tsdevine wrote:
I'm the same in generally preferring primes. In certain situations (like when I'm out with the family), I'd like to use a zoom as a walkaround, but I usually end up just going with one of my primes. The Tamron is more in the ballpark of my better primes (on the a7R III), so I finally think I can start using a zoom in those situations. (And yeah...I'll probably still have some primes in my bag for when I find something really really awesome and I'll swap just for those shots.)
Roadless wrote
Thank you for the comparison.
I have primes for normal use, but for backpacking I am interested in either three light primes or the 20mm f3.5 and the G2. Looks like the G2 will do it unless something better comes along in the next few months.
Your tests have been especially impressive. Tbh, I've avoided using my (loaned) 24-105 G very often because I find it doesn't really come into its own until 5.6/8, which isn't always the best for casual documentary... especially with the faster moving smaller subjects :P
Your tests showing it competing pretty well with the the APO-Lanthar of all lenses have been especially dramatic, and along with other reviews have made it very likely that at some point this will find its way into my bag as a dedicated spring/summer outing workhorse.
At this point, I think the only thing that could sway my opinion away from this lens would be an even more impressive reproduction ratio and/or an even greater reduction in size. I'd be fine with limiting the zoom range even further to make either happen, but this is the first zoom I've really seen that would relax the death grip my hands have on primes for their obvious advantages in image quality—and that's the one thing that can't change for me in a possible future purchase.