tsdevine wrote:
Dang my luck with Tamron....I've only ever bought 2 and they've both been perfect (okay.....not sure I can say the 28-75 is perfect, but it's close.)
Meanwhile I've had some trouble with just about every other manufacturer. It really does seem to come down to luck of the draw for the average Joe like us.
amv8 wrote
Roadless wrote
Has anyone tried the 28-75 G2 and the Sony 24-105 f4? How do they compare?
My wife has the Sony. While I find it to be a good all round lens, it doesn't really impress me.
I'm not expecting great things from any mid-range zoom, but Dustin Abbott's review seems promising. I had the Sony 24-105 but sold it a while back so I can't do a side-by-side comparison. The Sony has a great range, but was not as strong in the corners and the edges, especially on the wider end of the range. I also have the 16-35GM which performs much better where it overlaps with the 24-105mm which is one of the reasons I decided to sell the lens. I've done a brief side-by-side at 28mm and 35mm between the 28-75 G2 and the 16-35mm. The lenses looked pretty close. Depending on aperture, I'd generalize that for the specific test (flat wall), the Tamron was a touch better at the center and the Sony was a touch better at the corners/edges.
I've also read Dustin's review on the 28-75mm G2. I enjoy his reviews and think he does a very thorough job. However, I note that the Tamron lenses he's testing (at least recently) are being supplied by Tamron. So I'm going to assume that these are cherry picked/optimized copies that show best case performance. I've tested two copies of the 28-75mm with noticeable variation of performance between the two. Even the better copy doesn't show the level of field flatness/sharpness he's seeing wide open.
I have one other Tamron lens, the 70-180mm. The copy I received is stellar which is why I was a so disappointed with the first copy of the 28-75mm G2 I received...