Sony to Nikon?
ajamils wrote:
I expected A1 to be better but I'm surprised about A7rV.



Me, too - considering that both of my A7R V's were worse than the Z9 and even slightly worse than the Z8.

I felt the A7R V was about on par with my Olympus OM-1 for most things except tracking of fast moving birds, where the stacked sensor of the OM-1 gave it an advantage. For static subjects, I found the first A7R V and FE 200-600G combo locked onto rocks more often than it locked onto wading or swimming birds; the second body with updated firmware was a lot better.
Nov 24, 2023 at 12:46 PM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.13 #13Anybody switched from Sony to Nikon?
Thank you for at least trying the gear before posting your opinion.


What a crazy concept! Unfortunately, all too rare on so many of these forum threads...
Nov 24, 2023 at 12:47 PM
ajamils
Offline
Details
p.13 #14Anybody switched from Sony to Nikon?
Tried out Sigma 105/1.4, Samyang 501/1.4 II and Sony 20-70 F4 yesterday with Megadap Pro adapter and performance was nearly identical to what I've seen with A7rV except for Samyang which feels marginally slower, but it is not a fast focusing lens to begin with. One pleasant surprise was that the aperture ring of Sony 20-70 F4 works, which is something I wasn't expecting.

In terms of AF, both single AF and C-AF with eye detect worked instantly. Eye-AF seem to pick eyes from further away than A7rV but looking at the pictures, it seems like it is not 100% accurate because sometime it picks eye-lashes or frame of the glasses (shooting wide open at 1.4).

Another positive is that all lens models were reported correctly as well (I only took jpegs so viewed them in FastStone Viewer).

On the handling side of things, I'm not sold yet. I love the buttons and grip but every time I pick up the camera is reminds of dinosaurs...... I mean DSLRs. Big and bulky. On the other hand, as much as people hate A7rV ergonomics, it works amazingly well with lenses like 20-40 F4 and Samyang 50/1.4 II.

Edit Just realized that Megadap is on original firmware (v1) and the latest version is V1.26, so if it is a few firmware behind. So I'm going to upgrade and see if there is any big improvement.

Edited on Nov 24, 2023 at 02:03 PM · View previous versions
Nov 24, 2023 at 01:40 PM
ajamils
Offline
Details
p.13 #15Anybody switched from Sony to Nikon?
molson wrote:
ajamils wroteI expected A1 to be better but I'm surprised about A7rV.
Me, too - considering that both of my A7R V's were worse than the Z9 and even slightly worse than the Z8.

I felt the A7R V was about on par with my Olympus OM-1 for most things except tracking of fast moving birds, where the stacked sensor of the OM-1 gave it an advantage. For static subjects, I found the first A7R V and FE 200-600G combo locked onto rocks more often than it locked onto wading or swimming birds; the second body with updated firmware was a lot better.


So did you end up keeping any of the Sony's or fully back in the Nikon land?
Nov 24, 2023 at 01:41 PM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.13 #16Anybody switched from Sony to Nikon?
ajamils wrote:
molson wrote
ajamils wroteI expected A1 to be better but I'm surprised about A7rV.
Me, too - considering that both of my A7R V's were worse than the Z9 and even slightly worse than the Z8.

I felt the A7R V was about on par with my Olympus OM-1 for most things except tracking of fast moving birds, where the stacked sensor of the OM-1 gave it an advantage. For static subjects, I found the first A7R V and FE 200-600G combo locked onto rocks more often than it locked onto wading or swimming birds; the second body with updated firmware was a lot better.
So did you end up keeping any of the Sony's or fully back in the Nikon land?


All Nikon now - mostly because of their telephoto lenses; otherwise it probably would have been Sony.
Nov 24, 2023 at 01:53 PM
duncang
Offline
[X]
Details
p.13 #17Anybody switched from Sony to Nikon?
Vinnie_VdB wrote:
True Scott, ignoring this venom is one thing but it is just getting ridiculous with “DUNGcan” and his fellow satellite 1… I am to pull the trigger here at FM and more over to a far more respectful place that uses the proper measures in silences these unpleasant (understatement) characters.
And yes, despite reporting many posts to Fred is he allowing all this to happen. Well, if he is happy with that, I can conclude we have different opinions on what is a civilised place .

RoamingScott wrote
NikonClio64 wroteThere exists a large group of Sony sycophants who have devoted far too much of their lives to proselytizing their fundamentalism in forums - One of the worst places has been Nikon rumors where Nikon bashing by Sony trolls is an obsession when ever Nikon launches a new product
They try in dpr Nikon forums, although there they are banned by Mods.

they tried in BCG but silenced, and ironically amicable discussions are routine unlike FM where Sony posts in Nikon forum aim to incite and play silly games.

These Sony trolls stalk the FM Nikon Forum interjecting wherever they can stir up trouble - derailing threads about Nikon threads with Sony evangelizing.

Then ignoring requests by Nikon users who ask them to stay out of a Nikon thread....but gaslighting same responders. Case in point:- this post that 1bwana1 ignored with contempt and derailed the thread - more of the incessant the pathetic "backhanded compliments and condescending praise".

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1831247/4#16384750
Note that Fred is the only moderator for all forums here. You MUST click "report" and submit a report request, otherwise those posts will likely never been seen or rectified. Fred is very responsive to such matters.

The only reason they behave like this on FM is because there is less pushback, both in the form of admin moderation and self moderation by members. The best option is click "hide" on the offenders and never unhide them. Starve them of their precious oxygen.


Nope still not switching - just waiting for 120FPS 14 bit RAW with continuous autofocus !!

72 days and counting...

What's the next big thing for you guys ?
Nov 25, 2023 at 01:41 AM
bernardl
Offline
Details
p.13 #18Anybody switched from Sony to Nikon?


duncang wrote:
Vinnie_VdB wroteTrue Scott, ignoring this venom is one thing but it is just getting ridiculous with “DUNGcan” and his fellow satellite 1… I am to pull the trigger here at FM and more over to a far more respectful place that uses the proper measures in silences these unpleasant (understatement) characters.
And yes, despite reporting many posts to Fred is he allowing all this to happen. Well, if he is happy with that, I can conclude we have different opinions on what is a civilised place .

RoamingScott wrote
NikonClio64 wroteThere exists a large group of Sony sycophants who have devoted far too much of their lives to proselytizing their fundamentalism in forums - One of the worst places has been Nikon rumors where Nikon bashing by Sony trolls is an obsession when ever Nikon launches a new product
They try in dpr Nikon forums, although there they are banned by Mods.

they tried in BCG but silenced, and ironically amicable discussions are routine unlike FM where Sony posts in Nikon forum aim to incite and play silly games.

These Sony trolls stalk the FM Nikon Forum interjecting wherever they can stir up trouble - derailing threads about Nikon threads with Sony evangelizing.

Then ignoring requests by Nikon users who ask them to stay out of a Nikon thread....but gaslighting same responders. Case in point:- this post that 1bwana1 ignored with contempt and derailed the thread - more of the incessant the pathetic "backhanded compliments and condescending praise".

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1831247/4#16384750
Note that Fred is the only moderator for all forums here. You MUST click "report" and submit a report request, otherwise those posts will likely never been seen or rectified. Fred is very responsive to such matters.

The only reason they behave like this on FM is because there is less pushback, both in the form of admin moderation and self moderation by members. The best option is click "hide" on the offenders and never unhide them. Starve them of their precious oxygen.
Nope still not switching - just waiting for 120FPS 14 bit RAW with continuous autofocus !!

72 days and counting...

What's the next big thing for you guys ?


The 35mm f1.2 S would be a god sent for me, especially if it’s close to the quality/look of the 135mm f1.8 S that may be the best lens I own vs tough competition from Schneider and Rodenstock. My copy of the 135mm is clearly better than my copy of the 85mm f1.2 S btw. Insanely good.

Cheers,
Bernard
Nov 25, 2023 at 06:18 AM
Alistair1
Offline
Details
p.13 #19Anybody switched from Sony to Nikon?


duncang wrote:
Vinnie_VdB wroteTrue Scott, ignoring this venom is one thing but it is just getting ridiculous with “DUNGcan” and his fellow satellite 1… I am to pull the trigger here at FM and more over to a far more respectful place that uses the proper measures in silences these unpleasant (understatement) characters.
And yes, despite reporting many posts to Fred is he allowing all this to happen. Well, if he is happy with that, I can conclude we have different opinions on what is a civilised place .

RoamingScott wrote
NikonClio64 wroteThere exists a large group of Sony sycophants who have devoted far too much of their lives to proselytizing their fundamentalism in forums - One of the worst places has been Nikon rumors where Nikon bashing by Sony trolls is an obsession when ever Nikon launches a new product
They try in dpr Nikon forums, although there they are banned by Mods.

they tried in BCG but silenced, and ironically amicable discussions are routine unlike FM where Sony posts in Nikon forum aim to incite and play silly games.

These Sony trolls stalk the FM Nikon Forum interjecting wherever they can stir up trouble - derailing threads about Nikon threads with Sony evangelizing.

Then ignoring requests by Nikon users who ask them to stay out of a Nikon thread....but gaslighting same responders. Case in point:- this post that 1bwana1 ignored with contempt and derailed the thread - more of the incessant the pathetic "backhanded compliments and condescending praise".

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1831247/4#16384750
Note that Fred is the only moderator for all forums here. You MUST click "report" and submit a report request, otherwise those posts will likely never been seen or rectified. Fred is very responsive to such matters.

The only reason they behave like this on FM is because there is less pushback, both in the form of admin moderation and self moderation by members. The best option is click "hide" on the offenders and never unhide them. Starve them of their precious oxygen.
Nope still not switching - just waiting for 120FPS 14 bit RAW with continuous autofocus !!

72 days and counting...

What's the next big thing for you guys ?


Had 120fps for a couple of years now, but with higher DR. 😉
Nov 25, 2023 at 07:18 PM
1bwana1
Offline
Details
p.13 #20Anybody switched from Sony to Nikon?
Alistair1 wrote:
Had 120fps for a couple of years now, but with higher DR. 😉


Interesting, Do you have the format, mpx, bit rate, and DR numbers from both sides of that?

Nov 25, 2023 at 07:56 PM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister