fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2021 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2021Any love for 28-75 G2

  
 
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.7 #1Any love for 28-75 G2

Same disclaimer/disclosure as the samples above...

Sony a7R III + Tamron 28-75mm f/2.8 Di III VXD G2 - 50mm @ f/6.3
https://www.devine.photography/img/s/v-10/p3574430963-6.jpg

Full Size

Sony a7R III + Sony FE 24-105mm f/4 OSS G - 50mm @ f/6.3
https://www.devine.photography/img/s/v-10/p3574430971-6.jpg

Full Size

Sony a7R III + Voigtlander APO-LANTHAR 50mm F2 Aspherical - f/6.3
https://www.devine.photography/img/s/v-10/p3574431007-6.jpg

Full Size

-Tim
Nov 09, 2021 at 12:34 PM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.7 #2Any love for 28-75 G2

My guess is the Sigma will render slightly better, but I doubt it will be sharper, especially at the long end. (Talking Sigma 28-70.)

This is based on conjecture from what I've seen from the Sigma, no first hand experience. I have quite a few Sigma lenses though.

I actively use Sony, Voigtlander, Pentax, Zeiss, Tamron, Leica......and less actively use Nikon, Olympus...and probably some I'm forgetting. I've grown accustomed to things being different (direction, feel, location, etc.)

zeitlos wrote:
I‘m also tempted by the Sigma 28-70 f2.8. However, I already have a 24-70mm and I like 24mm because it provides you with a lot more versatility.

Any (valid) reasons to pick the Tamron and not the Sigma 28-70mm 2.8? I read that it‘s not really sharp at 70mm. The Tamron seems to be perfect at any focal length.

Edit and btw.: Do you mind the different directions of rotation of the Sigma zooms? I can already tell when I rarely use the Sigma 24-70 that I‘m always a bit “confused“ at first ...
So I wonder if the combination 17-28 (Tamron)
...Show more →

Nov 09, 2021 at 12:39 PM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.7 #3Any love for 28-75 G2

Sony a7R III + Tamron 28-75mm f/2.8 Di III VXD G2 - 34mm @ f/2.8
https://www.devine.photography/img/s/v-10/p3574517012-6.jpg

Full Size

Sony a7R III + Voigtlander APO-LANTHAR 35mm F2 Aspherical - f/2.8
https://www.devine.photography/img/s/v-10/p3574517142-6.jpg

Full Size
Nov 09, 2021 at 12:46 PM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.7 #4Any love for 28-75 G2

Sony a7R III + Tamron 28-75mm f/2.8 Di III VXD G2 - 51mm @ f/2.8
https://www.devine.photography/img/s/v-10/p3574517192-6.jpg

Full Size

Sony a7R III + Voigtlander APO-LANTHAR 50mm F2 Aspherical - f/2.8
https://www.devine.photography/img/s/v-10/p3574517181-6.jpg

Full Size
Nov 09, 2021 at 12:49 PM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.7 #5Any love for 28-75 G2
Notice the shallower depth of field in the foreground for the Tamron vs the CVs. The Tamron is wide open, so it can't be focus shift. Unless it's field curvature or something... But again it's not uncommon for me to see more range fall within the sharp area of the CVs than some of my other lenses.

I think this performance is pretty respectable for a zoom wide open against the CVs.
Nov 09, 2021 at 12:56 PM
Grievous Angel
Offline
Details
p.7 #6Any love for 28-75 G2
I can’t really see much difference. They’re all good lenses. 28-75 does just fine in these shots. Might be others where it’s not so good. But I am tempted.
Nov 09, 2021 at 12:58 PM
tschopp
Offline
Details
p.7 #7Any love for 28-75 G2
tsdevine wrote:
Okay, these comments are based on having the time to do a couple hours of shooting on one day...and my interest was more focused on how the Tamron compares to my primes, not the 24-105. My impression of the 24-105 is that it's an excellent all around lens, very flexible in covering a broad FL range, having OSS, etc. But at different FLs and different apertures it's a little bit of a mixed bag (some FLs are sharper across the frame than other FLs at the same aperture.) This is not uncommon for zooms.
Primes are easier to judge...you
...Show more →
tschopp wrote
tsdevine wroteSo these are informal tests in real word shooting scenarios. Not as controlled as some would want. I may try to do those at some point, but with autumn I'm more interested in shooting real things vs tests.

