nehemiahphoto wrote: zhangyue wrotenehemiahphoto wroteFred Miranda wrotenehemiahphoto wroteFred Miranda wroteI have the crops but I'm hesitant to post without testing another copy on Monday. However, I can already say it's a great landscape lens because it's flat field and at f/4 it's optimal and very sharp across the field. (61MP)Do you want crops of mine at 42MP FF? Not sure if it's helpful for youHi Nehemiah,
No need for infinity crops. I've got my second copy and it performs exactly like first one (even at 200% mag.).
To my surprise, the second copy is also 100% centered which is 2 out of 2!! (If someone wants a centered copy, let me know by PM)
The performance from my infinity test is very similar to the ephotozine's chart and different than what lenstip posted. I know the former uses IMATEST at closer distance which suggests that the 35/2 DG DN performs similarly at close and long distance.Sure. My lens also is as you describe and ephotozine's as well, and my copy is perfectly centered. I have crops from f2-11 if you'd like or something changes. I already shot the infinite scene.
p.s. Zhanyue's idea for an i-series image thread is great!OK, I will start that thread if nobody do that before I post. It will be on Alt and Sony forum.
I will post a few crop later today once I have those available but also curious about Fred's and your results Mine is SL2, I think Sigma will optimize their lens for FP but at 24M I don't want waste my time.This is how mine look. Curious if Fred's 61 sensor shows much of a difference.
zhangyue wrote: nehemiahphoto wrotezhangyue wrotenehemiahphoto wroteFred Miranda wrotenehemiahphoto wroteDo you want crops of mine at 42MP FF? Not sure if it's helpful for youHi Nehemiah,
No need for infinity crops. I've got my second copy and it performs exactly like first one (even at 200% mag.).
To my surprise, the second copy is also 100% centered which is 2 out of 2!! (If someone wants a centered copy, let me know by PM)
The performance from my infinity test is very similar to the ephotozine's chart and different than what lenstip posted. I know the former uses IMATEST at closer distance which suggests that the 35/2 DG DN performs similarly at close and long distance.Sure. My lens also is as you describe and ephotozine's as well, and my copy is perfectly centered. I have crops from f2-11 if you'd like or something changes. I already shot the infinite scene.
p.s. Zhanyue's idea for an i-series image thread is great!OK, I will start that thread if nobody do that before I post. It will be on Alt and Sony forum.
I will post a few crop later today once I have those available but also curious about Fred's and your results Mine is SL2, I think Sigma will optimize their lens for FP but at 24M I don't want waste my time.This is how mine look. Curious if Fred's 61 sensor shows much of a difference.
nehemiahphoto wrote: zhangyue wrotenehemiahphoto wrotezhangyue wrotenehemiahphoto wroteFred Miranda wroteHi Nehemiah,
No need for infinity crops. I've got my second copy and it performs exactly like first one (even at 200% mag.).
To my surprise, the second copy is also 100% centered which is 2 out of 2!! (If someone wants a centered copy, let me know by PM)
The performance from my infinity test is very similar to the ephotozine's chart and different than what lenstip posted. I know the former uses IMATEST at closer distance which suggests that the 35/2 DG DN performs similarly at close and long distance.Sure. My lens also is as you describe and ephotozine's as well, and my copy is perfectly centered. I have crops from f2-11 if you'd like or something changes. I already shot the infinite scene.
p.s. Zhanyue's idea for an i-series image thread is great!OK, I will start that thread if nobody do that before I post. It will be on Alt and Sony forum.
I will post a few crop later today once I have those available but also curious about Fred's and your results Mine is SL2, I think Sigma will optimize their lens for FP but at 24M I don't want waste my time.This is how mine look. Curious if Fred's 61 sensor shows much of a difference.
https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/50913155616_e025c8e6fa_o.jpgThis looks similar to what I got, how can you arrange all crop to a single image? I hope it is not too complicated I do it in PS then upload to my flickr. Do you know PS at all? If you do, super easy
New to the forum. I’ve been eagerly awaiting these I-Series lenses and enjoying your sample images so I thought I’d join so I could report on my experience.
I got the 35 and unfortunately I’m going to have to return it and try another one. The bottom left corner is very blurry in comparison to the others. I did some centering tests and it looks fine but every other way I’ve tested it shows a lot of blur in just one corner. I think something must be tilted or out of alignment. To put it in perspective, even my tamron 28-75 is better at 35mm and f/2.8 than the Sigma at 2.8...at least in that one corner.
Where it’s sharp, it’s very sharp, and I really like the rendering. I’m bummed I have to return it but I know I won’t be happy if I don’t at least try another one. I hope my second try works out because I really like the handling and aperture ring (I’m also a Fuji shooter).
Anyway, that’s my story. Thanks to everyone else for sharing.
My first Batis 25 was sharp in all 4 corners a every aperture at distance, but when I focused on something closer, the lower right corner always was blurry. Almost like it had a different depth of field. So I've seen some crazy things....
PaulMoorePhoto wrote:
Hi Everyone,
New to the forum. I’ve been eagerly awaiting these I-Series lenses and enjoying your sample images so I thought I’d join so I could report on my experience.
I got the 35 and unfortunately I’m going to have to return it and try another one. The bottom left corner is very blurry in comparison to the others. I did some centering tests and it looks fine but every other way I’ve tested it shows a lot of blur in just one corner. I think something must be tilted or out of alignment. To put it in perspective, even my tamron 28-75 is better at 35mm and f/2.8 than the Sigma at 2.8...at least in that one corner.
Where it’s sharp, it’s very sharp, and I really like the rendering. I’m bummed I have to return it but I know I won’t be happy if I don’t at least try another one. I hope my second try works out because I really like the handling and aperture ring (I’m also a Fuji shooter).
Anyway, that’s my story. Thanks to everyone else for sharing....Show more →
Fred Miranda wrote: nehemiahphoto wroteFred Miranda wroteengel001 wroteFor me the open question is infinity performance as a hiking/outdoor lens and am therefore anxiously waiting for Fred‘s tests. I have the cheap Tamron, currently one third the price and 2/3 the weight of the new Sigma. It is a little fatter but also shorter (particularly with the dome hood attached), and appears to be better at CA and perhaps resolution at f2.8-4 (at chart distances). I have both the Sony 35mm GM and the A1 on preorder, so don‘t yet see how the Sigma would fit in my kit.
At 65mm the choices are also difficult, as I do like the 70mm Art Macro and 65mm Voigtlander for my purposes. It is a great focal length though, reminds me a bit of medium format.I have the crops but I'm hesitant to post without testing another copy on Monday. However, I can already say it's a great landscape lens because it's flat field and at f/4 it's optimal and very sharp across the field. (61MP)Do you want crops of mine at 42MP FF? Not sure if it's helpful for youHi Nehemiah,
I received a second copy just to confirm how the 35/2 performs at infinity and it did just as good as the first copy. Now I can post the review crops with confidence.
The performance from my infinity test is very similar to the ephotozine's chart and different than what lenstip posted. I know the former uses IMATEST at closer distance which suggests that the 35/2 DG DN performs similarly at close and long distance.
So does the latter. I think (but am not sure) that EPZ might refocus at different chart locations like photo zone does, if only because they often show less difference one stop down than other people, suggesting that closer in FC is taken out of the equation. That would also explain the difference, since Lenstip's sample would have been centred too - they don't test uncenterd ones.
I was going to say I'll do a quick close range FC test, but actually, not now: for surely it doesn't matter. A flat field is important for infinity shooters, and we know it's flat there (mine certainly is, and perfectly centred). A bit of FC at closer distances (if there is any), where your subject is very unlikely to be planar, doesn't matter at all. But it will make a difference to chart tests that don't refocus.
DavidBM wrote: Fred Miranda wrotenehemiahphoto wroteFred Miranda wroteengel001 wroteFor me the open question is infinity performance as a hiking/outdoor lens and am therefore anxiously waiting for Fred‘s tests. I have the cheap Tamron, currently one third the price and 2/3 the weight of the new Sigma. It is a little fatter but also shorter (particularly with the dome hood attached), and appears to be better at CA and perhaps resolution at f2.8-4 (at chart distances). I have both the Sony 35mm GM and the A1 on preorder, so don‘t yet see how the Sigma would fit in my kit.
At 65mm the choices are also difficult, as I do like the 70mm Art Macro and 65mm Voigtlander for my purposes. It is a great focal length though, reminds me a bit of medium format.I have the crops but I'm hesitant to post without testing another copy on Monday. However, I can already say it's a great landscape lens because it's flat field and at f/4 it's optimal and very sharp across the field. (61MP)Do you want crops of mine at 42MP FF? Not sure if it's helpful for youHi Nehemiah,
No need for infinity crops. I've got my second copy and it performs exactly like first one (even at 200% mag.).
