In terms of resolution, the 28-75 will probably be right up there with the 24-70 2.8 S, which is to say state of the art. However, I think rendering will be the X-factor here.
Any zoom will most likely be (I'm aware exceptions exist here) behind equivalent primes when it comes to technical performance—and I think this is especially true of standard zooms. So if you compare the G2 with the two offerings from Sigma, you'll have two lenses that not quite meet prime performance, and while I'd imagine the G2 will be slightly better here I feel the Sigma will offer superior rendering.
Of course, this is all speculation as I'm not aware of a single review of the G2 that's out yet. It could be that the G2 is very close to, or perhaps within spitting distance, of the Sigma lenses—in which case you'd also have to factor in the Tamron's superior reproduction ratio and inclusion of linear motors into a purchasing decision more heavily.