p.2 #1The Incredible Voigtlander 50mm f2 APO Lanthar
ocean2059 wrote:
I went out for a walk this morning with my Z7 and Voigtlander 50mm f2 APO Lanthar (in E-mount with a MF adapter). Overall, the lens performs remarkably well, great sharpness and resolution with very neutral and subtle color retention. It just has the right amount of micro contrast with very 'clean' color definitions. Center sharpness may reach its peak at f/2.8 with excellent edge/corner sharpness to match.
p.2 #2The Incredible Voigtlander 50mm f2 APO Lanthar
Nice shots, y’all are bad influences.
Re: E vs M, Nikon is much closer to the E sensor stack than the M, and even at 50ish you can have stack issues with short registration distances, mostly noticeable with field curvature. Voigt does tweak the lens design for the stack, so E version should perform slightly better. M should still be fine though.
If you want to try it with AF, I’d go the M route and get the TZM or Megadap. Otherwise E is going to be a better bet, probably similar MFD as well even if you figure in a helical adapter.
One last point, an electronic adapter still isn’t a bad idea. One cool thing is that it’ll act like an AF-D lens where the box for focus point will turn red to green when in focus. Better than peaking and no magnification needed. Used to use Loxias this way and it’s very nice.
p.2 #3The Incredible Voigtlander 50mm f2 APO Lanthar
Ripolini wrote:
Devil, you're tempting me
P.S.: I wonder why the E version (for Sony) has 0.45 m minimum focus distance instead of 0.7 m of the VM-Mount lens. The E- and VM-mount versions share the same optics and performance on Nikon Z bodies?
Because Leicca rangefinders don't go closer than 0.7m? And making the lens go closer without coupling would complicate things internally.
p.2 #4The Incredible Voigtlander 50mm f2 APO Lanthar
gyoung143 wrote:
Because Leicca rangefinders don't go closer than 0.7m?
Correct.
gyoung143 wrote:
And making the lens go closer without coupling would complicate things internally.
Gerry
Yes, in fact the VM version is lighter than the E-mount lens.
The VM version has less APD elements than the E-mount sibling. I wonder why.
Could the closer focus distance of the E-mount 50/2 require more strict control of the aberrations?
I've read in the Voigtlander website that the VM version has floating elements; I couldn't find any mention to floating elements in the E-mount version webpage ...
In the same website they mention that the VM-version can be used also on Fuji-X and Nikon Z bodies.
It seems Voigtlander suggests the VM-mount for Nikon Z users ... https://www.voigtlaender.de/lenses/vm/50-mm-120-apo-lanthar-aspherical/?lang=en https://www.voigtlaender.de/lenses/e-mount/50-mm-120-apo-lanthar-e/?lang=en
p.2 #5The Incredible Voigtlander 50mm f2 APO Lanthar
AdaptedLenses wrote:
Re: E vs M, Nikon is much closer to the E sensor stack than the M, and even at 50ish you can have stack issues with short registration distances, mostly noticeable with field curvature. Voigt does tweak the lens design for the stack, so E version should perform slightly better. M should still be fine though.
Would the E version perform on Z bodies as it performs on Sony MILCs? could the slight difference in sensor stack thickness impair the performance of the E version on Z cameras? what's your opinion? Thanx.
p.2 #6The Incredible Voigtlander 50mm f2 APO Lanthar
Yes, it can / will change performance slightly. For example the Loxia 35mm had slightly better corners, slightly worse midfield due to the 2.3 vs 2.5mm sensor stack. But for most shots it won't be too noticeable.
Ripolini wrote: AdaptedLenses wroteRe: E vs M, Nikon is much closer to the E sensor stack than the M, and even at 50ish you can have stack issues with short registration distances, mostly noticeable with field curvature. Voigt does tweak the lens design for the stack, so E version should perform slightly better. M should still be fine though.Would the E version perform on Z bodies as it performs on Sony MILCs? could the slight difference in sensor stack thickness impair the performance of the E version on Z cameras? what's your opinion? Thanx.
p.2 #7The Incredible Voigtlander 50mm f2 APO Lanthar
Ripolini wrote: AdaptedLenses wroteRe: E vs M, Nikon is much closer to the E sensor stack than the M, and even at 50ish you can have stack issues with short registration distances, mostly noticeable with field curvature. Voigt does tweak the lens design for the stack, so E version should perform slightly better. M should still be fine though.Would the E version perform on Z bodies as it performs on Sony MILCs? could the slight difference in sensor stack thickness impair the performance of the E version on Z cameras? what's your opinion? Thanx.
Riccardo
I have used the Loxia 21, 25, & 85 as well as the Voigtlander 15, 21 f/1.4, 40 f/1.2, 50 f/1.2, 65 f/2 APO, and 110 f/2.5 APO on both a Sony 7r II and the Nikon Z7. There is very difference between the performance of any of the E mount lenses on these two cameras. The perform essentially the same. I have also shot the Voigtlander 28 f/2 II, and the 35 f/1.7, in VM mount and they are much better on my Leica M than on the Nikon Z7. From this experience I think Sony E mount lenses generally do better on Nikon Z mount cameras, than Leica M lenses, but there are a few Voigtlander VM lenses that do well on Nikon Z cameras these include the 15 f/4.5, 21 f/3.5, and 75 f/1.5. Basically you have to do you homework for VM lenses and see how they perform. So work well; others work not well at all. In contrast, Sony E mount lenses in my experience all work well on Nikon Z cameras.
p.2 #9The Incredible Voigtlander 50mm f2 APO Lanthar
Ripolini wrote:
Thanks Steve for sharing your experience. Nice to hear that the Voigtlander 21/3.5 VM works fine on Nikon Z cameras.
Steve Spencer wroteThere is very difference between the performance of any of the E mount lenses on these two cameras....I guess you meant "there is very little difference ..."
I would expect the Voigtlander 21 f/3.5 to work well on Z cameras--Fred reports it works virtually identically on Leica M mount, Sony E mount, and Leica L mount cameras, but I haven't tried that lens on the Z cameras. I have used the 21 f/1.4, however, and that works very well on my Nikon Z7. Sorry, I should have been more clear about which 21 I meant. And yes, I did mean there is very little difference. Sorry about leaving the word out. When I type fast, I do that far too often.
p.2 #11The Incredible Voigtlander 50mm f2 APO Lanthar
Ripolini wrote: Steve Spencer wroteI have used the 21 f/1.4, however, and that works very well on my Nikon Z7.Thanks Steve.
Does the Techart TZE-01 allows transmitting EXIF info (focal length, set aperture) to the Z body? Does IBIS work with 50/2?
Sorry I missed this until now. The TZE-01 does transit EXIF info to the Z body (both focal length and shot aperture) and the IBIS works well for the 50 f/2. When I had the TZE-01, IBIS worked best for 50mm lenses and not so well the farther you got from that but I believe TechArt has fixed that with a firmware upgrade,
p.2 #12The Incredible Voigtlander 50mm f2 APO Lanthar
Thanks for posting this. The Nikon 58mm 1.4 is by far my favorite lens. I’m planning on trying a Leica M soon and was planning to buy this APO lens as my first lens.
Preliminary comments:
- very good sharpness w/open at the minimum focus distance;
- few LoCA visible (probably my Zeiss 135/2 Apo Sonnar is slightly better @ f/2);
- bokeh ... well I don't dislike it, however I'll be glad to read your comments.
Hope to have time in the week-end to take more pictures.
p.2 #15The Incredible Voigtlander 50mm f2 APO Lanthar
Riccardo,
Congrats on the new lens!
At minimum focus distance, most of the image is out of focus, but seems pretty good.
Focus to bokeh transition seems very smooth too. Not too abrupt, which is more to my liking. Bokeh seems to have a little bit of a character, but that is highly depending on what they actually are, and the light conditions will affect it too, so I would not want to draw any conclusion on the bokeh. I can't wait to see more samples shot at f2.
p.2 #16The Incredible Voigtlander 50mm f2 APO Lanthar
'Which E -> Z adapter do you use and/or suggest?'
Sorry to miss this one, but you are there now in any case. I find the bokeh almost always very settled and attractive. Bear in mind this kind of lens seems to amp up many hyper-critical observers, they seem to find a higher level of forensic inspection about the APO-Lanthars, lol. It's very balanced in terms of usage, not much it cannot do well, as well as put out near-Otus performance technical levels. I see a little LoCA in ultra light shots, water sparkles and the like. [My copy of the 35mm version lacks even this.] Tremendous colour depth as you see in this thread, saturation can be pushed hard if need be. I often use f2.8 for the circular aperture effect, and it's probably the best overall image quality.
p.2 #17The Incredible Voigtlander 50mm f2 APO Lanthar
UPDATE
1) My 50/2 AL sample shows decentering (see attachment) at infinity (or so). I've already contacted the seller (the Italian importer) for replacement. New lenses should arrive on next week, and I told him that I prefer replacement to reimbursement (at least at present time). The importer office is just 20 min drive from my workplace.
BTW, I'm a little bit disappointed with Voigtlander quality control; if the 2nd sample will show misalignment problems too, I'll ask reimbursement and never buy again a Voigtlander lens.
2) Differently from my Zeiss lenses, EXIF data do not show neither the manufacturer nor the s/n. They indicate "50mm f/2" and aperture (just)
p.2 #18The Incredible Voigtlander 50mm f2 APO Lanthar
Ripolini wrote: UPDATE
1) My 50/2 AL sample shows decentering (see attachment) at infinity (or so). I've already contacted the seller (the Italian importer) for replacement. New lenses should arrive on next week, and I told him that I prefer replacement to reimbursement (at least at present time). The importer office is just 20 min drive from my workplace.
BTW, I'm a little bit disappointed with Voigtlander quality control; if the 2nd sample will show misalignment problems too, I'll ask reimbursement and never buy again a Voigtlander lens.
2) Differently from my Zeiss lenses, EXIF data do not show neither the manufacturer nor the s/n. They indicate "50mm f/2" and aperture (just)
p.2 #19The Incredible Voigtlander 50mm f2 APO Lanthar
Hi Steve,
check the right side, in particular top right corner. Compare to bottom left corner.
My Zeiss ZF.2 lenses are better.
For 1099 € I think I have the right to buy a perfect 50/2 lens (well, it vignettes but I knew)
p.2 #20The Incredible Voigtlander 50mm f2 APO Lanthar
Ripolini wrote:
Hi Steve,
check the right side, in particular top right corner. Compare to bottom left corner.
My Zeiss ZF.2 lenses are better.
For 1099 € I think I have the right to buy a perfect 50/2 lens (well, it vignettes but I knew)
Definitely not perfect but probably „within spec“ for most manufacturers.
Funny that you mention your Zeiss lenses as they are also manufactured by Cosina. In case your 2nd copy is also slightly decentered and you never buy a Voigtländer lens again, better be safe and never buy a Zeiss lens again either