To my surprise, the second copy is also 100% centered which is 2 out of 2!! (If someone wants a centered copy, let me know by PM)
The performance from my infinity test is very similar to the ephotozine's chart and different than what lenstip posted. I know the former uses IMATEST at closer distance which suggests that the 35/2 DG DN performs similarly at close and long distance.So does the latter. I think (but am not sure) that EPZ might refocus at different chart locations like photo zone does, if only because they often show less difference one stop down than other people, suggesting that closer in FC is taken out of the equation. That would also explain the difference, since Lenstip's sample would have been centred too - they don't test uncenterd ones. I'll do a quick close range FC test...
Is an FC test done as an infinite test, but at closer distance on a flat surface? Say 10 feet away brick wall type thing?
nehemiahphoto wrote: DavidBM wroteFred Miranda wrotenehemiahphoto wroteFred Miranda wroteengel001 wroteFor me the open question is infinity performance as a hiking/outdoor lens and am therefore anxiously waiting for Fred‘s tests. I have the cheap Tamron, currently one third the price and 2/3 the weight of the new Sigma. It is a little fatter but also shorter (particularly with the dome hood attached), and appears to be better at CA and perhaps resolution at f2.8-4 (at chart distances). I have both the Sony 35mm GM and the A1 on preorder, so don‘t yet see how the Sigma would fit in my kit.
At 65mm the choices are also difficult, as I do like the 70mm Art Macro and 65mm Voigtlander for my purposes. It is a great focal length though, reminds me a bit of medium format.I have the crops but I'm hesitant to post without testing another copy on Monday. However, I can already say it's a great landscape lens because it's flat field and at f/4 it's optimal and very sharp across the field. (61MP)Do you want crops of mine at 42MP FF? Not sure if it's helpful for youHi Nehemiah,
No need for infinity crops. I've got my second copy and it performs exactly like first one (even at 200% mag.).
To my surprise, the second copy is also 100% centered which is 2 out of 2!! (If someone wants a centered copy, let me know by PM)
The performance from my infinity test is very similar to the ephotozine's chart and different than what lenstip posted. I know the former uses IMATEST at closer distance which suggests that the 35/2 DG DN performs similarly at close and long distance.So does the latter. I think (but am not sure) that EPZ might refocus at different chart locations like photo zone does, if only because they often show less difference one stop down than other people, suggesting that closer in FC is taken out of the equation. That would also explain the difference, since Lenstip's sample would have been centred too - they don't test uncenterd ones. I'll do a quick close range FC test...Is an FC test done as in infinite test, but at closer distance on a flat surface? Say 10 feet away brick wall type thing?
Th kind I have in mind is something like 40x focal length, with a chart or some other high resolution targets, focus on centre, make image, then focus or corner or edge, make image, and compare the corner or edge image made with focus on centre and focus on corner/edge. If they are the same, no FC, if they are different, FC.
Annoying test to do (which is why I don't often do it) because it is incredibly sensitive to target/sensor plane parallelism.
This is also a reason to prefer the Photozone methodology of refocussing for chart distance tests. Sure, you don't learn about FC, but it does massively mitigate the problem of parallelism, as small deviations won't matter.
DavidBM wrote: nehemiahphoto wroteDavidBM wroteFred Miranda wrotenehemiahphoto wroteFred Miranda wroteI have the crops but I'm hesitant to post without testing another copy on Monday. However, I can already say it's a great landscape lens because it's flat field and at f/4 it's optimal and very sharp across the field. (61MP)Do you want crops of mine at 42MP FF? Not sure if it's helpful for youHi Nehemiah,
No need for infinity crops. I've got my second copy and it performs exactly like first one (even at 200% mag.).
To my surprise, the second copy is also 100% centered which is 2 out of 2!! (If someone wants a centered copy, let me know by PM)
The performance from my infinity test is very similar to the ephotozine's chart and different than what lenstip posted. I know the former uses IMATEST at closer distance which suggests that the 35/2 DG DN performs similarly at close and long distance.So does the latter. I think (but am not sure) that EPZ might refocus at different chart locations like photo zone does, if only because they often show less difference one stop down than other people, suggesting that closer in FC is taken out of the equation. That would also explain the difference, since Lenstip's sample would have been centred too - they don't test uncenterd ones. I'll do a quick close range FC test...Is an FC test done as in infinite test, but at closer distance on a flat surface? Say 10 feet away brick wall type thing?Th kind I have in mind is something like 40x focal length, with a chart or some other high resolution targets, focus on centre, make image, then focus or corner or edge, make image, and compare the corner or edge image made with focus on centre and focus on corner/edge. If they are the same, no FC, if they are different, FC.
Annoying test to do (which is why I don't often do it) because it is incredibly sensitive to target/sensor plane parallelism.
This is also a reason to prefer the Photozone methodology of refocussing for chart distance tests. Sure, you don't learn about FC, but it does massively mitigate the problem of parallelism, as small deviations won't matter....Show more →
My first thought is when you get closer distance that plane parallelism issue. Have fun doing that, it really does sound like a choir. And thanks for explaining.
DavidBM wrote:
Annoying test to do (which is why I don't often do it) because it is incredibly sensitive to target/sensor plane parallelism.
I recently attempted something like that to try check the corners of a 35mm lens. It wasn't difficult since it happens that the large mirror in a bathroom here is glued right to the wall. Focusing at 1.4 meters in the middle of the reflected image of the lens gave me what I thought was a pretty good crack at the parallelism problem, and I just taped paper currency on the mirror near center, at midfield, and at the edges and corners. It wasn't a precise test (I'm a biologist, not an engineer), but the corners all looked equally sharp (or, since the lens was a ZM 35/1.4, equally unsharp) in this test, just as they do at infinity on my copy of the lens.
zugzwang2 wrote: DavidBM wroteAnnoying test to do (which is why I don't often do it) because it is incredibly sensitive to target/sensor plane parallelism.I recently attempted something like that to try check the corners of a 35mm lens. It wasn't difficult since it happens that the large mirror in a bathroom here is glued right to the wall. Focusing at 1.4 meters in the middle of the reflected image of the lens gave me what I thought was a pretty good crack at the parallelism problem, and I just taped paper currency on the mirrors near center, at midfield, and at the edges and corners. It wasn't a precise test (I'm a biologist, not an engineer), but the corners all looked equally sharp (or, since the lens was a ZM 35/1.4, equally unsharp) in this test, just as they do at infinity on my copy of the lens.
My 35/2, 45/2.8, and 65/2 are all perfectly centered. Still waiting on the 24/3.5. I’m a Sigma convert now. The release of 18mm and 90/100mm I-Series lenses would enable me to dispose of most of my Sony FE lenses.
Here are crop of 35mm on SL2, corner only. I did both test with center focus only and didnt spend time on fine tune focus. And Leica L mount focus wide open only, so if there is focus shift, the result will not be optimized. However, I mainly do this test to make sure they are not decentered copy and this will be the way I shoot most likely. I didnt try to focus at corner or do anything optimize cross frame sharpness and it looks like not needed given at f4 and above, both lenses are very sharp.
Based on results, I would say I definitely saw some lens out solve both on extreme corner at f2. I don't think this is important for my photography though. I wouldn't worry about it even if I have to use both at f2 at infinity for landscape. Maybe SL2 is not the best platform to test this. We wouldnt know unless someone can tested them on S1R. Sigma doesn't have a body do them justice.
Dustin likes the 24mm Siggy: 'I think that Sigma has managed to strike a nice balance between a high quality rendering along with excellent sharpness. This isn’t a cold, sterile lens, but rather one with some character despite being well corrected. I was actually pleasantly surprised by the optical performance of this lens'
Here's his sample gallery: https://dustinabbott.net/2021/02/sigma-24mm-f3-5-dn-image-gallery/
Fred Miranda wrote: Petegh wroteFred Miranda wroterico wroteFred Miranda wroteI got a break from the rain today and took the Sigma 24/3.5 DG DN around the neighborhood.
All images wide open (f/3.5)
Some initial thoughts:I can scour the Net for hours and learn less about this lens than reading Fred's initial thoughts—100 words!The 24/3.5's rendering is really growing on me! At first I was sad it didn't share the 45/2.8's character but I actually prefer the way Sigma designed the 24mm. It has a very pleasant rendering and is sharp at 1:2 macro. Great combination.
I had the chance to proper test it at infinity for those hoping to use it for landscape photography.
At center it's already as sharp as it can be straight from f/3.5.
The mid zone is somewhat affected by FC (wavy) + a small resolution dip. f/5.6 looks best.
The extreme corners look great from wide open but improve slightly by stopping the lens down to f/5.6.
So, like I wrote in my previous post, f/5.6 and smaller gives you optimal performance for landscapes but the lens performs great from wide open.
I don't see any lateral CA
Here are some crops: (extend your browser window to see the full detail)Thanks Fred. I went back at looked at your 42Mp Batis 25 vs Loxia 25 comparison for context; with that caveat - the new Sigma 24 looks astonishingly sharp in the center - class leading perhaps, although the Batis and Loxia beat it in the mid-frame and corner.
I know you don't have your Loxia 25 anymore, but I'd be interested to see the new Sigma up against your 12-24GM to see if it can beat it in the center. Thanks. Peter.I'm pretty sure the 24/3.5 will beat the Sigma zoom @24mm at center but the Loxia 25 will do better at mid-zone where the Sigma is weakest. I will test it today with more precision if this is due to FC, resolution dip or a combination of both. In the case for the 45/2.8, it's a combination of both.
Thanks Fred; yes, what we need is a series where you focus on the midframe and corners, like you just published for the 35mm. The mid-frame field curvature looks pretty huge on the 24mm, just judging by how sharp that green tree (bottom left of frame) in the mid-ground is, relative to infinity.
genji wrote:
My 35/2, 45/2.8, and 65/2 are all perfectly centered. Still waiting on the 24/3.5. I’m a Sigma convert now. The release of 18mm and 90/100mm I-Series lenses would enable me to dispose of most of my Sony FE lenses.
My 65/2 was the only I series lens with a 0.07 tilt and 0.02 mount swing. I could adjust it easily with shims but have another review copy arriving next week. My 24/3.5, 35/2 and 45/2.8 are perfect on my A7R IV as well.
Petegh wrote: Fred Miranda wrotePetegh wroteFred Miranda wroterico wroteFred Miranda wroteI got a break from the rain today and took the Sigma 24/3.5 DG DN around the neighborhood.
All images wide open (f/3.5)
Some initial thoughts:I can scour the Net for hours and learn less about this lens than reading Fred's initial thoughts—100 words!The 24/3.5's rendering is really growing on me! At first I was sad it didn't share the 45/2.8's character but I actually prefer the way Sigma designed the 24mm. It has a very pleasant rendering and is sharp at 1:2 macro. Great combination.
I had the chance to proper test it at infinity for those hoping to use it for landscape photography.
At center it's already as sharp as it can be straight from f/3.5.
The mid zone is somewhat affected by FC (wavy) + a small resolution dip. f/5.6 looks best.
The extreme corners look great from wide open but improve slightly by stopping the lens down to f/5.6.
So, like I wrote in my previous post, f/5.6 and smaller gives you optimal performance for landscapes but the lens performs great from wide open.
I don't see any lateral CA
Here are some crops: (extend your browser window to see the full detail)Thanks Fred. I went back at looked at your 42Mp Batis 25 vs Loxia 25 comparison for context; with that caveat - the new Sigma 24 looks astonishingly sharp in the center - class leading perhaps, although the Batis and Loxia beat it in the mid-frame and corner.
I know you don't have your Loxia 25 anymore, but I'd be interested to see the new Sigma up against your 12-24GM to see if it can beat it in the center. Thanks. Peter.I'm pretty sure the 24/3.5 will beat the Sigma zoom @24mm at center but the Loxia 25 will do better at mid-zone where the Sigma is weakest. I will test it today with more precision if this is due to FC, resolution dip or a combination of both. In the case for the 45/2.8, it's a combination of both.Thanks Fred; yes, what we need is a series where you focus on the midframe and corners, like you just published for the 35mm. The mid-frame field curvature looks pretty huge on the 24mm, just judging by how sharp that green tree (bottom left of frame) in the mid-ground is, relative to infinity.
I still have not tested it if it's FC, resolution dip or a combination of both. I will know more today.
Fred Miranda wrote: genji wroteMy 35/2, 45/2.8, and 65/2 are all perfectly centered. Still waiting on the 24/3.5. I’m a Sigma convert now. The release of 18mm and 90/100mm I-Series lenses would enable me to dispose of most of my Sony FE lenses.My 65/2 was the only I series lens with a 0.07 tilt and 0.02 mount swing. I could adjust it easily with shims but have another review copy arriving next week. My 24/3.5, 35/2 and 45/2.8 are perfect on my A7R IV as well.
Teo Rey wrote: Fred Miranda wrotegenji wroteMy 35/2, 45/2.8, and 65/2 are all perfectly centered. Still waiting on the 24/3.5. I’m a Sigma convert now. The release of 18mm and 90/100mm I-Series lenses would enable me to dispose of most of my Sony FE lenses.My 65/2 was the only I series lens with a 0.07 tilt and 0.02 mount swing. I could adjust it easily with shims but have another review copy arriving next week. My 24/3.5, 35/2 and 45/2.8 are perfect on my A7R IV as well.How does one measure tilt and mount swing?