p.3 #2What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
chez wrote: smpetty wrotechez wrotesmpetty wrotewordfool wroteOh no, not this debate again. I look forward to trenchant opinions masquerading as objective facts As you say, there is no right or wrong answer and I doubt anyone could tell the IQ difference between no filter, a UV filter and a clear filter (as long as the filters are high quality of course). I use either UV or clear filters on some lenses, not on others, depending on lens, use case scenario, weather, and a host of other factors. And UV vs clear depending on what was cheapest at the time of purchase. The only time I definitely wouldn't use a filter is if there's a strong chance of flare (low sun or a lot of reflections etc.) because I've noticed over the years that filters can make it worse.
My opinion is that filters are much cheaper than replacing a front element and do little or nothing to degrade an image (especially when you factor in how much dust can accumulation on a nekkid front element during a day of shooting anyway). So why not use them for a bit of insurance to avoid having to clean crud off the front element all the time and risk scratches? And on those hood-not-required days they certainly make life easier than dealing with a big clumsy hood as "protection".Agree 100%.
I am unlikely to use the front of my shirt to clean dirt/salt water/sweat/finger smudges/dog slobber/whale gravy/cobra venom/alpaca spit/etc. off of the front of my lens when hiking/climbing/biking, but I won't hesitate to do the same if a good quality clear or UV filter is in place. It really is a decision best made on your own experiences. Those that go without must be a good bit more fastidious than me. I quite often clean my lenses when out in the field with my breath and tee shirt. Never had an issue with this. Now in environments that have blowing sand or salt, I'll put a filter on...but most of the time it's a polarizer for the effects.I agree, mostly, but I have had two lens injuries (front element) when not using filters that likely would have been less severe or prevented had a filter been in place. One was bumping the front element of my Canon 16-35/2.8 L on rock during a climb in Canyonlands, the other was scraping the front element of a 35mm lens on pit wall at the Charlotte Motor Speedway.
So my experiences have led to me often using protection filters. I have never had a front element nick, scratch, or fracture while using the protection filters, so my success rate, so far, is 100%
YMMVLens hoods would have prevented both of those situations. I find a lens hood provides much more protection against bumps or scrapes of the front element.
I almost always use lens hoods. I had lens hoods on in both cases. The pit wall scrape was on a corner of the wall, the climbing rock bump was with the shallow/small 16-35/2.8 hood in place.
p.3 #3What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
If you don't need a filter don't use one. If you think you do go for it. A thin piece of glass in front of the lens protects it but also theoretically degrades image quality.
p.3 #4What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
RoamingScott wrote:
I have to laugh at the notion of putting them on your MOST expensive lenses...you know, the lenses you paid that much for because of their superior IQ...and then slap a cheap piece of glass in front of it.
A novel idea: spend that money on insuring your gear instead and enjoy your lens as it's meant to be used.
No need to put a "cheap" filter on your lenses when very high quality expensive filters are available. High quality filters probably cost more than the cheapest element in even a very expensive lens.
Insurance does no good when at virtually every wedding I get smudges on my lenses and have to clean them, ... sometimes clean them very quickly as something important is about to happen.
p.3 #6What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
NJPhotographer wrote: RoamingScott wroteI have to laugh at the notion of putting them on your MOST expensive lenses...you know, the lenses you paid that much for because of their superior IQ...and then slap a cheap piece of glass in front of it.
A novel idea: spend that money on insuring your gear instead and enjoy your lens as it's meant to be used.No need to put a "cheap" filter on your lenses when very high quality expensive filters are available. High quality filters probably cost more than the cheapest element in even a very expensive lens.
Insurance does no good when at virtually every wedding I get smudges on my lenses and have to clean them, ... sometimes clean them very quickly as something important is about to happen.
But don't you still have to clean the smudge off the filter? What is the diff?
If it's just a finger print smudge with no chance of sand or other grit...quick breath onto the lens and a clean cloth and you are good to go in under 10 seconds.
p.3 #7What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
chez wrote: NJPhotographer wroteRoamingScott wroteI have to laugh at the notion of putting them on your MOST expensive lenses...you know, the lenses you paid that much for because of their superior IQ...and then slap a cheap piece of glass in front of it.
A novel idea: spend that money on insuring your gear instead and enjoy your lens as it's meant to be used.No need to put a "cheap" filter on your lenses when very high quality expensive filters are available. High quality filters probably cost more than the cheapest element in even a very expensive lens.
Insurance does no good when at virtually every wedding I get smudges on my lenses and have to clean them, ... sometimes clean them very quickly as something important is about to happen.But don't you still have to clean the smudge off the filter? What is the diff?
If it's just a finger print smudge with no chance of sand or other grit...quick breath onto the lens and a clean cloth and you are good to go in under 10 seconds.
With a high quality filter, I'm always good to go in under 10 seconds, without worry about the speed or pressure of cleaning. With an unprotected lens, I'd have to examine the smudge before cleaning (grit is possible), and then clean it with much greater care. Hard to do when time is of the essence. The used lens market (eBay, etc.) has plenty of lenses with scratches and cleaning marks showing how that approach fails.
p.3 #8What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
I've been shooting for 55 years and never once have I used a protective filter, and I've never had an issue because of it. On the other hand, I always use a lens hood. On 2 different occasions an expensive lens was saved from disaster by using a hood.
Jul 18, 2022 at 01:06 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.3 #9What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
Having worked in IT for many, many (too many) years, I've seen the effect of reckless, dirty people on expensive gear. It baffles me how people can be so careless with things that are that expensive, but I have come to understand that some people are just THAT WAY. Some of these people literally exude grease from every pore and their equipment gets gunked up in short order. For people like that, I could see a use for filters.
This isn't insinuating all filter users fall into this camp. It's just one set of people that would probably universally benefit from filters.
p.3 #10What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
I have oily skin, not that I want to. Does that make me reckless and dirty? Or just dirty? Wow, and I'm in IT.
In my 52 years of living, I've learned that people are different...do different types of things, have different priorities, handle things differently based on their priorities.
I've also seen the proclivity for people to judge their way, based on what they do, and what's important to them....as the only correct answer. I even fall into that trap sometimes.
Bottom line is that every choice has pros and cons. Find what makes sense to you, and don't worry about what other people think. Unless some insight makes sense for your priorities and you believe it can improve things for you.
If someone does things differently than you, be inquisitive.....make suggestions based on your experience if you like. But don't judge them as "wrong" if they don't do things exactly as you. Life is too short to get bogged down into "my way is better than your way" arguments.
To the OP. Some people use them, some people don't. There are pros and cons, many of which have been surfaced in this thread.
RoamingScott wrote:
Having worked in IT for many, many (too many) years, I've seen the effect of reckless, dirty people on expensive gear. It baffles me how people can be so careless with things that are that expensive, but I have come to understand that some people are just THAT WAY. Some of these people literally exude grease from every pore and their equipment gets gunked up in short order. For people like that, I could see a use for filters.
This isn't insinuating all filter users fall into this camp. It's just one set of people that would probably universally benefit from filters....Show more →
p.3 #12What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
NJPhotographer wrote: chez wroteNJPhotographer wroteRoamingScott wroteI have to laugh at the notion of putting them on your MOST expensive lenses...you know, the lenses you paid that much for because of their superior IQ...and then slap a cheap piece of glass in front of it.
A novel idea: spend that money on insuring your gear instead and enjoy your lens as it's meant to be used.No need to put a "cheap" filter on your lenses when very high quality expensive filters are available. High quality filters probably cost more than the cheapest element in even a very expensive lens.
Insurance does no good when at virtually every wedding I get smudges on my lenses and have to clean them, ... sometimes clean them very quickly as something important is about to happen.But don't you still have to clean the smudge off the filter? What is the diff?
If it's just a finger print smudge with no chance of sand or other grit...quick breath onto the lens and a clean cloth and you are good to go in under 10 seconds.With a high quality filter, I'm always good to go in under 10 seconds, without worry about the speed or pressure of cleaning. With an unprotected lens, I'd have to examine the smudge before cleaning (grit is possible), and then clean it with much greater care. Hard to do when time is of the essence. The used lens market (eBay, etc.) has plenty of lenses with scratches and cleaning marks showing how that approach fails.
I find I have to take the hood off whenever cleaning the lens so the quick turnaround is not likely. I also find I get very few smudges on my lens if I have a hood.
p.3 #13What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
To the OP. If you are concerned about damaging your lens element, I suggest looking into insurance coverage that not only will cover you damaging you lens element, but will cover your entire gear from any damage and theft. Damaging a front element is just one small risk, there are many other ways of damaging your equipment which a filter would have zero impact. I find insurance is the best approach from covering your equipment against damage costs and it also covers theft or even loss.
p.3 #14What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
tsdevine wrote:
I have oily skin, not that I want to. Does that make me reckless and dirty? Or just dirty? Wow, and I'm in IT.
In my 52 years of living, I've learned that people are different...do different types of things, have different priorities, handle things differently based on their priorities.
I've also seen the proclivity for people to judge their way, based on what they do, and what's important to them....as the only correct answer. I even fall into that trap sometimes.
Bottom line is that every choice has pros and cons. Find what makes sense to you, and don't worry about what other people think. Unless some insight makes sense for your priorities and you believe it can improve things for you.
If someone does things differently than you, be inquisitive.....make suggestions based on your experience if you like. But don't judge them as "wrong" if they don't do things exactly as you. Life is too short to get bogged down into "my way is better than your way" arguments.
To the OP. Some people use them, some people don't. There are pros and cons, many of which have been surfaced in this thread.
...Show more →RoamingScott wroteHaving worked in IT for many, many (too many) years, I've seen the effect of reckless, dirty people on expensive gear. It baffles me how people can be so careless with things that are that expensive, but I have come to understand that some people are just THAT WAY. Some of these people literally exude grease from every pore and their equipment gets gunked up in short order. For people like that, I could see a use for filters.
This isn't insinuating all filter users fall into this camp. It's just one set of people that would probably universally benefit from filters.
p.3 #15What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
DaveFP wrote:
... and the 652 earlier threads that have covered this same exact topic...
Yeah, but don't tell the OP that he could have done a Search, or else he might think you were making fun of him. He only wants opinions he agrees with, and no humorus ones.
Younjulius wrote:
....... there’s no correct answer to this, .......just curious of the latest opinions ........
p.3 #17What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
actually, i do use a filter when i know i'll be handing my camera to someone else, not judging them or anything but for some reason some people just like to touch the front element lol
p.3 #18What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
Imagemaster wrote: NJPhotographer wroteHigh quality filters probably cost more than the cheapest element in even a very expensive lens. That is really funny. So you put on a more expensive filter to protect a less expensive front element
The point is that filters don't have to be "cheap" or of poor quality. A high quality filter will cost, say $60 to $120, depending on the size. That's not cheap. And it's well in-line with the cost of some other elements in a typical high quality lens.
If a lens costs, say, $1400 and has, say, 14 elements, some of those 14 elements likely cost less than the cost of the filter. Yet we don't say that those elements are "cheap", and we don't complain that Sony put a "cheap" element in our expensive lens. Nobody complains about some "cheap" $49 lens element (among those 14 lens elements) degrading the image quality of their expensive lens.
Again, to be clear, the point is that there is not necessarily a mismatch between the quality of an expensive lens and the quality of an expensive filter. They can both be excellent, and an excellent match for each other.
p.3 #19What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
I've come to the conclusion that I'm too hard on my gear to go without a front filter in place. I used to go with the lens cap + hood for each lens on all of my outings, but I spend a lot of time outside and hiking around, bushwhacking, or stuffing the camera in and out of a pack, I scuffed the coatings on more than one expensive lens. No idea how, since I would use a lens cap religiously.
Now I use a quality clear filter on my nice lenses and I treat it almost like a lens cap in some ways. If I'm taking an image I know will be demanding, but is also something special; like a landscape in good light at infinity, I'll just unscrew the filter for the image and then screw it back in when I'm done.
I'm also in the camp of feeling that I have way more image quality that I usually need at my fingertips, so a very very slight drop doesn't bother me.
My exception to this is my longer lens when doing something like birding. I always end up cropping in and I want every pixel's worth of data, which I don't usually need for everything else.
p.3 #20What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
I put protective filter in front of all of my lenses since a few years now.
Back in my Nikon D700 days, I did a quick comparison to see if the filter affected sharpness or colors. I didn't see anything. Now I have 24mpx cameras so things may be a little bit more visible, or not. But honnestly I didn't check seriously again for any hypothetical sharpness loss.
The only thing that I noticed is a little bit more ghosting in backlight (most specifically at night with spot lights in the frame). But I can live with that. What I don't want to reproduce is the slight scratches and various type of degradations that affected my early lenses when I didn't have any filters in front of it. I'm a pro (weddings). I don't care about an uncertain loss of sharpness, I care about resale value.
(And yes, I use all the lens hoods as well, but sooner or later, it's not enough to really protect the front).