Here is a comparison, all tripod mounted, AF with lenses supported...MF for the CV. I did focus on the same spot on all 3. These were all processed in Lightroom, same sharpening/contrast, etc. I disabled all lens corrections that can be disabled, but I did check the remove CA checkbox.

If you look at the small versions displayed, you won't see much difference. You have to download the full size files to see differences. Granted, what is a material or not material in sharpness is really a subjective thing that each person needs to assess for themselves.

Sony a7R III + Tamron 28-75mm f/2.8 Di III VXD G2 - 35mm @ f/5.6
https://www.devine.photography/img/s/v-10/p3573099537-6.jpg
Full Size

Sony a7R III + Sony FE 24-105mm f/4 OSS G - 35mm @ f/5.6
https://www.devine.photography/img/s/v-10/p3573099716-6.jpg
Full Size

Sony a7R III + Voigtlander APO-LANTHAR 35mm F2 Aspherical - f/5.6
https://www.devine.photography/img/s/v-10/p3573099451-6.jpg
Full Size

Again I will try to do something more formal, like infinity shots from wide open to f/8 or so, at multiple FLs. But it will probably take me some time to do that.

-Tim
Tim, what was your impression between the 24-105 and the 28-75? Was there enough difference to be obvious or is it really a pixel peeping thing and mostly because you have identical shots? I imagine the 35 apo wins on resolution and contrast, that’s a very different lens.

My sigma 24-70 is supposed to arrive today. I am thinking I will order a 28-75 g2 to try as well. To some extent no matter how many reviews you look at nothing replaces trying it yourself. I think reviews help you to know what you don’t want to try. I am keeping my 24-105, but want to add a faster zoom as well.


Having had a chance to look at your full size photos on a 4k monitor. I agree the tamron is between the sony and the CV. All of the photos look very good to me. As you said the tamron has a bit more bite than the sony.
Nov 09, 2021 at 01:08 PM
tschopp
Offline
Details
p.7 #8Any love for 28-75 G2
I ordered the 28-75 today, B&H says it should arrive friday.
Nov 09, 2021 at 01:09 PM
Roadless
Offline
Details
p.7 #9Any love for 28-75 G2
Thank you for the comparison.

I have primes for normal use, but for backpacking I am interested in either three light primes or the 20mm f3.5 and the G2. Looks like the G2 will do it unless something better comes along in the next few months.
Nov 09, 2021 at 01:42 PM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.7 #10Any love for 28-75 G2

Sony a7R III + Tamron 28-75mm f/2.8 Di III VXD G2 - 35mm @ f/5.6
https://www.devine.photography/img/s/v-10/p3575721516-6.jpg

Full Size

Sony a7R III + Voigtlander APO-LANTHAR 35mm F2 Aspherical - f/5.6
https://www.devine.photography/img/s/v-10/p3575721554-6.jpg

Full Size

Note that there is more depth of field in the foreground for the CV 35, and less behind the subject. The Tamron has less in the foreground, but seems to have slightly more behind. I focused on the upstairs window for both.

Nov 09, 2021 at 02:37 PM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.7 #11Any love for 28-75 G2

I'm the same in generally preferring primes. In certain situations (like when I'm out with the family), I'd like to use a zoom as a walkaround, but I usually end up just going with one of my primes. The Tamron is more in the ballpark of my better primes (on the a7R III), so I finally think I can start using a zoom in those situations. (And yeah...I'll probably still have some primes in my bag for when I find something really really awesome and I'll swap just for those shots.)

Roadless wrote:
Thank you for the comparison.

I have primes for normal use, but for backpacking I am interested in either three light primes or the 20mm f3.5 and the G2. Looks like the G2 will do it unless something better comes along in the next few months.


Nov 09, 2021 at 02:40 PM
kevphoto
Offline
Details
p.7 #12Any love for 28-75 G2
Thank you for these comparison shots. For a zoom it holds up well to those CV primes, which are both among the sharpest out there. I'm also quite impressed by the rendering.
Nov 09, 2021 at 04:05 PM
rattlebonez
Offline
Details
Nov 09, 2021 at 05:39 PM
rattlebonez
Offline
Details
p.7 #14Any love for 28-75 G2
I would certainly choose the Tamron 28-75 G2 over the manual focus CV primes
Any slight image quality improvement on the prime is not work dealing with manual focus
Nov 09, 2021 at 05:41 PM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.7 #15Any love for 28-75 G2

For most of what I shoot, I don't mind manual focus at all, in fact I kind of enjoy it. Either way, choice is good, everyone can be happy.

rattlebonez wrote:
I would certainly choose the Tamron 28-75 G2 over the manual focus CV primes
Any slight image quality improvement on the prime is not work dealing with manual focus


Nov 09, 2021 at 06:05 PM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.7 #16Any love for 28-75 G2

Yeah, not an exhaustive testing, but I'm pretty pleased with the results so far. It's also very sharp at wider apertures.

kevphoto wrote:
Thank you for these comparison shots. For a zoom it holds up well to those CV primes, which are both among the sharpest out there. I'm also quite impressed by the rendering.


Nov 09, 2021 at 06:10 PM
JVan_02
Offline
Details
p.7 #17Any love for 28-75 G2
tsdevine wrote:
I'm the same in generally preferring primes. In certain situations (like when I'm out with the family), I'd like to use a zoom as a walkaround, but I usually end up just going with one of my primes. The Tamron is more in the ballpark of my better primes (on the a7R III), so I finally think I can start using a zoom in those situations. (And yeah...I'll probably still have some primes in my bag for when I find something really really awesome and I'll swap just for those shots.)

Roadless wroteThank you for the comparison.

I have primes for normal use, but for backpacking I am interested in either three light primes or the 20mm f3.5 and the G2. Looks like the G2 will do it unless something better comes along in the next few months.


Your tests have been especially impressive. Tbh, I've avoided using my (loaned) 24-105 G very often because I find it doesn't really come into its own until 5.6/8, which isn't always the best for casual documentary... especially with the faster moving smaller subjects :P

Your tests showing it competing pretty well with the the APO-Lanthar of all lenses have been especially dramatic, and along with other reviews have made it very likely that at some point this will find its way into my bag as a dedicated spring/summer outing workhorse.

At this point, I think the only thing that could sway my opinion away from this lens would be an even more impressive reproduction ratio and/or an even greater reduction in size. I'd be fine with limiting the zoom range even further to make either happen, but this is the first zoom I've really seen that would relax the death grip my hands have on primes for their obvious advantages in image quality—and that's the one thing that can't change for me in a possible future purchase.
Nov 10, 2021 at 09:03 AM
Alan Parker
Offline
Details
p.7 #18Any love for 28-75 G2
DPReview's review. They give the preference for the Tamron on autofocus performance and general sharpness and the preference for the Sigma when it comes to rendering and overall build quality.

Nov 10, 2021 at 09:34 AM
Fboss
Offline
Details
p.7 #19Any love for 28-75 G2
I owned the first version of this Tamron and the main reason why I sold it was the bokeh. dpreview has posted their review and confirms this has been improved with the G2.

This is really a nice upgrade from G1. Better AF, sharpness and rendering.

@tsdevine, thanks for posting the comparison pictures. The differences with the CV are really small. By any chance do you have a few (close up) shots taken with the G2 at 75mm f/2.8, I would like to see the rendering ?


Edited on Nov 12, 2021 at 10:56 AM · View previous versions
Nov 10, 2021 at 09:39 AM
keepcoding
Offline
Details
p.7 #20Any love for 28-75 G2
zz wrote:
DPReview's review. They give the preference for the Tamron on autofocus performance and general sharpness and the preference for the Sigma when it comes to rendering and overall build quality.



Looks really good overall, especially the improved rendering. But that flare resistance is a bit of a pickle. Either they picked the worst possible scenarios or the lens performs really poorly in this area. I had the first version but don't recall such severe flare issues.
Nov 10, 2021 at 12:00 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister