fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2023 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2023Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video

  
 
bernardl
Offline
Details
p.5 #1Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
Eric214 wrote:
Jemini wroteIs the Bird mode coming to Z8? Sorry for the ignorance. I kind of remember seeing something like "Z8 users have to wait" statement when this FW was released. Any confirmation on this?
Nikon's press release on the Bird SD mode said it was coming to the Z8 sometime in the 1st half of 2024. That could mean as late as June 2024 but I would expect it sometime by the end of the 1st quarter. I think Nikon just gave themselves some wiggle room in case there were issues, they gave themselves plenty of extra time.


I believe they are facing a complex task of code merging mixed with additional enhancements/new functions.

It's a difficult engineering topic considering that cameras are treated nowadays as mission critical devices for which no defects are tolerated.

Cheers,
Bernard


Nov 05, 2023 at 09:11 PM
1bwana1
Offline
Details
p.5 #2Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video


Eric214 wrote:
1bwana1 wrote
Alistair1 wroteSince you so helpfully pointed out the inadequacies of Steve Perry's analysis, you may wish to apply equal rigor to your own; Perhaps you mean that the Sony is small and light and therefore suits your own physique but won't suit many others. Also that it has the fastest frame rate for lossy compressed raw but lags Canon and Nikon in startup time, buffer clearance rate, 12 bit internal recording speed, card speed etc. And that it is indeed a remarkable camera to this day for what you do.you
I think the fact that even you feel that the current benchmark is still the Sony A1 says everything that needs to be said. One day you just might get over that need.
Personally I never felt the A1 was the benchmark once the Z9 was released. I have stated since the Z9 came out that the A1 is the one closer to a point and shoot. Taking less from the user to get good shots and probably best for a person new to mirrorless. Canon is in the middle of this and Nikon Z9 is the true flagship that requires the most from the user to get the most out of. Early on (I got my Z9 Jan 2022) I was able to get as good or better results than many A1
...Show more →

By benchmark I don't mean best. I mean the camera that is being used to compare to. The Steve Perry video, does just that as do many reviewers, and posters in this Forum.

Since my view is that parity now exists between the different brands offerings, best is probably correctly defined by which each user thinks most closely meets his needs and preferences.
Nov 05, 2023 at 09:20 PM
duncang
Offline
[X]
Details
p.5 #3Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
Eric214 wrote:
1bwana1 wrote
Alistair1 wroteSince you so helpfully pointed out the inadequacies of Steve Perry's analysis, you may wish to apply equal rigor to your own; Perhaps you mean that the Sony is small and light and therefore suits your own physique but won't suit many others. Also that it has the fastest frame rate for lossy compressed raw but lags Canon and Nikon in startup time, buffer clearance rate, 12 bit internal recording speed, card speed etc. And that it is indeed a remarkable camera to this day for what you do.you
I think the fact that even you feel that the current benchmark is still the Sony A1 says everything that needs to be said. One day you just might get over that need.
Personally I never felt the A1 was the benchmark once the Z9 was released. I have stated since the Z9 came out that the A1 is the one closer to a point and shoot. Taking less from the user to get good shots and probably best for a person new to mirrorless. Canon is in the middle of this and Nikon Z9 is the true flagship that requires the most from the user to get the most out of. Early on (I got my Z9 Jan 2022) I was able to get as good or better results than many A1
...Show more →

By your logic wouldn't the Z6 be the best FLAGSHIP camera then ?

Less megapixels, lower FPS, less subject detection modes ...

And with every firmware release the Z9 is getting further and further from being a flagship.



What will they think of next!
Nov 05, 2023 at 11:35 PM
Vinnie_VdB
Offline
Details
p.5 #4Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
Folks, it is the Nikon section and did not cross post to the Sony section.
So, Sony folks, stay over in your section, there is no need to be stingy and defensive, better praise your gear in mind-liked groups.
Nov 06, 2023 at 12:02 AM
NikonClio64
Offline
Details
p.5 #5Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
Vinnie_VdB wrote:
Folks, it is the Nikon section and did not cross post to the Sony section.
So, Sony folks, stay over in your section, there is no need to be stingy and defensive, better praise your gear in mind-liked groups.


The only explanation is jealously based in insecurity to try and bash Nikon. A lack of forum moderation allows it, which undermines the value of this Nikon forum, which can only impact on subscriptions. It means it's pointless paying the fee to share images here

Puritanism: The haunting fear that someone, somewhere, may be happy. H. L. Mencken, 1917

*Sonyfanism: The haunting fear that someone, somewhere, may be happy with other equipment. Roger Cicala, 2018

https://www.lensrentals.com/blog/2018/12/the-great-400mm-f2-8-teardown-competition-part-1-the-canon-400mm-f2-8-l-is-iii/
Nov 06, 2023 at 01:01 AM
NikonClio64
Offline
Details
p.5 #6Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
Vinnie_VdB wrote:
Indeed, a newly released video on how the Z9 with FW 4.1 is perceived by Steve Perry in the field and how it does hold ground with the flagships from Sony Canon



These comparisons between the current "flagship ILCs" are moving targets, particularly given the frequency in the new features Nikon continues to add via Z9 Firmware. Since April 2022: Custom Area-AF modes; PreCapture; Auto-Capture and more.... besides upgrading the Deep-learning software in the AF system of the Z9 (actually there are the two cameras - the lighter and more affordable Z8, which will get the new Bird AF mode early 2024).

These features have been added free by Nikon within 2 years of the Z9 launch, which leaves us indulged Nikonians to speculate at what features are next ?

I agree with Thom Hogan that Sony made a gallant effort with the a1, but that was early 2021. Sony is always been too weak on telephotos. Nikon have since leapfrogged ahead in the FX MILC lineup - for the Wildlife and Sports genres - with their Z9 and Z8 Pairing, and particularly the unmatched Z Nikkor line up (currently 40 optics, and Nikon has committed to 50+ by 2025 in their Mid-Term Investor Strategy)

https://www.zsystemuser.com/nikon-z-system-news-and/2021-newsviews/for-those-with-sony-paranoi.html

Regardless, I'm confident many here - at least the honest and genuine wildlife photographers - will agree it is the features and diversity of lenses that matters far far more in the situation for investing in such expensive photo gear - wildlife and sports. For the petrol-heads and tyre-kickers in the photography forums, Steve Perry published a more comprehensive comparison of the two Camera Systems in February :



PS since Steve P compared the telephotos options approx. 8 months ago, Nikon have released their 180-600 f5.6/f6.3 and yet another - their 4th! - Phase-Fresnel prime, the 600 f6.3S PF. These Z mount telephotos are above and beyond all the excellent F mount glass many of us still use : 300 PF, 500 PF, 180-400 TC14, 200 f2G, 300 f2.8G, the E FL "Exotics" etc etc




Nov 06, 2023 at 01:03 AM
NikonClio64
Offline
Details
p.5 #7Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
Eric214 wrote:
aboutthelight wroteI am not worked up one bit by any advancements with the Z9. It is quite the opposite. I am happy for my friends who shoot the Z9 and happy that the prospect of subject recognition when combined with bird eye af makes these already great cameras even better and more precise. I have not stated otherwise so I don't see where you would draw that conclusion. I have never once stated the A1 is better nor have I made any claims that an A1 is necessary to take any of the photos in my talk. I only put the video up after a snide remark about me having the good A1 and Steve not having it. It is simply to show that I have a very good idea of what I am talking about when it comes to auto focus and what these cameras are capable of. And that there are much more difficult situations for auto focus systems than what is being portrayed.

With regards to the video I stand by what I said. Steve is an accomplished photographer, extremely well spoken and has a huge following which he has worked extremely hard for. But that does not mean that I have to agree with his findings. Nor does it mean that by disagreeing that I am trashing the Z9 which I am not or promoting the A1 which I also am not. I simply think that there are way more taxing and difficult situations for auto focus systems. As you say all different systems can produce high quality photos and I am in no way suggesting that they can't. Peak action and against varied backgrounds with small, fast and erratic birds are vital in my opinion to make a determination as to which system is better. Until there is a video showing direct comparisons with those situations then I think any other determination has little to no value. I get that people need to keep putting out content and people need views on youtube. But it is one thing to say the subject recognition has made it easier to acquire initial focus. It is an entirely different thing to stay locked on in certain situations. And those situations are the ones needed in my opinion to draw a conclusion. You of course are free to come to a different conclusion. Hope that helps clear this up.
One thing about Sony is they are known for buying into specific industries, like Minolta for photography, and pushing hard to get market share and then sit back and rest on their laurels and fall back a bit. They did with TVs and other things. This is a bit evident in Sony's lack of interest in putting out firmware updates to their cameras, instead focusing on camera body after body with new features in them not going to the flagship models. Would be very frustrating to Sony user I would image.

Sony is also a company when it feels like it,
...Show more →

The history reveals how Sony arrived at a formula. The well worn narrative is Sony Imaging tricked the opposition and leapt ahead. The realities are rather different. Minolta had a large fan base and high percentage of the ILC market, and Sony rode on this momentum. Nikon had its innovative Nikon 1 MILC system in 2011, which was years ahead with 60 fps and MILC AF at the time.
The unforeseen opportunity was the smartphone circa 2007, which hit the Point&Shoot MILC market hard, and would penultimately kill the consumer/entry DSLR market, which presumably Nikon identified at latest in 2012 (the peak year in DSLR sales ironically). The future was obvious by early 2016. CaNikon were locked into their P&S and DSLR factories, and it took both companies several years to change priorities. This demanded Nikon write off inventory, and wind down the mass production of both P&S and bulk DSLRs (with remaining focus on the midrange and Pro DSLR Models, D850, D5, D500, D6, D780).

Behind the scenes of continuing releases of outstandingly high quality F-mount products, Nikon must have begun a radical shift in R&D toward a FX MILC System well before 2015, probably earlier. Given the outstanding innovations and detailed features across the current cameras and lenses, the Z System did not just happen within 1-2 years prior to 2018. The results are beyond doubt impressive in a mere 4-5 years; we see these in all the Zed MILC's lead by Z8 and, Z9 and Z Nikkors

This is purely history today, because the modern CaNiSony cameras tick almost all the boxes for serious ILC photographers, with the biggest advantages in the respective choices in optics

https://petapixel.com/2023/05/01/sony-didnt-have-a-clever-mirrorless-plan-to-fool-canon-and-nikon/
Nov 06, 2023 at 01:24 AM
1bwana1
Offline
Details
p.5 #8Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
To beleive the above narrative one must accept the premise that Nikon brilliantly planned to lower its market share to 1/3 or less of its former size, and its market cap by 60% or more. Looks like they executed the plan very well. Bonuses and raises are in order for everyone.

One must also believe that Nikon's CEO is a liar. He gave a pretty strong explanation of of how seriously the repercussions of missing the move to mirrorless effected the company.

Being honest and genuine, I will once again state that I believe Nikon is now the leading system for bird and wildlife photographers. This because of a huge lead in long glass, and the excellent Z8/9 cameras.

I and the majority of the market are not so bird/wildlife focused. We are more all around shooters with other priorities and therefore make other choices. It is good that we are all getting what we want and need these days.
Nov 06, 2023 at 02:27 AM
Jemini
Offline
Details
p.5 #9Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
Ok. Looks like it's useful from reviews. Can't wait to use it.

Eric214 wrote:
Jemini wroteIs the Bird mode coming to Z8? Sorry for the ignorance. I kind of remember seeing something like "Z8 users have to wait" statement when this FW was released. Any confirmation on this?
Nikon's press release on the Bird SD mode said it was coming to the Z8 sometime in the 1st half of 2024. That could mean as late as June 2024 but I would expect it sometime by the end of the 1st quarter. I think Nikon just gave themselves some wiggle room in case there were issues, they gave themselves plenty of extra time.

Nov 06, 2023 at 03:00 AM
dcisive
Offline
Details
p.5 #10Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
1bwana1 wrote:
To beleive the above narrative one must accept the premise that Nikon brilliantly planned to lower its market share to 1/3 or less of its former size, and its market cap by 60% or more. Looks like they executed the plan very well. Bonuses and raises are in order for everyone.

One must also believe that Nikon's CEO is a liar. He gave a pretty strong explanation of of how seriously the repercussions of missing the move to mirrorless effected the company.

Being honest and genuine, I will once again state that I believe Nikon is now the leading system for bird
...Show more →

I and the majority of the market are not so bird/wildlife focused. We are more all around shooters with other priorities and therefore make other choices. It is good that we are all getting what we want and need these days.

Sorry but time to move over. The new Plena is quickly being declared THE top dog for portrait lens. I can assure you (myself included) for portrait and wedding and event shooting Nikon is right at the top of this game as well. No categorizing of limiting Nikon's realm to Wildlife and Birding by any means. The Z9/Z8 are "Do It All" cameras. A brilliant move on their part if I do say so.
Nov 06, 2023 at 11:06 AM
1bwana1
Offline
Details
p.5 #11Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
dcisive wrote:
Sorry but time to move over. The new Plena is quickly being declared THE top dog for portrait lens. I can assure you (myself included) for portrait and wedding and event shooting Nikon is right at the top of this game as well. No categorizing of limiting Nikon's realm to Wildlife and Birding by any means. The Z9/Z8 are "Do It All" cameras. A brilliant move on their part if I do say so.


You forgot to mention the money you save on a gym membership by lugging that heavy stuff around all day. When you look at it that way, it does sort of make sense for some. Myself, I prefer to keep my workouts and photography separate, so I make other choices like I said. My most used system these days is Leica M. Pretty much the opposite orientation of the A1 Z8/9 style cameras. I know I am not alone in this because Leica stuff is almost always backordered, and they are having their biggest years in history this year. Once again, it is all person preference when it comes to photographic equipment and many other things. There is no objective best.

I do love the look from the Plena!
Nov 06, 2023 at 11:13 AM
MikeInPa
Offline
Details
p.5 #12Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
Vinnie_VdB wrote:
Folks, it is the Nikon section and did not cross post to the Sony section.
So, Sony folks, stay over in your section, there is no need to be stingy and defensive, better praise your gear in mind-liked groups.


Thank you Vinnie, it’s precisely the reason I rarely bother even viewing the FM forum. All these Sony fanboys with their barbed praise as their reason for posting on the NIKON forum. They have a perfectly adequate forum of their own to cast as many envious aspersions about Nikon as they like without polluting the Nikon forum.
Nov 06, 2023 at 11:36 AM
saaketham
Offline
Details
p.5 #13Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
MikeInPa wrote:
All these Sony fanboys with their barbed praise as their reason for posting on the NIKON forum.


I'm glad I'm not the only one recognizes the backhanded compliments and condescending praise
The dude's a genius at this ...
Nov 06, 2023 at 12:04 PM
henry albert
Offline
Details
p.5 #14Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video

MikeInPa wrote:
All these Sony fanboys with their barbed praise as their reason for posting on the NIKON forum.


Agreed. However, this thread and the "where's the mirrorless D500" thread demonstrate that pomposity and arrogance are also alive and well in the Nikon forum.
Nov 06, 2023 at 12:33 PM
dalegaspi
Offline
Details
p.5 #15Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video

saaketham wrote:
MikeInPa wroteAll these Sony fanboys with their barbed praise as their reason for posting on the NIKON forum.
I'm glad I'm not the only one recognizes the backhanded compliments and condescending praise
The dude's a genius at this ...


he would make the backhanded compliment on Nikon while vigorously defending Sony and bashing Nikon. when you call him out...he will accuse you of being defensive.

gaslighting at its worst...and he thinks nobody can see through it.
Nov 06, 2023 at 12:37 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.5 #16Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
A genius in his own mind, sadly. All those hobbies he claims to have, and yet he sits around Nikon forums with a persistent case of butthurt

It's a tired schtick from a tired ol poster that just can't let it go.
Nov 06, 2023 at 12:40 PM
Alistair1
Offline
Details
p.5 #17Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
It looks like Sony will release a new camera body soon (A9III) which will undoubtedly have more interesting technology. Hopefully that will occupy our friends from the Sony forum for a while.
Nov 06, 2023 at 12:45 PM
1bwana1
Offline
Details
p.5 #18Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
RoamingScott wrote:
A genius in his own mind, sadly. All those hobbies he claims to have, and yet he sits around Nikon forums with a persistent case of butthurt

It's a tired schtick from a tired ol poster that just can't let it go.


Hey, I thought you hid me? Darn...
Nov 06, 2023 at 01:11 PM
1bwana1
Offline
Details
p.5 #19Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
You guys need to get your sense of humor back. That post was entirely tongue in cheek. Jeez, so sensitive. Time to get over it.
Nov 06, 2023 at 01:13 PM
MikeInPa
Offline
Details
p.5 #20Steve Perry on the Z9 with FW 4.1 - follow up video
1bwana1 wrote:
You guys need to get your sense of humor back. That post was entirely tongue in cheek. Jeez, so sensitive. Time to get over it.


Which one of the hundreds of Sony fanboy posts on the Nikon forum are you referring to this time, as if there’s only one.
Nov 06, 2023 at 01:18 PM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister