fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2022 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2022What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?

  
 
chez
Offline
Details
p.4 #1What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
Ayoul wrote:
I'm a pro (weddings). I don't care about an uncertain loss of sharpness, I care about resale value.

(


Well you are the first pro that I've met that cares about the resale value of their gear. Most have that gear written off long before they resell it...and most of the time the gear is really bashed up. I've never seen a pro baby their gear. Shooting from the pits at concerts next to the pros, I've seen them drop a camera / lens onto the ground as they reach for another. Couple friends of mine shoot weddings and their gear is very well used.

I personally would never buy equipment that was used by a pro as most replace their gear once it's been pretty worn out.
Jul 18, 2022 at 05:01 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.4 #2What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
Unless I’m under water issues than never
Jul 18, 2022 at 05:04 PM
NJPhotographer
Offline
Details
p.4 #3What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
Ayoul wrote:
I put protective filter in front of all of my lenses since a few years now.

Back in my Nikon D700 days, I did a quick comparison to see if the filter affected sharpness or colors. I didn't see anything. Now I have 24mpx cameras so things may be a little bit more visible, or not. But honnestly I didn't check seriously again for any hypothetical sharpness loss.

The only thing that I noticed is a little bit more ghosting in backlight (most specifically at night with spot lights in the frame). But I can live with that. What I don't want
...Show more →

Agreed. Resale value matters for sure, as does the ability to function for its intended purpose. For example, buy a new lens for $1,500 and use it for some years, and it's still worth $1,000 or more. But if one strong scrape scratches the front element, it's now worth just $500. And it's going to be out for a few weeks for a $500 repair. The lens instantly loses its functionality and trustworthiness. A protective filter significantly increases both the value retention and the ability to function as expected at the moment it's needed.
Jul 18, 2022 at 05:35 PM
Charlie N
Offline
Details
p.4 #4What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
I took a loss on a scratched lens, as well as bought scratched lenses at incredible prices.

I filter up and remove the filter only when I detect something wrong (which you should be able to)
Jul 18, 2022 at 05:56 PM
ramesesthe2nd
Offline
Details
p.4 #5What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
I put protective UV filters and I also use lens hoods on all my lenses. I take diligent care of all my gear. The only thing I am a little easy on is lens caps. I usually put caps in my jeans pocket with all my other stuff and don't worry too much about scratches and scuffs on those.

I have seen those YouTube videos, and I am aware that it takes a lot of damage for IQ to take a hit, but it just gives me an extra peace of mind and at this point I have enough UV filters in all sizes and shapes already that I usually don't have to buy anything new when buying a new lens.


Edited on Jul 18, 2022 at 07:26 PM · View previous versions
Jul 18, 2022 at 06:06 PM
Ayoul
Offline
Details
p.4 #6What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
chez wrote:
Ayoul wroteI'm a pro (weddings). I don't care about an uncertain loss of sharpness, I care about resale value.

(
Well you are the first pro that I've met that cares about the resale value of their gear. Most have that gear written off long before they resell it...and most of the time the gear is really bashed up. I've never seen a pro baby their gear. Shooting from the pits at concerts next to the pros, I've seen them drop a camera / lens onto the ground as they reach for another. Couple friends of mine shoot weddings and their gear is very well used.

I personally would never buy equipment that was used by a pro as most replace
...Show more →

Hehe, that was the case with my old nikon lenses. At first I didn't put filters on it. I can't sell them for a good price by now, to many scratches. Because I didn't protect them. But things have changed. All of my Sony lenses are, at least optically, like new. So unless I bump them to often and got them decentered or tilted, I will be able to sell them at a decent price if I want.

Another advantage of protective filter is that if you have an emergency (an obvious dirty thing on your filter), you can clean your lens fast on the field without worrying too much about doing something wrong (like adding an additional scratches if you didn't pay enough attention about the things on your filter). My front element is secure. If something happens on the field, at worst I remove the filter and buy another one for the next job.

I know that it's an endless debate and my opinon won't stop it, but for me the days of questionning this matter are long gone. I protect every lens that I can, I don't see any meaningful difference in image quality, I replace my filters when they are obviously too damaged and can cause some visible degradation (and I take years for me to reach that point).

If I want to sell a lens, at least I will not have to write that famous "small dirts and scratches that won't affect image quality on the front element", which may or may not affect the image quality but will without a doubt make my lens a lot cheaper.
Jul 18, 2022 at 06:13 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.4 #7What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
Seriously I never scratched a front element in 47 years. I’m careful but not anal
Jul 18, 2022 at 06:26 PM
wordfool
Offline
Details
p.4 #8What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
smpetty wrote:
I agree, mostly, but I have had two lens injuries (front element) when not using filters that likely would have been less severe or prevented had a filter been in place. One was bumping the front element of my Canon 16-35/2.8 L on rock during a climb in Canyonlands, the other was scraping the front element of a 35mm lens on pit wall at the Charlotte Motor Speedway.

So my experiences have led to me often using protection filters. I have never had a front element nick, scratch, or fracture while using the protection filters, so my success rate, so
...Show more →

Yes, the sort of use cases when I'd also use a filter on a lens -- when there's a strong chance of me/camera colliding with something hard (or something hard like sand colliding with me/camera). Other times I'd probably not bother, like taking photos of relatives at a nice peaceful garden party, for example. So filters serve a purpose for me, one that might save me whatever it costs these days to replace a front element (or take an equivalent hit on the used value of a lens).

And the beauty of using filters selectively is that you don't need one for every lens, just a few of the right size to rotate as needed.
Jul 18, 2022 at 08:47 PM
Imagemaster
Offline
Details
p.4 #9What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
Now that we have regurgitated this subject for the umpteenth time, do you think we could have as much fun discussing whether you prefer white or black lenses, or prefer putting protective covers on them?

Just because this subject has also been discussed many times does not mean we can’t get several pages of varying opinions.
Jul 18, 2022 at 09:06 PM
Younjulius
Offline
Details
p.4 #10What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
On a slight different note, are those lens cleaner liquids safe to use that won’t damage the coating? I’d like to know a good cleaning product since there’re so many out there.
Jul 18, 2022 at 09:10 PM
doc4x5
Offline
Details
p.4 #11What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
I'm with Guy, I cannot recall damaging a lens in well over 50 years of definitely non-professional photography but I do use filters at the beach, blowing sand is genuinely evil, salt water as well. Having said all that, it seems to me to make minimal sense to use a filter when there is no obvious need, eg in the woods, around town, in one's home. There's a bell curve with high risk takers at one end and the perhaps overly cautious at the other. Each of us should stand where we're most comfortable.
Jul 19, 2022 at 12:30 AM
ruthenium
Offline
Details
p.4 #12What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
This thread illustrates, in small ways, how people can be driven by fears, guided by beliefs, and end up divided, sometimes bitterly, by what they chose to believe in.
Jul 19, 2022 at 01:43 AM
MARKFER
Offline
Details
p.4 #13What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
Ruthenium, I would argue not one person in the history of the internet has ever been convinced by somebody else something that they were not already convinced themselves of or open to the idea already. People divide they rarely come together. It's our nature.
Jul 19, 2022 at 06:28 AM
Younjulius
Offline
Details
p.4 #14What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
ruthenium wrote:
This thread illustrates, in small ways, how people can be driven by fears, guided by beliefs, and end up divided, sometimes bitterly, by what they chose to believe in.


Peoples are just stating their opinions here. If you can’t stand it, you don’t need to come to read this. You and imagemaster are only two bitter on this subject for some reason.
Jul 19, 2022 at 06:36 AM
smpetty
Offline
Details
p.4 #15What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
Younjulius wrote:
ruthenium wroteThis thread illustrates, in small ways, how people can be driven by fears, guided by beliefs, and end up divided, sometimes bitterly, by what they chose to believe in.
Peoples are just stating their opinions here. If you can’t stand it, you don’t need to come to read this. You and imagemaster are only two bitter on this subject for some reason.


I think that @ruthenium was just recognizing a broader trend on social media and in American society. We are very divided by so many issues, even ones as trivial as whether or not to use protective filters. It is a sad state of affairs. I did not read his comment as being critical in any way of your original question.

@Imagemaster is always grumpy and argumentative, nothing new...
Jul 19, 2022 at 07:16 AM
naturephoto1
Offline
Details
p.4 #16What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
With the exception of my lenses that will not accept front filters and my 2 lenses with highly recessed elements- my Voigtlander 65mm f2 Macro Apo-Lanthar Asph and my Leica R 100mm f4 Macro Bellows lenses, I use B+W or Heliopan UV filters to protect the front elements of my lenses. With the filters in place, I protect the lens front elements elliminating in most instances the need for cleaning the lens front element. I would rather clean and if need be replace the filter than a lens front element. If there is a slight loss in resolution, I can live with it and if I find in certain lighting conditions I get more reflections, I will remove the filter to take an image.

Rich
Jul 19, 2022 at 07:21 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.4 #17What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
I almost never use UV filters and almost always use a hood. My wife keeps a UV filter on almost all her lenses almost all the time. I like insurance with fairly limited coverage and a high deductible for a lower price. She likes insurance with lots of coverage and a lower deductible at a higher price. As you might guess we have a difference in how much risk we tolerate. Both positions are reasonable (both for filters and insurance). This doesn't have to be a divisive issue and a range of positions are reasonable. In my opinion there is no right or wrong answer. If you can tolerate a small chance of damaging your lens (something I can tolerate), then you don't have to add a protective filter. If you can't tolerate that small chance (as my wife can't) then add a UV or clear filter. Each person will know whether they can tolerate the risk or not.
Jul 19, 2022 at 07:34 AM
DaveFP
Offline
Details
p.4 #18What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
ruthenium wrote:
This thread illustrates, in small ways, how people can be driven by fears, guided by beliefs, and end up divided, sometimes bitterly, by what they chose to believe in.


I might be misunderstanding you but I don't see anything in this topic that revolves around beliefs.

There are certainly facts and preferences here but not really beliefs.

Protective glass does, in fact, protect the front element and with some lenses they can help provide sealing.

Protective glass does, in fact, potentially reduce image quality.

Preferences are based on the perceived risk:benefit associated with each choice.

Everything else is noise.



Jul 19, 2022 at 08:27 AM
tschopp
Offline
Details
p.4 #19What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
It would be helpful if people would let me know if the use of a UV filter is a conservative or liberal issue. This will help me know what my opinion should be.

But in all seriousness, I tend to fall into the use protection group as apposed to riding bareback. My main concern is keeping the lens clean and enabling easy cleaning. I'm not worried about damage, but I like to have clean glass. I have some grandkids that are skilled in getting fingerprints on the lens. Also just random stuff that lands on the glass. I can take the filter off and wash it in the sink then a rinse with distilled (sometimes the best option for toddler fingerprints).

I like testing, scientific testing is what I do for a living. I tested images from a 135GM to see if I could see any difference with a filter and I could not. But, in astro work with stacked images that tend to magnify small differences I am able to see a negative impact from the filter. For that work I leave the filter off, and am surprised ad how much debris can get on a lens just exposed to the clean night air. Listening to Roger from lens rentals he has seen some subtle issues from filters on bokah and other odd distortions. Does anyone know if their rentals come with filters? It sounded like they did. It makes me want to do more testing on all my filters. But fortunately I am currently in the mode of just shoot, don't worry, and enjoy.

So yes, risk reward tradeoff. A filter allows me to have cleaner glass than I might otherwise.
Jul 19, 2022 at 11:34 AM
Imagemaster
Offline
Details
p.4 #20What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
Younjulius wrote:
On a slight different note, are those lens cleaner liquids safe to use that won’t damage the coating? I’d like to know a good cleaning product since there’re so many out there.


Really? Sounds like you are just trolling some more. Maybe try and use the Search feature, just like you could have for the subject of this thread.

Did you miss: If it's just a finger print smudge with no chance of sand or other grit...quick breath onto the lens and a clean cloth and you are good to go in under 10 seconds. And you will get many other different opinions.

What coating are you talking about? You think most lens cleaner liquids being sold are going to damage something

Go to B&H website and read reviews:

https://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/search?q=lens%20cleaner&sts=ma
Jul 19, 2022 at 11:47 AM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister