p.6 #5The Incredible Voigtlander 50mm f2 APO Lanthar
'company declares: The optical design is optimized for mirrorless camera image sensors that use the Nikon Z mount.'
This small and market-insignificant lens maker does not appear to be in the hyperbole business so characteristic of the high powered megacorps that fill out the huge centre of the industry. And as Lloyd Chambers opines: 'they hide their light under a bushell.' They are shy and quiet achievers.
I expect them to be painfully aware of the sensor issue. It means this: while you might be considering using an M/E mount CV lens on a Z camera, well it won't work as well as the one we make specifically for those cameras.
After all, they know the forensic attention their lenses will receive, and criticism is not off-limits for reviewers in the way it is for the review lenses from the industry giants. Even tiny faults in CV lenses are worth a mention to many of us here.
Maybe readers can hopefully point to evidence to the contrary, either in past behaviours or later findings to the contrary of the very little that Cosina utters. Some of it will get lost in translation, though. When they say an M lens can be used with an adapter on S/N cameras, they are simply referring to the practicality of doing so. I haven't read any actual endorsements of IQ from them from adapters.
p.6 #6The Incredible Voigtlander 50mm f2 APO Lanthar
'I was shocked to note that the 50Z @ f/2 is sharper than the 135/2 AS @ f/2.8!'
It's a common experience, the f2 image quality is astounding, and, importantly, opens new pathways of creative exploration due to the super focal plane and its fade. WRT the above quote, the 50/2 is also better at f2 than the 135/2 at its best aperture of f4. It's hair-splitting in this company, and different design choices too, but there it is. Cosina's main business is as a glass specialist. They have a huge and diversified inventory and accumulated knowledge and expertise. It feeds into the ALs.
I always get the impression from my 50/2 images that they remind me of high end medium format film transparencies. The content just looks so 'dense' with a rich luminance - very satisfying. High quality imaging is 'immersive', that might best describe it.
p.6 #11The Incredible Voigtlander 50mm f2 APO Lanthar
Thanks Mike.
However it's difficult to compare pictures under different lighting conditions (see for example the gator signal) and/or with not coincident focus point (it seems the leaf pictures weren't focused on the same point).
p.6 #15The Incredible Voigtlander 50mm f2 APO Lanthar
Steve Spencer wrote: Ripolini wrotephilip_pj wroteSecond, Cosina get 'two for one' when they specifically target Sony and Nikon because of the great similarity of the cameras/sensors/focus methods.In the Cosina website, in the Z-mount lenses page (https://www.cosina.co.jp/voigtlander/z-mount/), the Company declares: The optical design is optimized for mirrorless camera image sensors that use the Nikon Z mount.
Now, I wonder if they did really teak the design of Z mount lenses to take into account the small difference in the Sony/Nikon sensor stack thickness, or if that sentence is just marketing ...I suspect it is just marketing, but we will probably never know. Note the sentence from Cosina is true even if the optical design was originally developed for Sony and it just turns out that they think that is also optimized for Nikon. From Cosina's perspective they could very well think that the one design they made was optimized for both Sony E mount and Nikon Z mount. Kind of slippery to say it the way they do, but marketing is often like that.
Wonder if any one compared the Z vs E lens on the Nikon Z mount to discern if any difference in performance/rendering can be seen.
p.6 #16The Incredible Voigtlander 50mm f2 APO Lanthar
This lens is on sale new for $750 at CameraQuest. (Can order directly or thru the CameraQuest store via Amazon). I ordered directly for the business relationship . Other Z Voigtlander lenses also are at reduced prices.
p.6 #17The Incredible Voigtlander 50mm f2 APO Lanthar
Well, I've joined the cult. Received what appears to be a well-centered copy today and the render is exactly what I hoped for after reading 88 pages of commentary about the Sony version of this lens. The 3-D pop, resolution, and incredible performance wide open are highly reminiscent of the Leica SL APO Summicrons I used to own - at a fraction of the cost. It does sunstars way better than the Leicas. The little green focus indicator works very well on the Z7. IBIS also works after entering the lens settings - was able to get some crisp shots at 1/15s on day one.
p.6 #18The Incredible Voigtlander 50mm f2 APO Lanthar
Some of accessory questions:
1) anyone using extension tubes with this lens to get closer, if so, which ones and how do you like the results? I will say the mfd isn’t bad at all (0.18x I think) but I’d like to get to 0.3x at times. I’m also open to diopters but feel like that could be like putting a pig on some lipstick.
2) the absence of weather sealing is a bit disconcerting for a Florida shooter. Any off the shelf rain cover that would fit a Z7 with this lens and not heinously interfere with operation? I know, probably a unicorn. My fallback is a clear shower cap attached with a bit of gaffer tape around the hood. I can see the headline now ‘Florida man puts shower cap on camera, gets eaten by fashion conscious alligator.’
3) maybe I’m not color-cast sensitive but so far I’m not seeing the magenta cast on the margins of the frame Sony users were encountering. Or maybe Florida sunshine eats marginal magenta for breakfast. If I ever start to notice, my understanding is there’s a Zeiss UV filter to get. I think something like would also help protect the lens from Florida. Thoughts?
p.6 #19The Incredible Voigtlander 50mm f2 APO Lanthar
woodstork wrote:
1) anyone using extension tubes with this lens to get closer, if so, which ones and how do you like the results? I will say the mfd isn’t bad at all (0.18x I think) but I’d like to get to 0.3x at times. I’m also open to diopters but feel like that could be like putting a pig on some lipstick.
Consider that Leica makes a even higher quality close-up filter, the (expensive) Elpro 52 that can be used on their M 50/2 Apo-Summicron: https://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/1431562-REG/leica_14125_elpro_52_set.html/overview
With the Elpro 52 + Leica M 50/2 Apo Summicron one gets magnifications in the range 1:2.6-1:2 (0.38-0.5 X) at 20-22 cm focusing distances. I bet similar figures holds for the 50/2 Apo Lanthar too.
As a general remark, a lens that was not designed to take close-ups will not maintain its full optical qualities when "forced" to focus closer by adding extension. Therefore, a loss of quality (e.g., field curvature) must be expected even with extension tubes (even if they don't have any lens element).
woodstork wrote:
3) maybe I’m not color-cast sensitive but so far I’m not seeing the magenta cast on the margins of the frame Sony users were encountering. Or maybe Florida sunshine eats marginal magenta for breakfast. If I ever start to notice, my understanding is there’s a Zeiss UV filter to get. I think something like would also help protect the lens from Florida. Thoughts?
I use permanently the Kenko Zéta UV L41. It reduces the (slight) magenta color cast I noted with my Z6. And sunshine in Rome (Italy) is not that different from Florida's
No image degradation occurs.
p.6 #20The Incredible Voigtlander 50mm f2 APO Lanthar
Thank you for the excellent advice! Only disagreement is I would contend the light in Italy is more beautiful than Florida. At least that’s what I saw the week I was in Rome and Naples. Florida light is almost always angry, probably by being choked by stifling humidity all day. It’s best to shoot before it’s had its coffee and wakes up.
I will shop the Nikon and Leica diopters (and order the Kenko UV41). How much better is the Leica Elpro vs Nikon 4T? Worth the price difference? For reference, I have Canon 500D closeup filter that I’ve used maybe twice in 20 years. It’s very good but I’d like better.
Ripolini wrote: woodstork wrote1) anyone using extension tubes with this lens to get closer, if so, which ones and how do you like the results? I will say the mfd isn’t bad at all (0.18x I think) but I’d like to get to 0.3x at times. I’m also open to diopters but feel like that could be like putting a pig on some lipstick.Achromatic (two-element) close-up filters have higher quality and aren't "pig on lipstick"
In my previous post I showed some results one can get with the Nikon 4T diopter: https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1722699/3#16070017
Consider that Leica makes a even higher quality close-up filter, the (expensive) Elpro 52 that can be used on their M 50/2 Apo-Summicron: https://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/1431562-REG/leica_14125_elpro_52_set.html/overview
With the Elpro 52 + Leica M 50/2 Apo Summicron one gets magnifications in the range 1:2.6-1:2 (0.38-0.5 X) at 20-22 cm focusing distances. I bet similar figures holds for the 50/2 Apo Lanthar too.
As a general remark, a lens that was not designed to take close-ups will not maintain its full optical qualities when "forced" to focus closer by adding extension. Therefore, a loss of quality (e.g., field curvature) must be expected even with extension tubes (even if they don't have any lens element).
I use permanently the Kenko Zéta UV L41. It reduces the (slight) magenta color cast I noted with my Z6. And sunshine in Rome (Italy) is not that different from Florida's
No image degradation occurs.
...Show more →woodstork wrote3) maybe I’m not color-cast sensitive but so far I’m not seeing the magenta cast on the margins of the frame Sony users were encountering. Or maybe Florida sunshine eats marginal magenta for breakfast. If I ever start to notice, my understanding is there’s a Zeiss UV filter to get. I think something like would also help protect the lens from Florida. Thoughts?