tsdevine wrote:
My copy is pretty darn good all the way to the corners at 28mm, must be due to having an a7R III. At 75mm it seems the weakest to me.
rvh23 wrote
Alex W wrote
Went out and did some testing my way today and shot some photos from 28-75mm. I find this lens just fantastic throughout its focal range. I actually found no weakness regardless of focal range. The colors, rendering, sharpness are just fantastic to my eyes. MFD is great and the bokeh looked great. I have owned 2.8 primes that did not perform this good. I even find the images more pleasing than my 24-70mm GM including corner to corner sharpness. I think for the price its a steal. Just my eyes and opinion. At 28mm we're still waiting for a high end (mirrorless) prime lens that is excellent all the way into the corners.
But for the rest of the range, there are many primes that do noticeably better (at 61MP) than this zoom in the corners. But as far as I can tell, the same is true of all other zooms in this range (unlike the ultra-wide range).
Maybe the next version of the GM 24-70 will change that, but in the meantime I will go back to a prime or two.
To be clear, I don't mean to imply the Tamron isn't capable of producing very good IQ even in the corners at normal print sizes. But I've been spoiled by the IQ of my 12-24GM, and was hoping to find a mid range zoom to approximately match that. I really wanted the Tamron to work in my kit because it's a great trade off of IQ, size/weight, and price.
My copy was weakest at 75mm too, but it was actually very good at 50mm already, more so I think than at the wide end.
Do you think your Tamron corners (and mid regions) at 28mm match the IQ of your Sigma 14-24 DN at 24mm?